fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4

  
 
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.15 #1Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
fsi22 wrote:
tzhang4284 wrote
Buckeye2604 wrote
tzhang4284 wroteRight, cause it's the Sony users making bold statements like "You'll have to live with it - Nikon currently has the best value proposition in the ML market" or trying to validate their gear decisions with cherry picked data points.
Didn’t you just write a page worth of bold statements that included this gem:
“a mediocre 50mm f1.2 (compared to Sony and Canon)“
Not bold when it’s true - go see the lenstip.con comparisons.
Sony shooter myself, but that’s some selective reading. Lenstip review is excellent and highlights that Nikon went a different route, by choosing character/ rendering / bokeh over sharpness and they implicitly say as bokeh is subjective, that may be risky , and wondered if it’s complexity and size would be an issue. They also never called that lens mediocre, no photographer would, the 50 1.2s is a stunning lens, for my taste, it has the most beautiful rendering between the Canon, Nikon and Sony options. Stay classy


Why can't there be more of these level headed posts?
Dec 31, 2021 at 10:13 PM
Ludvig83
Offline
Details
p.15 #2Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
I decided to read the article and it’s not clear cut as you say. The author clearly shows strengths for both lenses and it all depends on your needs. I own both Sony and Nikon and I chose the 50 1.2s for the strengths that the article mentioned as well because I want to record video with it. Minimal distortion, less vignetting and minimal focus breathing when compared to the GM are strengths for my needs and difficult to correct vs still photography. The slightly lower peak sharpness is certainly not a hindrance for video.

One article is not the end all and everybody has different needs. It’s important to read strengths and weaknesses of lenses to make sure you get the correct lens that you need vs straight up saying this lens is better or mediocre especially if sharpness is heavily weighted in an opinion.

tzhang4284 wrote:
Buckeye2604 wrote
tzhang4284 wroteRight, cause it's the Sony users making bold statements like "You'll have to live with it - Nikon currently has the best value proposition in the ML market" or trying to validate their gear decisions with cherry picked data points.
Didn’t you just write a page worth of bold statements that included this gem:
“a mediocre 50mm f1.2 (compared to Sony and Canon)“
Not bold when it’s true - go see the lenstip.con comparisons.

Dec 31, 2021 at 10:20 PM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.15 #3Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
So who won? 🤔
Dec 31, 2021 at 10:47 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.15 #4Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
The computer keyboard. Not whomever is taking part in the current digital dick measuring contest.
saaketham wrote:
So who won? 🤔


Dec 31, 2021 at 10:49 PM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.15 #5Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
Arguments over who has the better looking mini vans (long mid rage zooms) aren’t very interesting. I’ll just keep pixel peeping my APO primes. 😁😛
Dec 31, 2021 at 11:11 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.15 #6Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
All I know tonight is my whiskey is better than your whiskey. I love Nikon and Sony. Some of y’all idiots, not so much.
Dec 31, 2021 at 11:17 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #7Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
You and your new DSLR, since you don’t have to argue about this crap with us

saaketham wrote:
So who won? 🤔

Dec 31, 2021 at 11:31 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #8Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
Good point about sharpness. I’d take the Canon 135/2 over the Sony 135 GM because I find the clinical sharpness of the Sony highly unappealing. Taste wins over any objective metrics when it comes to lenses.

Ludvig83 wrote:
I decided to read the article and it’s not clear cut as you say. The author clearly shows strengths for both lenses and it all depends on your needs. I own both Sony and Nikon and I chose the 50 1.2s for the strengths that the article mentioned as well because I want to record video with it. Minimal distortion, less vignetting and minimal focus breathing when compared to the GM are strengths for my needs and difficult to correct vs still photography. The slightly lower peak sharpness is certainly not a hindrance for video.

One article is not the
...Show more →
tzhang4284 wrote
Buckeye2604 wrote
tzhang4284 wroteRight, cause it's the Sony users making bold statements like "You'll have to live with it - Nikon currently has the best value proposition in the ML market" or trying to validate their gear decisions with cherry picked data points.
Didn’t you just write a page worth of bold statements that included this gem:
“a mediocre 50mm f1.2 (compared to Sony and Canon)“
Not bold when it’s true - go see the lenstip.con comparisons.

