fredmiranda.com Login

Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review

  
 
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
serhan_ wroteInteresting 50mm M lens testing including Nokton 1.1, Nokton 1.2, Nokton 1.5, Nokton 1.5 II, Summilux ASPH, Summicron v5, Zeiss Planar, Zeiss C Sonnar, 7Artisans 1.1, TTArtisans 1.4:
The introduction and first tests: https://www.47-degree.com/focus-shift/leica-m-50mm-lens-comparison-part-1
The technical analysis: https://www.47-degree.com/focus-shift/leica-m-50mm-lens-comparison-part-2
The bokeh and portrait rendering: https://www.47-degree.com/focus-shift/leica-m-50mm-lens-comparison-part-3
The conclusion: https://www.47-degree.com/focus-shift/leica-m-50mm-lens-comparison-part-4
Thanks for posting! Amazing review.

My favorite of the bunch is the Voigtlander 50/1.2 followed by the Leica 50/1.4 lux. The Voigtlander 50/1.5 II performs great and is very compact but the high optical vignetting bothers me a bit. (swirling, extreme cats' eye + DOF increase towards the corners)
Interesting, I flip-flop them and see the Summilux 1.4 followed by the Sonnar or CV 1.2. I like the color/contrast/punch of the Lux and what seems like a more narrow FOV than the CV. Even a few mm wider than 50 starts really feeling like a 40mm lens to my eye. Maybe the Lux is 53mm and the CV is 47mm? – seems like quite a difference. My CV 50 APO shows that same wider FOV than my Lux.
Yes, the CV is shorter than 50mm. (perhaps 48-49mm). I prefer the Voigtlander 50/1.2 over the Lux in rendering, especially if the subject is focused at 5m or longer where the transition zone is visible in the background. Nowadays, I have the CV 50/2 APO as my main 50mm on the Leica. It's well corrected but still has very pleasant rendering even at mid-distance. IMO, the best APO so far. I never tried the Leica 50/2 APO though.
I haven't had the Lux (Black Chrome) very long, not long enough to try mid distance. I agree about the 50 APO. It reminds me a lot of the GF 50 shot wide open @ f/3.5 at close distance – not for how it renders, just for how it appeals to me. Both are flat-field and sharp at infinity, and both give pleasing results at MFD without the bokeh becoming the subject.

I'm on the fence about the CV 50 1.2 – I want to get it, but the CV 75 1.5 and my GF 80 1.7 are so good, I keep putting it on the back burner. That and the CV 35 1.2 III is still keeping me busy. "It's on the list" so to speak
I've been encountering calibration issues which are now amplified by the M10-R's 40MP sensor.

My new copy of the 50/1.4 lux is perfectly calibrated at MFD, 2m and infinity. I appreciate this level of accuracy and tight tolerance which is not easy to do. On the other hand, lens focus calibration has been disappointing with the modern ultra fast f/1.2 Nokton lenses. (35mm, 40mm and 50mm). Calibration is not noticeably off but when shooting at f/1.2, especially at close distance, it's enough to bother me. Surprisingly this not an issue with the 'slower f/1.5' lenses like the Voigt 35/1.7, Voigt
...Show more →

The CV 35 1.2 III I have (and it sounds like the 50 1.2 is the same way) is a great hybrid as it of course does well to separate the subject wide open, but the corners look pretty good when stopped down to f/5.6 for landscape use. But since I have the CV 35 and 50 APO, it's almost a crime not to switch to them when I shoot landscape. For that reason, I mainly use the 50 Lux for subject separation and for the joy of the user experience since I have the black chrome version. The 50 Lux corners as you say are nothing to write home about at infinity even stopped down.

Probably the most versatile 35/50 combo would be the CV 50 1.2 and CV 35 1.2 III, and I could leave the CV 35/50 APO and 50 Lux behind. But one of the main reasons I would perhaps prefer to only use the APOs is because of how easily they snap into focus in the EVF or LCD. No clear winners or losers on all fronts.

