fredmiranda.com Login

Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review

  
 
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.18 #1Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
You are in the minority when you say the atrocious bokeh of CV 35/2 does not bother anyone. Sales figures of that lens will tell Cosina what not to do again.

vdo1 wrote:
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.



Apr 20, 2021 at 03:47 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.18 #2Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
I don't think APO's intended audience will care about subpar bokeh, there are noktons for that...
I'd be more worried about the GM though ...

realVivek wrote:
You are in the minority when you say the atrocious bokeh of CV 35/2 does not bother anyone. Sales figures of that lens will tell Cosina what not to do again.

vdo1 wrote
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.

Apr 20, 2021 at 04:07 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.18 #3Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
j4nu wrote:
I don't think APO's intended audience will care about subpar bokeh, there are noktons for that...
I'd be more worried about the GM though ...

realVivek wroteYou are in the minority when you say the atrocious bokeh of CV 35/2 does not bother anyone. Sales figures of that lens will tell Cosina what not to do again.

vdo1 wrote
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.


Ah the Noktons... they have purple fringing, LoCa, onion rings, cat eyes and other ailments, but no one is bothered by those either.... Their "rendering" is not to be questioned. Because "Nokton". They have "character" unlike "sterile" lenses.
Apr 20, 2021 at 04:40 PM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.18 #4Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
The GM (from the images thread) is sitting pretty.

j4nu wrote:
I don't think APO's intended audience will care about subpar bokeh, there are noktons for that...
I'd be more worried about the GM though ...

realVivek wroteYou are in the minority when you say the atrocious bokeh of CV 35/2 does not bother anyone. Sales figures of that lens will tell Cosina what not to do again.

vdo1 wrote
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.


Apr 20, 2021 at 04:57 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.18 #5Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
So you folks that have had both this and the 35 1.8 feel that this is a significantly better lens for overall rendering?

Images in the image thread look quite nice.
Apr 20, 2021 at 07:13 PM
lora_to
Offline
Details
p.18 #6Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Jonas B wrote:
Hmm... Your napkin may be out with a factor of ten. Then again I also make mistakes... but I suspect something is off with your numbers. Logic also tells us that every lens test made at a short distance is impossible, or close to impossible. Yet people, all IMA-test folks and so on have done this for years.

Anyway, it doesn't matter really as:
a) I can repeat the test easily
b) other lenses work fine with the same setup
c) Check the "resolution" curves I showed and you'll see the Sigmas were better when checked at the right most patch (patch 7)
...Show more →

Yep, it's just very hard to test lenses accurately - especially at such short distances and such high spacial frequencies up to 60lp/mm. Alignment just becomes so critical. I just don't think you can test up to 60lp/mm accurately in a home setup at under 1m distance, the DoF is just too shallow and there are too many (6) degrees of freedom in setting up a camera. Heck, even the flatness of your shelf front could matter - some testers even dry the paper of their charts in an oven to minimize curling problems due to humidity. I found documentation for a photo magazine testing film lenses at 55 times focal length - that'd be about 2 meters, but lower lp/mm than 60.

The math is pretty simple, mostly just basic trig. Let a = sensor to target, b = imaged length of the shelf/2, c = sensor to "patch 7" diagonal distance, d = a + depth-of-field_at_distance(a). FOV horz 35mm is 54.4 deg, so half-angle theta is 27.2 deg. You just need to calculate c = a / tan(theta) and then solve the "opposite" angle of the triangle with hypotenuse c and adjacent d, so we have theta' = 90 - arccos(d/c) and then the difference theta - theta' is the max allowed angular deviation to stay within DoF.

I could be off by a factor of 10 but a quick check using the old physics trick of "projecting" a force (cos of angle times magnitude of force) shows that an 8 degree error moves back the right edge focal plane by 5.3cm, 4 deg by 2.8cm, 1 deg 8mm, so that looks right to me, based on your 60lp/mm chart your acceptable DoF is 8.5mm.

You could look into MTFMapper "Automatic chart orientation estimation" to check your alignment, http://mtfmapper.blogspot.com/2017/02/automatic-chart-orientation-estimation.html and https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/4116202 .

It would be interesting if you could replicate your findings at longer distances - the problems should also show at other distances if the elements are misaligned or even incorrectly ground. You should see a marked difference in image quality of the edges at infinity.
Apr 20, 2021 at 07:40 PM
nehemiahphoto
Online
Details
p.18 #7Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
DaveFP wrote:
So you folks that have had both this and the 35 1.8 feel that this is a significantly better lens for overall rendering?

Images in the image thread look quite nice.


YES
Apr 20, 2021 at 07:44 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.18 #8Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
DaveFP wroteSo you folks that have had both this and the 35 1.8 feel that this is a significantly better lens for overall rendering?

Images in the image thread look quite nice.
YES



Well that's pretty unequivocal.

Apr 20, 2021 at 07:59 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.18 #9Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
I'll second that comment
Apr 20, 2021 at 08:11 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.18 #10Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
vdo1 wrote:
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.



Nonsense, rendering can be measured in blind tests like nehemiahphoto did recently on the alt forum. It can be just as measurable as anything else, and is applicable for any one who makes it part of their evaluation of a lens. The APO 35 f/2 is sharp but it does not do well in such tests of rendering. I wouldn't say it bokeh is atrocious, but I would say it is quite busy int he transition zone and it is fairly high contrast.

I think Fred's tests of rendering in this thread are a quite useful part of the review he did here.
Apr 20, 2021 at 08:27 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.18 #11Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Do you guys know:

I have an older version of LR (need to upgrade my OS).

It will not contain the corrections for this Sigma.

Anyone know what they are so I can manually input?

Apr 20, 2021 at 08:27 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.18 #12Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
vdo1 wrote:
j4nu wroteI don't think APO's intended audience will care about subpar bokeh, there are noktons for that...
I'd be more worried about the GM though ...

realVivek wroteYou are in the minority when you say the atrocious bokeh of CV 35/2 does not bother anyone. Sales figures of that lens will tell Cosina what not to do again.

vdo1 wrote
ikit wroteActually I don't understand the popularity of sigma 35/2 over FE35/1.8:

- sigma has a bit better sharpness (mostly offcenter and more open) but bigger distortion so after correction the sharpness may be very similar
- on f8 the sharpness is very similar
- sigma has onion bokeh:/
- is 50g heavier
- 1/3EV darker
- in my country it's more expensive
- doesn't have a button
- has worse AF performance
- worse MFD
- worse focus breathing

So what makes it so special?
"Rendering". That ineffable quality that can be always invoked to defend one's preferences against some measurable evidence.

It's applicable though only when convenient. Just check how the Voigtlander APO 35/2 atrocious bokeh doesn't seem to bother anyone.
Ah the Noktons... they have purple fringing, LoCa, onion rings, cat eyes and other ailments, but no one is bothered by those either.... Their "rendering" is not to be questioned. Because "Nokton". They have "character" unlike "sterile" lenses.


Another big mischaracterization of Voigtlander lenses. These are f/1.2 lenses. Wide open they have lots of aberrations, but stopped down a bit they do have nice rendering especially in the transition zone. They do have cat's eyes until well stopped down, but onion rings are exceedingly rare. Of course their rendering can be questioned, but that doesn't mean some people don't like what they have to offer.
Apr 20, 2021 at 08:32 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.18 #13Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
DaveFP wrote:
Do you guys know:

I have an older version of LR (need to upgrade my OS).

It will not contain the corrections for this Sigma.

Anyone know what they are so I can manually input?



Fred reviews the manual distortion correction earlier in the review under his discussion of distortion.
Apr 20, 2021 at 08:34 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.18 #14Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Steve Spencer wrote:
DaveFP wroteDo you guys know:

I have an older version of LR (need to upgrade my OS).

It will not contain the corrections for this Sigma.

Anyone know what they are so I can manually input?
Fred reviews the manual distortion correction earlier in the review under his discussion of distortion.


Thanks Steve.

Apr 20, 2021 at 08:48 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.18 #15Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
Apr 20, 2021 at 08:59 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.18 #16Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
vdo1 wrote:
One of the most popular Voigtlanders:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1508676/18&year=2017#14207572


You seem to love to bring this up!

Yes, the CV 40/1.2's specular highlights can show onion ring pattern although not the worse I've seen. The 35/1.2 III and 50/1.2 Nokton lenses not so much. Sony is doing better with their aspherical molding process compared to Sigma.

The Nokton's focus transitions are generally very smooth but rendering is not perfect:
There is strong axial CA at f/1.2
Cats' eye bokeh off-axis at f/1.2

It's the compromise for having super fast + compact lenses. Many of us love the images they produce and they should only be compared to other ultra fast lenses that are compact as well.

Please, let's put this to rest. Thank you!
Apr 20, 2021 at 09:38 PM
gordec
Offline
Details
p.18 #17Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
i35 is glued to the a7c. Almost perfect for everyday stuff. Somehow Capture 1 thinks this is Loxia 35. Maybe C1 thinks it's like Loxia with autofocus and softer transition.






Edited on Apr 21, 2021 at 12:51 PM · View previous versions
Apr 21, 2021 at 12:06 PM
offtraildog
Offline
Details
p.18 #18Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
@gordec. I am of the same opinion.
Apr 21, 2021 at 12:17 PM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #19Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
DaveFP wrote:
So you folks that have had both this and the 35 1.8 feel that this is a significantly better lens for overall rendering?

Images in the image thread look quite nice.


---------------------------------------------

nehemiahphoto wrote:
DaveFP wroteSo you folks that have had both this and the 35 1.8 feel that this is a significantly better lens for overall rendering?

Images in the image thread look quite nice.
YES


+1

Apr 21, 2021 at 01:33 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.18 #20Sigma 35mm f/2 DG DN Contemporary Review
chiron wrote:
I'm assuming that you keep the tripod in place as you go through the different Sigma lenses. If so, one way to get some evidence on whether it is your setup or the lenses creating the softness would be to break down your setup (tripod, camera, lens, and including dismounting the test charts) and then set it all up again and retest one of the lenses with the second setup.. If the flaw is in your setup, it is very unlikely that your error would occur in the same way a second time. If you get the same results with
...Show more →

I get your point and it's not bad at all.
However, I never had more than one of the Sigmas at hand at any given day. Borrowed, returned, ordered and returned... and I didn't keep the last one either.
So, the test shots with the Sigma are all taken different days and can't be repeated.
But, doing some alterations...I'll do that if I get another lens not working as expected. it doesn't happen often.
Apr 21, 2021 at 02:05 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister