fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)

  
 
p.1 #1Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Nobody asked for this but I was curious to see how these two lenses compare.



https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/88/2079188.jpg



The Batis 135 is well known for being one of the sharpest 135mm on the market. But how well a 135mm lens from 1971 compares?
http://www.l-camera-forum.com/leica-wiki.en/index.php/135mm_f/4_Tele-Elmar

I have been impressed with this vintage Leica, so let's see some side by sides.

All comparisons were made at f/5.6 which is optimal for the Leica. The Batis is optimal at f/4.

Spoil-alert: The Batis is superior but the Leica puts up a good fight which is impressive to say the least.



















































Dec 02, 2020 at 03:55 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
You have the 100-400GM ? I'd be curious how that does at 135 compared to both. I have debated on the Batis 135mm multiple times as it is the only Batis that is not bloated. It just feels redundant since I love my 100-400GM so much.
Dec 02, 2020 at 04:05 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Not bad for a simple five-element 50 year-old plus design.
Dec 02, 2020 at 04:09 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #4Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
You have the 100-400GM ? I'd be curious how that does at 135 compared to both. I have debated on the Batis 135mm multiple times as it is the only Batis that is not bloated. It just feels redundant since I love my 100-400GM so much.


I've compared the Batis 135mm to the 100-400@135mm and they are pretty much equal at infinity distance. The zoom has more elements and it's optimal around that focal length so that's not really surprising.

I think the crops are in the Voigtlander 110/2.5 review.
Dec 02, 2020 at 04:13 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Fred Miranda wrote:
nhsonyshooter wroteYou have the 100-400GM ? I'd be curious how that does at 135 compared to both. I have debated on the Batis 135mm multiple times as it is the only Batis that is not bloated. It just feels redundant since I love my 100-400GM so much.
I've compared the Batis 135mm to the 100-400@135mm and they are pretty much equal at infinity distance. The zoom has more elements and it's optimal around that focal length so that's not really surprising.

I think the crops are in the Voigtlander 110/2.5 review.


Thanks. Saved me some money
Dec 02, 2020 at 05:02 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Thanks for this very interesting comparison. That is the difference 55 years makes, from a 5/3 design to a 14/11 lens. Erwin Puts on this Walter Mandler design:

"With the Tele-Elmar-M from 1965 the design reached the theoretical optimum attainable in these days and reigned unchallenged for more then 30 years. Indeed the optical performance of the Tele-Elmar-M in its various redesigned mounts (three times) stayed the same, as *the computation was not changed*. Even today it delivers outstanding image quality."

"The Tele-Elmar-M is optically unchanged since 1965 and has been given several facelifts. The optical performance is, even from today’s high standards, outstanding."

- Erwin Puts, in Leica-M Lenses, their Soul and Secrets.

The newer lens delivers better wide open IQ, and a stronger center at f5.6, which Zeiss use as their 'best aperture'. The Leica may have the edge for low spatial frequencies (10-20 lpmm), certainly it seems easier on the eye in several crop motifs, less 'crunchy'. Its MTF chart indicates strong corners, as seen here. Better green separation as well.

That's against a modern state-of-the-art APO design with a close to the commercial ceiling budget - hence the initial price of the B135. On a camera that would have been science fiction in 1965.
Dec 02, 2020 at 05:32 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #7Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
philip_pj wrote:
Thanks for this very interesting comparison. That is the difference 55 years makes, from a 5/3 design to a 14/11 lens.


You are welcome!

That's against a modern state-of-the-art APO design with a close to the commercial ceiling budget - hence the initial price of the B135. On a camera that would have been science fiction in 1965.

Love it!

I checked the serial number and my copy was produced in 1971....the year I was born!
The lens acquired no tilt or swing during all this time. A testament of how well built it is. (focusing is still smooth as butter)

Seriously, it will outlast me which may not be the case with the modern Batis.
Dec 02, 2020 at 05:44 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Fred Miranda wrote:
philip_pj wroteThanks for this very interesting comparison. That is the difference 55 years makes, from a 5/3 design to a 14/11 lens.
You are welcome!

Earlier quoteThat's against a modern state-of-the-art APO design with a close to the commercial ceiling budget - hence the initial price of the B135. On a camera that would have been science fiction in 1965.
Love it!

I checked the serial number and my copy was produced in 1971....the year I was born!
The lens acquired no tilt or swing during all this time. A testament of how well built it is. (focusing is still smooth as butter)

Seriously, it will outlast me which may not be the case with the modern Batis.


You wouldn't happen to have a Samyang 135 f2 hanging around. That would be another one to compare against. Kinda surprised Samyang has not release a modern mirrorless version of that yet. But if they did that you probably couldn't use a converter on it though.
Dec 02, 2020 at 07:36 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #9Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
philip_pj wroteThanks for this very interesting comparison. That is the difference 55 years makes, from a 5/3 design to a 14/11 lens.
You are welcome!

Earlier quoteThat's against a modern state-of-the-art APO design with a close to the commercial ceiling budget - hence the initial price of the B135. On a camera that would have been science fiction in 1965.
Love it!

I checked the serial number and my copy was produced in 1971....the year I was born!
The lens acquired no tilt or swing during all this time. A testament of how well built it is. (focusing is still smooth as butter)

Seriously, it will outlast me which may not be the case with the modern Batis.
You wouldn't happen to have a Samyang 135 f2 hanging around. That would be another one to compare against. Kinda surprised Samyang has not release a modern mirrorless version of that yet. But if they did that you probably couldn't use a converter on it though.


