Good thoughts, and I was ahead of you matrix and spot metering show the same behavior, with matrix working best.
zhangyue wrote:
If the scene with Highlight meter enabled causes under exposure, this will affect focus. If it is way underexposure, in deep dark area, sensor can’t focus if it can’t see. Low light focus will enable higher sensor gain to focus but will slow the response to the point make AFC not very meaningful. That is my guess why Z7 give up for this case in AFC but not AFS.
You could try set EVF/LCD effect off to see if it improve this regard. Or simply change another meter mode or over exposure to see if this is the cause of sloppy AF C you saw here. Not suggesting you change the way you shooting but try to understand the root cause.
No longer having Z camera, but this is how I remembered and would try if I face the same situation. ...Show more →
RoamingScott wrote:
Good thoughts, and I was ahead of you matrix and spot metering show the same behavior, with matrix working best.
zhangyue wroteIf the scene with Highlight meter enabled causes under exposure, this will affect focus. If it is way underexposure, in deep dark area, sensor can’t focus if it can’t see. Low light focus will enable higher sensor gain to focus but will slow the response to the point make AFC not very meaningful. That is my guess why Z7 give up for this case in AFC but not AFS.
You could try set EVF/LCD effect off to see if it improve this regard. Or simply change another meter mode or over exposure to see if this is the cause of sloppy AF C you saw here. Not suggesting you change the way you shooting but try to understand the root cause.
No longer having Z camera, but this is how I remembered and would try if I face the same situation.
Well, we can safely say that in this condition with this particular shooting method, Nikon is inferior in AFC performance as your test show.
I'd love to see a comparison with good light in AFC for both cameras. Just for my curiosity. However, again, as you point out, lens could be also a factor.
Modern digital camera is really a computer and DSP processor. If we value those fancy speed and feature, we are in the loop of endless upgrade. The cameras are doing all type of processing back end without let end users know what is going on. what low light focus does in term algorithm change, how AF-C and AF-S works for each camera, when PDAF and CDAF used individually or combined etc... every manufacture did a lot of back end process. I hate manufacture lack of transparency for advanced users on those setting.
Personally, for most shooting cases if not all, All major cameras from big three or four pass my threshold feature wise. I just pick one I like to shoot more and change when I see one I like more. So, I am at peace finally.
zhangyue wrote: RoamingScott wroteGood thoughts, and I was ahead of you matrix and spot metering show the same behavior, with matrix working best.
zhangyue wroteIf the scene with Highlight meter enabled causes under exposure, this will affect focus. If it is way underexposure, in deep dark area, sensor can’t focus if it can’t see. Low light focus will enable higher sensor gain to focus but will slow the response to the point make AFC not very meaningful. That is my guess why Z7 give up for this case in AFC but not AFS.
You could try set EVF/LCD effect off to see if it improve this regard. Or simply change another meter mode or over exposure to see if this is the cause of sloppy AF C you saw here. Not suggesting you change the way you shooting but try to understand the root cause.
No longer having Z camera, but this is how I remembered and would try if I face the same situation.Well, we can safely say that in this condition with this particular shooting method, Nikon is inferior in AFC performance as your test show.
I'd love to see a comparison with good light in AFC for both cameras. Just for my curiosity. However, again, as you point out, lens could be also a factor.
Modern digital camera is really a computer and DSP processor. If we value those fancy speed and feature, we are in the loop of endless upgrade. The cameras are doing all type of processing back end without let end users know what is going on. what low light focus does in term algorithm change, how AF-C and AF-S works for each camera, when PDAF and CDAF used individually or combined etc... every manufacture did a lot of back end process. I hate manufacture lack of transparency for advanced users on those setting.
Personally, for most shooting cases if not all, All major cameras from big three or four pass my threshold feature wise. I just pick one I like to shoot more and change when I see one I like more. So, I am at peace finally. ...Show more →
I tried an indoor test this morning, and the Sony completely fell on its face in a similar foreground to background shift. Where the Nikon would simply fail to find a target and not change the focus, the Sony would rack back and forth, continuing to find focus.
I think with enough time you could make a case that either system is worse
I guess Sony is only hands down superior if you have a 4500 or 6500 stacked sensor camera and do nothing but bird with it. Meanwhile I shoot...so many different things and Nikon Z has been mostly fine 90% of the time. RoamingScott wrote: zhangyue wroteRoamingScott wroteGood thoughts, and I was ahead of you matrix and spot metering show the same behavior, with matrix working best.
zhangyue wroteIf the scene with Highlight meter enabled causes under exposure, this will affect focus. If it is way underexposure, in deep dark area, sensor can’t focus if it can’t see. Low light focus will enable higher sensor gain to focus but will slow the response to the point make AFC not very meaningful. That is my guess why Z7 give up for this case in AFC but not AFS.
You could try set EVF/LCD effect off to see if it improve this regard. Or simply change another meter mode or over exposure to see if this is the cause of sloppy AF C you saw here. Not suggesting you change the way you shooting but try to understand the root cause.
No longer having Z camera, but this is how I remembered and would try if I face the same situation.Well, we can safely say that in this condition with this particular shooting method, Nikon is inferior in AFC performance as your test show.
I'd love to see a comparison with good light in AFC for both cameras. Just for my curiosity. However, again, as you point out, lens could be also a factor.
Modern digital camera is really a computer and DSP processor. If we value those fancy speed and feature, we are in the loop of endless upgrade. The cameras are doing all type of processing back end without let end users know what is going on. what low light focus does in term algorithm change, how AF-C and AF-S works for each camera, when PDAF and CDAF used individually or combined etc... every manufacture did a lot of back end process. I hate manufacture lack of transparency for advanced users on those setting.
Personally, for most shooting cases if not all, All major cameras from big three or four pass my threshold feature wise. I just pick one I like to shoot more and change when I see one I like more. So, I am at peace finally. I tried an indoor test this morning, and the Sony completely fell on its face in a similar foreground to background shift. Where the Nikon would simply fail to find a target and not change the focus, the Sony would rack back and forth, continuing to find focus.
I think with enough time you could make a case that either system is worse
RoamingScott wrote:
I think with enough time you could make a case that either system is worse
No question about it. Just pick the one with features you value more and move on. I dont feel Z AF was a problem even with Gen1 but internet don't agree with me
L mount I have right now is worse on AF for sure but meet my need. I do Like what Sony did for their GM lenses, may get it once A9III comes or Z8 whichever fit me better.
saaketham wrote:
Looks like Scott's done experimenting with the z7ii .. selling it already eh
Super spotty AF-C + only 5fps before the slideshow HI+ mode is just a no go. I tried every use case I'd use it for (except birding, which was only gonna get worse lol).
I really like the feature set of the camera, it's a shame.
(Plus the 200-600 is a killer price right now in Sony land and I still have EDU )
Yeah that's basically Sony's only leg up...being early. I think I was just invested enough on Z mount and have enough toss away stuff to trade in and like integrated grip bodies to make me want the Z9. I don't bird that heavily enough to have that be that much of a determining factor and Z9 can bird so it turned into a whatever for me. RoamingScott wrote: saaketham wroteLooks like Scott's done experimenting with the z7ii .. selling it already ehAF-C + only 5fps before the slideshow HI+ mode is just a no go. I tried every use case I'd use it for (except birding, which was only gonna get worse lol).
I really like the feature set of the camera, it's a shame.
(Plus the 200-600 is a killer price right now in Sony land and I still have EDU )
RoamingScott wrote:
I don't think being "lost in bokeh" should be a thing for a camera of this price point. If there is no contrast under the focus point, why does it freeze there? It should try to find focus instead, that's kinda the essence of AF, in my opinion.
I redid this test using single point but with AF-S, where I'd re-initiate focus in those same spots manually.
Guess what?
It worked 100% of the time, quickly, and without hunting/breathing.
The AF is capable...I just can't explain the discrepancy between AF-C and AF-S behavior.
I know you don’t feel this way, but I think you are seeing the camera have difficulties with a lack of contrast for the AF system to grab onto.
In AF-S, the camera finds just enough contrast to lock on, and it does. Maybe it does the old PDAF “wobble”, but in the end you get a green box, and you’re happy with your good lock.
In AF-C, the camera does the same and dutifully focuses. But then it immediately loses its “lock” and hunts, thinking that it is seeing blur instead of a low-contrast subject. It “wobbles” between these two states endlessly.
I just tested this with my Z6 and 24-70/2.8… I focused on something close and contrasty, then put the small AF point (not pinpoint, as that’s CDAF-only) inside a flat white piece of wood. In AF-S, the camera hunted slightly then locked. In AF-C, the camera focused momentarily, then hunted, then repeated that cycle endlessly.
When I instead aimed at something with good contrast, the camera performed roughly the same in AF-S and AF-C. The faster I had the A3 setting, the faster and more reliably AF-C performed.
I think this can easily describe why there’s a discrepancy in reports of AF-C performance. For my part, I’m very happy with my Z6’s AF-C performance, lack of bird eye AF notwithstanding. But I’m careful to avoid low contrast on my AF points, as I’ve been schooled to do for a couple decades now.
Theodoric wrote:
I appreciate your input everyone, many thanks for the video tests.
Thing is, I'm really eying the MC 105mm but I'm afraid that the Z AF will be disappointing. This thread didn't really help with that so far, I'm afraid
Using the a7R4 with the Sigma 105mm DG DN right now, which isn't even a great AF experience to start with, to be honest.
I really don't want to lug around the Z9 just to get acceptable AF...
Any input, experienced lads that you are?
I don’t have a Z 105 MC, but I do have a 105VR. Aside from its VR sounding like the smallest jackhammer in the world while AF is engaged, its AF performance should be similar.
I use AF for macro extensively. I shoot macro AF in one of two ways:
1) Quick grab shot: AF-C, small area, focus priority. Frame, hold AF-ON, hold shutter. Wait for the camera to fire.
I do this if it’s windy or for skittish subjects, and I try to do numerous frames because DOF is so small that I get a fair number of misses. But it’s brain-dead easy, and I get good results after I cull the missed shots.
2) Careful focus: AF-S, single point. Frame, hold AF-ON, wait for focus to be close. Turn the focus ring slightly to engage MF override and get your focus peaking. Focus manually using focus peaking and fire when ready.
I do this when I have time to carefully frame and focus… mostly for still life. This method gets me nearly-perfect focus quickly (no cranking on the ring), and make it quick and easy to tune focus with the EVF or LCD.
Mirrorless macro is a dream, and my Z6 and 105VR do very well. Best of any system I have used. I am tempted to upgrade to the 105MC, but can’t come up with a reason other than a smaller, quieter lens.
CKrueger wrote:
I redid this test using single point but with AF-S, where I'd re-initiate focus in those same spots manually.
Guess what?
It worked 100% of the time, quickly, and without hunting/breathing.
The AF is capable...I just can't explain the discrepancy between AF-C and AF-S behavior.
I know you don’t feel this way, but I think you are seeing the camera have difficulties with a lack of contrast for the AF system to grab onto.
In AF-S, the camera finds just enough contrast to lock on, and it does. Maybe it does the old PDAF “wobble”, but in the end you get a green box, and you’re happy with your good lock.
In AF-C, the camera does the same and dutifully focuses. But then it immediately loses its “lock” and hunts, thinking that it is seeing blur instead of a low-contrast subject. It “wobbles” between these two states endlessly.
I just tested this with my Z6 and 24-70/2.8… I focused on something close and contrasty, then put the small AF point (not pinpoint, as that’s CDAF-only) inside a flat white piece of wood. In AF-S, the camera hunted slightly then locked. In AF-C, the camera focused momentarily, then hunted, then repeated that cycle endlessly.
When I instead aimed at something with good contrast, the camera performed roughly the same in AF-S and AF-C. The faster I had the A3 setting, the faster and more reliably AF-C performed.
I think this can easily describe why there’s a discrepancy in reports of AF-C performance. For my part, I’m very happy with my Z6’s AF-C performance, lack of bird eye AF notwithstanding. But I’m careful to avoid low contrast on my AF points, as I’ve been schooled to do for a couple decades now.
I believe that the orientation of the contrast is also important. Mirrorless cameras often do much better with vertical contrast than horizontal contrast. keep that in mind when focusing on a subject. Look for vertical contrast areas.
This is probably why I just go to the park and just shoot things instead of doing tests that don't reflect how I naturally shoot things. One could go through my posts (and others) in the Z mount image thread and realize quite quickly that the Z cameras aren't trainwrecks. They're finicky as F yes, but I shoot graduations with the Z6II so clearly something in there works.
Super slow day at work, and no nibbles on the Nikon stuff yet, so I'm back in the yard comparing a few things They key takeaway, which was already known, is that the Sony files require more fiddling out of cam than the Nikons. The Sony files also consistently exhibit worse CA across the board. Actually very impressed by how well the 85/1.8 S handles CA. Easily the best budget 85 I've ever tested.
Nikon left, Sony right. Both in AF-S, highlight metering, f2.8, both on auto WB. A great example of what annoys me about Sony's metering and WB.
In both I simply copied to the Nikon WB over to the Sony file, and tweaked exposure until I felt they roughly matched.
I had to raise the Sony exposure in post a full stop to get these to match.
I rarely shoot in AF-S because I use BBF. Decided to do some tests of my own, I turned off AF assist light and Low light. Manually set exposure to underexpose and moved focus point back and forth between similar foreground object and low contrast dark area. AFC struggled with the low contrast area. AFS worked every time because the camera increases the exposure for a split second when focus is initiated. It’s not clear in your video because it’s daylight, but if you under expose or are in a dim lit area you’ll see AFS mode flashes the scene brighter in the viewfinder for a split second when focus is initiated.
I’ve never come across this issue in everyday shooting. But now I know a work around if I ever do (switch to AFS).
Once you adjusted exposure, I see no meaningful difference between your Sony and Nikon samples except for the bokeh might be a little smoother with the Nikon 85mm f1.8 lens vs the Sony 85mm f1.8. There's some color differences but hard to say one is better than the other.
I usually add 0.3 EV to my Sony camera otherwise it tends to be a bit darker based on my experience.
Buckeye2604 wrote:
I rarely shoot in AF-S because I use BBF. Decided to do some tests of my own, I turned off AF assist light and Low light. Manually set exposure to underexpose and moved focus point back and forth between similar foreground object and low contrast dark area. AFC struggled with the low contrast area. AFS worked every time because the camera increases the exposure for a split second when focus is initiated. It’s not clear in your video because it’s daylight, but if you under expose or are in a dim lit area you’ll see AFS mode flashes the scene brighter in the viewfinder for a split second when focus is initiated.
I’ve never come across this issue in everyday shooting. But now I know a work around if I ever do (switch to AFS). ...Show more →
It’s borders aren’t anything to write home about either. What lenses are you using from Sony besides the 24-105?
RoamingScott wrote: Shotokan wroteThis video by Nigel Danson, a UK landscape photographer, argues for the 24-200mm z lens, especially for hiking. He also owns and regularly uses the 24-70 f4 and 24-70 f2.8 lenses. Until recently, he relied on the 24-70 f4 almost exclusively for his woodland photography and he was pleased with the results.I can see the 24-200 being more appealing on the Z6, but I'd rather have F4 at 120mm and crop as needed on the Z7ii. You start to lose light on this lens at 35mm, and you're already down to f/6 by 70mm.
