Anecdotally, for a short while back in the day I shot weddings using NiZn AA's in my canon speedites. No more need for the external battery pack on my belt to get decent charge times between shots. But, they got dangerously hot and I only got some 80 shots if I was lucky before they died completely. Of course these days the flashguns all use Li packs which have solved that problem but literally burning my hand when dropping out batteries mid first dance after far too short a time was the last straw for me.
bemei wrote:
Anecdotally, for a short while back in the day I shot weddings using NiZn AA's in my canon speedites. No more need for the external battery pack on my belt to get decent charge times between shots. But, they got dangerously hot and I only got some 80 shots if I was lucky before they died completely. Of course these days the flashguns all use Li packs which have solved that problem but literally burning my hand when dropping out batteries mid first dance after far too short a time was the last straw for me.
NiZn has been around for a long time but hasn't gained much traction. It's interesting you noticed heat issues. Most advocates of NiZn claim it should have better thermal safety than lithium chemistry. From what little info I can find, NiZn seems to suffer from significantly shorter life cycles compared to NiMH or Li-ion.
NiZn were a dismal failure. The electrolyte is aqueous like other Ni cells, so hazards are mostly to the body if the vent/seal opens due to overpressure. LSD NiMH (Sanyo Eneloop) solved the problems of consumer Ni cells by 2006.
jeffbuzz wrote: bemei wroteAnecdotally, for a short while back in the day I shot weddings using NiZn AA's in my canon speedites. No more need for the external battery pack on my belt to get decent charge times between shots. But, they got dangerously hot and I only got some 80 shots if I was lucky before they died completely. Of course these days the flashguns all use Li packs which have solved that problem but literally burning my hand when dropping out batteries mid first dance after far too short a time was the last straw for me.NiZn has been around for a long time but hasn't gained much traction. It's interesting you noticed heat issues. Most advocates of NiZn claim it should have better thermal safety than lithium chemistry. From what little info I can find, NiZn seems to suffer from significantly shorter life cycles compared to NiMH or Li-ion.
It would get burning (literally) hot during high intensity usage.