p.14 #1Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Steve Spencer wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI received my lens this morning (black VM version). The lens box was relatively large but the lens inside was surprisingly small (much smaller than I had imagined when opening the box). The handling is pretty much perfect and my lens has infinity focus hard stop at the perfect place with my Rayqual adapter. When focusing far away (e.g. 100m or more) I can use hard infinity as is which makes it easy to use.
I did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.Hi Juha,
Thanks again for providing the first shots, and as usual they are very helpful. I am hopeful this lens will work well on both the Sony and Leica M. Looks great so far.
Thanks Steve! Yes, I think it should work pretty well on Sony too based on my very initial testing. I'll share some more samples later this week when I've had more time to shoot.
p.14 #2Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
rscheffler wrote:
Knowing what I know now, and if I was to start over again, I think I'd be happy with pretty much an all-VM lineup. 21/3.5 should be close enough to the 21 SEM, 28/2, 50/1.5 and/or 50 APO and this 90/2.8. For 35 I'd probably keep the VM35/1.7 over the 35 APO and maybe get the Vintage Line 35/2 Type II (tabbed) for a compact 35 along the lines of the Light Lens Lab 35 Cron v1 replica. Only things missing are a faster 28 and 90, but not absolutely necessary for my current needs.
Agree. VC line of lenses are quite special now. 40mm f1.2 is very good too though M doesn't have 40mm frame line. I would have settled with 35 and 50 APO if I dont have 50APO M and 35 ASPH FLE. and definitely this 90 if I want a M APO set. I am not growing my M lens anymore. I just keep shooting them on 24M M. I don't really use M much during day to day shooting. If there are still some complains about VC glasses, first is ergo that is all over the place. 75mm looks very different than 35/40/50mm f1.2 or 35/50APO. And this 90 add another flavor in additional to all those type I, II, III
And then, the coverage constrain (cat eye) on corner are prone to show up more with VC glasses as well. I know size and weight are priority but I can't keep not thinking or looking for it once I noticed it.
---------------------------------------------
Juha Kannisto wrote: zhangyue wroteThank you as always, Juha.
The lens looks great, I would have ordered it if I dont have 75mm Noct. I have to say these two are overlap to me. If not consider minor weight difference, one has speed the other has size and better color control. I would say f1.5 is a little more important for me and I don't want two manual focus mid tele lenses.
The color looks great, sharpness should be great too. In term of "look", I like it but dont feel it is 'that' special. Again, my opinion is still valid that most 85-90mm lens at f2.8 will look decent if not great.
I might get sigma 90mm personally. my first copy suck so I decide wait for this one or next batch. I have to say a small AF 90mm match my need better.Thanks! I have Sigma 90/2.8 DG DN for E-mount as well and the CV is pretty much overlapping with it, I'm thinking of using the Sigma when I need AF and CV when I prefer using MF. Sigma has the benefit of 0.5m minimum focus distance. I much prefer the MF experience on the CV as focus throw on the Sigma is very long and there's not way to adjust it for the E-mount version... I think I understand what you mean by the "look" of 85-90/2.8 lenses.
I also have Konica M-Hexanon 90/2.8 and Minolta M-Rokkor 90/4 but I haven't used those so actively recently.
I also have CV 75/1.5 VM and 75/2.5 Color-Heliar (LTM) as well. My 75/1.5 has some focus creep (the lens doesn't stay at set focus distance when I walk around with it and it tends to extend by itself while I walk which annoys me a bit) and I feel I may prefer using these 90/2.8 lenses more frequently thanks to their slightly smaller/lighter size & weight....Show more →
Haha, you have lots of glasses. I dare not to mention I have 85D, 85OTUS, 85ZE, 100APOR, 85art L mount, 100cron S etc....So no, definitely will add sigma 90
p.14 #3Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Juha Kannisto wrote: freaklikeme wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI received my lens this morning (black VM version). The lens box was relatively large but the lens inside was surprisingly small (much smaller than I had imagined when opening the box). The handling is pretty much perfect and my lens has infinity focus hard stop at the perfect place with my Rayqual adapter. When focusing far away (e.g. 100m or more) I can use hard infinity as is which makes it easy to use.
I did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.Sweet! Thanks for posting the samples, Juha. Now I'm even more excited. Have you tried any backlit shots or anything with the sun in the frame?Thanks! I didn't really test backlit shots or anything with the sun in the frame yet. I think 90mm lenses are not great at shooting towards the sun in general but I'll try to get some samples like that later this week when I have more time to shoot again.
I know it's not typically the forte of the short teles, but, since Cosina is partially responsible for the excellent performance of the Loxia 85, I'm hoping this lens, like the Loxia, will be an exception. Thanks in advance for indulging my curiosity.
p.14 #4Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
...
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.
Ripolini wrote:
However I'm not convinced by the border performance in a couple of shots ...
Here are few crops from the samples Juha provided so kindly.
The foreground out-of-focus rendition is rather harsh, nervous, particularly in planes just above the focus plane.
Some CA, probably removable in PP, is also detectable at the border of oof bright objects (e.g. see the scooter picture #4).
I don't know if this is a sample-dependent behavior, or if it's typical of the lens design.
I would love seeing some landscape oriented shots to check if the issue is equally present.
p.14 #5Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
I received an e-mail from Camerquest about 15 minutes ago that my lens was shipping tomorrow Priority Mail Express. So hopefully my lens will be delivered Friday or Saturday or Monday at the latest.
p.14 #6Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Ripolini wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
...
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.Ripolini wroteHowever I'm not convinced by the border performance in a couple of shots ...Here are few crops from the samples Juha provided so kindly.
The foreground out-of-focus rendition is rather harsh, nervous, particularly in planes just above the focus plane.
Some CA, probably removable in PP, is also detectable at the border of oof bright objects (e.g. see the scooter picture #4).
I don't know if this is a sample-dependent behavior, or if it's typical of the lens design.
I would love seeing some landscape oriented shots to check if the issue is equally present.
Thanks for the crops. Yes, focus transition does not seem smooth for the foreground. The good new is that this usually benefits background rendering. So we could have smooth transition there.
The new ones were taken at f2.8 & f5.6 and a couple were shot with sun somewhere in the frame (partly obscured). Hard to judge so far how strong it is when shooting against the light as I don't usually shoot towards the sun with my tele lenses. It could get overwhelmed if there was too much sun in the frame but I think it's normal and it was very bright today.
p.14 #8Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I added 58 new SOOC samples (taken today with my Sony A7C) to the same Album that also contains the original ones as well: https://photos.app.goo.gl/wnyX1gEEUBaxcsPBA
The new ones were taken at f2.8 & f5.6 and a couple were shot with sun somewhere in the frame (partly obscured). Hard to judge so far how strong it is when shooting against the light as I don't usually shoot towards the sun with my tele lenses. It could get overwhelmed if there was too much sun in the frame but I think it's normal and it was very bright today.
Thanks! These latest ones are really helpful to me. Sharp. great color. Great tones.
p.14 #9Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I added 58 new SOOC samples (taken today with my Sony A7C) to the same Album that also contains the original ones as well: https://photos.app.goo.gl/wnyX1gEEUBaxcsPBA
The new ones were taken at f2.8 & f5.6 and a couple were shot with sun somewhere in the frame (partly obscured). Hard to judge so far how strong it is when shooting against the light as I don't usually shoot towards the sun with my tele lenses. It could get overwhelmed if there was too much sun in the frame but I think it's normal and it was very bright today.
Thanks for doing that, Juha. It looks good. No ghosts with shots where older 85's and 90's would show them and the worst of the veiling flare (the tree behind the rod iron fence) looks to be recoverable with some work in post. All-in-all, it's looking like it might replace my Nikon 85/1.8D for landscapes and panos. I don't think my F-mount will arrive until mid-to-late December, so thanks for letting me live vicariously through your excellent shots.
p.14 #10Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
freaklikeme wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI added 58 new SOOC samples (taken today with my Sony A7C) to the same Album that also contains the original ones as well: https://photos.app.goo.gl/wnyX1gEEUBaxcsPBA
The new ones were taken at f2.8 & f5.6 and a couple were shot with sun somewhere in the frame (partly obscured). Hard to judge so far how strong it is when shooting against the light as I don't usually shoot towards the sun with my tele lenses. It could get overwhelmed if there was too much sun in the frame but I think it's normal and it was very bright today.Thanks for doing that, Juha. It looks good. No ghosts with shots where older 85's and 90's would show them and the worst of the veiling flare (the tree behind the rod iron fence) looks to be recoverable with some work in post. All-in-all, it's looking like it might replace my Nikon 85/1.8D for landscapes and panos. I don't think my F-mount will arrive until mid-to-late December, so thanks for letting me live vicariously through your excellent shots.
Hi Brad,
Sorry yours will arrive so late. My M-mount version has been picked up by USPS and is scheduled for delivery on Saturday by 6:00 PM.
Cameraquest shows the lens in F-mount is now in stock:
p.14 #11Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
naturephoto1 wrote: freaklikeme wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI added 58 new SOOC samples (taken today with my Sony A7C) to the same Album that also contains the original ones as well: https://photos.app.goo.gl/wnyX1gEEUBaxcsPBA
The new ones were taken at f2.8 & f5.6 and a couple were shot with sun somewhere in the frame (partly obscured). Hard to judge so far how strong it is when shooting against the light as I don't usually shoot towards the sun with my tele lenses. It could get overwhelmed if there was too much sun in the frame but I think it's normal and it was very bright today.Thanks for doing that, Juha. It looks good. No ghosts with shots where older 85's and 90's would show them and the worst of the veiling flare (the tree behind the rod iron fence) looks to be recoverable with some work in post. All-in-all, it's looking like it might replace my Nikon 85/1.8D for landscapes and panos. I don't think my F-mount will arrive until mid-to-late December, so thanks for letting me live vicariously through your excellent shots.Hi Brad,
Sorry yours will arrive so late. My M-mount version has been picked up by USPS and is scheduled for delivery on Saturday by 6:00 PM.