Have you tried the 1.2 CVs stopped down a half stop? Wondering out loud if they would behave better like you found the CV 75 1.5 does when shot between 1.5 and 2 (same bokeh as wide open but point of focus is sharper). My copy of the CV 35 1.2 III seems ok with the rangefinder wide open – in fact, it's easier to focus that way for me since there's so little contrast with it for peaking to work well – and with peaking off, it doesn't snap into focus easily, either. In any case, I mostly use the CV 1.2s wide open for mid-distance (fitting an entire vehicle in the frame for example) where they really shine, and where accuracy wide open with the rangefinder is usually spot-on. Using the CV 1.2s at MFD wide open is not only soft, but it just annihilates the background. For MFD subject isolation, I usually prefer the rendering of the 50 Lux over my 35 1.2 III or either CV APO. I need to buy the CV 50 1.2 to see how it would compare, but my wallet has taken a beating recently since I bought the 28 Summilux-M, which should arrive on Monday.
Jun 27, 2021 at 02:32 PM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
Taken with Panasonic S1R with Voigtlander (VM) 50mm F1.5 II (Vintage Line) MC (Nikel)
Very sharp at corner and middle zone at F5.6 as mentioned from Fred's review.
But soft at 4 extreme corners as expected.
Nice color character is its great merit. Top center Cyan is questionable.
After checking original image, it is mainly caused by tiny spot of blue sky in the middle of thick cloud atmosphere .





VM 50mm F1.5 MC II (Nikel)

Jun 29, 2021 at 01:01 PM
luoyyisvic
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
I have sonnar 50mm f1.5 and just ordered Voigt 50/1.5 II. l love how sonnar renders on film with my M6 but as a new m240 owner the focus shift becomes quite annoying on digital. Will compare them and curious which one I'll keep!
Jul 01, 2021 at 11:46 PM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
luoyyisvic wrote:
I have sonnar 50mm f1.5 and just ordered Voigt 50/1.5 II. l love how sonnar renders on film with my M6 but as a new m240 owner the focus shift becomes quite annoying on digital. Will compare them and curious which one I'll keep!


I think you will like the VM. Wide open it has a bit of character, (not near the Sonnar however) but modern rendering stopped down.














Jul 02, 2021 at 09:27 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
Beautiful image with abundant color tones
Jul 02, 2021 at 09:30 AM
luoyyisvic
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
helimat wrote:
luoyyisvic wroteI have sonnar 50mm f1.5 and just ordered Voigt 50/1.5 II. l love how sonnar renders on film with my M6 but as a new m240 owner the focus shift becomes quite annoying on digital. Will compare them and curious which one I'll keep!
I think you will like the VM. Wide open it has a bit of character, (not near the Sonnar however) but modern rendering stopped down.


Thank you for these photos, look amazing! And I think so! Maybe I'll keep Sonnar on M6 and use VM for digital...Let's see.
Jul 02, 2021 at 01:12 PM
Arvaker
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
A tractor...

Tractor
Jul 02, 2021 at 01:31 PM
Prosophos
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review

↑ Leica M3, Voigtländer 50mm Nokton f/1.5 II, Kodak Tri-X 400, and Plustek 8200i.

—Peter.
Jul 02, 2021 at 08:37 PM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
Prosophos wrote:
https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2021/06/prosophos-leica-m3-voigtlander-50mm-nokton-1.5-ii-kodak-tri-x-400.jpg
↑ Leica M3, Voigtländer 50mm Nokton f/1.5 II, Kodak Tri-X 400, and Plustek 8200i.

—Peter.


That's simply fantastic.
Jul 03, 2021 at 09:20 PM
Prosophos
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
helimat wrote:
Prosophos wrotehttps://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2021/06/prosophos-leica-m3-voigtlander-50mm-nokton-1.5-ii-kodak-tri-x-400.jpg
↑ Leica M3, Voigtländer 50mm Nokton f/1.5 II, Kodak Tri-X 400, and Plustek 8200i.

—Peter.
That's simply fantastic.


Thank you!

—Peter.
Jul 03, 2021 at 09:59 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

luoyyisvic
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
astrobuoy wrote:
I just wish he'd have tested off-center sharpness as well.

I'm curious, what makes you feel like you'll stick with the Sonnar (I've got both, but juggling with the question of whether I really need both)?


Have you decided which one to keep?
Jul 04, 2021 at 02:07 PM
astrobuoy
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review


luoyyisvic wrote:
astrobuoy wroteI just wish he'd have tested off-center sharpness as well.

I'm curious, what makes you feel like you'll stick with the Sonnar (I've got both, but juggling with the question of whether I really need both)?
Have you decided which one to keep?


No, I’ve still got both! 😂 I’ve been slow with shooting but I’ve got a roll coming back where I shot both lenses I believe, hopefully I’ll remember which was which. I may still just hold onto them both for the time being. My sense is that there must be some significant sample variation among the Sonnars, as mine doesn’t perform anywhere nearly as poor (to my eye) as on the massive head-to-head lens test someone else posted earlier in this thread.
Jul 05, 2021 at 06:21 AM
luoyyisvic
Offline
Details
p.12 #13Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
astrobuoy wrote:
luoyyisvic wrote
astrobuoy wroteI just wish he'd have tested off-center sharpness as well.

I'm curious, what makes you feel like you'll stick with the Sonnar (I've got both, but juggling with the question of whether I really need both)?
Have you decided which one to keep?
No, I’ve still got both! 😂 I’ve been slow with shooting but I’ve got a roll coming back where I shot both lenses I believe, hopefully I’ll remember which was which. I may still just hold onto them both for the time being. My sense is that there must be some significant sample variation among the Sonnars, as mine doesn’t perform anywhere nearly as poor (to my eye) as on the massive head-to-head lens test someone else posted earlier in this thread.


Haha I know it's hard to decide. I've looked at as many photos as I could find online taken by these two but still not sure. I do find Sonnar has slightly more pleasing rendering and Notkon vignettes quite a lot. It would awesome if you could keep us updated and maybe post some photos to compare! 🙌
Jul 06, 2021 at 12:39 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
Taken with Sony A7R2 at F = 5.6 without filter
VM 50/1.5 MC (Nikel) II





Voigtlander 50mm F1.5 II MC (Nikel)

Jul 09, 2021 at 11:27 AM
lemouette
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
I really wonder how this lens can perform on a crop sensor. I do not have a full-frame rangefinder, but am pretty much interested in buying either this lens or Nokton 35mm f1.4 ii for Fujifilm Xpro2.
Jul 09, 2021 at 06:35 PM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
I think this lens provides impressive image in sharpness and color and its own trait that is different from
CV 50mm f2 APO-Lanthar that I have used and and am using. Each of them has its own trait and very unique.
50/1.5 MC II slightly enhanced its sharpness from the predecessor and old one also has its very unique tone.
I never used this one to APS-C, but have learned it is also great for crop factor camera too.
Jul 09, 2021 at 07:27 PM
astrobuoy
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
luoyyisvic wrote:
astrobuoy wrote
luoyyisvic wrote
astrobuoy wroteI just wish he'd have tested off-center sharpness as well.

I'm curious, what makes you feel like you'll stick with the Sonnar (I've got both, but juggling with the question of whether I really need both)?
Have you decided which one to keep?
No, I’ve still got both! 😂 I’ve been slow with shooting but I’ve got a roll coming back where I shot both lenses I believe, hopefully I’ll remember which was which. I may still just hold onto them both for the time being. My sense is that there must be some significant sample variation among the Sonnars, as mine doesn’t perform anywhere nearly as poor (to my eye) as on the massive head-to-head lens test someone else posted earlier in this thread.
Haha I know it's hard to decide. I've looked at as many photos as I could find online taken by these two but still not sure. I do find Sonnar has slightly more pleasing rendering and Notkon vignettes quite a lot. It would awesome if you could keep us updated and maybe post some photos to compare! 🙌


Ok, I did end up taking some photos with both the C-Sonnar and Nokton II on both color and black & white film. I'll try posting some samples from both below.

First up, the Sonnar:













Jul 22, 2021 at 09:45 AM
astrobuoy
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
And then the Nokton:











Jul 22, 2021 at 09:48 AM
astrobuoy
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
If you'd like you can see the full-sized images to compare here.

I feel like they're pretty close, though there are slight differences in the way they draw. First, unlike the two round-ups I've seen, my Sonnar is plenty sharp to my eye (though I don't really do resolution tests, so take that with a grain of salt I guess). I don't know if anyone would agree, and I don't know if I quite have the words, but in general I think the Nokton renders a bit "flatter" and more even, while there's a kind of "roundness," if that makes sense, to the Sonnar images that I can't put my finger on. The Nokton definitely vignettes more when it's open, and the bokeh is a little busier and more nervous, while the Sonnar is very creamy. And the focus transition in the Sonnar images looks very gentle and smooth to me.

And yet, I like them both. This hasn't helped me decide which one I'd keep, as I think they each do something a little different, and I find myself reaching for either one depending on the day. I think I'll just keep shooting and perhaps make a decision further down the line.
Jul 22, 2021 at 09:59 AM
expwmbat
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 II Aspherical Review
I think your assessment/comparison makes good sense. I’m on my second copy of the Sonnar—the first one suffered a tragic fall into a flooding creek. As a result, I can confirm copy variation between it and my second, which is significantly sharper in every way, from wide open to across the frame when stopped down. To me the “roundness” of the Sonnar rendering is central to its appeal and a key part of its magic. Mine is a keeper for sure.

DJK
Jul 22, 2021 at 12:28 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister