naturephoto1 wrote: Fred Miranda wrotenaturephoto1 wroteMy new Voigtlander 28mm f2 Ultron II lens from Cameraquest was delivered at about 3:15 PM today. That was too late for my running any tests comparing the lens with my Leica R 28mm f2.8 Elmarit V2.
I did take the image below though comparing the sizes of my Leica M 24mm f3.8 Asph lens with Leica hood to the far left, my Minolta CLE MC 28mm f2.8 M-Rokkor (without white spots) and Minolta hood to its right, my new Voigtlander 28mm f2 Ultron II with the Haoge LH-VM12 hood (their replacement for the Voigtlander LH-12 hood) to its right, and my Leica R 28mm f2.8 Elmarit V2 with the hood extended at the far right.
The new Voigtlander 28mm f2 Ultron II is quite small and without the hood, I believe is smaller than the Minolta CLE 28mm M-Rokker lens though it is heavier than the Minolta.
Hopefully tomorrow I will run some tests of the new Voigtlander 28mm f2 Ultron II including confirming the lens is centered. I will test the lens on my Kolari Vision UT sensor modded A7rII and compare the performance of the lens with my Leica R 28mm f2.8 Elmarit V2 on the Kolari UT A7rII and also on my stock A7rIII. I do not intend to test the Voigtlander on my stock A7rIII.
Once I have some of the test results, I plan to post them here.
RichHi Rich,
Which hood are you using for your CV 28/2 II on this picture?Hi Fred,
I am using the Haoge LH-VM12 Bayonet Square Metal Lens Hood:
hmzimelka wrote: Steve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteDavidBM wroteThe transmission is likely less than the aperture, but that doesn’t make it not an f2.4 lens as that just is defined by the (relative) aperture size. It might make it less than T2.4, but that’s a different matter. Nor does off axis falloff affect the aperture - it just affects the sensors view of the aperture, as it were. f2.4 is f2.4.
That’s termininology though. What matters? Well slight reduction of transmission across the field I don’t care about in the slightest. I can’t recall when I last took a wide aperture photo where, say, a stop of transmission reduction pushed the noise levels into unacceptable territory. Off axis mechanical/optical vignetting, OTOH, can make the bokeh very uneven, and is an almost universal problem with compact rangefinder lenses.Yeah.
I'm not claiming that at f/2 the light transmission is the same as f/2.4, measured at the centre. As mentioned there is a centre portion that gets brighter. In theory and on paper it may be f/2, but the high amounts of natural and optical vignetting of the Ultron 28 and 35mm, at least to me, leave an impression that the lens should have mechanically stopped at f/2.4. Opening to f/2 just seems a little redundant and impractical. Most lenses I've used have at least in the greater central area, a more significant light transmission difference from their widest aperture to the next half step down.
Both my Ultron 35 and 28mm can have the same shutter speed at f/2 and f/2.4 that a very large majority of the frame is exposed the same. The difference between my Ultron 35mm at f/2.4 and my Color Skopar 35/2.5 PII is significant enough that I would prefer the Color Skopar even with its nominal f/2.5 aperture.Ok, so we can all agree this is an f/2 lens, or at least I hope we can all agree. I think we can all agree that the lens has strong vignetting when it is not corrected. My lens performs just like the lens that Bastian reviewed. Here is a link to his picture depicting the vignetting:
As you will see there the corners are definitely darkened at f/2 and there is even some darkening on the long edges (but very little to no darkening on the short edges). This tells us there is a circle with a 24mm diameter in the center that does not have significant reduction in illumination. I don't think it is accurate to call that a small section in the center, but call it whatever you want we can describe the actual measurement of the bright area in the center.
Further given this, IMO, rather larger 24mm circle with little to no effect of vignetting I can't see how changing the aperture on your lens from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the shutter speed. If I were you I would investigate both your camera and lens to see if they are functioning properly. Opening up the lens to f/2 from f/2.4 should get you about a 50% increase in shutter speed and that is what I see with my camera (M10) and my copy of the lens. Now I do always use center weighted metering and perhaps you will have better luck if you switch to center weighted metering if you are using something else. Of course one of the advantages of center weighted metering is that it isn't affected very much at all by vignetting when exposure on the outer part of the frame is not much of a concern.
Finally, it should be noted that either six-bit coding this lens or selecting in Lightroom corrections for the Leica 28 summicron, nicely cleans up the vignetting. The majority of my shots using a rangefinder I crop to 4 X 5 aspect ratio, so I don't bother with vignetting correction for most of my shots, but when I need it with this lens it does work quite well with all the usual caveats about increasing noise in the corners.
So, this is a f/2 lens with a lot vignetting. Each individual user will have to decide how much the vignetting bothers them and even whether it is a deal breaker for the lens and if it is not how they want to handle it. Personally, I find it a mild annoyance but not really that big of a deal.Both my lenses and camera are functioning fine. A difference in exposure is absolutely noticable from f/2 to f/2.8. From f/2 to that half step position, which I refer to as f/2.4, the difference is so small that keeping the shutter speed the same results in two images that look identical with exception of little brighter small central area. The 28mm Elmarit that I had, my Color Skopar 35mm, and Summicron 50mm all show a much wider spread affect of exposure with the first half step.
In terms of my attempts at matching brightness at the centre, the difference between f/2 and the half step to f/2.4 on the Ultron 28mm is around 0.25 stop.
I get it, its an f/2 lens because (unverified) the aperture measurement is theoretically wide enough to claim the nominal value. It may or may not be a rounded value too. Who knows. But as much as aperture should be aperture value, so should focal length be focal length. But then we have situations like the Leica Q with its 28mm lens.
Anyways. I suppose I was more questioning the point at which one should accept a claim of a lens being f/2. Suppose the next lens that comes along and claims its f/2, but with a transmission change across an even smaller portion at the dead centre. Still acceptable?
Here are two images shot with the Ultron 28mm. Both have the same shutter speed and ISO value. Aperture was the only thing changed from f/2 to the next half step f/2.4. It would seem this is perfectly acceptable for most. I find it disappointing and pointless that the lens has an f/2 aperture that may technically classify as f/2 but functionally falls short. Again, the difference in brightness in Lightroom is around 0.25 stop to match brightness. Lets even round that up to 0.3. Still a fair bit away from the supposed 0.5 stops at dead centre!
(The lens is in camera coded to the Summicron 28mm ASPH)
1/45sec, f/2.4 https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52368402093_cf205234a1_h.jpgSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.
PS - We also know that in the past Voigtlander has been relatively precise about reporting f numbers. For example they had at one point a 28 f/1.9, and they had a 50 f/1.1, etc. Given that history I think we can expect that any rounding of the aperture value would be small f/2.04 or less.Ok, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.
Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.
I'm not claiming that at f/2 the light transmission is the same as f/2.4, measured at the centre. As mentioned there is a centre portion that gets brighter. In theory and on paper it may be f/2, but the high amounts of natural and optical vignetting of the Ultron 28 and 35mm, at least to me, leave an impression that the lens should have mechanically stopped at f/2.4. Opening to f/2 just seems a little redundant and impractical. Most lenses I've used have at least in the greater central area, a more significant light transmission difference from their widest aperture to the next half step down.
Both my Ultron 35 and 28mm can have the same shutter speed at f/2 and f/2.4 that a very large majority of the frame is exposed the same. The difference between my Ultron 35mm at f/2.4 and my Color Skopar 35/2.5 PII is significant enough that I would prefer the Color Skopar even with its nominal f/2.5 aperture.Ok, so we can all agree this is an f/2 lens, or at least I hope we can all agree. I think we can all agree that the lens has strong vignetting when it is not corrected. My lens performs just like the lens that Bastian reviewed. Here is a link to his picture depicting the vignetting:
As you will see there the corners are definitely darkened at f/2 and there is even some darkening on the long edges (but very little to no darkening on the short edges). This tells us there is a circle with a 24mm diameter in the center that does not have significant reduction in illumination. I don't think it is accurate to call that a small section in the center, but call it whatever you want we can describe the actual measurement of the bright area in the center.
Further given this, IMO, rather larger 24mm circle with little to no effect of vignetting I can't see how changing the aperture on your lens from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the shutter speed. If I were you I would investigate both your camera and lens to see if they are functioning properly. Opening up the lens to f/2 from f/2.4 should get you about a 50% increase in shutter speed and that is what I see with my camera (M10) and my copy of the lens. Now I do always use center weighted metering and perhaps you will have better luck if you switch to center weighted metering if you are using something else. Of course one of the advantages of center weighted metering is that it isn't affected very much at all by vignetting when exposure on the outer part of the frame is not much of a concern.
Finally, it should be noted that either six-bit coding this lens or selecting in Lightroom corrections for the Leica 28 summicron, nicely cleans up the vignetting. The majority of my shots using a rangefinder I crop to 4 X 5 aspect ratio, so I don't bother with vignetting correction for most of my shots, but when I need it with this lens it does work quite well with all the usual caveats about increasing noise in the corners.
So, this is a f/2 lens with a lot vignetting. Each individual user will have to decide how much the vignetting bothers them and even whether it is a deal breaker for the lens and if it is not how they want to handle it. Personally, I find it a mild annoyance but not really that big of a deal.Both my lenses and camera are functioning fine. A difference in exposure is absolutely noticable from f/2 to f/2.8. From f/2 to that half step position, which I refer to as f/2.4, the difference is so small that keeping the shutter speed the same results in two images that look identical with exception of little brighter small central area. The 28mm Elmarit that I had, my Color Skopar 35mm, and Summicron 50mm all show a much wider spread affect of exposure with the first half step.
In terms of my attempts at matching brightness at the centre, the difference between f/2 and the half step to f/2.4 on the Ultron 28mm is around 0.25 stop.
I get it, its an f/2 lens because (unverified) the aperture measurement is theoretically wide enough to claim the nominal value. It may or may not be a rounded value too. Who knows. But as much as aperture should be aperture value, so should focal length be focal length. But then we have situations like the Leica Q with its 28mm lens.
Anyways. I suppose I was more questioning the point at which one should accept a claim of a lens being f/2. Suppose the next lens that comes along and claims its f/2, but with a transmission change across an even smaller portion at the dead centre. Still acceptable?
Here are two images shot with the Ultron 28mm. Both have the same shutter speed and ISO value. Aperture was the only thing changed from f/2 to the next half step f/2.4. It would seem this is perfectly acceptable for most. I find it disappointing and pointless that the lens has an f/2 aperture that may technically classify as f/2 but functionally falls short. Again, the difference in brightness in Lightroom is around 0.25 stop to match brightness. Lets even round that up to 0.3. Still a fair bit away from the supposed 0.5 stops at dead centre!
(The lens is in camera coded to the Summicron 28mm ASPH)
1/45sec, f/2.4 https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52368402093_cf205234a1_h.jpgSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.
PS - We also know that in the past Voigtlander has been relatively precise about reporting f numbers. For example they had at one point a 28 f/1.9, and they had a 50 f/1.1, etc. Given that history I think we can expect that any rounding of the aperture value would be small f/2.04 or less.Ok, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2....Show more →
Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...
Sorry Steve, I missed that! I'm going to chalk it up to not enough morning caffeine (although I'm not sure I can blame it on that......)
Steve Spencer wrote: tsdevine wroteCould metering mode possibly impact the differences (forgetting variability of ambient light for the moment)? I would have to believe center weighted vs multi might have some impact on exposure in this scenario.
Steve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteYeah.
I'm not claiming that at f/2 the light transmission is the same as f/2.4, measured at the centre. As mentioned there is a centre portion that gets brighter. In theory and on paper it may be f/2, but the high amounts of natural and optical vignetting of the Ultron 28 and 35mm, at least to me, leave an impression that the lens should have mechanically stopped at f/2.4. Opening to f/2 just seems a little redundant and impractical. Most lenses I've used have at least in the greater central area, a more significant light transmission difference from their widest aperture to the next half step down.
Both my Ultron 35 and 28mm can have the same shutter speed at f/2 and f/2.4 that a very large majority of the frame is exposed the same. The difference between my Ultron 35mm at f/2.4 and my Color Skopar 35/2.5 PII is significant enough that I would prefer the Color Skopar even with its nominal f/2.5 aperture.Ok, so we can all agree this is an f/2 lens, or at least I hope we can all agree. I think we can all agree that the lens has strong vignetting when it is not corrected. My lens performs just like the lens that Bastian reviewed. Here is a link to his picture depicting the vignetting:
As you will see there the corners are definitely darkened at f/2 and there is even some darkening on the long edges (but very little to no darkening on the short edges). This tells us there is a circle with a 24mm diameter in the center that does not have significant reduction in illumination. I don't think it is accurate to call that a small section in the center, but call it whatever you want we can describe the actual measurement of the bright area in the center.
Further given this, IMO, rather larger 24mm circle with little to no effect of vignetting I can't see how changing the aperture on your lens from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the shutter speed. If I were you I would investigate both your camera and lens to see if they are functioning properly. Opening up the lens to f/2 from f/2.4 should get you about a 50% increase in shutter speed and that is what I see with my camera (M10) and my copy of the lens. Now I do always use center weighted metering and perhaps you will have better luck if you switch to center weighted metering if you are using something else. Of course one of the advantages of center weighted metering is that it isn't affected very much at all by vignetting when exposure on the outer part of the frame is not much of a concern.
Finally, it should be noted that either six-bit coding this lens or selecting in Lightroom corrections for the Leica 28 summicron, nicely cleans up the vignetting. The majority of my shots using a rangefinder I crop to 4 X 5 aspect ratio, so I don't bother with vignetting correction for most of my shots, but when I need it with this lens it does work quite well with all the usual caveats about increasing noise in the corners.
So, this is a f/2 lens with a lot vignetting. Each individual user will have to decide how much the vignetting bothers them and even whether it is a deal breaker for the lens and if it is not how they want to handle it. Personally, I find it a mild annoyance but not really that big of a deal.Both my lenses and camera are functioning fine. A difference in exposure is absolutely noticable from f/2 to f/2.8. From f/2 to that half step position, which I refer to as f/2.4, the difference is so small that keeping the shutter speed the same results in two images that look identical with exception of little brighter small central area. The 28mm Elmarit that I had, my Color Skopar 35mm, and Summicron 50mm all show a much wider spread affect of exposure with the first half step.
In terms of my attempts at matching brightness at the centre, the difference between f/2 and the half step to f/2.4 on the Ultron 28mm is around 0.25 stop.
I get it, its an f/2 lens because (unverified) the aperture measurement is theoretically wide enough to claim the nominal value. It may or may not be a rounded value too. Who knows. But as much as aperture should be aperture value, so should focal length be focal length. But then we have situations like the Leica Q with its 28mm lens.
Anyways. I suppose I was more questioning the point at which one should accept a claim of a lens being f/2. Suppose the next lens that comes along and claims its f/2, but with a transmission change across an even smaller portion at the dead centre. Still acceptable?
Here are two images shot with the Ultron 28mm. Both have the same shutter speed and ISO value. Aperture was the only thing changed from f/2 to the next half step f/2.4. It would seem this is perfectly acceptable for most. I find it disappointing and pointless that the lens has an f/2 aperture that may technically classify as f/2 but functionally falls short. Again, the difference in brightness in Lightroom is around 0.25 stop to match brightness. Lets even round that up to 0.3. Still a fair bit away from the supposed 0.5 stops at dead centre!
(The lens is in camera coded to the Summicron 28mm ASPH)
1/45sec, f/2.4 https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52368402093_cf205234a1_h.jpgSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.Yes, Tim. I made the same suggestion in my post above. I use center-weight metering almost exclusively with my M10 largely because I don't want metering affected by vignetting and many rangefinder lenses (like this one) have pretty high vignetting. I don't know what metering hmzimelka is using but if he is using metering in live view that may account for at least part of the differences we are reporting.
hmzimelka wrote: Steve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wroteOk, so we can all agree this is an f/2 lens, or at least I hope we can all agree. I think we can all agree that the lens has strong vignetting when it is not corrected. My lens performs just like the lens that Bastian reviewed. Here is a link to his picture depicting the vignetting:
As you will see there the corners are definitely darkened at f/2 and there is even some darkening on the long edges (but very little to no darkening on the short edges). This tells us there is a circle with a 24mm diameter in the center that does not have significant reduction in illumination. I don't think it is accurate to call that a small section in the center, but call it whatever you want we can describe the actual measurement of the bright area in the center.
Further given this, IMO, rather larger 24mm circle with little to no effect of vignetting I can't see how changing the aperture on your lens from f/2 to f/2.4 doesn't change the shutter speed. If I were you I would investigate both your camera and lens to see if they are functioning properly. Opening up the lens to f/2 from f/2.4 should get you about a 50% increase in shutter speed and that is what I see with my camera (M10) and my copy of the lens. Now I do always use center weighted metering and perhaps you will have better luck if you switch to center weighted metering if you are using something else. Of course one of the advantages of center weighted metering is that it isn't affected very much at all by vignetting when exposure on the outer part of the frame is not much of a concern.
Finally, it should be noted that either six-bit coding this lens or selecting in Lightroom corrections for the Leica 28 summicron, nicely cleans up the vignetting. The majority of my shots using a rangefinder I crop to 4 X 5 aspect ratio, so I don't bother with vignetting correction for most of my shots, but when I need it with this lens it does work quite well with all the usual caveats about increasing noise in the corners.
So, this is a f/2 lens with a lot vignetting. Each individual user will have to decide how much the vignetting bothers them and even whether it is a deal breaker for the lens and if it is not how they want to handle it. Personally, I find it a mild annoyance but not really that big of a deal.Both my lenses and camera are functioning fine. A difference in exposure is absolutely noticable from f/2 to f/2.8. From f/2 to that half step position, which I refer to as f/2.4, the difference is so small that keeping the shutter speed the same results in two images that look identical with exception of little brighter small central area. The 28mm Elmarit that I had, my Color Skopar 35mm, and Summicron 50mm all show a much wider spread affect of exposure with the first half step.
In terms of my attempts at matching brightness at the centre, the difference between f/2 and the half step to f/2.4 on the Ultron 28mm is around 0.25 stop.
I get it, its an f/2 lens because (unverified) the aperture measurement is theoretically wide enough to claim the nominal value. It may or may not be a rounded value too. Who knows. But as much as aperture should be aperture value, so should focal length be focal length. But then we have situations like the Leica Q with its 28mm lens.
Anyways. I suppose I was more questioning the point at which one should accept a claim of a lens being f/2. Suppose the next lens that comes along and claims its f/2, but with a transmission change across an even smaller portion at the dead centre. Still acceptable?
Here are two images shot with the Ultron 28mm. Both have the same shutter speed and ISO value. Aperture was the only thing changed from f/2 to the next half step f/2.4. It would seem this is perfectly acceptable for most. I find it disappointing and pointless that the lens has an f/2 aperture that may technically classify as f/2 but functionally falls short. Again, the difference in brightness in Lightroom is around 0.25 stop to match brightness. Lets even round that up to 0.3. Still a fair bit away from the supposed 0.5 stops at dead centre!
(The lens is in camera coded to the Summicron 28mm ASPH)
1/45sec, f/2.4 https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52368402093_cf205234a1_h.jpgSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.
PS - We also know that in the past Voigtlander has been relatively precise about reporting f numbers. For example they had at one point a 28 f/1.9, and they had a 50 f/1.1, etc. Given that history I think we can expect that any rounding of the aperture value would be small f/2.04 or less.Ok, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...
So, now with careful control it looks like we are talking a very small difference from the nominal aperture (namely a third of stop instead of the half stop that would be expected). We live with those sorts of exposure differences all the time. Is an f/1.2 lens a third of a stop or half a stop faster than an f/1.4 lens? Here rounding really can make an f/1.2 lens properly round only .35 stops faster or if you round the other way you can get .6 stops. I don't see any reason to quibble about such a small difference, so I am glad we have clarified that any difference between the nominal aperture and the aperture in practice on this lens is perhaps a sixth of a stop and nowhere near a half stop. For me a sixth of a stop isn't worth worrying about. It is certainly a much smaller issue, IMO, than the two to three stop vignetting in the corner and one to two stops along the wide edge. Even that for me, however isn't a big issue. With the relatively large 24mm image circle even wide open that is basically unaffected by the vignetting I find the lens very useful. Of course, YMMV.
Steve Spencer wrote: hmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteBoth my lenses and camera are functioning fine. A difference in exposure is absolutely noticable from f/2 to f/2.8. From f/2 to that half step position, which I refer to as f/2.4, the difference is so small that keeping the shutter speed the same results in two images that look identical with exception of little brighter small central area. The 28mm Elmarit that I had, my Color Skopar 35mm, and Summicron 50mm all show a much wider spread affect of exposure with the first half step.
In terms of my attempts at matching brightness at the centre, the difference between f/2 and the half step to f/2.4 on the Ultron 28mm is around 0.25 stop.
I get it, its an f/2 lens because (unverified) the aperture measurement is theoretically wide enough to claim the nominal value. It may or may not be a rounded value too. Who knows. But as much as aperture should be aperture value, so should focal length be focal length. But then we have situations like the Leica Q with its 28mm lens.
Anyways. I suppose I was more questioning the point at which one should accept a claim of a lens being f/2. Suppose the next lens that comes along and claims its f/2, but with a transmission change across an even smaller portion at the dead centre. Still acceptable?
Here are two images shot with the Ultron 28mm. Both have the same shutter speed and ISO value. Aperture was the only thing changed from f/2 to the next half step f/2.4. It would seem this is perfectly acceptable for most. I find it disappointing and pointless that the lens has an f/2 aperture that may technically classify as f/2 but functionally falls short. Again, the difference in brightness in Lightroom is around 0.25 stop to match brightness. Lets even round that up to 0.3. Still a fair bit away from the supposed 0.5 stops at dead centre!
(The lens is in camera coded to the Summicron 28mm ASPH)
1/45sec, f/2.4 https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52368402093_cf205234a1_h.jpgSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.
PS - We also know that in the past Voigtlander has been relatively precise about reporting f numbers. For example they had at one point a 28 f/1.9, and they had a 50 f/1.1, etc. Given that history I think we can expect that any rounding of the aperture value would be small f/2.04 or less.Ok, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...So, now with careful control it looks like we are talking a very small difference from the nominal aperture (namely a third of stop instead of the half stop that would be expected). We live with those sorts of exposure differences all the time. Is an f/1.2 lens a third of a stop or half a stop faster than an f/1.4 lens? Here rounding really can make an f/1.2 lens properly round only .35 stops faster or if you round the other way you can get .6 stops. I don't see any reason to quibble about such a small difference, so I am glad we have clarified that any difference between the nominal aperture and the aperture in practice on this lens is perhaps a sixth of a stop and nowhere near a half stop. For me a sixth of a stop isn't worth worrying about. It is certainly a much smaller issue, IMO, than the two to three stop vignetting in the corner and one to two stops along the wide edge. Even that for me, however isn't a big issue. With the relatively large 24mm image circle even wide open that is basically unaffected by the vignetting I find the lens very useful. Of course, YMMV....Show more →
I don't mean to be nasty, but I think this disagreement really is of little value. I like the lens, it performs exceedingly well for me, is sharp with good color and contrast, is small and light, balances well on my Kolari Vision UT sensor modified A7rII and the issues are easy to deal with. Not much more that I could ask for in this focal length for my needs.
naturephoto1 wrote: Steve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wroteSorry, but this is a really uncontrolled test. You are using sunlight to illuminate the image and that can change easily with movements of clouds, etc. What I know from my experience with my lens is that changing the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4 does result in exposure changes and it is about a half stop difference. As I said, perhaps your lens is different, but mine is no different from my other rangefinder lenses in this regard.
PS - We also know that in the past Voigtlander has been relatively precise about reporting f numbers. For example they had at one point a 28 f/1.9, and they had a 50 f/1.1, etc. Given that history I think we can expect that any rounding of the aperture value would be small f/2.04 or less.Ok, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...So, now with careful control it looks like we are talking a very small difference from the nominal aperture (namely a third of stop instead of the half stop that would be expected). We live with those sorts of exposure differences all the time. Is an f/1.2 lens a third of a stop or half a stop faster than an f/1.4 lens? Here rounding really can make an f/1.2 lens properly round only .35 stops faster or if you round the other way you can get .6 stops. I don't see any reason to quibble about such a small difference, so I am glad we have clarified that any difference between the nominal aperture and the aperture in practice on this lens is perhaps a sixth of a stop and nowhere near a half stop. For me a sixth of a stop isn't worth worrying about. It is certainly a much smaller issue, IMO, than the two to three stop vignetting in the corner and one to two stops along the wide edge. Even that for me, however isn't a big issue. With the relatively large 24mm image circle even wide open that is basically unaffected by the vignetting I find the lens very useful. Of course, YMMV.I don't mean to be nasty, but I think this disagreement really is of little value. I like the lens, it performs exceedingly well for me, is sharp with good color and contrast, is small and light, balances well on my Kolari Vision UT sensor modified A7rII and the issues are easy to deal with. Not much more that I could ask for in this focal length for my needs.
Rich
Hi Rich,
I agree with you as you know (I think I recommended the lens to you if I remember rightly, or perhaps it was the other way around?). For my part I was just trying to share my experience and that experience is nothing like what was described. I simply didn't want people to think the lens was something it was not.
Steve Spencer wrote: naturephoto1 wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteOk, I think this is just becoming a redundant discussion. The EXIF states 1 sec difference in date stamp. Clear Sky.
The above images represent exactly what I said. If you want to question my technique or the integrity of my camera and lens or lenses, then thats also fine. It's easy to replicate for those that are curious; Lock the Exposure speed and ISO, and just change the aperture from f/2 to f/2.4.Or you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...So, now with careful control it looks like we are talking a very small difference from the nominal aperture (namely a third of stop instead of the half stop that would be expected). We live with those sorts of exposure differences all the time. Is an f/1.2 lens a third of a stop or half a stop faster than an f/1.4 lens? Here rounding really can make an f/1.2 lens properly round only .35 stops faster or if you round the other way you can get .6 stops. I don't see any reason to quibble about such a small difference, so I am glad we have clarified that any difference between the nominal aperture and the aperture in practice on this lens is perhaps a sixth of a stop and nowhere near a half stop. For me a sixth of a stop isn't worth worrying about. It is certainly a much smaller issue, IMO, than the two to three stop vignetting in the corner and one to two stops along the wide edge. Even that for me, however isn't a big issue. With the relatively large 24mm image circle even wide open that is basically unaffected by the vignetting I find the lens very useful. Of course, YMMV.I don't mean to be nasty, but I think this disagreement really is of little value. I like the lens, it performs exceedingly well for me, is sharp with good color and contrast, is small and light, balances well on my Kolari Vision UT sensor modified A7rII and the issues are easy to deal with. Not much more that I could ask for in this focal length for my needs.
RichHi Rich,
I agree with you as you know (I think I recommended the lens to you if I remember rightly, or perhaps it was the other way around?). For my part I was just trying to share my experience and that experience is nothing like what was described. I simply didn't want people to think the lens was something it was not.
Best wishes,
Steve
Hi Steve,
I wasn't singling you out just commenting on where this discussion had gone. By the way, I paid for my lens with Cameraquest on May 6, 2021.
naturephoto1 wrote: Steve Spencer wrotenaturephoto1 wroteSteve Spencer wrotehmzimelka wroteSteve Spencer wroteOr you can just read Bastian's review that I linked and is done very well and you don't have to rely on subjective judgments of how big the brighter area in the center actually is (the lens has at least a diameter of 24mm not really affected by vignetting, which I wouldn't call small) and subjective judgments of just how much brighter the image is. If you do try to make such judgments I would suggest at least try to match the histograms to reduce the subjectivity. It is also best to use a constant light source. By all means test your own lens for yourself. When I test mine I do get the half-stop difference or very nearly that that would be expected when you stop down to f/2.4 from wide open at f/2.Thanks. I have read the review prior to purchasing the lens.
Matching the histogram against an evenly lit surface, focus at infinity, locked exposure. A tight centre crop of the images were used to match histograms. Best I could do was 0.35 stop exposure difference between f/2 and f/2.4 but unfortunately I wasn't shooting through photographic grade tissues...So, now with careful control it looks like we are talking a very small difference from the nominal aperture (namely a third of stop instead of the half stop that would be expected). We live with those sorts of exposure differences all the time. Is an f/1.2 lens a third of a stop or half a stop faster than an f/1.4 lens? Here rounding really can make an f/1.2 lens properly round only .35 stops faster or if you round the other way you can get .6 stops. I don't see any reason to quibble about such a small difference, so I am glad we have clarified that any difference between the nominal aperture and the aperture in practice on this lens is perhaps a sixth of a stop and nowhere near a half stop. For me a sixth of a stop isn't worth worrying about. It is certainly a much smaller issue, IMO, than the two to three stop vignetting in the corner and one to two stops along the wide edge. Even that for me, however isn't a big issue. With the relatively large 24mm image circle even wide open that is basically unaffected by the vignetting I find the lens very useful. Of course, YMMV.I don't mean to be nasty, but I think this disagreement really is of little value. I like the lens, it performs exceedingly well for me, is sharp with good color and contrast, is small and light, balances well on my Kolari Vision UT sensor modified A7rII and the issues are easy to deal with. Not much more that I could ask for in this focal length for my needs.
RichHi Rich,
I agree with you as you know (I think I recommended the lens to you if I remember rightly, or perhaps it was the other way around?). For my part I was just trying to share my experience and that experience is nothing like what was described. I simply didn't want people to think the lens was something it was not.
Best wishes,
SteveHi Steve,
I wasn't singling you out just commenting on where this discussion had gone. By the way, I paid for my lens with Cameraquest on May 6, 2021.
Rich
I got one very early as well, as soon as they were shipping which is rare for me. I very well might have got it on your advice, however, and was a little slower than you because I believe mine came in July, 2021. I have always appreciated your thoughts and advice on lenses. Cheers.
The Leica lens has markedly less vignetting wide open, both in the mid-frame and corners. This was also easily seen when I did optical vignetting tests. Of course, it doesn't mean that the Ultron II isn't an f/2 lens, but as I have said previously in this thread, and as others also have found out, stopping down to f/2.4 only affects a small spot in the center (even at shorter focus distances). That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
When using the matrix light metering in my Nikon Z6UT, it often fooled the exposure (in aperture mode) creating underexposure. This didn't happen with the Summicron either. The vignetting in the Ultron II causes the illumination to decrease so sharply that I don't use the lens wide open at long focus distances, but stop down to at least f/2.4, since there is no practical gain shooting wide open.
That said, it's the only real complaint I have with this lens (apart from that it won't work on a stock Nikon Z camera).
I see the same vignetting behavior with my Nokton 50mm f/1.2, and I have seen others saying the same regarding the Ultron 35mm f/1.7.
LarsHP wrote:
I just revisited this thread and saw the discussion regarding vignetting.
Here's my vignetting test compared to the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II:
The Leica lens has markedly less vignetting wide open, both in the mid-frame and corners. This was also easily seen when I did optical vignetting tests. Of course, it doesn't mean that the Ultron II isn't an f/2 lens, but as I have said previously in this thread, and as others also have found out, stopping down to f/2.4 only affects a small spot in the center (even at shorter focus distances). That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
When using the matrix light metering in my Nikon Z6UT, it often fooled the exposure (in aperture mode) creating underexposure. This didn't happen with the Summicron either. The vignetting in the Ultron II causes the illumination to decrease so sharply that I don't use the lens wide open at long focus distances, but stop down to at least f/2.4, since there is no practical gain shooting wide open.
That said, it's the only real complaint I have with this lens (apart from that it won't work on a stock Nikon Z camera).
I see the same vignetting behavior with my Nokton 50mm f/1.2, and I have seen others saying the same regarding the Ultron 35mm f/1.7. ...Show more →
Now I remember having this same sort of conversation earlier with you Lars. I just don't see the huge difference you describe in your own vignetting shots, nor in other shots, nor in the data provided by Bastian and Leica, nor in my own shooting. I am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph. As you will see these measured data contradict your subjective judgements about vignetting. In my experience this claim that the Voigtlander lens has vignetting that is so bad it is a huge problem but the Leica lens does not, just isn't supported by the data or the photographic evidence. Of course one could be bothered by the vignetting of both lenses. They both have a lot of vignetting, but the claim that the Voigtlander lens is a problem while the Leica lens is not in my view is refuted by the data.
The Ultron does have an advantage I noticed when quickly testing a Summicron 28 ASPH II, that it has less vignetting at the corners from f/5.6. Not much, but noticeable and certainly preferable for my use case anyways. Lars' image shows this too. However, my use with the Summicron was with the screw on hood.
Steve Spencer wrote:
I am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph.
Those graphs are not directly comparable.
Part of the reason for that is that all I can measure is the whole "system" of sensor, in camera processing, lens, post processing/raw development.
Whereas - I am guessing - Leica gives data for the lens only. And even if not, their process chain is most likely different from mine.
The Leica's corner illumination at f/2.0 is roughly 21% acc. to that graph, which would translate to -2.25 EV.
That does sound surprisingly low to me, at least on digital.
On film it might very well be true though, due to the absence of pixel vignetting.
Please revisit Bastian Kratzkes optical vignetting tests. That proves my point perfectly. Even the inner middle bokeh "ball" is clearly truncated, and the truncation becomes quite extreme in the corner. That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
Comparing Bastians measurement to Leicas graph is apples to bananas. I tested the two lenses on the same camera. That's apples to apples, and it's not subjective. You can measure the illumination in various places in the frame and conclude what I say.
Steve Spencer wrote: LarsHP wroteI just revisited this thread and saw the discussion regarding vignetting.
Here's my vignetting test compared to the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II:
The Leica lens has markedly less vignetting wide open, both in the mid-frame and corners. This was also easily seen when I did optical vignetting tests. Of course, it doesn't mean that the Ultron II isn't an f/2 lens, but as I have said previously in this thread, and as others also have found out, stopping down to f/2.4 only affects a small spot in the center (even at shorter focus distances). That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
When using the matrix light metering in my Nikon Z6UT, it often fooled the exposure (in aperture mode) creating underexposure. This didn't happen with the Summicron either. The vignetting in the Ultron II causes the illumination to decrease so sharply that I don't use the lens wide open at long focus distances, but stop down to at least f/2.4, since there is no practical gain shooting wide open.
That said, it's the only real complaint I have with this lens (apart from that it won't work on a stock Nikon Z camera).
I see the same vignetting behavior with my Nokton 50mm f/1.2, and I have seen others saying the same regarding the Ultron 35mm f/1.7.Now I remember having this same sort of conversation earlier with you Lars. I just don't see the huge difference you describe in your own vignetting shots, nor in other shots, nor in the data provided by Bastian and Leica, nor in my own shooting. I am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph. As you will see these measured data contradict your subjective judgements about vignetting. In my experience this claim that the Voigtlander lens has vignetting that is so bad it is a huge problem but the Leica lens does not, just isn't supported by the data or the photographic evidence. Of course one could be bothered by the vignetting of both lenses. They both have a lot of vignetting, but the claim that the Voigtlander lens is a problem while the Leica lens is not in my view is refuted by the data....Show more →
My test actually show that the Ultron II has less vignetting already at f/4.
hmzimelka wrote:
The Ultron does have an advantage I noticed when quickly testing a Summicron 28 ASPH II, that it has less vignetting at the corners from f/5.6. Not much, but noticeable and certainly preferable for my use case anyways. Lars' image shows this too. However, my use with the Summicron was with the screw on hood.
I should add that vignetting in my Kolari Vision Ultra Thin modified Nikon Z6 was stronger than the Leica M 240 that I tested my Summicron on. This means the vignetting (from any lens with quite short exit pupil) will be stronger in my test than yours, since you used your M10, I expect.
BastianK wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph.Those graphs are not directly comparable.
Part of the reason for that is that all I can measure is the whole "system" of sensor, in camera processing, lens, post processing/raw development.
Whereas - I am guessing - Leica gives data for the lens only. And even if not, their process chain is most likely different from mine.
The Leica's corner illumination at f/2.0 is roughly 21% acc. to that graph, which would translate to -2.25 EV.
That does sound surprisingly low to me, at least on digital.
On film it might very well be true though, due to the absence of pixel vignetting.
LarsHP wrote:
Please revisit Bastian Kratzkes optical vignetting tests. That proves my point perfectly. Even the inner middle bokeh "ball" is clearly truncated, and the truncation becomes quite extreme in the corner. That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
Comparing Bastians measurement to Leicas graph is apples to bananas. I tested the two lenses on the same camera. That's apples to apples, and it's not subjective. You can measure the illumination in various places in the frame and conclude what I say.
Steve Spencer wroteLarsHP wroteI just revisited this thread and saw the discussion regarding vignetting.
Here's my vignetting test compared to the 28mm Summicron-M Asph II:
The Leica lens has markedly less vignetting wide open, both in the mid-frame and corners. This was also easily seen when I did optical vignetting tests. Of course, it doesn't mean that the Ultron II isn't an f/2 lens, but as I have said previously in this thread, and as others also have found out, stopping down to f/2.4 only affects a small spot in the center (even at shorter focus distances). That wasn't the case with the Summicron.
When using the matrix light metering in my Nikon Z6UT, it often fooled the exposure (in aperture mode) creating underexposure. This didn't happen with the Summicron either. The vignetting in the Ultron II causes the illumination to decrease so sharply that I don't use the lens wide open at long focus distances, but stop down to at least f/2.4, since there is no practical gain shooting wide open.
That said, it's the only real complaint I have with this lens (apart from that it won't work on a stock Nikon Z camera).
I see the same vignetting behavior with my Nokton 50mm f/1.2, and I have seen others saying the same regarding the Ultron 35mm f/1.7.Now I remember having this same sort of conversation earlier with you Lars. I just don't see the huge difference you describe in your own vignetting shots, nor in other shots, nor in the data provided by Bastian and Leica, nor in my own shooting. I am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph. As you will see these measured data contradict your subjective judgements about vignetting. In my experience this claim that the Voigtlander lens has vignetting that is so bad it is a huge problem but the Leica lens does not, just isn't supported by the data or the photographic evidence. Of course one could be bothered by the vignetting of both lenses. They both have a lot of vignetting, but the claim that the Voigtlander lens is a problem while the Leica lens is not in my view is refuted by the data.
It hardly proves your point at all and proof when we are talking about data is a word that should always be avoided. You can talk about data supporting or being consistent with your position, but data never "proves," anything, and certainly doesn't in this case. Yes, the bokeh ball test Bastian presents shows no truncation of the bokeh balls in the middle and the next distance (which he does not specify - perhaps he can tell us now) does show some truncation. This does show that that lens has strong vignetting as I think we have all maintained all along. That is not in dispute, so yes Bastian's test provides evidence for what we agree upon, but it provides exactly zero evidence for what is in dispute which is your claim that the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II has much worse vignetting than the Summicron 28 f/2 Asph and that the difference is so big and so night and day that for the Voigtlander f/2 isn't really usable and for the Summicron it is. I don't see any of the evidence being consistent with that proposition and it is the proposition that is in dispute. And in my experience that characterization of the Voigtlander is just not accurate. Now YMMV, you might find the Voigtlander unacceptable. That is fine, but I don't see any evidence (certainly in Bastian's review as he never compares the lenses) that it is that much worse than the Summicron. It may be slightly worse and that may matter to you, but these false claims that Bastian review supports the difference between the Voigtlander and the Summicron are just that a false claim.
LarsHP wrote:
I should add that vignetting in my Kolari Vision Ultra Thin modified Nikon Z6 was stronger than the Leica M 240 that I tested my Summicron on. This means the vignetting (from any lens with quite short exit pupil) will be stronger in my test than yours, since you used your M10, I expect.
BastianK wroteSteve Spencer wroteI am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph.Those graphs are not directly comparable.
Part of the reason for that is that all I can measure is the whole "system" of sensor, in camera processing, lens, post processing/raw development.
Whereas - I am guessing - Leica gives data for the lens only. And even if not, their process chain is most likely different from mine.
The Leica's corner illumination at f/2.0 is roughly 21% acc. to that graph, which would translate to -2.25 EV.
That does sound surprisingly low to me, at least on digital.
On film it might very well be true though, due to the absence of pixel vignetting.
And that means of course that your test was an apples to oranges test and that has to be considered when comparing the two lenses. And, in my view, given that the summicron in your test had a clear advantage and the difference in vignetting is small at best your own tests provide pretty strong refutation of your own position that the summicron is night and day better than the Voigtlander.
As you can see from the link I provided above, the vignetting test with the Summicron and Ultron were done on the same camera, my Z6UT. That means apples to apples and proves my point, yes.
(I have also done some optical vignetting tests that support this point, but haven't posted those.)
My point you are quoting here refers to why Bastians test shows less vignetting than my test WITH THE SAME LENS, namely the Ultron II. So, the difference in illumination between the M10 and Z6UT is sensor related (caused by the micro lenses). That explains why we can't compare his and my vignetting images.
EDIT: In the YouTube review Benj Haisch did, it is also quite evident that the bokeh balls (in the bushes) from the Ultron II are clearly oval-shaped already in the mid-frame which isn't the case with his Summicron Asph II. This is consistent with what I am saying.
Steve Spencer wrote: LarsHP wroteI should add that vignetting in my Kolari Vision Ultra Thin modified Nikon Z6 was stronger than the Leica M 240 that I tested my Summicron on. This means the vignetting (from any lens with quite short exit pupil) will be stronger in my test than yours, since you used your M10, I expect.
BastianK wroteSteve Spencer wroteI am posting below the vignetting curves that Bastian included in his review of the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II and the official vignetting curves from the Leica data sheet for the 28 summicron Asph.Those graphs are not directly comparable.
Part of the reason for that is that all I can measure is the whole "system" of sensor, in camera processing, lens, post processing/raw development.
Whereas - I am guessing - Leica gives data for the lens only. And even if not, their process chain is most likely different from mine.
The Leica's corner illumination at f/2.0 is roughly 21% acc. to that graph, which would translate to -2.25 EV.
That does sound surprisingly low to me, at least on digital.
On film it might very well be true though, due to the absence of pixel vignetting.And that means of course that your test was an apples to oranges test and that has to be considered when comparing the two lenses. And, in my view, given that the summicron in your test had a clear advantage and the difference in vignetting is small at best your own tests provide pretty strong refutation of your own position that the summicron is night and day better than the Voigtlander.