Cameraquest shows the lens in F-mount is now in stock:
Thanks, Rich. I ordered locally, knowing it would take a little more time. I so rarely order lenses brand new, I wanted to throw my business to the shop where I buy my film.
p.14 #12Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
I strongly suspect that these are from the camera used and specifically due to its sensor shake (aka IBIS) mechanism.
Ripolini wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
...
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.Ripolini wroteHowever I'm not convinced by the border performance in a couple of shots ...Here are few crops from the samples Juha provided so kindly.
The foreground out-of-focus rendition is rather harsh, nervous, particularly in planes just above the focus plane.
Some CA, probably removable in PP, is also detectable at the border of oof bright objects (e.g. see the scooter picture #4).
I don't know if this is a sample-dependent behavior, or if it's typical of the lens design.
I would love seeing some landscape oriented shots to check if the issue is equally present.
p.14 #14Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
realVivek wrote:
I strongly suspect that these are from the camera used and specifically due to its sensor shake (aka IBIS) mechanism.
Ripolini wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI did a little walk with my Sony A7C and the new lens this afternoon around Ebisu/Tokyo and took some sample shots.
...
All were taken at f2.8 or f4. Close range shots at f2.8 and most of the long range building shots at f4. I think this lens works very well on Sony A7C too and I didn't notice any field curvature caused by the sensor stack.Ripolini wroteHowever I'm not convinced by the border performance in a couple of shots ...Here are few crops from the samples Juha provided so kindly.
The foreground out-of-focus rendition is rather harsh, nervous, particularly in planes just above the focus plane.
Some CA, probably removable in PP, is also detectable at the border of oof bright objects (e.g. see the scooter picture #4).
I don't know if this is a sample-dependent behavior, or if it's typical of the lens design.
I would love seeing some landscape oriented shots to check if the issue is equally present.
Cheers,
Riccardo
Can you say more? I have never heard or seen that IBIS can cause harsh bokeh. It should be easy to document that it does by just showing the difference with IBIS turned on and off. Do you have pictures or a link where this has been demonstrated.
p.14 #15Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
I will leave that up to Juha-san to check.
I do not see that kind of nervous OOF effect so far (only few hours in my hand). I do not have an A7c and also I never share OOC jpegs from any camera.
[before the advent of IBIS, OIS is documented to cause nervy OOF areas when the camera is on a stable tripod, for example. Yes, such things are known.]
p.14 #16Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
realVivek wrote:
I will leave that up to Juha-san to check.
I do not see that kind of nervous OOF effect so far (only few hours in my hand). I do not have an A7c and also I never share OOC jpegs from any camera.
[before the advent of IBIS, OIS is documented to cause nervy OOF areas when the camera is on a stable tripod, for example. Yes, such things are known.]
I did use IBIS on my A7C set to 90mm on all of my samples. Everything was shot handheld without using a tripod (with electronic / silent shutter). I'll try to recreate some similar shots that were referred to as showing nervous OOF area in front of focus plane with IBIS on and off.
p.14 #17Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
realVivek wrote:
I have the F mount lens since yesterday and it appears to be a keeper.
...
Needs more investigation.
Thanks. Me too would love using the 90/2.8 Apo on Z6.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I did use IBIS on my A7C set to 90mm on all of my samples. Everything was shot handheld without using a tripod (with electronic / silent shutter). I'll try to recreate some similar shots that were referred to as showing nervous OOF area in front of focus plane with IBIS on and off.
Thank you. It will be an important test to understand the lens behavior.
p.14 #19Pre-order: Voigtlander APO-SKOPAR 90mm f/2.8 VM and F-mount
Ripolini wrote: realVivek wroteI have the F mount lens since yesterday and it appears to be a keeper.
...
Needs more investigation.Thanks. Me too would love using the 90/2.8 Apo on Z6.
Juha Kannisto wroteI did use IBIS on my A7C set to 90mm on all of my samples. Everything was shot handheld without using a tripod (with electronic / silent shutter). I'll try to recreate some similar shots that were referred to as showing nervous OOF area in front of focus plane with IBIS on and off.Thank you. It will be an important test to understand the lens behavior.
I took 2 pairs of photos that are pretty similar to 2 shots from the original set that showed nervousness in front of focus plane: https://photos.app.goo.gl/wzkpXgq8SYK75jPs8
These are again SOOC JPEGs from my A7C where the only difference in settings was IBIS between the pairs of shots.
State of IBIS can be confirmed from EXIF data:
Tree shots:
DSC08629.JPG Image Stabilization : Off
DSC08630.JPG Image Stabilization : On
Joël Robuchon Restaurant (yellow building) entrance:
DSC08660.JPG Image Stabilization : On
DSC08661.JPG Image Stabilization : Off
Do you see noticeable differences with regards to OOF area in front of focus plan on these pairs? I could see some differences on the 8660/8661 shots but I'm not sure if IBIS is making so much of a real impact here.
Do you happen to have a picture of the lens mounted on the Z6 and/or an F mount body? I assume it’s very similar in size / handling to my Nikkor-H 50, but would be nice to see the real thing