Definitely could get great shots midday, though, in one convenient lens.
JadedWriter wrote:
This is probably why I just go to the park and just shoot things instead of doing tests that don't reflect how I naturally shoot things. One could go through my posts (and others) in the Z mount image thread and realize quite quickly that the Z cameras aren't trainwrecks. They're finicky as F yes, but I shoot graduations with the Z6II so clearly something in there works.
I just had my 50th HS reunion weekend. There was a team of photographers hired for the whole weekend. This school is first rate and doesn't skimp on things. They hired a well known and respected photography company. They all shot with Z6IIs. They turned in hundreds of excellent shots taken under a wide variety of conditions, and activities. Including a night time football game under the lights.
They certainly didn't experience a train wreck. So, I must assume that they understood the equipment, and how to use it in a quality professional manner. I am sure they would not risk their good reputation by using train wreck equipment.
I am with JadeWriter on this. Pictures are worth thousands of Forum words.....
AdaptedLenses wrote:
It’s borders aren’t anything to write home about either. What lenses are you using from Sony besides the 24-105?
RoamingScott wroteShotokan wroteThis video by Nigel Danson, a UK landscape photographer, argues for the 24-200mm z lens, especially for hiking. He also owns and regularly uses the 24-70 f4 and 24-70 f2.8 lenses. Until recently, he relied on the 24-70 f4 almost exclusively for his woodland photography and he was pleased with the results.I can see the 24-200 being more appealing on the Z6, but I'd rather have F4 at 120mm and crop as needed on the Z7ii. You start to lose light on this lens at 35mm, and you're already down to f/6 by 70mm.
Definitely could get great shots midday, though, in one convenient lens.
20 1.8, 85 1.8, 90 macro, 100-400gm, had the 16-35gm and didn't find myself using it, nor did i find it remarkable, enough to keep.
The 24-105 is a banger of a lens...but, given what I've seen with these two Nikon S lenses, I anticipate the 24-120 to beat it handily.
1bwana1 wrote:
I am with JadeWriter on this. Pictures are worth thousands of Forum words.....
Marcus himself said the AF system is more fiddly than it should be, and that area AF is simply not to be trusted. In the land of A7/A1/R5/R6 AF that essentially reads your mind, this is troublesome and worthy of discussion.
The Z7ii AF system reminds me very much of the Sony A7R3 where wide mode was a crap shoot, but flex spot was handily reliable.
If Nikon manages to push one last AF update to the Z6/7 and can bring their AF up to A7R4 levels, that would be a tremendous win. I don't think they will, nor do I think that the hardware can even support it.
I have zero doubt that I could get amazing images with a Z camera. I've done it on plenty of lesser cameras for years. The point is...do I want to? Are the shortcomings of the Z AF system enough to disqualify it against a modern competitor? I think the answer is a solid maybe. AF is very important, especially when you've grown your skills into a system that supports the kind of shooting you do.
I have serious doubts, for instance, that any Z short of the Z9 could get a decent dragonfly in flight shot, and even my "lowly" R4 handled that.
Yeah I basically just override the camera if I have to. At least it's easier for me to override the camera. Photograph a dog just sitting there on the RIV and witness how it's going to default to the hair in front of the eyes even if the AF point is squarely on the dog eye. I have seen the RIV have problems with basic flowers so nothings perfect. It's a lot easier to dive into MF and correct it out on Nikon than it is on Sony, but I think I just don't have numerous years on nothing but Sony so I'm just used to not letting the camera do random things also have years of Nikon muscle memory. Me and Scott basically have what's like the opposite experiences to this. I have also never tried photographing a flying dragonfly and I'd probably hate that on the Z6II. I do have a few hummingbird and hummingbird moths with the RIV that would probably be stress with the Z6II so it kind of feels like right tool for the right job sort of argument. Perched birds I'm basically fine with Nikon Z, flying ones...I better have more than one chance to get the shot because you really have to wrestle the things.