So, I have a birthday coming up in February and as I’ve done many times, I typically buy myself an expensive gift. This year, I plan on getting a new lens.
Last year, I bought a Nikon D850 (to replace my D800E) and a Nikon 70-700 F2.8E and absolutely love this combo. In fact, it has become my main setup.
This year I’m looking to fill the void of a 24-70 zoom lens. In fact, I did consider the Nikon 24-70 F 2.8E but I don’t like the size; so, for now it’s a non-consideration. I also looked at both the Tamron and Sigma variants, but in the end I’m not really keen on a 24-70 zoom.
That said, I do have the Nikon AF-S 24-85 F3.5-4.5 VR lens and have gotten some great results with it on my D800E. Yeah, it’s not the sharpest lens, but it works for what I do – mainly landscape, nature, and still life. Plus, its small size makes it a versatile all-around zoom lens when weight is a factor.
Anyway, I’m now leaning towards the Nikon 58 F1.4G lens since I really don’t have a good 50. I do have the old Sigma 50mm 1.4 EX DG HSM lens (non-Art) lens, but its auto focus tends to be a bit hit and miss at times, and its slow focusing, even on my D850. Love the bokeh though.
I understand the Nikon 58 is somewhat of a controversial lens with a ridiculous price tag, but I also see what it produces. I also like the focal length and lens size. It would also compliment my primes in the Nikon 24 F1.4G lens, the Nikon 85 F1.4ED lens, and my Sigma 35 F1.4 Art lens. And if I only wanted to carry just two lenses it would be the 58 + 70-200 lens. It would also be nice alternative to carrying the 70-200 around all day.
No offense, but your posted question wanders all over the place when it comes to WHAT you want to use your next lens for. So it might help if you could clarify that.
The 58/1.4 is a unique "look" lens, consistent centrally at closer to medium distances with designed in edge resolution fall-off, but then can get wonky at distance or with off-center subjects. In all honesty the final look is not far off what you can already get with your older Sigma 50/1.4 non-art at f1.4 though 2.8 (I used to own one); and then the Sigma is going to be better at distance, stopped down, or as an all-around 50 IMHO...
By comparison most of the Sigma Arts and Nikon GN primes are sharp corner to corner throughout the aperture range.
I think a 24-70 is more versatile and very useful if you want a single lens for most everyday occasions. It's likely a better choice as a lens to buy in the earlier stages vs the 58mm.
When I had a D750 I owned the Tamron 24-70 f2.8 G2 and loved it. I sold it when I went mirrorless since the f/4 z version is better despite f4. I'm still on the fence if I'm buying the f2.8 Z version and probably will one day.....but for now the primes and the f4 meet my needs.
The 58mm I'm still learning with. I love it as it gives me images I can't get with other 50mm primes (I might disagree with Gear-nut on that small point), but I do think that the 58mm is not reliable enough to work quickly and accurately with......at least for me. The 58mm has that special artistic something that I love but I'm glad I added it to my kit after having other lenses. The Sigma 50mm f1.4 is fantastic....sharp and nice transition to bokeh (though some argue otherwise). I did find it to be a bit too boring though.
So if you want something to be creative and artistic with, the 58mm is fantastic. If you want a reliable workhorse that nails a wide array of images but in a more standard way, I would recommend the Tamron (and its VR).
Lastly, if you're thinking you'll move to mirrorless one day soon, I'd save your money. The Tamron 24-70 G2 was awkward on my Z7 and not as sharp as the native Z lenses. The 58mm works well with the Z7 if that helps.
gear-nut wrote:
No offense, but your posted question wanders all over the place when it comes to WHAT you want to use your next lens for. So it might help if you could clarify that.
The 58/1.4 is a unique "look" lens, consistent centrally at closer to medium distances with designed in edge resolution fall-off, but then can get wonky at distance or with off-center subjects. In all honesty the final look is not far off what you can already get with your older Sigma 50/1.4 non-art at f1.4 though 2.8 (I used to own one); and then the Sigma is going to be better at distance, stopped down, or as an all-around 50 IMHO...
By comparison most of the Sigma Arts and Nikon GN primes are sharp corner to corner throughout the aperture range. ...Show more →
My "wandering" is the thought process I went through in coming to the decision to give the Nikon 58 a serious look.
For me "sharpness" isn't the only thing I judge a lens by, and if it was strictly about corner to corner sharpness, the Nikon 50 F1.4g or perhaps the Sigma 50 Art would be front and center over the 58.
Anyway, I understand the 58 F1.4 is a "unique" lens, and why I'm now considering it. Yeah, I'm looking at creativity as well.
I had the Nikon 24-70 f28G sold that to get the Nikon 24-70 f2.8E VR and didn't think it was very good overall. At least not to the kennel everyone else thought of it. I found it lacking.
I bought the Tamron 24-70 f2.8 G2 and it's by far the best of the 3. I did buy the Tamron tap-in console and the sharpness is crazy. Now I do use it on a D500 so I don't use the out 1/3 of the lens. The Tamron is significantly sharper at center and mid image area than either of the 2 Nikons. It also faster focusing when you tune it with the tap-in console too.
The 58mm is my favourite lens I have ever owned. I use it for travel photography, portraits and landscapes. For me, I'd rather have 1 good fast prime than a slower zoom. You just can't go wrong with the 58 imo.
When I'm travelling and I have the 58mm on it forces me to compose my images to fit the lens. The results for me have been an improvement in my photography. I don't think anyone would ever say... I see you should have had a zoom because it looks like you left some of the scene out. The images just work, the compression is just enough and when you need that creamy, painterly like background for portraits or shots of you beer at a restaurant, you got it
Hardcore wrote:
The 58mm is my favourite lens I have ever owned. I use it for travel photography, portraits and landscapes. For me, I'd rather have 1 good fast prime than a slower zoom. You just can't go wrong with the 58 imo.
When I'm travelling and I have the 58mm on it forces me to compose my images to fit the lens. The results for me have been an improvement in my photography. I don't think anyone would ever say... I see you should have had a zoom because it looks like you left some of the scene out. The images just work, the compression is just enough and when you need that creamy, painterly like background for portraits or shots of you beer at a restaurant, you got it ...Show more →
That's kind of what I'm looking for. Good post.
@sjms, I thought about getting that lens a couple of years back as a replacement to my 24-85. But, right now my just too happy with my 70-200 2.8E. And if I need a wide end, I' could always go to my Nikon 24 F1.4G or AF-S 17-35 F2.8ED lens.
Agree the 24-120 F4 makes a good single wandering lens though. However, already owning the 24-85, I can put that money towards the 58. I'm going sell off (locally) my Nikon 70-200 F4 lens to help pay for the 58 F1.4 as the decision has been made.
right now i'm waiting for the 24-105 that is supposedly going to some out for the Z.
17-35
24-120
70-200
enough overlap to prevent excessive lens swapping
a single focal length doesn't work well all the time
you like using your 70-200 take a ride over to Kenilworth park in DC in the beginning of july. you'll get tons of use out of it there if you like lotus blossoms. a 4hr drive each way for me and has always been worth it.
If you plan on buying new, my advice is to rent the 58 1.4G to see how well you like it. If you plan on buying used, then you won't take much of a financial hit if it doesn't work out and you want to sell it. People either really like it or really don't like it. Not too many are ambivalent about it.
Hardcore wrote:
The 58mm is my favourite lens I have ever owned. I use it for travel photography, portraits and landscapes. For me, I'd rather have 1 good fast prime than a slower zoom. You just can't go wrong with the 58 imo.
When I'm travelling and I have the 58mm on it forces me to compose my images to fit the lens. The results for me have been an improvement in my photography. I don't think anyone would ever say... I see you should have had a zoom because it looks like you left some of the scene out. The images just work, the compression is just enough and when you need that creamy, painterly like background for portraits or shots of you beer at a restaurant, you got it ...Show more →
A very biased opinion from someone is responsible for many people buying the 58mm including myself
Seriously stunning images with the 58mm in your hands - if only it were that easy!
Shotokan wrote:
If you plan on buying new, my advice is to rent the 58 1.4G to see how well you like it. If you plan on buying used, then you won't take much of a financial hit if it doesn't work out and you want to sell it. People either really like it or really don't like it. Not too many are ambivalent about it.
I don't buy used. And I don't buy to return - If I buy I keep; thus why I research before buying.