fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #1Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Continuing on distortion, how is it with the 24/2 DG DN? The little sister f/3.5 is virtually distortion free.
Oct 04, 2021 at 01:01 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.22 #2Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Juha Kannisto wrote:
jhinkey wrote
jhinkey wroteJust got back from taking some quick hand held comparison shots between the 90/2.8Sig and:
- 85/4ZM
- 90/3.5 CV
- 85/1.8G

I can say that the manual focus experience is mediocre. Build quality is great, but you turn the focus ring forever and very little happens. I suppose that might be good as once you get the focus, minor bumps to the focus ring won't change anything. The focus distance scale in the viewfinder with this lens, as with many lenses, is useless.

Quick full image/center/right/left wide open manually focused.

First glance they are not bad. Haven't checked the corners. Time for dinner.
I must have messed up the focus for the f/4 and f/5.6 shots that followed the f/2.8 shots I showed above as they are less sharp. I re-focused between aperture settings to make sure there was no focus shift going on as the aperture was stopped down.

I must say that I find this lens difficult to accurately manually focus because you turn the ring a lot and hardly anything happens, thus you'll turn it to get to critical focus and then you turn it too much because nothing is happening it seems or at least focus is changing very very slowly.

Also, when in AF mode on my A7RIII at least when you turn the focus ring it doesn't cause the camera to jump into fine AF mode with the + in the middle of the magnified view. Seems this lens will need some firmware updates. I haven't tried it yet with my A7C.
I also feel that the focus throw for MF is too long especially when the ring is turned at a slow speed and it's hard to pick the ideal focus point that way since focus doesn't visibly change much at all when turning the ring several degrees. Therefore I've been using my lens primarily with AF only. The feel of the focus ring is otherwise very nice but a shorter MF throw would be welcome for my use.

I don't have auto-magnification (when turning the focus ring) enabled on my cameras as I don't like that being triggered always when
...Show more →

Glad I'm not the only one that feels this way about the manual focus experience. Can't believe this behavior got out the door from Sigma.

I'll be giving it another go later this afternoon as the weather is good. I'll try to get the manual focus much more accurate. I'll also try a test with using AF instead to see how well it does compared to manual focusing.

More later . . .
Oct 04, 2021 at 02:59 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.22 #3Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
chiron wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHow is distortion with the 90/2.8i? High pincushion distortion is what stops me from getting the 85/1.4 DG DN.
Also, the 90/2.8 is capable of almost twice the magnification of the 85/1.4. (0.2x vs 0.12x)
What was your concern with the 85s distortion? My sense is that it is designed with resolution to “spare” so that after distortion correction it’s still super high rez. Obviously some lenses are at a threshold so they are very sharp before correction but not after, but my sense of the art 85 is that that isn’t a problem. (By sense I mean what I see with my copy without having done careful tests, not having reviewed it)
The 85/1.4 DN DG's pincushion is not mild and although resolution is still great after correction there is always a MTF reduction.
Personally I prefer lenses with low distortion even if the compromise is slightly bigger size.
Sure there is a reduction in resolution from before it was corrected; but I’m not sure there is a reduction compared to how it would be if it was optically corrected and the same size (because optical correction also can reduce MTF)

But sure if you are prepared to have larger size you can probably have optical correction and have resolution as high as the smaller sized one pre-correction. That goes both ways with software correction….when LaCA is corrected, the post correction chart improves!

I think it’d be great if manufacturers have us both pre and post correction MTF charts.
Can anyone provide an example of an image that was harmed in its visual impact and actual use by optical correction? I would be interested to see one or more as examples.


No they can’t, because to do that you would need a lens built to almost the same design, but without optical correction.And that will never happen even if you had access to manufacturers prototypes (because the decision is made before the prototyping stage). You can only see the tradeoff in lens designing software.
Oct 04, 2021 at 04:55 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.22 #4Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I think of distortion correction this way. Optical correction of distortion involves streching parts of the image, which can reduce resolution. We know that a teleconverter, which stretches the whole image can incur a resolution loss, so why wouldn’t optical distortion correction also incur a resolution loss? The difference between digital and optical correction might just be if it’s done optically or digitally, but either way you may have a resolution loss.

Wide angles with optical correction of distortion typically end up with a moustache shape distortion, which is bad for architecture, but not distortion free. Then the moustache ditortion is corrected digitally with a profile in post processing. Is that any better than just doing it digitally in one step?

How different are the end results? Just like @DavidBM says, no one can show you the tradeoffs without lens design software. And those are tradeoffs between hypothetical lens design, since only one is ever likely to make it to becoming an actual product that we can buy.
Oct 04, 2021 at 05:12 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.22 #5Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
Continuing on distortion, how is it with the 24/2 DG DN? The little sister f/3.5 is virtually distortion free.


In their preview lenstip.com makes an assesment, « It seems the Sigma is close to the performance of the Tamron 24 mm f/2.8 Di III OSD M 1:2 which distortion was on a level of -5%.». Link, Sigma C 24 mm f/2 DG DN – first impressions and sample images
Oct 04, 2021 at 05:54 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #6Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
bjornthun wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteContinuing on distortion, how is it with the 24/2 DG DN? The little sister f/3.5 is virtually distortion free.
In their preview lenstip.com makes an assesment, « It seems the Sigma is close to the performance of the Tamron 24 mm f/2.8 Di III OSD M 1:2 which distortion was on a level of -5%.». Link, Sigma C 24 mm f/2 DG DN – first impressions and sample images


"As we've already mentioned distorion – you can notice distinct barrel variant of this aberraion in sample shorts. It seems the Sigma is close to the performance of the Tamron 24 mm f/2.8 Di III OSD M 1:2 which distortion was on a level of -5%. It seems the correction of that aberration really wasn't a priority for Sigma specialists."

That's bad news. So, the 24/3.5 has many advantages: (price, 1:2 macro, smaller size/weight + zero distortion). I wonder if bokeh is also better at f/3.5.
Of course the new 24/2 will offer better subject isolation. (more blur at same distance)
Oct 04, 2021 at 06:36 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.22 #7Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
DavidBM wrote:
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHow is distortion with the 90/2.8i? High pincushion distortion is what stops me from getting the 85/1.4 DG DN.
Also, the 90/2.8 is capable of almost twice the magnification of the 85/1.4. (0.2x vs 0.12x)
What was your concern with the 85s distortion? My sense is that it is designed with resolution to “spare” so that after distortion correction it’s still super high rez. Obviously some lenses are at a threshold so they are very sharp before correction but not after, but my sense of the art 85 is that that isn’t a problem. (By sense I mean what I see with my copy without having done careful tests, not having reviewed it)
The 85/1.4 DN DG's pincushion is not mild and although resolution is still great after correction there is always a MTF reduction.
Personally I prefer lenses with low distortion even if the compromise is slightly bigger size.
Sure there is a reduction in resolution from before it was corrected; but I’m not sure there is a reduction compared to how it would be if it was optically corrected and the same size (because optical correction also can reduce MTF)

But sure if you are prepared to have larger size you can probably have optical correction and have resolution as high as the smaller sized one pre-correction. That goes both ways with software correction….when LaCA is corrected, the post correction chart improves!

I think it’d be great if manufacturers have us both pre and post correction MTF charts.
Can anyone provide an example of an image that was harmed in its visual impact and actual use by optical correction? I would be interested to see one or more as examples.
No they can’t, because to do that you would need a lens built to almost the same design, but without optical correction.And that will never happen even if you had access to manufacturers prototypes (because the decision is made before the prototyping stage). You can only see the tradeoff in lens designing software.


Not at all. I am asking specifically about digital correction of distortion as a process affecting an image.

What I mean is, can you point to a photograph where the effects of digital correction of distortion are visible in diminishing the visual impact of the photograph?

That wouldn't require an impossible comparison of designs (where there would also be a dozen other confounding factors anyway), just a before-and-after-digital correction where >something other< than distortion has been changed to the visible loss of visual impact? (Sometimes the images look better with the distortion left in--that is not the case I mean.)

Since digital distortion of correction alters resolution a little bit in stretched sections of the image, an example might show how this small loss of resolution in parts of the picture altered the visual impact of the photograph. This seems very unlikely to me.

Possibly more likely is an example where the removal of a slight part of the edges because of the digital correction of distortion has reduced the visual impact of the photo. But I would expect such cases to be very few. I don't think I have come across one in my own years of making pictures, but others may of course have done so.

Anyway, if there are such cases, I think it would add some empiricism to the discussion. And if there aren't, that would be an interesting fact.