Sorry, only 3 lenses per focal length allowed!

My only other 135mm is the Zeiss 135/1.8 ZA.
Dec 02, 2020 at 07:42 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Fred Miranda wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
philip_pj wroteThanks for this very interesting comparison. That is the difference 55 years makes, from a 5/3 design to a 14/11 lens.
You are welcome!

Earlier quoteThat's against a modern state-of-the-art APO design with a close to the commercial ceiling budget - hence the initial price of the B135. On a camera that would have been science fiction in 1965.
Love it!

I checked the serial number and my copy was produced in 1971....the year I was born!
The lens acquired no tilt or swing during all this time. A testament of how well built it is. (focusing is still smooth as butter)

Seriously, it will outlast me which may not be the case with the modern Batis.
You wouldn't happen to have a Samyang 135 f2 hanging around. That would be another one to compare against. Kinda surprised Samyang has not release a modern mirrorless version of that yet. But if they did that you probably couldn't use a converter on it though.
Sorry, only 3 lenses per focal length allowed!

My only other 135mm is the Zeiss 135/1.8 ZA.


Understandable. That's 2 more lenses per focal length than I have
Dec 02, 2020 at 07:45 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
I had a lot of Leica glass at one time but I still need a Working AF lens . The Batis is one of my favorites
Dec 02, 2020 at 07:47 PM
EltonTeng
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
I just paid $175 (shipped) for a C/Y Zeiss 135/2.8. I wonder how it would compare to the modern Batis?
Dec 02, 2020 at 08:18 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
It would be interesting to run the test again once 24x36mm sensors break 100MP to see what differences remain. To my eyes, the Batis has the edge in very fine detail separation/contrast, which I guess we call micro contrast. The 135/4 is certainly a bargain in the realm of Leica lenses and apparently the current f/3.4 version doesn't improve much on it, IIRC.
Dec 02, 2020 at 10:06 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Nobody asked for this but I was curious to see how these two lenses compare.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/83/2078283.jpg

The Batis 135 is well known for being one of the sharpest 135mm on the market. But how well a 135mm lens from 1971 compares?
http://www.l-camera-forum.com/leica-wiki.en/index.php/135mm_f/4_Tele-Elmar

I have been impressed with this vintage Leica, so let's see some side by sides.

All comparisons were made at f/5.6 which is optimal for the Leica. The Batis is optimal at f/4.

Spoil-alert: The Batis is superior but the Leica puts up a good fight which is impressive to say the least.



Hi Fred,

Thanks for running the tests. I had purchased my Leica M 135mm f4 Elmarit based upon your initial reporting of the lens. Mine was actually made in 1964 in the first production run of 1000 with the Red Scale and before the lens was actually released to the public.

Unfortunately my copy needed to go in to DAG for an adjustment because the lens wouldn't focus to infinity so the lens cost me more than I wanted, but cost much less than the Leica M 135mm f3.4 Apo-Telyt for wich I was unwilling to pay the difference. But, I purchased the lens as a smaller and lighter, and more compact option than carrying my Leica R 180mm f3.4 when I was unwilling to carry such a large and heavy lens.

So, when I want a smaller, more compact kit and particularly kit of only M mount lenses with my Sony A7r camera series, the 135mm f4 Elmarit is in my bag or backpack when I do not want to carry my Leica R 180mm f3.4 Apo Telyt, Sony FE 100-400mm GM, Sony FE 200-600mm G, or the Zeiss 135mm Batis or Sony 135mm GM lenses that I do not own.

Rich
Dec 03, 2020 at 08:27 AM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
rscheffler wrote:
It would be interesting to run the test again once 24x36mm sensors break 100MP to see what differences remain.


They already have (kind of) with multi-shot modes. We just need to find someone to do the comparison on a static scene
Dec 03, 2020 at 10:17 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #16Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
rscheffler wrote:
It would be interesting to run the test again once 24x36mm sensors break 100MP to see what differences remain. To my eyes, the Batis has the edge in very fine detail separation/contrast, which I guess we call micro contrast. The 135/4 is certainly a bargain in the realm of Leica lenses and apparently the current f/3.4 version doesn't improve much on it, IIRC.


I see better contrast for the Batis as well and higher frequency detail when examining the files at pixel level. But the high amount of fine detail from the vintage Leica is impressive and it goes from center to the very edges without any noticeable mid-zone dip. In the real world, after some post-processing, I think it would be difficult to tell them apart.

The thing about the Leica though is that it's all metal construction and therefore not a light lens. (I'm not complaining )
Lighter than the Batis but not by much. (only 76g weight difference)

Batis without caps: 616g
Leica + adapter and without caps: 540g

I mostly use the Leica on the M10 though and can nail focus using the rangefinder.
Dec 03, 2020 at 11:00 AM
1joel1
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Batis 135mm f/2.8 vs Leica 135mm f/4 (compared at infinity)
That's a fun test. I happen to own both of those lenses and the Leica is the best buy in Leica lenses these days and a Mandler lens to boot. I have three Mandler lenses and while they're not known for sharpness, the 135 really shines. Stopped down, they are quite sharp and contrasty.

Thanks for the test,
Joel
Dec 03, 2020 at 11:03 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister