I saw this video recently. One of few youtube video I surprisingly found that I finished it without skipping.
A very interesting talk. Especially a few topics about sharpness, CA, telecentricity and manual focus. I wouldn't mind my lenses bigger now after this video or the lens mount is too big
Anyway, I just find there are very interesting topics covered. It basically indirectly answer many of my personal experience and finding regarding lenses over the years. I seldom find lens talk interesting TBH but this one is good. It also indirectly answer why Leica S is still my favorite camera system in term of output compare any system I ever touched.
zhangyue wrote:
I saw this video recently. One of few youtube video I surprisingly found that I finished it without skipping.
A very interesting talk. Especially a few topics about sharpness, CA, telecentricity and manual focus. I wouldn't mind my lenses bigger now after this video or the lens mount is too big
Anyway, I just find there are very interesting topics covered. It basically indirectly answer many of my personal experience and finding regarding lenses over the years. I seldom find lens talk interesting TBH but this one is good. It also indirectly answer why Leica S is still my favorite camera system in term of output compare any system I ever touched.
Thank you for sharing! It seems like a less technical heavy video compared to the one from Leica with Dr. Karbe. Though to be honest, we constantly talk about these points here, maybe not in these terms, like telecentricity, bokeh quality not just in the background but foreground, transition and how CA and SA affect it.
And while I love the idea of having a lens with Arri Signature Prime (ASP) quality, I do wonder if the compromises (namely size, weight and cost) will be appealing to me, and to many other photographers. Like Art said in the video, it's often undesirable (or not feasible) to correct some of these optical flaws in camera or in PP, so they want to minimize all of these flaws optically. Is it truly needed in a still lens? What sort of compromises do they need to take to bring the cost, size and weight down for photography while being still appealing to the target audience (though as wide as possible)?
Art also said Arri focuses on super smooth bokeh, which is also a quality that many don't prefer here. Most seem to prefer a neutral, busier blur than a pure Gaussian blur that a Canon DS or Sony STF would provide. Art implied that such bokeh quality will give the subject more dimensionality.
I would love to hear what you guys think, maybe to state what kind of compromises you can put up with. If I truly go after the ASP experience in photography, I think the Nikon Z ticks all the boxes (bigger mount than the sensor for absolute telecentricity if needed, huge ginormous lenses to minimize flaws, etc.). But it doesn't seem to be as popular of a system, even around here.
P.S.: It's amazing how they shot that entire film with only 2 normal lenses, 35 & 40.
hiepphotog wrote:
Thank you for sharing! It seems like a less technical heavy video compared to the one from Leica with Dr. Karbe. Though to be honest, we constantly talk about these points here, maybe not in these terms, like telecentricity, bokeh quality not just in the background but foreground, transition and how CA and SA affect it.
And while I love the idea of having a lens with Arri Signature Prime (ASP) quality, I do wonder if the compromises (namely size, weight and cost) will be appealing to me, and to many other photographers. Like Art said in the video, it's often undesirable (or not feasible) to correct some of these optical flaws in camera or in PP, so they want to minimize all of these flaws optically. Is it truly needed in a still lens? What sort of compromises do they need to take to bring the cost, size and weight down for photography while being still appealing to the target audience (though as wide as possible)?
Art also said Arri focuses on super smooth bokeh, which is also a quality that many don't prefer here. Most seem to prefer a neutral, busier blur than a pure Gaussian blur that a Canon DS or Sony STF would provide. Art implied that such bokeh quality will give the subject more dimensionality.
I would love to hear what you guys think, maybe to state what kind of compromises you can put up with. If I truly go after the ASP experience in photography, I think the Nikon Z ticks all the boxes (bigger mount than the sensor for absolute telecentricity if needed, huge ginormous lenses to minimize flaws, etc.). But it doesn't seem to be as popular of a system, even around here.
P.S.: It's amazing how they shot that entire film with only 2 normal lenses, 35 & 40....Show more →
Motion and still need different things. For example some nervous and "interesting" or "lively" bokeh in a still may add something to the photo and people may want it for their still photos but it can become very distracting and annoying if you have to constantly try to ignore it when watching a movie. So different things for different uses. Similarly, size and weight are a non issue in a large production when this "big" lens is dwarfed by the camera which sits on a tripod that sits on a trolley that has 3 people pushing it around on tracks and all that.
hiepphotog wrote:
Thank you for sharing! It seems like a less technical heavy video compared to the one from Leica with Dr. Karbe. Though to be honest, we constantly talk about these points here, maybe not in these terms, like telecentricity, bokeh quality not just in the background but foreground, transition and how CA and SA affect it.
And while I love the idea of having a lens with Arri Signature Prime (ASP) quality, I do wonder if the compromises (namely size, weight and cost) will be appealing to me, and to many other photographers. Like Art said in the video, it's often undesirable (or not feasible) to correct some of these optical flaws in camera or in PP, so they want to minimize all of these flaws optically. Is it truly needed in a still lens? What sort of compromises do they need to take to bring the cost, size and weight down for photography while being still appealing to the target audience (though as wide as possible)?
Art also said Arri focuses on super smooth bokeh, which is also a quality that many don't prefer here. Most seem to prefer a neutral, busier blur than a pure Gaussian blur that a Canon DS or Sony STF would provide. Art implied that such bokeh quality will give the subject more dimensionality.
I would love to hear what you guys think, maybe to state what kind of compromises you can put up with. If I truly go after the ASP experience in photography, I think the Nikon Z ticks all the boxes (bigger mount than the sensor for absolute telecentricity if needed, huge ginormous lenses to minimize flaws, etc.). But it doesn't seem to be as popular of a system, even around here.
P.S.: It's amazing how they shot that entire film with only 2 normal lenses, 35 & 40....Show more →
Yes, It straight to the point without too tech heavy. The Arri fella is really good here I have to say that he illustrated and broke fancy term down to bottom to easy digest. I personally know most of these over the years but watch this is still refreshing
I think the benefit I got from this video is really concept level how to interpret CA, sharpness, mount size, aperture location and lens size etc... I don't think Still lens should be designed with same thinking as motion picture, as I don't really care about focus breath or mechanical design or size etc...However, I do think the rendering goal are very similar for me personally. I got more inspiration from motion picture than still nowadays to form my preference in term of lens rendering. This is also become a goal for me to assemble my glasses selection. Size is for travel and landscape but not a consideration for me to shooting for love or fun at daily base.
If you allow I disagree with you one thing is about "ultra smoothness" interpretation in the video. It is definitely not Gaussian blur or the look you get from most 85~135 f1.4 look but very neutral look of background without double line, bokeh fringing or corner funkiness but not boring at all in the same time. I can't put word to describe it however, watch movie is the only way to appreciate it. (The latest one using ALEXA LF and ARRI Signature Primes is Enola Holmes) It is not shallow DOF look but really the calm, smooth look of background with all the info there, and especially watch the focus transition.
I really have no intention to bring mount size to introduce brand war here. The general rule applies in term of preference of telecentricity design in bokeh and corner rendering. However we can't just make it rule of thumb. I think it is really affect wide to standard focal length than long glass given lens physical length, light path and aperture location. And latest Sony wide angle are fine without obvious disadvantage to Canon or Nikon in additional to having size benefits.
As you rightly pointed out that Latest Nikon design is using the mount size and telecentricity design,(50mm f1.2) but size is huge and rendering benefit (if there is) is unclear so I don't know if market appreciate that but it would a good topic to discuss in the future when we compare them together later.
If you ask me, my personally favorite glasses set are Leica S. They are sharp but smooth at the same time, you don't see picture speak sharpness but picture and story. You don't see corner render issue on any of them, the cat eye behave better than most similar focal glasses out there. and they are all long glasses with telecentric design with big S mount. (Lecia use S glass formula to build a set of Thalia for ARRI ALEXA 65 large format). In loose term, I prefer S to R(and some hand picked Nikon F, Zeiss SLR) to M glass in term of rendering. I know this become subjective so take that with a grain of salts if you don't agree.
These are really nerd terms but that is too niche to be relevant to most people I would say. Nowadays, I almost treat sharpness as my number 3 or 4 items in consideration of lens selection as it is really easy to achieve it TBH.
You can envisage potentially a high degree of convergence happening via technology, if we ever see intelligently made movies again. So much of the cine experience now revolves around the level of kinetic activity and inevitably, FX and digital fakery.
The most memorable movies tend to be relentlessly storyboarded (a stills exercise), with few jump cuts and strong inter- and intra-scene continuity. Depends on audience demographics to such an extent, but games have dealt the art of modern movie-making a terrible blow - cartoons need not be sharp. Nothing works like giving the viewer a visual hold in the form of a strong composition, so many of the best movies come over as a series of stills. In times of relentless chaos, nothing works like 'stopping the world' and giving audiences the opportunity to engage more deeply.
'The Movies' in the main should be retitled 'the Jerkies'. Sharpness in reality-based movies can never progress to the point it interferes with the visual, aural and verbal narrative. We might get there yet in stills. The better lenses don't have to be so obviously sharp, they have a kind of trustworthiness to their performance once it's realised how high resolving they are at 100%. Micro-contrast deals with the edge of what can be seen/unseen, it's essentially the knowledge that more resolution is waiting just past the limits of visibility in the viewed media.