Oct 04, 2021 at 06:55 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #8Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
bjornthun wrote:
I think of distortion correction this way. Optical correction of distortion involves streching parts of the image, which can reduce resolution. We know that a teleconverter, which stretches the whole image can incur a resolution loss, so why wouldn’t optical distortion correction also incur a resolution loss? The difference between digital and optical correction might just be if it’s done optically or digitally, but either way you may have a resolution loss.

Wide angles with optical correction of distortion typically end up with a moustache shape distortion, which is bad for architecture, but not distortion free. Then the moustache ditortion is
...Show more →

This past weekend, I was talking pictures of a group of four people with my Sigma 45/2.8i which only has mild distortion. The heads closest to the edge of the frame were elongated/distorted due to pincushion distortion. In post, the distortion was 100% corrected without a noticeable reduction in resolution/contrast.
However, even with portraits, when inspecting the in-focus subject closest to the edges at pixel level, I could detect a slight resolution/contrast reduction. This would be even more noticeable if the lens was stopped down for optimal corner performance and the very edges were actually in focus (like in a landscape image).

After correction, I see slightly less 'micro' contrast which would definitely affect the lens MTF performance. So, lenses with higher distortion can offer a great trade-off in terms of optical design complexity, size and price but there is no free lunch.
In this case, almost!
Oct 04, 2021 at 06:59 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.22 #9Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
bjornthun wroteI think of distortion correction this way. Optical correction of distortion involves streching parts of the image, which can reduce resolution. We know that a teleconverter, which stretches the whole image can incur a resolution loss, so why wouldn’t optical distortion correction also incur a resolution loss? The difference between digital and optical correction might just be if it’s done optically or digitally, but either way you may have a resolution loss.

Wide angles with optical correction of distortion typically end up with a moustache shape distortion, which is bad for architecture, but not distortion free. Then the moustache ditortion is corrected digitally with a profile in post processing. Is that any better than just doing it digitally in one step?

How different are the end results? Just like @DavidBM@@ says, no one can show you the tradeoffs without lens design software. And those are tradeoffs between hypothetical lens design, since only one is ever likely to make it to becoming an actual product that we can buy.
This past weekend, I was talking pictures of a group of four people with my Sigma 45/2.8i which only has mild distortion. The heads closest to the edge of the frame were elongated/distorted due to pincushion distortion. After correction, the distortion was 100% corrected without a noticeable reduction in resolution/contrast. However, even with portraits, when inspecting the subject closest to the edges, I could detect a slight resolution/contrast reduction. This would be even more noticeable if the lens was stopped down for optimal corner performance and the very edges were actually in focus (like in a landscape image).

After
...Show more →

So just a penny's worth of difference and even that only on the very edges at 100 percent? Could you see it in a print at viewing distance?

It might also be that the allowed but correctable distortion is related to that lens's beautiful rendering as well as to its size and price. The final package is certainly a great lens.
Oct 04, 2021 at 07:09 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.22 #10Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
DavidBM wrote:
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wroteHow is distortion with the 90/2.8i? High pincushion distortion is what stops me from getting the 85/1.4 DG DN.
Also, the 90/2.8 is capable of almost twice the magnification of the 85/1.4. (0.2x vs 0.12x)
What was your concern with the 85s distortion? My sense is that it is designed with resolution to “spare” so that after distortion correction it’s still super high rez. Obviously some lenses are at a threshold so they are very sharp before correction but not after, but my sense of the art 85 is that that isn’t a problem. (By sense I mean what I see with my copy without having done careful tests, not having reviewed it)
The 85/1.4 DN DG's pincushion is not mild and although resolution is still great after correction there is always a MTF reduction.
Personally I prefer lenses with low distortion even if the compromise is slightly bigger size.
Sure there is a reduction in resolution from before it was corrected; but I’m not sure there is a reduction compared to how it would be if it was optically corrected and the same size (because optical correction also can reduce MTF)

But sure if you are prepared to have larger size you can probably have optical correction and have resolution as high as the smaller sized one pre-correction. That goes both ways with software correction….when LaCA is corrected, the post correction chart improves!

I think it’d be great if manufacturers have us both pre and post correction MTF charts.
Can anyone provide an example of an image that was harmed in its visual impact and actual use by optical correction? I would be interested to see one or more as examples.
No they can’t, because to do that you would need a lens built to almost the same design, but without optical correction.And that will never happen even if you had access to manufacturers prototypes (because the decision is made before the prototyping stage). You can only see the tradeoff in lens designing software.


I just noticed that I miswrote "optical correction" when I meant to write "digital correction." So I think you correctly answered a question I didn't mean to ask! Sorry for the confusion.
Oct 04, 2021 at 07:35 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #11Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
chiron wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
bjornthun wroteI think of distortion correction this way. Optical correction of distortion involves streching parts of the image, which can reduce resolution. We know that a teleconverter, which stretches the whole image can incur a resolution loss, so why wouldn’t optical distortion correction also incur a resolution loss? The difference between digital and optical correction might just be if it’s done optically or digitally, but either way you may have a resolution loss.

Wide angles with optical correction of distortion typically end up with a moustache shape distortion, which is bad for architecture, but not distortion free. Then the moustache ditortion is corrected digitally with a profile in post processing. Is that any better than just doing it digitally in one step?

How different are the end results? Just like @DavidBM@@@ says, no one can show you the tradeoffs without lens design software. And those are tradeoffs between hypothetical lens design, since only one is ever likely to make it to becoming an actual product that we can buy.
This past weekend, I was talking pictures of a group of four people with my Sigma 45/2.8i which only has mild distortion. The heads closest to the edge of the frame were elongated/distorted due to pincushion distortion. After correction, the distortion was 100% corrected without a noticeable reduction in resolution/contrast. However, even with portraits, when inspecting the subject closest to the edges, I could detect a slight resolution/contrast reduction. This would be even more noticeable if the lens was stopped down for optimal corner performance and the very edges were actually in focus (like in a landscape image).

After correction, I see slightly less 'micro' contrast which would definitely affect the lens MTF performance. So, lenses with higher distortion can offer a great trade-off for size and price but there is no free lunch. In this case, almost!
So just a penny's worth of difference and even that only on the very edges at 100 percent? Could you see it in a print at viewing distance?


I doubt it. That's why the ill effects of distortion correction can de dismissed in the case of your scenario. Having said that, I find it annoying to shoot with lenses with high distortion that need to be corrected in post. Subjectively I give more praise to low distortion optical designs.
Oct 04, 2021 at 07:43 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.22 #12Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
chiron wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
bjornthun wroteI think of distortion correction this way. Optical correction of distortion involves streching parts of the image, which can reduce resolution. We know that a teleconverter, which stretches the whole image can incur a resolution loss, so why wouldn’t optical distortion correction also incur a resolution loss? The difference between digital and optical correction might just be if it’s done optically or digitally, but either way you may have a resolution loss.

Wide angles with optical correction of distortion typically end up with a moustache shape distortion, which is bad for architecture, but not distortion free. Then the moustache ditortion is corrected digitally with a profile in post processing. Is that any better than just doing it digitally in one step?

How different are the end results? Just like @DavidBM@@@@ says, no one can show you the tradeoffs without lens design software. And those are tradeoffs between hypothetical lens design, since only one is ever likely to make it to becoming an actual product that we can buy.
This past weekend, I was talking pictures of a group of four people with my Sigma 45/2.8i which only has mild distortion. The heads closest to the edge of the frame were elongated/distorted due to pincushion distortion. After correction, the distortion was 100% corrected without a noticeable reduction in resolution/contrast. However, even with portraits, when inspecting the subject closest to the edges, I could detect a slight resolution/contrast reduction. This would be even more noticeable if the lens was stopped down for optimal corner performance and the very edges were actually in focus (like in a landscape image).

After correction, I see slightly less 'micro' contrast which would definitely affect the lens MTF performance. So, lenses with higher distortion can offer a great trade-off for size and price but there is no free lunch. In this case, almost!
So just a penny's worth of difference and even that only on the very edges at 100 percent? Could you see it in a print at viewing distance?
I doubt it. That's why the ill effects of distortion correction can de dismissed in the case of your scenario. Having said that, I find it annoying to shoot with lenses with high distortion that need to be corrected in post. Subjectively I give more praise to low distortion optical designs.


It annoys you because you see the distortion so clearly when you are composing? Given your eye and sensitivity to image characteristics, that would make sense to me. I rarely notice the distortion until I post-process an image.
Oct 04, 2021 at 08:05 PM
memzinla
Offline
Details
p.22 #13Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Haven't really had a chance to play with the Sigma 24mm F2, so I took some pictures of the plushies. haha

Sigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr

Sigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary test by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr

Sigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr
Oct 04, 2021 at 08:50 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.22 #14Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Dustin Abbott reports a 'minus 11' is needed to correct the pincushion in the 90/2.8, no idea what software was used. But each can decide on this - if turned off in camera, does it show in the EVF for roof lines, wall edges etc?

Here is the image of the basin-like but linear distortion, at 18.09, YT video title:

Sigma 90mm F2.8 DG DN Definitive Review | DA
Oct 04, 2021 at 08:58 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #15Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
philip_pj wrote:
Dustin Abbott reports a 'minus 11' is needed to correct the pincushion in the 90/2.8, no idea what software was used. But each can decide on this - if turned off in camera, does it show in the EVF for roof lines, wall edges etc?

Here is the image of the basin-like but linear distortion, at 18.09, YT video title:

Sigma 90mm F2.8 DG DN Definitive Review | DA


If it's Lightroom, "-11" is not mild pincushion distortion.
Oct 04, 2021 at 09:16 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #16Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
It's confusing because Cameralabs says "barrel" distortion:

"Before taking a close look at the detail I wanted a quick look at geometric distortion starting with the Sigma 90 f2.8 with Distortion Compensation on the Sony A7 III set to OFF, which is the default. With this setting, the Sigma lens exhibits some barrel distortion, so for my in-camera JPEG tests"

https://www.cameralabs.com/sigma-90mm-f2-8-dg-dn-review/



I wish my copy would arrive sooner!
Oct 04, 2021 at 09:20 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.22 #17Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
philip_pj wrote:
Dustin Abbott reports a 'minus 11' is needed to correct the pincushion in the 90/2.8, no idea what software was used. But each can decide on this - if turned off in camera, does it show in the EVF for roof lines, wall edges etc?

Here is the image of the basin-like but linear distortion, at 18.09, YT video title:

Sigma 90mm F2.8 DG DN Definitive Review | DA


I think you would see it. My Nikon 80-200/2.8 has a little less pincushioning at 200mm, and I see it in buildings, fence lines, and trees every time I use it. It bugs me, but then I remind myself I brought the zoom because I needed multiple focal lengths and wouldn't have time to change lenses.

Oct 04, 2021 at 09:38 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.22 #18Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
It's confusing because Cameralabs says "barrel" distortion:

"Before taking a close look at the detail I wanted a quick look at geometric distortion starting with the Sigma 90 f2.8 with Distortion Compensation on the Sony A7 III set to OFF, which is the default. With this setting, the Sigma lens exhibits some barrel distortion, so for my in-camera JPEG tests"

https://www.cameralabs.com/sigma-90mm-f2-8-dg-dn-review/



I wish my copy would arrive sooner!


That's weird. DA was definitely showing pincushion. If they've got test copies floating around with different types of distortion, that would not bode well for quality control. I'm thinking the Cameralabs report is a typo. Or they hired an intern who doesn't know the difference.
Oct 04, 2021 at 09:43 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.22 #19Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
memzinla wrote:
Haven't really had a chance to play with the Sigma 24mm F2, so I took some pictures of the plushies. haha

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51552688329_33ac789c18_k.jpgSigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51551173942_672fce9f61_k.jpgSigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary test by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51552713149_15c6d16b9f_k.jpgSigma 24mm F2 DG DN Contemporary by Guillermo Moreno, on Flickr


I do like the colors in these and what I can see of the rendering!
Oct 04, 2021 at 09:45 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.22 #20Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
freaklikeme wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteIt's confusing because Cameralabs says "barrel" distortion:

"Before taking a close look at the detail I wanted a quick look at geometric distortion starting with the Sigma 90 f2.8 with Distortion Compensation on the Sony A7 III set to OFF, which is the default. With this setting, the Sigma lens exhibits some barrel distortion, so for my in-camera JPEG tests"

https://www.cameralabs.com/sigma-90mm-f2-8-dg-dn-review/



I wish my copy would arrive sooner!
That's weird. DA was definitely showing pincushion. If they've got test copies floating around with different types of distortion, that would not bode well for quality control. I'm thinking the Cameralabs report is a typo. Or they hired an intern who doesn't know the difference.


Perhaps Cameralabs misspoke because it's not likely a telephoto lens would have barrel distortion. Still we don't know for sure the severity of the pincushion distortion. Worse or better than the 85/1.4 DG DN?
Oct 04, 2021 at 09:45 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister