Keunish wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
lensfan wrote
Daran wrote
I do understand, that your point isn't about technical IQ. But if, as you say, the images are less "engaging on macro level", then that could be a difference in the images (which you could show others) or something outside the image (e.g. how you "feel" while taking image, which likely would not affect others in the same way). While both can be worthwhile points, I think the distinction is absolutely essential for a productive discussion. You are absolutely right. However, I'm afraid I'm not good or experienced enough to provide proper fuel for such a meaningful discussion. This will turn into me not being able to find great subjects that provide the best illustration or variations with photo samples due to me not able to keep conditions identical.
Browsing through hundreds of photos made with 35GM, I feel that it lacks micro-contrast, 3d and color pop to the level I would be expecting from the best 35mm lens ever. This probably contributes to the results not being engaging enough. While a lot of detail is there, bokeh/rendering is non-distracting under challenging conditions, everything is smooth, still my eye does not snap to something on the picture. Its like the lens does not guide or force me to snap on something - its like I need to make a decision/effort to choose something to focus on.
Or maybe it is the nature of 35mm focal length which is somewhere in between being close and wide, getting stuff in the picture with no distortion but lacking focus? And it was Zeiss/Cosina pop that drove me to it despite the inherent characteristics of 35mm FL? I am not at all sure the 35 GM is the best 35mm lens ever, but it certainly is a wonderful 35mm lens with lots of good qualities. Contrary to what you say here, however, it does have lots of microcontrast, and I think that is one of the strengths of the lens. I have used lots of 35mm lenses including the Zeiss Milvus 35 f/1.4; Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4; Zeiss ZE 35 f/1.4; Voigtlander 35 f/1.2; Voigtlander 35 f/1.7; Leica R 35 f/2; Minolta MD 35 f/1.8; Olympus OM 35 f/2, and Canon EF 35 f/2, and only the Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4 has more microcontrast and that lens has some weaknesses the 35 GM does not (primarily field curvature that brings the focus closer to the camera in the edges and corners). I'm not sure the 35 GM is the best of all these lenses, but I think it is perfectly reasonable for someone to come to that conclusion. It is a great performing and very balanced lens and used well I think it can certainly be used to direct your eye where you want in the shot. I think the 35mm focal length can be a challenge to get those shots where your focus is directed, but the 35 GM can handle that as well as any of the 35mm lenses I have used and actually it is probably better than any of them at doing that. The one lens that might be better at doing that is the Zeiss C/Y mount 35 f/1.4, from which I have seen many shots that do the well, but that lens too has several weaknesses the 35 GM does not. I agree, I have a bunch of lenses and one thing I'm sure of is the 35mm GM has a lot of local contrast (or microcontrast).This is the main strenghts of this lens for me (I've posted some pics in the Sony GM vs Zeiss Distagon 35mm 1.4 thread).
I'm very interested by the 35mm ZM now ... Does this lens has a lot more microcontrast than the 35mm GM or just a little bit ? Because this GM is one the lens I own with the best microcontrast (almost as much as my 25-50mm Pana Leica).
In my experience the Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4 has a noticeable amount more microcontrast than the 35 GM, but I am comparing years apart so I very well might not be right. The Zeiss ZM is a Leica M mount lens and doesn't adapt all the well to a Sony camera, so you would have that to contend with if you try it.