Here is the other thread with lots of discussion before the lens was released then quite a few pictures with lots of discussion at the end of the thread. My quick take: It is an excellent lens with few flaws but perhaps not quite as sharp or quite as low in aberrations as the recent APO Lanthars but still excellent. I am very happy it is available and it will replace my two Leica 90's (f/2.4 Summarit, and f/4 Macro Elmar).
realVivek wrote:
Lou, as pmeheut has shown, it is not good for the M.
[ Unless you call color moire as an indication of “soul”]
I'm not sure the moire is a problem. Most of my sharp lenses exhibit moire on the curtains I shot, including the Leica 50mm/1.4 ASPH and the Voigt 50mm/1.2. Both are excellent.
But maybe you were making a joke? If so, sorry for not understanding it.
I have a couple copies and will start a review soon. So far my only complaint is how fast the focus throw is. Any tiny movement makes a big difference in optimal focus. This is more troublesome when using the rangefinder.
Not a joke but a fact. Yes, M is not a good platform for sharp lenses unless it is a monochrome camera (even on monochrome there may be issues. Lou knows that from his experience.)
YMMV.
pmeheut wrote: realVivek wroteLou, as pmeheut has shown, it is not good for the M.
[ Unless you call color moire as an indication of “soul”]I'm not sure the moire is a problem. Most of my sharp lenses exhibit moire on the curtains I shot, including the Leica 50mm/1.4 ASPH and the Voigt 50mm/1.2. Both are excellent.
But maybe you were making a joke? If so, sorry for not understanding it.
realVivek wrote:
Not a joke but a fact. Yes, M is not a good platform for sharp lenses unless it is a monochrome camera (even on monochrome there may be issues. Lou knows that from his experience.)
YMMV.
pmeheut wroterealVivek wroteLou, as pmeheut has shown, it is not good for the M.
[ Unless you call color moire as an indication of “soul”]I'm not sure the moire is a problem. Most of my sharp lenses exhibit moire on the curtains I shot, including the Leica 50mm/1.4 ASPH and the Voigt 50mm/1.2. Both are excellent.
But maybe you were making a joke? If so, sorry for not understanding it.
Yes, having moire is the flip side of not having an AA filter. An AA filter reduces sharpness and moire, but this isn't an M issue it is an AA filter issue. I believe if the moire really is a problem you can use an add on filter. Going up in MP to the M10R will also help with this issue. Personally, I would prefer the 24 MP M10 to have an AA filter, but the 40MP M10R to be without one, but again this isn't really an M10 issue it is an AA filter issue.
Fred Miranda wrote:
I have a couple copies and will start a review soon. So far my only complaint is how fast the focus throw is. Any tiny movement makes a big difference in optimal focus. This is more troublesome when using the rangefinder.
Thanks Fred, I will be eagerly awaiting your review. I am holding off buying it until I see your review, but I am 99% sure I will get it as I don't expect any significant gotchas in your or anyone else's review.
genji is correct. And for the camera/ bokeh comment I don't recall genji saying that. I have seen plenty of reviews on the world wide web about all kinds of different cameras that are insanely incorrect. If you love rangefinders there isnt a better platform than Leica M.
pmeheut wrote: genji wroteYep, Vivek lives in Pathological Haters of the Leica M World.He also seems to have no idea what he is talking about but this is common with haters.
Fits right in with what I said. One needs the correct drink.
realVivek wrote: pmeheut wrotegenji wroteYep, Vivek lives in Pathological Haters of the Leica M World.He also seems to have no idea what he is talking about but this is common with haters.Fits right in with what I said. One needs the correct drink.
Yeah theres all different kinds of drinks. Looks like you have your own brand. Only problem is you hate the other brand and think for some reason its your duty to let others know. The big question is why do you care?
Well, it is for this reason I asked the qustion and Fred answered properly. Soon a review. Thanks to all and pmeheut and Steve Spencer not to mention my old friend Vivek.
I had stopped reading that thread you all referred me to as it for ages it did not indicate any actual usage of the VM APO 90 Skopar with its comments going on and on about non-essentials to me.
stgrove wrote:
I had stopped reading that thread you all referred me to as it for ages it did not indicate any actual usage of the VM APO 90 Skopar with its comments going on and on about non-essentials to me.
This is what happens between the announce and the availability.
I wondered if I should start a new thread for this very reason but decided against it. I do not know why.
pmeheut wrote:
This is what happens between the announce and the availability.
I wondered if I should start a new thread for this very reason but decided against it. I do not know why.
No point starting a new thread. Leica M-related threads on FM follow the same trajectory: the M users are happily discussing the thread topic until some clown/hater arrives to inform us that Leica M cameras are mediocre, overpriced shit and we’re deluded morons/suckers for buying and using them.