Dec 31, 2021 at 11:33 PM
osv2
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #9Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
Buckeye2604 wrote:
osv2 wrote
Buckeye2604 wroteI’m convinced Sony users favorite pastime is racking focus from MFD to infinity as fast as possible. Focus motor discussion really gets that group aroused.
it's a technology/performance thing, and given the glacial speed of nikon innovation, it's understandable that nikon owners don't get it.

Buckeye2604 wroteI know there’s a list of lenses that support the A1 30fps. Has Nikon said if any of the S line lenses won’t keep up at 30fps or even 120fps? Are there any tests showing otherwise?
where is the z9 30fps lens compatibility list? canon and sony both have it for the r3/a1.
From what I’ve read all Z mount lenses are compatible but I’m sure more info will be obtained with the Z9 now in the wild.


true, without a z9 30fps compatibility list from nikon people will have to rely on outside sources like this jared polin video.

in reference to what i posted earlier, see where he comments at length that the "s" lenses with one focus motor have slower focusing speeds than the dual focus motor lenses, and how specific nikon lenses compare to sony/canon focusing speeds; that is important for shooting sports, among other things, so it probably won't matter much for many people, but nikon has positioned the z9 as a d5/d6 replacement.



Jan 01, 2022 at 01:43 PM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.15 #10Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
I don’t like the recent approach of making lenses that are perfect, biting sharp etc

Sony began well on GM line with 85 and 24, but then they started producing these clinical lenses, aberration less, perfect chart beaters.


RoamingScott wrote:
Good point about sharpness. I’d take the Canon 135/2 over the Sony 135 GM because I find the clinical sharpness of the Sony highly unappealing. Taste wins over any objective metrics when it comes to lenses.

Ludvig83 wroteI decided to read the article and it’s not clear cut as you say. The author clearly shows strengths for both lenses and it all depends on your needs. I own both Sony and Nikon and I chose the 50 1.2s for the strengths that the article mentioned as well because I want to record video with it. Minimal distortion, less vignetting and minimal focus breathing when compared to the GM are strengths for my needs and difficult to correct vs still photography. The slightly lower peak sharpness is certainly not a hindrance for video.

One article is not the end all and everybody has different needs. It’s important to read strengths and weaknesses of lenses to make sure you get the correct lens that you need vs straight up saying this lens is better or mediocre especially if sharpness is heavily weighted in an opinion.

tzhang4284 wrote
Buckeye2604 wrote
tzhang4284 wroteRight, cause it's the Sony users making bold statements like "You'll have to live with it - Nikon currently has the best value proposition in the ML market" or trying to validate their gear decisions with cherry picked data points.
Didn’t you just write a page worth of bold statements that included this gem:
“a mediocre 50mm f1.2 (compared to Sony and Canon)“
Not bold when it’s true - go see the lenstip.con comparisons.



Edited on Jan 01, 2022 at 04:12 PM · View previous versions
Jan 01, 2022 at 02:31 PM
osv2
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #11Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
1bwana1 wrote:
This thread isn't even about which system is better at this stage in each systems development.

It is about a single member of the FM community who is looking for the best system for him. Scott has recently experimented with other systems as well. At a minimum that indicates to me that there is something in Scott's Sony system that is not fully satisfying him. He has decided to sell his Sony system equipment and try the Nikon system. Each of us would likely make different choices for different reasons. That is appropriate and expected.

Scott has been a valuable contributor
...Show more →

i don't care why he's a serial platform switcher, i do value his point-by-point impressions and i'm glad he posted it, so it's not about that, it's about his blatantly false claims like "The flagship A7R4 got 0 feature update", when in fact the a7riv got firmware updates that included at least two feature updates.

he continued to troll sony and the a7riv firmware updates with a failed comparison to canon r3 eye control af, which was obviously not a firmware update, that was really stupid lol, and he claimed that fuji has "kaizen", which it doesn't, as someone else pointed out the "kaizen" that fuji supposedly had years ago was marketing drivel to hide incompetence.

those things aren't arguments about his decision to switch platforms, it's arguments over his false claims.
Jan 01, 2022 at 02:57 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #12Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
osv2 wrote:
1bwana1 wroteThis thread isn't even about which system is better at this stage in each systems development.

It is about a single member of the FM community who is looking for the best system for him. Scott has recently experimented with other systems as well. At a minimum that indicates to me that there is something in Scott's Sony system that is not fully satisfying him. He has decided to sell his Sony system equipment and try the Nikon system. Each of us would likely make different choices for different reasons. That is appropriate and expected.

Scott has been a valuable contributor to FM and the Sony forums in particular. Rather than argue with him about his decision we should be wishing him the best going forward.

Yes, Scott has a checked past, and a reputation for being a bit camera and lens promiscuous. But none of us are angels and we shouldn't judge. LoL
i don't care why he's a serial platform switcher, i do value his point-by-point impressions and i'm glad he posted it, so it's not about that, it's about his blatantly false claims like "The flagship A7R4 got 0 feature update", when in fact the a7riv got firmware updates that included at least two feature updates.

he continued to troll sony and the a7riv firmware updates with a failed comparison to canon r3 eye control af, which was obviously not a firmware update, that was really stupid lol, and he claimed that fuji has "kaizen", which it doesn't, as someone else
...Show more →

Sony Real Time Eye AF

IS

NOT

EYE

CONTROLLED

AF

Literally no one but you in this thread is talking about the R3.
Jan 01, 2022 at 03:19 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.15 #13Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
nandadevieast wrote:
Best Sony lenses:

FE 28
FE 55
24 GM
ZA 50/1.4
50 GM
85 GM
90 G


After seeing this list, all I've got to say is I feel sorry for the people at Sony responsible for lens development choices (and that you seem to enjoy LoCA ) ...

Jan 01, 2022 at 03:37 PM
Holger
Offline
Details
p.15 #14Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
RoamingScott wrote:
I don’t think it is. Just look how Sony shooters will gladly upgrade to the latest and greatest for a seemingly small bump of features like red AF boxes, intervalometer, or menu improvements. I’ve only had 1 Sony body that got any sort of meaningful update. Fuji, Canon, and Nikon consistently improve their modern bodies via FW. Sony sends their bodies to die.

The flagship A7R4 got 0 feature updates. It’s essentially now end of life.

tctmp wrote
RoamingScott wroteThe fact that Sony locked colored AF points to newer bodies tells you everything you need to know about how Sony views their customers.

tylerdurden801 wroteI just rented a Z7II for a week with the 24-70 2.8, and in my testing I didn't find much in it, IQ wise. I liked having ISO 64, but found high ISO noise more pleasant on my RIII. The lens I rented was a dud, sadly, so it made comparing IQ harder as the left side was noticeably decentered. I didn't love the menu system, found the EVF's to be a wash, same with the ergos. The things I learned I really wanted are things that newer Sony bodies have. A colored AF point, better touch controls and a better rear screen. I also really want a shutter that closes when the camera is off, which doesn't have anything to do with the Z7, but still. The only things I found that were clear improvements is the IBIS and video quality. In the end, jumping ship and all that comes with it doesn't seem worth it to me, but everyone's different.
That's too strong a statement. Nikon used to not provide any meaningful firmware enhancements until a couple of years ago when it's clear that it's losing market share left and right, and started to promise firmware updates before they are ready to hold onto customers.


Hmm. I thought you wanted to be above fanboyism. But this comment destroyed that. This comment is ridiculous, to be honest. Sad.
Jan 01, 2022 at 03:54 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.15 #15Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
Cool, thanks for your input.

Holger wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI don’t think it is. Just look how Sony shooters will gladly upgrade to the latest and greatest for a seemingly small bump of features like red AF boxes, intervalometer, or menu improvements. I’ve only had 1 Sony body that got any sort of meaningful update. Fuji, Canon, and Nikon consistently improve their modern bodies via FW. Sony sends their bodies to die.

The flagship A7R4 got 0 feature updates. It’s essentially now end of life.

tctmp wrote
RoamingScott wroteThe fact that Sony locked colored AF points to newer bodies tells you everything you need to know about how Sony views their customers.

tylerdurden801 wroteI just rented a Z7II for a week with the 24-70 2.8, and in my testing I didn't find much in it, IQ wise. I liked having ISO 64, but found high ISO noise more pleasant on my RIII. The lens I rented was a dud, sadly, so it made comparing IQ harder as the left side was noticeably decentered. I didn't love the menu system, found the EVF's to be a wash, same with the ergos. The things I learned I really wanted are things that newer Sony bodies have. A colored AF point, better touch controls and a better rear screen. I also really want a shutter that closes when the camera is off, which doesn't have anything to do with the Z7, but still. The only things I found that were clear improvements is the IBIS and video quality. In the end, jumping ship and all that comes with it doesn't seem worth it to me, but everyone's different.
That's too strong a statement. Nikon used to not provide any meaningful firmware enhancements until a couple of years ago when it's clear that it's losing market share left and right, and started to promise firmware updates before they are ready to hold onto customers.
Hmm. I thought you wanted to be above fanboyism. But this comment destroyed that. This comment is ridiculous, to be honest. Sad.

Jan 01, 2022 at 04:04 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.15 #16Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
Can we lock this thread yet?
Jan 01, 2022 at 04:07 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.15 #17Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
nandadevieast wrote:
I don’t like the recent approach of making lenses that are perfect, biting sharp etc

Sony began well on GM line with 85 and 24, but then they started producing these clinical lenses, aberration less, perfect chart beaters.

I think lowly FE 28 F2 is a much better lens than 35 GM, not technically, but in my hands at least. If you search FE 28 images on Flickr, you may agree. One of the best lenses Sony have done, maybe that punchy center with softer corners wide open give a unique look to images.

Sharpness has become a bit like
...Show more →
RoamingScott wroteGood point about sharpness. I’d take the Canon 135/2 over the Sony 135 GM because I find the clinical sharpness of the Sony highly unappealing. Taste wins over any objective metrics when it comes to lenses.

Ludvig83 wroteI decided to read the article and it’s not clear cut as you say. The author clearly shows strengths for both lenses and it all depends on your needs. I own both Sony and Nikon and I chose the 50 1.2s for the strengths that the article mentioned as well because I want to record video with it. Minimal distortion, less vignetting and minimal focus breathing when compared to the GM are strengths for my needs and difficult to correct vs still photography. The slightly lower peak sharpness is certainly not a hindrance for video.

One article is not the end all and everybody has different needs. It’s important to read strengths and weaknesses of lenses to make sure you get the correct lens that you need vs straight up saying this lens is better or mediocre especially if sharpness is heavily weighted in an opinion.

tzhang4284 wrote
Buckeye2604 wrote
tzhang4284 wroteRight, cause it's the Sony users making bold statements like "You'll have to live with it - Nikon currently has the best value proposition in the ML market" or trying to validate their gear decisions with cherry picked data points.
Didn’t you just write a page worth of bold statements that included this gem:
“a mediocre 50mm f1.2 (compared to Sony and Canon)“
Not bold when it’s true - go see the lenstip.con comparisons.


No right or wrong answer here since it is personal preference. But to me I would rather have the optically sharper lens in 2022 because the results look better when I want to soften something in post. Instead of trying to make something look sharper in post that was softer. To my eye it just doesn't look as natural. I also think it helps if you are cropping heavily. But again personal opinion. No right answer here. Luckily we have so many lenses to choose from both bases are covered.
Jan 01, 2022 at 04:12 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.15 #18Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
AdaptedLenses wrote:
Can we lock this thread yet?


No reason to do that.

Jan 01, 2022 at 04:16 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.15 #19Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
1bwana1 wrote:
AdaptedLenses wroteCan we lock this thread yet?
No reason to do that.



Sony rats?

Or at least remove it from Sony forum ...

Edited on Jan 01, 2022 at 04:25 PM · View previous versions
Jan 01, 2022 at 04:24 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.15 #20Comparing Z7ii to my Sony A7R4
I tend to like different lens characteristics for different usages.

I really am impressed by the astounding level of sharpness and detail captured by both the 35mm 1.4 GM, and the 50mm 1.2 GM lenses. These are what I use when doing certain types of images. They deliver really impressive image quality, are not too large, have amazing focus accuracy and speed due to their linear motors.

I also have lenses that I purchased based on their unique personalities in rendering. Primarily these types of lenses tend to be manual focus Cosina Voigtlander lenses. I really like the CV line of native lenses both for the shooting experience, and the images they deliver.

There is a place in my bag for all of them. Which one I pull out depends on my mood, the subject, and the image I am creating. I feel blessed to be able to have so many native choices for my system.
Jan 01, 2022 at 04:25 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister