Of course, she didn't move very fast but all cat owners know the tendancy of this little fur balls to get immediately very, very close every time you point a camera at them (you know, whith this look in the eyes which means : "if I was 80 pounds heavier I would eat you"). A9, af-c, small flexible spot (neither real time tracking activated or animal AF). The first picture was the closer she gets while maintaining a sharp picture around the eyes wide open....Show more →
So, what's your overall impression of tracking in AF-C?
There is an ongoing debate here that all Sigma stepper motors are bad (significantly worse than Sony native lenses) at tracking (so the whole I series).
There were also people returning the lens because it coulnd't keep up with their kids. On the other hand, when I had it, I didn't notice any major AF slowness (and managed to take snaps of my kids with a similar success rate as Sony lenses), but I didn't really test tracking (e.g. multiple shots of something coming towards the camera)...
mjk115 wrote: nhsonyshooter wrotemjk115 wrotenhsonyshooter wroteIt would be interesting to see it compared to the 20mm 1.8 then in crop mode?The 20 F1.8 in crop mode is wider. I think the Sigma is more like 32-33mm. I've done quick and dirty test, nothing on tripods.Yes I know, it's 30mm. But 30mm is closer to 32 than the 24GM is which is 36mm.So this is a far cry from Fred's tests, but I did a quick tripod test between the i35 and he 20G. I had to adjust the exposure slightly to make them look the same, and the light was a bit variable which may have created some differences. I shot the 20 in APS-C mode at 1.8, and the 35 at 2.8. Anyway, this is for anyone who might find it useful:
Nice! Just as expected. Not much difference. Thanks!
Of course, she didn't move very fast but all cat owners know the tendancy of this little fur balls to get immediately very, very close every time you point a camera at them (you know, whith this look in the eyes which means : "if I was 80 pounds heavier I would eat you"). A9, af-c, small flexible spot (neither real time tracking activated or animal AF). The first picture was the closer she gets while maintaining a sharp picture around the eyes wide open.So, what's your overall impression of tracking in AF-C?
There is an ongoing debate here that all Sigma stepper motors are bad (significantly worse than Sony native lenses) at tracking (so the whole I series).
There were also people returning the lens because it coulnd't keep up with their kids. On the other hand, when I had it, I didn't notice any major AF slowness (and managed to take snaps of my kids with a similar success rate as Sony lenses), but I didn't really test tracking (e.g. multiple shots of something coming towards the camera)...
Honnestly, I think that the af-c looks good enough. I've been pleasantly surprised by the AF speed, accuracy and silence of the Sigma 35. It may be slightly slower than the Samyang(s) that I returned for a tilted focal plane, but it's perfectly usable. Honnestly not significantly worse than my Zony 35 1.4. (When I bought it a few years ago, despite its flaws, I was impressed by the speed and silence of its AF).
It may just be a tad less accurate at short distance when taking still subjects, but it may just be my imagination.
But before I took the picutres of this cat, I never took any challenging subject moving toward me with it. I may have been lucky but it did the job very well.
Precision : 99% of the time I use af-c with small flexible spot, in fact like a good old DSLR, without real time tracking. I think that it hurts a little bit the accuracy of AF sometimes. I turn eye/face af on or off depending on the situation. It can hurts accuracy as well sometimes. In dim light and backlight, face AF looks sometimes more like a hair-around-the-face AF than anything else...
EDIT : you know what, she came back while I was writing. I've tried tracking again, this time with animal eye-af and real time tracking. The weather is good and there is plenty of light (3 pm here in France), so, why not. In this good light it works well, very well, even at short distance where it starts to be more challenging.
3 pictures and a crop :
The 2 first pictures are perfectly focused on the eye. Trust me on this. The third one, I'm not sure. I give you the 100% crop :
The fur above the eye is not sharp, which is not surprising given the DOF at this distance. The eye itself, I don't know, I had to raise the exposure on it to see something, but it still looks decent to me. But it t has to be THIS close for the AF to be challenged. So, my guess is that for slow moving subjects at close distance (let's say a kid playing gently inside the house with a proper light), it's good.
However, I don't know how it behaves for fast moving subjects at greater distance, or in really dim light (the same kid jumping around your swimming pool at nightfall could be another story, for instance).
Of course, she didn't move very fast but all cat owners know the tendancy of this little fur balls to get immediately very, very close every time you point a camera at them (you know, whith this look in the eyes which means : "if I was 80 pounds heavier I would eat you"). A9, af-c, small flexible spot (neither real time tracking activated or animal AF). The first picture was the closer she gets while maintaining a sharp picture around the eyes wide open.So, what's your overall impression of tracking in AF-C?
There is an ongoing debate here that all Sigma stepper motors are bad (significantly worse than Sony native lenses) at tracking (so the whole I series).
There were also people returning the lens because it coulnd't keep up with their kids. On the other hand, when I had it, I didn't notice any major AF slowness (and managed to take snaps of my kids with a similar success rate as Sony lenses), but I didn't really test tracking (e.g. multiple shots of something coming towards the camera)...Honnestly, I think that the af-c looks good enough. I've been pleasantly surprised by the AF speed, accuracy and silence of the Sigma 35. It may be slightly slower than the Samyang(s) that I returned for a tilted focal plane, but it's perfectly usable. Honnestly not significantly worse than my Zony 35 1.4. (When I bought it a few years ago, despite its flaws, I was impressed by the speed and silence of its AF).
It may just be a tad less accurate at short distance when taking still subjects, but it may just be my imagination.
But before I took the picutres of this cat, I never took any challenging subject moving toward me with it. I may have been lucky but it did the job very well.
Precision : 99% of the time I use af-c with small flexible spot, in fact like a good old DSLR, without real time tracking. I think that it hurts a little bit the accuracy of AF sometimes. I turn eye/face af on or off depending on the situation. It can hurts accuracy as well sometimes. In dim light and backlight, face AF looks sometimes more like a hair-around-the-face AF than anything else......Show more →
Thanks! That mostly matches my impression from the brief time I had with 35i.
I will start a new Voigtlander 35/2 APO review soon and compare it to the Sigma 35/2 DG DN. I can already say they are close in resolution while the Sigma's rendering is smoother in comparison.
I was planning on selling the i35 when the 35GM arrives, which I pre-ordered back in January. Now, after getting an A7c to replace my A7III (I am transitioning now from A6400/A7III to A7C/A7RIII or IV, have not yet decided on the latter) and seeing Fred's test, I am not so sure anymore. Coming from the original NEX series, I am a big fan of small and light kits. The A7C with the Sigma 35/2 DG DN is perfect in that respect. In addition, it handles both close-up (rendering) and landscapes really well, and its sunstar is nicer to my eyes to that of the GM (from what I have seen). I think I'll wait for the GM to arrive and then make a full comparison for myself, including handling on the A7C to see what is best for me.
In addition, my whole photography adventure got a new turn as I recently bought a printer (Canon PROGRAF 1000) and starting selling/exhibiting some prints in a small downtown gallery/shop, which I rented primarily as a non-home home-office for my day job. Suddenly the "quest for most bokeh" is not a driver in my photography anymore, all the images I printed and framed are tack-sharp corner to corner So I might not need the 1.4 of the GM. We will see...
Flaxx74 wrote:
I was planning on selling the i35 when the 35GM arrives, which I pre-ordered back in January. Now, after getting an A7c to replace my A7III (I am transitioning now from A6400/A7III to A7C/A7RIII or IV, have not yet decided on the latter) and seeing Fred's test, I am not so sure anymore. Coming from the original NEX series, I am a big fan of small and light kits. The A7C with the Sigma 35/2 DG DN is perfect in that respect. In addition, it handles both close-up (rendering) and landscapes really well, and its sunstar is nicer to my eyes to that of the GM (from what I have seen). I think I'll wait for the GM to arrive and then make a full comparison for myself, including handling on the A7C to see what is best for me.
In addition, my whole photography adventure got a new turn as I recently bought a printer (Canon PROGRAF 1000) and starting selling/exhibiting some prints in a small downtown gallery/shop, which I rented primarily as a non-home home-office for my day job. Suddenly the "quest for most bokeh" is not a driver in my photography anymore, all the images I printed and framed are tack-sharp corner to corner So I might not need the 1.4 of the GM. We will see......Show more →
Important to differentiate between the best bokeh (quality) and the most bokeh (quantity).
I'd love to have the bestest and the mostest in one lens but if forced to choose I'll take the best over the most.
Rather shoot an f/2 with a lovely OOF rendering than a harsh 1.4.
smpetty wrote:
These are awesome! What is your job?
Thanks smpetty. I run a small secondary metal refinery with my brother. I do all the melting. My grandfather started the business back in '54 and some things haven't changed since then. We tend to use things until they're done, and then we use them some more. Makes for a lot of interesting textures and colors though. Thanks again,
Mike
35 f1.4 GM size comparison. We already know the 35 F2 delivers in terms of IQ/output. If people are drawn to the GM because it is small, then the Sigma makes a compelling case as an alternative: