fredmiranda.com Login

Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review

  
 
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
genji wrote:
Edward Teller wrote
genji wrote
Edward Teller wrotehttps://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-GxKbLkP/0/b8e6d62a/X3/Nokton-50-1-%40-f-1-sconces-X3.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-LCkd5ns/0/113cd992/X3/Noctilux-50-1-%40-f-1-sconces-X3.jpg

After using both these lenses in a variety of settings for a week, many, not all, of the image pairs (not all shown here) have struck me as if the images from the Noctilux were as if from a dream, and the images from the Nokton were as if from a documentary. Not a very nuts and bolts appraisal, and possibly I've looked at them too long.
Dream vs. Documentary, what a great way to express the difference (and the fact that you have looked at both of them so well makes you uniquely qualified to offer that appraisal).
I need to sell one, as that was the original plan, but as strange as it might seem, I can’t decide which one. Am leaning towards keeping the “worse” one, but that seems wrong.
I’d choose the Noctilux over the Nokton without hesitation. As for what you should do, if your heart says “Noctilux” then I don’t believe it’s the “worse” of the two nor that you’d be making the “wrong” choice.


It’s definitely become a heart/mind thing. Thanks for the push
Feb 10, 2022 at 06:04 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #2Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.
Feb 10, 2022 at 07:25 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.


Same thing with how people railed on the old Nokton 50 1.1. It actually is a very sharp lens (well was at the time and I have no complaints on film); if it was a Leica people would have been raving about it!
I use it not for bokeh, but as an available light lens.
Feb 10, 2022 at 07:28 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.


Fred, it’s because we’ve now ventured into the realm of religious belief, where forgiveness is paramount.
Feb 10, 2022 at 08:10 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
rscheffler wrote:
The VM doesn't change character much as it's stopped down. To my eyes the Nocti 50/1 is more of a 'dual character' lens wide open compared to stopped down a bit. This could offer some versatility. If you already have one or more modern 50s, then I'd lean towards keeping the Leica over the VM. If you need the best sharpness, contrast, etc. at f/1.0, then pick the VM.

Edward Teller wrote:
I’ve got the 50/1.4 Summilux ASPH already, so either the Nokton or the Noctilux is really going to be a niche lens, used mostly at 1.4 or below, used mostly those times when I just want to go out and look for things to shoot at f/1. At 5.6 it’s certainly nice, but those pictures could have been made by a lot of nice lenses, unlike the ones shot at f/1. There’s just something about the look I like, if I nail it, and I don’t know if it’s just because I’m older and grew up with film, or
...Show more →

There you go. IMO based on the recent examples here, the Noctilux 0.95 and the Nokton look like faster Lux ASPHs. The Noct f/1.0 has a distinct look wide open compared to the other two. I think it might even be better optimized off-axis at closer distances than the 0.95. Some of your comparison images show how similarly the Noctilux and Nokton can look in certain scenes. But in others, the Noctilux has a 'fingerprint' that IMO the newer lenses don't.

Fred Miranda wrote:
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.


I've also forgiven the Nokton after seeing the quality of photos from it here. Sure, FC is a weakness, but care with composition can camouflage the deeper edge DoF effect.
Feb 10, 2022 at 09:46 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
The Leica lenses (to my eyes) appear to abstract more fully whereas the Nokton presents motifs more defined relative to distance from the lens, yielding more apparent image depth, context. It can be best seen in Edward's set against the Summilux (f1.4 and f2.8), but shows against the fast Leicas as well. Looks like a combination of planar performance, colour and contrast, but also design choice.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1741370/5#mt
Feb 10, 2022 at 10:38 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.


It called "expectation" I never put too much expectation for both Noctlux given they are out of my reach and I was never convinced for both performance.

I did buy Ttartisan 0.95 as it match or exceed my expectation, I am aware of its weakness and also strength and understand the user cases for me are mainly use its strength. Given the price, build and lens speed, I didn't complain and just use it.

For this one, I have higher expectation than what I saw here TBH. I especially surprised with such high vignette and FC given its so short and fat body design. Especially after saw what VC can do with their 50mm and 40mm f1.2, My hope was quite high on this one TBH. I expect it will beat both on rendering which it didn't.

The Pros of this lens doesn't click for me on the cases I will use this lens, the Cons do question the goal of getting it. If those pros highlight the usage of this lens for anyone, I think it is a bargain for a f1 glass.

Feb 11, 2022 at 12:02 AM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
I find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.

Not by me, but I already knew before no one would even remotely consider these Noctilux lenses if it weren't for the Leica dot.
But I gave up discussing with the Leica collectors/fanboys a long long time ago.
Feb 11, 2022 at 12:46 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #9Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
zhangyue wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteI find it interesting that most of the criticism about the CV 50/1 Nokton’s field curvature + optical vignetting affect on rendering is somehow forgiven for the Leica 50/1 even though it performs worse in this regard.
It called "expectation" I never put too much expectation for both Noctlux given they are out of my reach and I was never convinced for both performance.

I did buy Ttartisan 0.95 as it match or exceed my expectation, I am aware of its weakness and also strength and understand the user cases for me are mainly use its strength. Given the price, build and lens speed, I didn't complain and just use it.

For this one, I have higher expectation than what I saw here TBH. I especially surprised with such high vignette and FC given its so short
...Show more →

I find the TTA 50/0.95 an interesting design not to be dismissed. It has much lower field curvature which means more even rendering compared to other F/1 lenses. In some ways it behaves like the 50/1.2 Nokton with some SA at close distance and higher contrast and resolution after 2m. I've owned one for about 2 months but could not get used to carrying such big lens on the M.
The Voigtlander 50/1 is the first F/1 lens that I would consider due to its the size. The Noctilux 50/1 is not that big but its still front heavy.

Feb 11, 2022 at 09:15 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #10Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Here are some rendering comparisons:

TTArtisan 50/0.95 vs Nokton 50 f/1.2 (Both wide open)

The TTA has a little warmer cast but I can definitely see a difference in blur amount between the two wide open. Also field curvature and optical vignetting is just as well controlled compared to the Nokton, perhaps even better behaved.














Feb 11, 2022 at 09:31 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #11Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
It's only fair to compare the Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton to the TTArtisan 50/0.95, so I just ordered one and should have it next Wednesday.
I've tricked you guys, this review never ends.
Feb 11, 2022 at 11:26 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
It's only fair to compare the Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton to the TTArtisan 50/0.95, so I just ordered one and should have it next Wednesday.
I've tricked you guys, this review never ends.


There was also talk of a GM 50/1.2 vs CV 50/1
Feb 11, 2022 at 11:28 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #13Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteIt's only fair to compare the Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton to the TTArtisan 50/0.95, so I just ordered one and should have it next Wednesday.
I've tricked you guys, this review never ends.
There was also talk of a GM 50/1.2 vs CV 50/1


I will throw that in the mix too but the GM will crush these guys.
Feb 11, 2022 at 11:31 AM
SoulKey
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
I shot the TTArtisan for pro work and while the rendering is beautiful from short to mid distance (and more distracting at longer distance), the lens seriously lacks sharpness, which becomes very evident with full body shots and is especially an issue for any working photographers who delivers printed products where every flaw is more easily seen.

In that regard the Nokton 50/1.2 VM is far ahead which makes it more applicable for a lot of paid work.

Btw the Mitakon 50/0.95 III for E-Mount had even smoother bokeh, way less vignetting and a slightly longer focal length than the TTArtisan (but also lacks sharpness). In case you wanna give it a try

Thanks for putting in the work. Cheers
Feb 11, 2022 at 12:32 PM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Since the review never ends, and for fun, here's a quick answer to a question that no one has asked: "How do the Nokton 50/1, the Noctilux 50/1, and the Nikkor 58/1.2 Ai-s compare?"
Shot on a Nikon Z 7. From .DNG files. All at f/1.2











It's hard to tell here, but from the few I've done, the center sharpness/contrast of the Nikkor is as good as, if not possibly a smidge better than the Nokton, if judged only by the way focus peaking lights up. Not saying that's accurate, but I keep seeing it, and it doesn't surprise me at all. By f/4 the Nikkor Nocts are very sharp, but mostly in the center. So, maybe the Nikkor is similar to the Nokton 50/1.2, but with a busier background and faster falloff. So many choices, so little time.
Feb 11, 2022 at 04:20 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #16Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Edward Teller wrote:
Since the review never ends, and for fun, here's a quick answer to a question that no one has asked: "How do the Nokton 50/1, the Noctilux 50/1, and the Nikkor 58/1.2 Ai-s compare?"
Shot on a Nikon Z 7. From .DNG files. All at f/1.2

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-fFNkjk8/0/26c0927c/X2/Noctilux-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-SspNMFB/0/b93c74e1/X2/Nokton-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-thHSn3b/0/c005fc80/X2/Nikkor-Noct-58-1.2-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

It's hard to tell here, but from the few I've done, the center sharpness/contrast of the Nikkor is as good as, if not possibly a smidge better than the Nokton, if judged only by the way focus peaking lights up. Not saying that's accurate, but I keep seeing it, and it doesn't surprise me at
...Show more →

What I've learned from shooting with lenses under corrected for SA is that focus peaking is tricky because it gives you the version with higher contrast, not higher resolution. I prefer turning peaking off and look a the detail amount instead.
Feb 11, 2022 at 04:38 PM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
Edward Teller wroteSince the review never ends, and for fun, here's a quick answer to a question that no one has asked: "How do the Nokton 50/1, the Noctilux 50/1, and the Nikkor 58/1.2 Ai-s compare?"
Shot on a Nikon Z 7. From .DNG files. All at f/1.2

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-fFNkjk8/0/26c0927c/X2/Noctilux-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-SspNMFB/0/b93c74e1/X2/Nokton-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-thHSn3b/0/c005fc80/X2/Nikkor-Noct-58-1.2-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

It's hard to tell here, but from the few I've done, the center sharpness/contrast of the Nikkor is as good as, if not possibly a smidge better than the Nokton, if judged only by the way focus peaking lights up. Not saying that's accurate, but I keep seeing it, and it doesn't surprise me at all. By f/4 the Nikkor Nocts are very sharp, but mostly in the center. So, maybe the Nikkor is similar to the Nokton 50/1.2, but with a busier background and faster falloff. So many choices, so little time.
What I've learned from shooting with lenses under corrected for SA is that focus peaking is tricky because it gives you the version with higher contrast, not higher resolution. I prefer turning peaking off and look a the detail amount instead.


I know, it's why I said center sharpness/contrast. But, looking at some of them at 200%, there is not a whole lot of difference in the center detail between the Nokton and the Nikkor. It's well within the range of the error inherent in my ability to focus the camera. At least for the ones I've done, which I'm not thinking is definitive. But, the Nocts are quite sharp in center, if nowhere else, and they're impressive for old designs. Small and light too!
Feb 11, 2022 at 05:02 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #18Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Edward Teller wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Edward Teller wroteSince the review never ends, and for fun, here's a quick answer to a question that no one has asked: "How do the Nokton 50/1, the Noctilux 50/1, and the Nikkor 58/1.2 Ai-s compare?"
Shot on a Nikon Z 7. From .DNG files. All at f/1.2

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-fFNkjk8/0/26c0927c/X2/Noctilux-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-SspNMFB/0/b93c74e1/X2/Nokton-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-thHSn3b/0/c005fc80/X2/Nikkor-Noct-58-1.2-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

It's hard to tell here, but from the few I've done, the center sharpness/contrast of the Nikkor is as good as, if not possibly a smidge better than the Nokton, if judged only by the way focus peaking lights up. Not saying that's accurate, but I keep seeing it, and it doesn't surprise me at all. By f/4 the Nikkor Nocts are very sharp, but mostly in the center. So, maybe the Nikkor is similar to the Nokton 50/1.2, but with a busier background and faster falloff. So many choices, so little time.
What I've learned from shooting with lenses under corrected for SA is that focus peaking is tricky because it gives you the version with higher contrast, not higher resolution. I prefer turning peaking off and look a the detail amount instead.
I know, it's why I said center sharpness/contrast. But, looking at some of them at 200%, there is not a whole lot of difference in the center detail between the Nokton and the Nikkor. It's well within the range of the error inherent in my ability to focus the camera. At least for the ones I've done, which I'm not thinking is definitive. But, the Nocts are quite sharp in center, if nowhere else, and they're impressive for old designs. Small and light too!


Does the Nikkor keeps up even at 1m?
Feb 11, 2022 at 05:07 PM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
Edward Teller wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Edward Teller wroteSince the review never ends, and for fun, here's a quick answer to a question that no one has asked: "How do the Nokton 50/1, the Noctilux 50/1, and the Nikkor 58/1.2 Ai-s compare?"
Shot on a Nikon Z 7. From .DNG files. All at f/1.2

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-fFNkjk8/0/26c0927c/X2/Noctilux-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-SspNMFB/0/b93c74e1/X2/Nokton-50-1-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

https://photos.smugmug.com/Nokton-501-ASPH-vs-Noctilux-501-vs-Summilux-5014-ASPH/i-thHSn3b/0/c005fc80/X2/Nikkor-Noct-58-1.2-%40-f-1.2-Figurine-X2.jpg

It's hard to tell here, but from the few I've done, the center sharpness/contrast of the Nikkor is as good as, if not possibly a smidge better than the Nokton, if judged only by the way focus peaking lights up. Not saying that's accurate, but I keep seeing it, and it doesn't surprise me at all. By f/4 the Nikkor Nocts are very sharp, but mostly in the center. So, maybe the Nikkor is similar to the Nokton 50/1.2, but with a busier background and faster falloff. So many choices, so little time.
What I've learned from shooting with lenses under corrected for SA is that focus peaking is tricky because it gives you the version with higher contrast, not higher resolution. I prefer turning peaking off and look a the detail amount instead.
I know, it's why I said center sharpness/contrast. But, looking at some of them at 200%, there is not a whole lot of difference in the center detail between the Nokton and the Nikkor. It's well within the range of the error inherent in my ability to focus the camera. At least for the ones I've done, which I'm not thinking is definitive. But, the Nocts are quite sharp in center, if nowhere else, and they're impressive for old designs. Small and light too!
Does the Nikkor keeps up even at 1m?


I haven't done that, had only done some random shots to satisfy my curiosity vis a vis rendering. I'm tired I guess I could. Had really just posted those for general interest in the difference in rendering, but now you have me curious, while I've still got the Nokton. Will see what I can do, while paying more attention to that aspect when I shoot a couple. (Those were probably at 2m or a bit less. Am guessing it won't keep up, given the construction, but we'll see.)
Feb 11, 2022 at 05:33 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #20Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
For those wondering how the Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton's FC shape changes from close distance to long distance on both Leica M10-R and Sony A7R IV, here is a comparison.

Notice how the field curvature flattens from close distance towards long distance on the Leica M10-R while it becomes more "Wavy" on the A7R IV's thicker sensor




Feb 11, 2022 at 06:13 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister