fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020A Wonderful R5 Charging Option

  
 
TeamSpeed
Offline
Details
p.2 #1A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
I have something similar and added a large fold up solar panel that I can put out when I am outside doing a shoot where it charges my batteries.
Dec 16, 2020 at 12:43 PM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #2A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
I did some tests with the Neewer NH batteries vs. OEM, and here are my findings. I posted this earlier in the Photography on the Net (POTN) forum, so this is pretty much a copy and paste:

What I wanted to know with these batteries by Neewer are: 1) does the R5 recognize them as LP-E6NH and register them in the Battery Info; 2) will they display that Green H+ indicator; 3) if so, at what percentage does it drop to White H+, specifically in comparison to the OEM; 4) do Neewer NH batteries with 2250mAh behave any differently from the OEM’s 2130mAh; 5) does the Neewer dual charger that came with the batteries charge the OEM and other compatible batteries; and 6) do the Neewer NH batteries charge in body or in the grip like the OEM using either a PD wall charger or a PD power bank?

My findings to these questions are (in most cases, tests were done with the batteries in the BG-R10 Grip):

1) Yes, the R5 recognize the Neewer batteries just like the OEM and registers them

2) Yes, both in body and in the grip and in Mechanical and Elec. 1st-Curtain modes. In Electronic mode, it displays White H+. If Electronic is always shooting at approximately 20 fps, the display of White H+ can only be confusing, since the White H+ signifies 9.2 fps. The findings are identical with the OEM batteries.

3) Although the Canon manual states that at least approximate 60% level is needed for the Green H+ for both in body and in the grip, both the Neewer and the OEM went below that and still maintained the Green H+. What’s surprising is that, while the OEM batteries changed from Green H+ to White H+ at 54%/53% (in the grip), the Neewer outperformed at 53%/50%. I decided not to test at what percentage do the batteries go from White H+ to White-blinking as that’s rather insignificant to me. If anyone's okay with using the R5/R6 at that point, then just use the old LP-E6 batteries that give you the same White-blinking. (NB: I believe the reason why my % of Green H+ turning to White H+ is higher than what others have reported here and elsewhere has to do with the temperature of the testing environment, as the % for both Neewer and OEM batteries were consistently at higher point).

4) The reason for the surprise is that I was rather skeptical with the Neewer’s higher mAh rating than the OEM prior to the test. Another indication that validated the Neewer’s higher mAh was that their set of batteries also outperformed in my self-discharge test overnight. With the R5 set not to power off, I inserted a set of two batteries at 100% at 10:30 p.m. before I went to bed and checked for the self-discharge percentage in the following morning at 8 a.m. The result with the OEM was 51%/47% remaining in the grip while the Neewer’s was 53%/50%, again consistent with the latter’s stated higher mAh. Both the OEM and the Neewer displayed White H+ at those percentage points.

Another thing that my test showed was how fast the batteries will self-discharge if you forget to turn the power off. This point has a significant implication for those who do timelapse photography, for example. To conserve the battery power in between the normal shoot it’d be wise to turn the power off as long as doing so will not miss any important opportunities. I did another test to see how much power gets drained with the R5 powered off. The same overnight test came back with unmoved percentage points, i.e., 100%. Since the top LCD has an electronic display of mode last used (e.g., “M”) even when the camera is powered off, some folks have gone as far as to take the battery out when not in use (or, with the grip, turn the knob just enough to release the electronic contact point without taking the whole tray out) to prevent the battery from self-discharging. Given my test, however, the self-discharge rate when powered off is so negligible to take such inconvenient steps.

5) Yes, the Neewer dual charger can charge all compatible batteries including the OEM.

6) Yes, the Neewer batteries in body and in the grip do charge with a PD wall charger and a PD power bank just as the OEM. With a 30W PD power bank, you can even power the camera with a USB-C cable that came with the R5.

For $39.99 that includes two NH batteries and a dual charger, Neewer is a no brainer, clear winner. The only thing that remains to be seen is how these batteries perform in a long term comparison to the OEM. I'll come back to this after 6 months and a year from now to give an update.
Dec 28, 2020 at 12:57 PM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.2 #3A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
I concur with your findings. I too noted that when left in my camera overnight after a charge, they remained 99% later the following day. I love how they tend to keep their charge even when used as compared to the stock Canon batteries. Heck for the $35 from Amazon it's almost worth it to have a 2nd set. The charger is like a gift, and it also works brilliantly. It's so nice to find a good deal on products that actually WORK!
Dec 28, 2020 at 01:07 PM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #4A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
dcisive wrote:
I concur with your findings. I too noted that when left in my camera overnight after a charge, they remained 99% later the following day. I love how they tend to keep their charge even when used as compared to the stock Canon batteries. Heck for the $35 from Amazon it's almost worth it to have a 2nd set. The charger is like a gift, and it also works brilliantly. It's so nice to find a good deal on products that actually WORK!


The problem now is that Neewer NH batteries are out of stock everywhere, not that these were available everywhere to begin with. These Neewer NH batteries perplexes me. Which battery manufacturer provides and has them sold under Neewer brand? Must be small if they can't seem to handle even a modest demand. In fact, I have yet to see them selling just the batteries like other brands, only as a set with the dual charger. It's not the case that Neewer's NH batteries are universally recognized as a strong competitor to the OEM batteries the way Wasabi has. In fact, in 40 years of using batteries for photography, this was the first time I've ever heard of Neewer NH batteries. They are more known for other photographic equipment, never for batteries. Then, they suddenly show up and as suddenly out of stock now.

I must have purchased the very last unit from Newegg, as it said out of stock right afterward. Hopefully, their manufacturer gets really busy and have them back in stock soon.

Dec 28, 2020 at 01:20 PM
Bruce n Philly
Offline
Details
p.2 #5A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
SSO-Images wrote:
.... In Electronic mode, it displays White H+. If Electronic is always shooting at approximately 20 fps, the display of White H+ can only be confusing, since the White H+ signifies 9.2 fps. The findings are identical with the OEM batteries.


Regarding White H+ for electronic shutter: The manual denotes that this is full 20 fps and is white H+. This is inconsistent on Canon's part, not an issue with batteries. In mechanical and 1st curtain, the fastest shutter speed is denoted with a Green H+, slower in White.

So why is the fasted fps in electronic show as White? Only Canon's QA department knows that one, and "oops" is probably in their internal report.

Peace
Bruce in Philly
Dec 28, 2020 at 01:45 PM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.2 #6A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
That's a bummer. Glad I got it when I did. Sorry now I didn't just order 2 of them. When they come back into stock down the road I'll likely have another set just for the heck of it.
Dec 28, 2020 at 01:52 PM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #7A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
dcisive wrote:
That's a bummer. Glad I got it when I did. Sorry now I didn't just order 2 of them. When they come back into stock down the road I'll likely have another set just for the heck of it.


Right after I finished my tests comparing Neewer to OEM, I immediately ordered another one from Newegg without realizing that it was the very last one they had in stock apparently. For one OEM battery cost, you can have 4 Neewer NH batteries that perform better and 2 dual chargers to charge all 4 batteries. That, to me, is sweet!

Dec 28, 2020 at 02:57 PM
TeamSpeed
Offline
Details
p.2 #8A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
Maybe several crates of the Canon battery was "diverted" and then later sold under the Neewer name, and now are gone? We have seen exact units of other manufacturers' items come under the Yong Nuo and Neewer name in the past, for a period of time, so I wonder if this was the situation here. This diversionary tactic on goods have happened many times in the past for various products, "9 for you, 1 for me, 9 for you, 2 for me, 10 for you, 3 for me...."
Dec 28, 2020 at 04:41 PM
shrigg
Offline
Details
p.2 #9A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
SSO-Images wrote:
dcisive wroteThat's a bummer. Glad I got it when I did. Sorry now I didn't just order 2 of them. When they come back into stock down the road I'll likely have another set just for the heck of it.
Right after I finished my tests comparing Neewer to OEM, I immediately ordered another one from Newegg without realizing that it was the very last one they had in stock apparently. For one OEM battery cost, you can have 4 Neewer NH batteries that perform better and 2 dual chargers to charge all 4 batteries. That, to me, is sweet!



I I got lucky enough to get some of the last of NewEgg's stock of Neewers as well. Ordered on 12/24 and received an email today (12/28) with tracking. I'm excited to try them with my R6

Dec 28, 2020 at 04:51 PM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #10A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
TeamSpeed wrote:
Maybe several crates of the Canon battery was "diverted" and then later sold under the Neewer name, and now are gone? We have seen exact units of other manufacturers' items come under the Yong Nuo and Neewer name in the past, for a period of time, so I wonder if this was the situation here. This diversionary tactic on goods have happened many times in the past for various products, "9 for you, 1 for me, 9 for you, 2 for me, 10 for you, 3 for me...."


I don't think that's the case with the Neewer NH batteries, because the Neewer's behave differently from the OEM's, not to mention different mAh. With the OEM's in the grip, the Battery Info displays that the camera draws mostly from one battery initially, then both batteries get drawn about equally at a later stage. With the Neewer's, however, the camera draws from both batteries right from the beginning.

Dec 28, 2020 at 07:17 PM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.2 #11A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
That was one thing that really threw me for a loop. That both the Neewer batteries drain together. But it quite obviously in my experience, slows the process down considerably. I rather like that
Dec 28, 2020 at 08:34 PM
Dave_E
Offline
Details
p.2 #12A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
I got one ordered in Canada should be here Jan 7.Can't wait to check it out.

Dave
Dec 28, 2020 at 09:11 PM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.2 #13A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
stanj wrote:
I like this charger better:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PHYCKLK/ref=dp_prsubs_2

This because it's much much smaller. When packing for a major remote trip, I have a lot of gear, a lot of it in duplicate (no spares in Antarctica, for example) and it all adds up. I had four of these chargers with me last time, two for Canon and two for Sony. Flawless.


I like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.

RE the OP ... I'd be interested in those Neewer if there was a different charger for them without all the cord crap. Presently, STK is the only 3rd party batteries I have a few remnants of and am not impressed with them. I didn't care for Wasabi either.

Dec 28, 2020 at 11:17 PM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #14A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
mdvaden wrote:
stanj wroteI like this charger better:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PHYCKLK/ref=dp_prsubs_2

This because it's much much smaller. When packing for a major remote trip, I have a lot of gear, a lot of it in duplicate (no spares in Antarctica, for example) and it all adds up. I had four of these chargers with me last time, two for Canon and two for Sony. Flawless.
I like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.

RE the OP ... I'd be interested in those Neewer if there was a different charger for them without all the cord crap. Presently, STK is the only 3rd party batteries I have a few remnants of and am not impressed with them. I didn't care for Wasabi either.



You can charge Neewer batteries in Canon's charger.

Dec 28, 2020 at 11:43 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.2 #15A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
mdvaden wrote:
I like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.


That's precisely the reason why I don't like it: because of travel. It takes up more cm^3 per charging capacity, and worse, its charging prongs are wrong in half of the world or more, so it requires a plug converter. If you have a USB cable bound charger you need only one adapter for a plethora of gadgets, and are still ahead by volume. At least that's true for me who travels internationally a lot (well, not this year ) and has more than just the camera to charge.
Dec 29, 2020 at 12:05 AM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.2 #16A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
SSO-Images wrote:
mdvaden wrote
stanj wroteI like this charger better:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PHYCKLK/ref=dp_prsubs_2

This because it's much much smaller. When packing for a major remote trip, I have a lot of gear, a lot of it in duplicate (no spares in Antarctica, for example) and it all adds up. I had four of these chargers with me last time, two for Canon and two for Sony. Flawless.
I like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.

RE the OP ... I'd be interested in those Neewer if there was a different charger for them without all the cord crap. Presently, STK is the only 3rd party batteries I have a few remnants of and am not impressed with them. I didn't care for Wasabi either.
You can charge Neewer batteries in Canon's charger.



That would be handy.

Have you tried it yourself, or know someone who has done it?
Dec 29, 2020 at 12:23 AM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.2 #17A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
stanj wrote:
mdvaden wroteI like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.
That's precisely the reason why I don't like it: because of travel. It takes up more cm^3 per charging capacity, and worse, its charging prongs are wrong in half of the world or more, so it requires a plug converter. If you have a USB cable bound charger you need only one adapter for a plethora of gadgets, and are still ahead by volume. At least that's true for me who travels internationally a lot (well, not this year ) and has more than just the camera to charge.


I charge camera batteries, flash batteries and several other things. So when I travel in the USA, I carry a very compact and short power strip to plug several things into. If I went overseas, I'd only need one adapter for the strip to plug into, then any chargers pronged for USA outlets would fit conveniently

Less cm and even better I suspect.

But it's quite awesome how many types of chargers and configurations are available through Amazon and other outlets for each of us to fit our style of travel.

Dec 29, 2020 at 12:29 AM
SSO-Images
Offline
Details
p.2 #18A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
mdvaden wrote:
SSO-Images wrote
mdvaden wrote
stanj wroteI like this charger better:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PHYCKLK/ref=dp_prsubs_2

This because it's much much smaller. When packing for a major remote trip, I have a lot of gear, a lot of it in duplicate (no spares in Antarctica, for example) and it all adds up. I had four of these chargers with me last time, two for Canon and two for Sony. Flawless.
I like Canon's basic charger even better because if folds prongs compact for travel, or simply plugs in at home.

RE the OP ... I'd be interested in those Neewer if there was a different charger for them without all the cord crap. Presently, STK is the only 3rd party batteries I have a few remnants of and am not impressed with them. I didn't care for Wasabi either.
You can charge Neewer batteries in Canon's charger.
That would be handy.

Have you tried it yourself, or know someone who has done it?


I do it all the time, as well as OEM batteries in the Neewer dual chargers, too.
Dec 29, 2020 at 12:52 AM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.2 #19A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
mdvaden wrote:
But it's quite awesome how many types of chargers and configurations are available through Amazon and other outlets for each of us to fit our style of travel.


That is very true - options are countless, and different people have different needs. I always travel with a MacBook Pro, camera charger, iPhone & watch charger, and a AA/AAA charger. All of them take a USB/C charger, so I have a power brick with 4 USB-A and one USB-C port, which take one power outlet and delivers enough power for everything. All folded up the "gadgets" fit into a small toiletries bag that I love to abuse for this purpose. With today's GaN charger options the biggest component has gotten even smaller, but I'm not shopping yet because before next time I get on a plane there will be even more choices, sadly.

Speaking of power strip: when I travel with more diverse things that need AC, instead of a power strip I take a power splitter - it's a cable that turns into 4 outlets, but it's like a hydra - one cable turns into multiple cables. It's a little bit bigger by volume than a power strip but it allows me to plug in whatever power brick I want, without the usual problem where one power brick can't sit next to the other one. I have it as a leftover from the days before everything was USB powered Yes, that's a 1.5TB drive in a eSATA drive dock, back when that was incredible storage...




Dec 29, 2020 at 01:06 AM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.2 #20A Wonderful R5 Charging Option
mdvaden wrote:
That would be handy.

Have you tried it yourself, or know someone who has done it?


I've done it. I have two R5 batteries, a handful of 5D batteries, and two handfuls of these knockoffs, all charge well in my 5D3 charger.
Dec 29, 2020 at 01:15 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister