fredmiranda.com Login

Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #1Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
LarsHP wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI was re-reading this thread, and perhaps I missed it, but can anyone link me to some systematic testing between the CV 28v2 and 28 Cron v1 or v2 (tripod, leica sensor stack, etc). I find a lot of video reviews and people with opinions about both lenses, but I would like to see some systematic testing for my own understanding (and honestly too much bias in Leica land for me, despite I own and like some Leica glass).

Especially WO at mid distance—I am sure the CV 28v2 will beat the Crons for resolution across the frame, but I’d like to see if there’s an appreciable difference in rendering the way I’d use a 28/2.
I posted several times in this thread. Check the link below where I have uploaded test shots with the Ultron II and Summicron Asph II.

Not using M camera though, but a Kolari UT modded Nikon Z6. I did a quick comparison with my cron v2 on a M240 and Z6UT, and the difference was that the Z6UT had more vignetting, but less color shift ("Italian flag" issue). Regarding field curvature and corner sharpness etc., I couldn't detect any difference.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ngYCuU1OzRZVbnbjGtwge1Mx78vuUp8q
Thanks @LarsHP@@@ and @naturephoto1. as far as I’m concerned, a UTI and native sensor are the same to me effectively. Just what I am hoping for Curious to hear your thoughts as well @genji@@@
Why didn't you send your Sony to Kolari instead?
Because the UT (works out to 0.9) is not as thin as the NKIR v3+ (0.75), and while this may not affect many modern RF lenses, other lenses like the Contax G line I believe will do better with thinner while not negatively affecting most current M glass. Additionally, the color management/WB issues seem better on the NKIR versus the Kolari with the UT vs. V3+. On top of that, NKIR told me they are trying out a newer thinner (V5), and that filter is (0.58), so I am hoping for further improvements on those more difficult lenses, so I
...Show more →

That makes sense Nehemiah. Will this coverglass + filter be even thinner than the native Leica M sensors?
Nov 04, 2021 at 11:08 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.24 #2Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
LarsHP wrote:
Honestly, it was a surprise to me that the Ultron II was sharper across the frame than my Summicron-M Asph II (both wide open). In terms of bokeh, they both have their strengths and weaknesses; the Ultron smoother in the central area, the Summicron in the sides and corners at medium focus distance. My biggest complaint about the Ultron II is that its vignetting is so strong that I consider it roughly a f/2.4 lens with a small hot spot in the center.


“f/2.4 lens with a small hot spot in the center” describes the Ultron perfectly. The obsessive devotion to making tiny lenses at the cost of excessive vignetting turns what could have been a superb lens into a merely excellent one.
Nov 04, 2021 at 11:18 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #3Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
LarsHP wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI was re-reading this thread, and perhaps I missed it, but can anyone link me to some systematic testing between the CV 28v2 and 28 Cron v1 or v2 (tripod, leica sensor stack, etc). I find a lot of video reviews and people with opinions about both lenses, but I would like to see some systematic testing for my own understanding (and honestly too much bias in Leica land for me, despite I own and like some Leica glass).

Especially WO at mid distance—I am sure the CV 28v2 will beat the Crons for resolution across the frame, but I’d like to see if there’s an appreciable difference in rendering the way I’d use a 28/2.
I posted several times in this thread. Check the link below where I have uploaded test shots with the Ultron II and Summicron Asph II.

Not using M camera though, but a Kolari UT modded Nikon Z6. I did a quick comparison with my cron v2 on a M240 and Z6UT, and the difference was that the Z6UT had more vignetting, but less color shift ("Italian flag" issue). Regarding field curvature and corner sharpness etc., I couldn't detect any difference.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ngYCuU1OzRZVbnbjGtwge1Mx78vuUp8q
Thanks @LarsHP@@@@ and @naturephoto1. as far as I’m concerned, a UTI and native sensor are the same to me effectively. Just what I am hoping for Curious to hear your thoughts as well @genji@@@@
Why didn't you send your Sony to Kolari instead?
Because the UT (works out to 0.9) is not as thin as the NKIR v3+ (0.75), and while this may not affect many modern RF lenses, other lenses like the Contax G line I believe will do better with thinner while not negatively affecting most current M glass. Additionally, the color management/WB issues seem better on the NKIR versus the Kolari with the UT vs. V3+. On top of that, NKIR told me they are trying out a newer thinner (V5), and that filter is (0.58), so I am hoping for further improvements on those more difficult lenses, so I am hoping that passes into production and I get that (should know soon). Lastly, I can test my NKIR (either V3+ or V5) against Sebboh's Kolari UT as we live near and are friends. The NKIR mod is also cheaper a bit and less of a known quantity, which naturally heightens my interest as well.
That makes sense Nehemiah. Will this coverglass + filter be even thinner than the native Leica M sensors?


Yup—M10 is the same as the UT at 0.9. I think the m9 is 0.8.

edit: Digital M is 0.85

https://medium.com/rokkorxblog/sony-a7rii-a7riii-a7iii-thin-filter-mod-d854c63fb1a0
Nov 05, 2021 at 01:09 AM
genji
Offline
Details
p.24 #4Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
LarsHP wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI was re-reading this thread, and perhaps I missed it, but can anyone link me to some systematic testing between the CV 28v2 and 28 Cron v1 or v2 (tripod, leica sensor stack, etc). I find a lot of video reviews and people with opinions about both lenses, but I would like to see some systematic testing for my own understanding (and honestly too much bias in Leica land for me, despite I own and like some Leica glass).

Especially WO at mid distance—I am sure the CV 28v2 will beat the Crons for resolution across the frame, but I’d like to see if there’s an appreciable difference in rendering the way I’d use a 28/2.
I posted several times in this thread. Check the link below where I have uploaded test shots with the Ultron II and Summicron Asph II.

Not using M camera though, but a Kolari UT modded Nikon Z6. I did a quick comparison with my cron v2 on a M240 and Z6UT, and the difference was that the Z6UT had more vignetting, but less color shift ("Italian flag" issue). Regarding field curvature and corner sharpness etc., I couldn't detect any difference.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ngYCuU1OzRZVbnbjGtwge1Mx78vuUp8q
Thanks @LarsHP@@@ and @naturephoto1. as far as I’m concerned, a UTI and native sensor are the same to me effectively. Just what I am hoping for Curious to hear your thoughts as well @genji@@@
Why didn't you send your Sony to Kolari instead?
Because the UT (works out to 0.9) is not as thin as the NKIR v3+ (0.75), and while this may not affect many modern RF lenses, other lenses like the Contax G line I believe will do better with thinner while not negatively affecting most current M glass. Additionally, the color management/WB issues seem better on the NKIR versus the Kolari with the UT vs. V3+. On top of that, NKIR told me they are trying out a newer thinner (V5), and that filter is (0.58), so I am hoping for further improvements on those more difficult lenses, so I
...Show more →

What inclines me to go with the NKIR rather than the Kolari conversion was a very long FM post a while ago from a member in Hong Kong (IIRC) which was packed with sample images made with a wide range of lenses on an NKIR converted camera. And the images not only looked great but the member specifically stated that—as nehemiahphoto says—color management/WB issues were minimal.
Nov 05, 2021 at 02:46 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.24 #5Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
You could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
Nov 05, 2021 at 02:52 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.24 #6Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
Wouldn't that introduce smearing and other issues in the sides and corners with wide angle RF lenses too?

My understanding is that with angled light passing through (in this case at least two) glass surfaces, the light path will bend. Since different wavelengths will bend to different degrees => an optical nightmare outside the center.

freaklikeme wrote:
You could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.

Nov 05, 2021 at 03:20 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.24 #7Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
LarsHP wrote:
Wouldn't that introduce smearing and other issues in the sides and corners with wide angle RF lenses too?

My understanding is that with angled light passing through (in this case at least two) glass surfaces, the light path will bend. Since different wavelengths will bend to different degrees => an optical nightmare outside the center.

freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.


It hasn't so far (tested with the Distagon 18/4, Biogon 21/2.8, Elmarit-M 21/2.8 vI, and Biogon 28/2.8) but the wide RF's do require a "hot mirror" filter rather than a standard UV/IR cut. Kolari's latest filters are the best I've used for this purpose.

That said, modern mirrorless and M-mount lenses tend to take a big hit in this configuration, so you really have to love film-era lenses.
Nov 05, 2021 at 03:53 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.24 #8Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
freaklikeme wrote:
LarsHP wroteWouldn't that introduce smearing and other issues in the sides and corners with wide angle RF lenses too?

My understanding is that with angled light passing through (in this case at least two) glass surfaces, the light path will bend. Since different wavelengths will bend to different degrees => an optical nightmare outside the center.

freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
It hasn't so far (tested with the Distagon 18/4, Biogon 21/2.8, Elmarit-M 21/2.8 vI, and Biogon 28/2.8) but the wide RF's do require a "hot mirror" filter rather than a standard UV/IR cut. Kolari's latest filters are the best I've used for this purpose.

That said, modern mirrorless and M-mount lenses tend to take a big hit in this configuration, so you really have to love film-era lenses.

Wait a minute. Are you talking about using a filter in the regular filter thread on the lens? If so, then I understand.

(I thought you suggested putting the filter on the rear of the lens.)
Nov 05, 2021 at 06:30 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.24 #9Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
genji wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
LarsHP wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI was re-reading this thread, and perhaps I missed it, but can anyone link me to some systematic testing between the CV 28v2 and 28 Cron v1 or v2 (tripod, leica sensor stack, etc). I find a lot of video reviews and people with opinions about both lenses, but I would like to see some systematic testing for my own understanding (and honestly too much bias in Leica land for me, despite I own and like some Leica glass).

Especially WO at mid distance—I am sure the CV 28v2 will beat the Crons for resolution across the frame, but I’d like to see if there’s an appreciable difference in rendering the way I’d use a 28/2.
I posted several times in this thread. Check the link below where I have uploaded test shots with the Ultron II and Summicron Asph II.

Not using M camera though, but a Kolari UT modded Nikon Z6. I did a quick comparison with my cron v2 on a M240 and Z6UT, and the difference was that the Z6UT had more vignetting, but less color shift ("Italian flag" issue). Regarding field curvature and corner sharpness etc., I couldn't detect any difference.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ngYCuU1OzRZVbnbjGtwge1Mx78vuUp8q
Thanks @LarsHP@@@@ and @naturephoto1. as far as I’m concerned, a UTI and native sensor are the same to me effectively. Just what I am hoping for Curious to hear your thoughts as well @genji@@@@
Why didn't you send your Sony to Kolari instead?
Because the UT (works out to 0.9) is not as thin as the NKIR v3+ (0.75), and while this may not affect many modern RF lenses, other lenses like the Contax G line I believe will do better with thinner while not negatively affecting most current M glass. Additionally, the color management/WB issues seem better on the NKIR versus the Kolari with the UT vs. V3+. On top of that, NKIR told me they are trying out a newer thinner (V5), and that filter is (0.58), so I am hoping for further improvements on those more difficult lenses, so I am hoping that passes into production and I get that (should know soon). Lastly, I can test my NKIR (either V3+ or V5) against Sebboh's Kolari UT as we live near and are friends. The NKIR mod is also cheaper a bit and less of a known quantity, which naturally heightens my interest as well.
What inclines me to go with the NKIR rather than the Kolari conversion was a very long FM post a while ago from a member in Hong Kong (IIRC) which was packed with sample images made with a wide range of lenses on an NKIR converted camera. And the images not only looked great but the member specifically stated that—as nehemiahphoto says—color management/WB issues were minimal.


Hi Jonathan,

White Balance is a piece of cake with the Kolari Vision UT sensor modification providing you make WB standards using a white card and store them in the memory of the camera for different Lighting Conditions. I have them saved in my Kolari Vision UT Sensor Modified A7rII and my Kolari Vision V3 Thin Sensor modified A7r for Daylight, Cloudy, and Shade conditions. If you need even more accurate WB adjustments for the conditions, you can photograph the White Card in the series to make your adjustments. Also, when I had Kolari Vision perform the UT sensor modification, Vivek (real Vivek) and I were stunned that the turnaround time for me in February of 2020 (just before the start of the Covid Pandemic) was about 1 week (from arrival at Kolari Vision to the return, but I live in Pennsylvania and Kolari Vision is in New Jersey only about 75 miles or so away). Also, I believe that Vivek has indicated the Kolari Vision UT sensor stack is more rugged (can take more abuse) than the NKIR modification. But, don't quote me on the last comment.

Rich



Edited on Nov 05, 2021 at 07:01 AM · View previous versions
Nov 05, 2021 at 06:44 AM
genji
Offline
Details
p.24 #10Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
naturephoto1 wrote:
genji wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
LarsHP wroteI posted several times in this thread. Check the link below where I have uploaded test shots with the Ultron II and Summicron Asph II.

Not using M camera though, but a Kolari UT modded Nikon Z6. I did a quick comparison with my cron v2 on a M240 and Z6UT, and the difference was that the Z6UT had more vignetting, but less color shift ("Italian flag" issue). Regarding field curvature and corner sharpness etc., I couldn't detect any difference.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ngYCuU1OzRZVbnbjGtwge1Mx78vuUp8q
Thanks @LarsHP@@@@@ and @naturephoto1. as far as I’m concerned, a UTI and native sensor are the same to me effectively. Just what I am hoping for Curious to hear your thoughts as well @genji@@@@@
Why didn't you send your Sony to Kolari instead?
Because the UT (works out to 0.9) is not as thin as the NKIR v3+ (0.75), and while this may not affect many modern RF lenses, other lenses like the Contax G line I believe will do better with thinner while not negatively affecting most current M glass. Additionally, the color management/WB issues seem better on the NKIR versus the Kolari with the UT vs. V3+. On top of that, NKIR told me they are trying out a newer thinner (V5), and that filter is (0.58), so I am hoping for further improvements on those more difficult lenses, so I am hoping that passes into production and I get that (should know soon). Lastly, I can test my NKIR (either V3+ or V5) against Sebboh's Kolari UT as we live near and are friends. The NKIR mod is also cheaper a bit and less of a known quantity, which naturally heightens my interest as well.
What inclines me to go with the NKIR rather than the Kolari conversion was a very long FM post a while ago from a member in Hong Kong (IIRC) which was packed with sample images made with a wide range of lenses on an NKIR converted camera. And the images not only looked great but the member specifically stated that—as nehemiahphoto says—color management/WB issues were minimal.
Hi Jonathan,

White Balance is a piece of cake with the Kolari Vision UT sensor modification providing you make WB standards using a white card in the memory of the camera for different Lighting Conditions. I have them saved in my Kolari Vision UT Sensor Modified and my Kolari Vision V3 Thin Sensor modified A7r for Daylight, Cloudy, and Shade conditions. If you need even more accurate WB adjustments for the conditions, you can photograph the White Card in the series to make your adjustments. Also, when I had Kolari Vision perform the UT sensor modification, Vivek (real Vivek) and I
...Show more →

Thank you for the information and suggestions regarding the Kolari conversions, Rich. I’ll wait for nehemiahphoto’s report about his NKIR conversion before making a decision.
Nov 05, 2021 at 06:57 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #11Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
Blue Hour
M9 + CV 28/2 II @f/5.6




Nov 05, 2021 at 11:37 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #12Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
freaklikeme wrote:
You could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.


I thought about this route, but I do want to use lots of current m glass as well and have a native/strong performance. If you take out the filter stack completely, lenses perform as native correct? Even picky WA RF film lenses?
Nov 05, 2021 at 12:01 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.24 #13Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
LarsHP wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
LarsHP wroteWouldn't that introduce smearing and other issues in the sides and corners with wide angle RF lenses too?

My understanding is that with angled light passing through (in this case at least two) glass surfaces, the light path will bend. Since different wavelengths will bend to different degrees => an optical nightmare outside the center.

freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
It hasn't so far (tested with the Distagon 18/4, Biogon 21/2.8, Elmarit-M 21/2.8 vI, and Biogon 28/2.8) but the wide RF's do require a "hot mirror" filter rather than a standard UV/IR cut. Kolari's latest filters are the best I've used for this purpose.

That said, modern mirrorless and M-mount lenses tend to take a big hit in this configuration, so you really have to love film-era lenses.
Wait a minute. Are you talking about using a filter in the regular filter thread on the lens? If so, then I understand.

(I thought you suggested putting the filter on the rear of the lens.)


Yeah, just a front filter, though I did try creating rear filters for the Batis 18, Samyang 18, and Loxia 25- all miserable failures. I've only been successful with rear filters on lenses that were built to work with rear filters (the Nikon 16 FE, the Laowa 10-18, and the IRIX 15 with the Aurora glass filter holder replacement).
Nov 05, 2021 at 03:41 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.24 #14Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
I thought about this route, but I do want to use lots of current m glass as well and have a native/strong performance. If you take out the filter stack completely, lenses perform as native correct? Even picky WA RF film lenses?


As native might be a stretch. There's typically a vignetting penalty in using the front filters (even the hot mirror filters don't allow as much light to pass to the corners as a bare lens on a film camera does). It's probably better to say as close to native film performance as digital allows.
Nov 05, 2021 at 03:56 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #15Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
freaklikeme wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
I thought about this route, but I do want to use lots of current m glass as well and have a native/strong performance. If you take out the filter stack completely, lenses perform as native correct? Even picky WA RF film lenses?
As native might be a stretch. There's typically a vignetting penalty in using the front filters (even the hot mirror filters don't allow as much light to pass to the corners as a bare lens on a film camera does). It's probably better to say as close to native film performance as digital allows.


I am sorry, let me phrase my understanding and question more clearly: If you remove the filter stack which does significantly help film lenses, that hurts the native performance of current m glass. Is that correct?
Nov 05, 2021 at 04:03 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.24 #16Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
freaklikeme wroteYou could always just remove the filter stack completely and put the UV/IR cut filter on the end of the lens. It's film-era lens nirvana.
I thought about this route, but I do want to use lots of current m glass as well and have a native/strong performance. If you take out the filter stack completely, lenses perform as native correct? Even picky WA RF film lenses?
As native might be a stretch. There's typically a vignetting penalty in using the front filters (even the hot mirror filters don't allow as much light to pass to the corners as a bare lens on a film camera does). It's probably better to say as close to native film performance as digital allows.
I am sorry, let me phrase my understanding and question more clearly: If you remove the filter stack which does significantly help film lenses, that hurts the native performance of current m glass. Is that correct?


Absolutely, though I will say M-mount lenses are really the last of modern lenses that take film performance into account. The MA, while backordered, is still actively produced, and Leica still wants to sell modern lenses to people buying that camera, so they tend to make more compromises biased to film-users and make up for those compromises in software on the digital M's. So, if you are going to adapt digital-age lenses to a bare-sensor digital camera, Leica's your best-bet so far as getting the most out of them. The mod is more impactful to the camera's performance with native mirrorless lenses.
Nov 05, 2021 at 04:37 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.24 #17Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
freaklikeme wrote:
Yeah, just a front filter, though I did try creating rear filters for the Batis 18, Samyang 18, and Loxia 25- all miserable failures. I've only been successful with rear filters on lenses that were built to work with rear filters (the Nikon 16 FE, the Laowa 10-18, and the IRIX 15 with the Aurora glass filter holder replacement).

OK. This totally makes sense and affirms my understanding as posted above.

I actually have a Sony a7 which is full spectrum converted, and it did very well with the 28mm Summicron Asph II when using a hot mirror type filter in front of the lens. Resolution seemed to be even higher than the UT converted Z6 if I recall correctly.
Nov 06, 2021 at 02:49 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #18Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
M9 + CV 28/2 Ultron II

Handheld, bracketed.




Nov 06, 2021 at 03:38 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.24 #19Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
M9 + CV 28/2 Ultron II

Handheld, bracketed.


Hand held for 1 full second? You must have steady hands like a tripod!

May I ask how you process your bracketed images? (I assume we are talking some kind of HDR proces - either in Photoshop, Photomatix or the like.
Nov 07, 2021 at 07:54 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.24 #20Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron II Review
28mm Ultron II @ f/5.6. Hand-held @ 1/60, 1/250 & 1/2000s. HDR done in Photomatix.





Nov 07, 2021 at 08:08 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister