Would be curious to learn about this as well. I'm currently using a Sony for my manual focus lenses, but am not entirely satisfied. Wondering if the S5 would be a better experience.
I don't think so, due to sensor stack and microlenses. On Leica M (especially M10-R), these are designed to achieve a minimal optical thickness of the sensor element, and most current M lenses are designed for those sensors. Older M lenses are designed for film, and the M sensor is optically closer to film than other sensors. Thus, with many Leica M lenses, the optical system with a Panasonic (or Sony, Nikon etc.) sensor will show color drift towards the corners, and, in particularly bad cases, visible astigmatism in the periphery.
AcuteShadows wrote:
I don't think so, due to sensor stack and microlenses. On Leica M (especially M10-R), these are designed to achieve a minimal optical thickness of the sensor element, and most current M lenses are designed for those sensors. Older M lenses are designed for film, and the M sensor is optically closer to film than other sensors. Thus, with many Leica M lenses, the optical system with a Panasonic (or Sony, Nikon etc.) sensor will show color drift towards the corners, and, in particularly bad cases, visible astigmatism in the periphery.
Do we have a known value for the S5 sensor stack vs. the M sensor stack?
Understanding the trig for refraction, etc. the amount of difference could make it anywhere from barely noticeable to tolerable to intolerable. Granted the M will be better, but I think the question for some might be how much / little difference. Of course, it'll be lens dependent, too.
RustyBug wrote: AcuteShadows wroteI don't think so, due to sensor stack and microlenses. On Leica M (especially M10-R), these are designed to achieve a minimal optical thickness of the sensor element, and most current M lenses are designed for those sensors. Older M lenses are designed for film, and the M sensor is optically closer to film than other sensors. Thus, with many Leica M lenses, the optical system with a Panasonic (or Sony, Nikon etc.) sensor will show color drift towards the corners, and, in particularly bad cases, visible astigmatism in the periphery.Do we have a known value for the S5 sensor stack vs. the M sensor stack?
Understanding the trig for refraction, etc. the amount of difference could make it anywhere from barely noticeable to tolerable to intolerable. Granted the M will be better, but I think the question for some might be how much / little difference. Of course, it'll be lens dependent, too.
From everything that I have read about this issue, the actual thickness of the sensor stack is only part of the story. The whole setup of the sensor influences its optical properties. For example, the sensor stack of the M10-R is probably not significantly thinner than that of the M10, yet it shows almost no astigmatism or color shift, even without applying lens profiles.
I have an S1, same sensor as S5. Unless you are using the latest m lenses i wouldnt recommend it. At least thats been my experience, if its not corner smearing its color cast. I havent been able to get any great results with any of my m lenses, they all shine in the m system, but in the s1 they really are not worth the prices. If you want to use m lenses with an evf, better go for a use SL, they are going for around 2k usd, and will offer you much better results.
Some examples below:
Leica 24mm elmar, (sharp corners, but i am not able to get the colors i want, seems to have some strong color cast, specially seen in day shots)
The sensor stack is but one piece of the puzzle. The microlens shape for redirecting the light path is the other (and likely more significant) for contending with the challenging angles imposed with optical projections set so close to the film plane. Lenses which have their projection set farther from the film plane don't have to contend with such steep angles.
Leica essentially made a "curved sensor" via the elongated microlens in order to bend the light more (at the microlens) so it enters the stack more perpendicular (i.e. less refraction through the stack).
Imo, there's little point to expect a lens set so close to the film plane to do well in the corners ... unless you have a way of contending with the steep angles (such as Leica has done).
The alternative is to use lenses whose projection is NOT set so close to the film plane. Of course, as you move the projection farther from the film plane, it's inherent contrast changes. For those who aspire for the contrast that the M lenses afford by being so close to the film plane, it makes sense to use the Leica sensor to capture it best ... that, or use it on a crop body, so you're cutting out the problem area beyond the 1:1 portion of the projection / capture (i.e. edges / corners).