p.2 #1Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
Juha Kannisto wrote: chiron wroteJuha Kannisto wrotej4nu wroteJuha Kannisto wrote・SIGMA 45mm F2.8 DG DN | Contemporary in SONY E-mount
[Benefits of the update]
・It has improved focusing accuracy in single AF (AF-S)I hope that's a typo ...Since they wrote both "single AF" and "AF-S" it's probably not meaning AF-C...
But I'm happy to update in any case... I still have 45/2.8 in both E and L mounts.
I haven't used my 45/2.8 much recently though since I got so many new lenses in last few months, including all the other I-series. Will probably be hard to notice what has changed in use.Juha,
When you were using the 45/2.8, did you notice any difficulties with AF in any of the modes? If so, what occurred? I just got the Sigma i 35 and 45, and I am expecting delivery today on the 24 and 65. I am very pleased with the 35, but I just got the 45 yesterday and haven't had a chance to shoot with it yet. I'd be very interested in your experience with AF on the 45, and anything else you have to say about any of the i lenses.In 2019 when the 45/2.8 DG DN was still new I used it a lot on my A9 during summer holiday in Finland with my family and I took many casual family portrait shots in 1-2 m range over the table etc. using eye-AF and face-AF with my A9 in AF-C mode (as long as I remember). It's been a while so I don't remember the exact settings but it was wide open at f2.8 / ISO 100 and there was usually plenty of light so shutter speeds were not too slow. Focus acquisition was working seemingly fine but later when checking the photos on my PC I noticed that critical focus was off in quite many shots and not exactly in the eye or face where I had focused. I didn't have problems focusing on other type of objects and at longer range. I also took many other type of shots with that lens on that holiday that I really liked a lot and overall the experience was positive but AF seemed a bit suspicious especially for close range people shots.
I had also already shot an Okinawa-style Eisa dance event outdoors in Shinjuku before that with hundreds of shots of dancers using real time tracking and I didn't notice any AF issues at that time. The focusing distances were a bit longer there, in the 2-10 m range for the most part.
Later on I've mostly shot still subjects and not many people shots with the lens as that's what I mostly shoot anyway especially these days when there are no events. I've been very pleased with the lens overall, especially the rendering and of course the build quality and handling.
As for the other I-series lenses, all are still pretty new and I haven't shot any one of them extensively yet but all 3 have impressed me. I've especially enjoyed shooting the 24/3.5 and 65/2 as a pair swapping the lenses at times and 35/2 on single lens outings with my A7C. The whole 4-set makes a nice AF lens kit with the A7C and I'm still contemplating getting some more of them in L-mount for my Sigma fp (currently I just have the 45/2.8 in L-mount that I bought as kit with the fp originally).
I just finished updating the firmware of both lenses and my Sigma fp as well (as I hadn't yet applied the latest firmware update on that before). Will try to use the lens again this week on my A7C, can't shoot much now as it's midnight......Show more →
Thank you, Juha. That is a great report and it will be very helpful to me in knowing what probles tolook for and in what types of shooting situations they are most likely to occur. I have taken some short range people pictures this morning where the Eye-af seemed to acquire well, but now I knw the question is whether in fact it was focused on the eyes. I will get the images into Lightroom later to check. Thanks again. I would of course be interested in any updates as you go along.
p.2 #2Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
I couldn't use my Mac to update the FW. The FW updated crashed each time. Like in the old days of Sony FW updates, I took out my old, really old PC notebook and it worked fine. Thank you for the info, Juha and others.
p.2 #3Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
hco0 wrote:
I'll have it tested tomorrow. Hope it improves! I'm finding a hard time shooting my 8 month-old daughter with AF-S
btw, it's really hard to switch the AF-MF button on my 45C. I nearly shattered my fingernail one time trying to switch it. Is it normal or it should be this way? The switch on my Sigma 85mm DG DN works smoothly.
I guess it's just smaller, hence harder to switch. If I use my thumb (not nail) it switches relatively easily, but a bit harder than on bigger Sigmas...
p.2 #4Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
I just updated the firmware on my Sigma 45mm, using it on an A7RIV. The eye AF in single shot mode is based on my initial impressions much more accurate now. Very sharp on the eyes at f2.8. I am using back button autofocus and a separate button to initiate eye AF in single shot mode. . . . Out of 13 test images at medium light levels indoors (ISO 1000, f2.8, 1/200 second), 12 are pin sharp at a variety of distances, most very close up. . . . I'm excited, but need to keep using it more to confirm.
p.2 #5Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
Another 23 test images in single shot AF, using eye AF. 21 are very sharp on the eyes at various distances at about same indoor lights as before. The two that are soft are one after the other, so it's probably user error of some sort, and they're very soft, not a near miss like I would get before. . . In any event, this is looking like a whole new lens. It's plenty sharp for portraits at f2.8, whereas before I would use it at f3.5 or f4 to have a better likelihood of hitting autofocus. I feel like I just got a present. Such a small, fun lens, that produces consistent beautiful rendering and now is sharp at f2.8!
httivals wrote:
I just updated the firmware on my Sigma 45mm, using it on an A7RIV. The eye AF in single shot mode is based on my initial impressions much more accurate now. Very sharp on the eyes at f2.8. I am using back button autofocus and a separate button to initiate eye AF in single shot mode. . . . Out of 13 test images at medium light levels indoors (ISO 1000, f2.8, 1/200 second), 12 are pin sharp at a variety of distances, most very close up. . . . I'm excited, but need to keep using it more to confirm....Show more →
p.2 #6Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
To add a data point, I've just upgraded my 45/2.8C to v3 firmware and briefly tested it on toddlers moving at different speeds. In AF-C with Eye AF (both real time and back button), high contrast late afternoon spring sunlight, my A7R III is consistently backfocusing with maybe 1-2 accurately focused eyes out of 20 shots. Disappointing if unsurprising perhaps given that the Sigma release notes explicitly refer to AF-S.
I will test AF-S next, at least if that works better it's still an improvement.
p.2 #7Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
Very similar to my experience and also for others. Just this afternoon I foolishly used the lens to photograph my grandson discovering he could open kitchen drawers. Good afternoon light--100 ISO & 1/100 sec & f2.8. Four shots. Each time the camera was indicating that focus was locked on the eye. All four shots are out of focus on the eye, ruining the pictures.
It's not even that it refuses to lock green, which would at least warn you that you weren't going to get the picture. It tells you that you are in focus and in real time tracking.
They should market that lens with an explicit statement that it does not have eye-af capability. I'm not sure it even has Real Time Tracking capability. This is probably why it is the only one of the i series lenses that B&H has on sale.
p.2 #8Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
It’s the oldest, that’s why it’s on sale. The 14-24, released at the same time, is also on sale. The other I lenses are brand new, too soon for discounts. But the discounts will come
I find eye af is working fine for me with af-s now, though the lens is still more sluggish overall then I’d like. I don’t photograph my kids slower than 1/250 unless it’s too dark to avoid.
p.2 #9Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
itai195 wrote:
It’s the oldest, that’s why it’s on sale. The 14-24, released at the same time, is also on sale. The other I lenses are brand new, too soon for discounts. But the discounts will come
I find eye af is working fine for me with af-s now, though the lens is still more sluggish overall then I’d like. I don’t photograph my kids slower than 1/250 unless it’s too dark to avoid.
I'm sure that what you are doing can work and that one can adapt one's shooting practices to make it work. Nor do I mind the limited sharpness at shorter distances at f2.8 with this lens--I can live with that. But I do find it unacceptable that one of the most powerful and useful features of the camera won't work with this lens. The nice rendering is not worth the sluggishness and missed shots for me. Great lens for landscapers, but terrible for event or candid documentary photography involving people.
p.2 #11Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
chiron wrote:
But I do find it unacceptable that one of the most powerful and useful features of the camera won't work with this lens. The nice rendering is not worth the sluggishness and missed shots for me. Great lens for landscapers, but terrible for event or candid documentary photography involving people.
Sorry to hear it's not working out for you, but just to highlight how subjective the user experience with this lens can be... I use the 45c successfully for just that type of shooting. More or less candid, social/documentary, just grabbing a moment... indoors, outdoors, so far exclusively in natural light. And I make absolutely no adjustment from how I shoot my other lenses in order to get the shot.
I'm not big on using af-c, no. But I do have eye af active on my A7III and sort of just let it do its thing when there's an eye in the frame. It just works. For me.
Oh and I just updated the fw last night. Haven't tried it with v3 yet.
p.2 #12Sigma firmaware update for 24-70/2.8 and 45/2.8 DG DN (Sony E)
twelveish wrote: chiron wroteBut I do find it unacceptable that one of the most powerful and useful features of the camera won't work with this lens. The nice rendering is not worth the sluggishness and missed shots for me. Great lens for landscapers, but terrible for event or candid documentary photography involving people.Sorry to hear it's not working out for you, but just to highlight how subjective the user experience with this lens can be... I use the 45c successfully for just that type of shooting. More or less candid, social/documentary, just grabbing a moment... indoors, outdoors, so far exclusively in natural light. And I make absolutely no adjustment from how I shoot my other lenses in order to get the shot.
I'm not big on using af-c, no. But I do have eye af active on my A7III and sort of just let it do its thing when there's an eye in the frame. It just works. For me.
Oh and I just updated the fw last night. Haven't tried it with v3 yet. ...Show more →
I'm glad it works for what you want to do.
The af-c and eye-af with real time tracking is very important to me for what I want to shoot and is why I use the A9 and A1. The Sigma 45 can't do them. Reports from users are 20% to 50% hit rates. The V3 update, which I did before ever using the lens, only affects af-s.