Thanks for reminding me how awesome this lens is. I don't what the heck I was doing when I thought of selling mine.
Wide open sharpness, great color, light weight, nice bokeh? What more could you ask for?a
Neighborhood Wild Turkeys roost in the trees behind my house. They're pretty tame and now it's breeding season. Shot through the sliding glass patio door.
Planning to use a CPL and exposure bracketing next time.
I am wondering how this would stack up with the new Sigma 85 f/1.4 DG DN for Sony. Almost every review describes the Sigma as a faster version of the Batis.
For me, I would prefer the faster lens for around the same price which has fairly similar dimensions.
Any reason those of you chose the Batis over the 85 DN? I mean, other than it may not have been available at the time of your purchase.
gheller wrote:
I am wondering how this would stack up with the new Sigma 85 f/1.4 DG DN for Sony. Almost every review describes the Sigma as a faster version of the Batis.
For me, I would prefer the faster lens for around the same price which has fairly similar dimensions.
Any reason those of you chose the Batis over the 85 DN? I mean, other than it may not have been available at the time of your purchase.
g
I would put my answer in simple terms, something like this:
Leica -Ferrari
Zeiss - Porsche
Sigma - Toyota
The Sigma wasn't available when I picked up my Batis. If I was purchasing now, I may still go for the Batis. While new they're about the same, used the Batis is substantially cheaper. Most of my other lenses are Zeiss, so I like having a similar color signature. I really love the images I've created with the lens, my only real gripe is not having an aperture ring.
gheller wrote:
I am wondering how this would stack up with the new Sigma 85 f/1.4 DG DN for Sony. Almost every review describes the Sigma as a faster version of the Batis.
For me, I would prefer the faster lens for around the same price which has fairly similar dimensions.
Any reason those of you chose the Batis over the 85 DN? I mean, other than it may not have been available at the time of your purchase.
GMPhotography wrote:
Like to see that bold statement as a working test. I have the Samyang 75 and it is quite good and yes I had the Batis, Sony 1.4 and 1.8 as well. Not doubting the Batis but I am doubting the "much better in every aspect" thats a broad statement and like to see that
I test a lot of lenses
Agreed, 75mm is a sleeper lens. Take it all day over the Batis and it as nothing to do with the price.
I guess I'm just old-school enough to have always revered Zeiss. And I'm enough of a gear head to appreciate aesthetics and want my lenses to have a definite appeal. Zeiss on Sony does that for me for the time being.
Zeiss IQ is excellent and has a certain quality to it only matched or bested by VC and a few Nikon lenses in my experience with 35mm and FF digital.
I also have the Sigma 45/2.8 which is great and I like the direction Sigma is taking with their Contemporary lenses.
The price is nice too and I happily pay for MIJ quality from Sigma, VC and Zeiss all day, any day.
I had the Rokinon 35/2.8 and quick tested the 85/1.4 and while the 85 was a big improvement it still felt cheap and fragile to me. Neither of those lenses had any aesthetic appeal to me either.
That said, it's great to have inexpensive options that perform well and I'm all for having more choices.
gheller wrote:
I am wondering how this would stack up with the new Sigma 85 f/1.4 DG DN for Sony. Almost every review describes the Sigma as a faster version of the Batis.
For me, I would prefer the faster lens for around the same price which has fairly similar dimensions.
Any reason those of you chose the Batis over the 85 DN? I mean, other than it may not have been available at the time of your purchase.
g
Weight: It is 50% lighter than Sigma.
Price: A used Batis is significantly cheaper than Sigma. Sigma is too new and still in the honeymoon period.
Size: Still smaller than Sigma and 67mm filter thread is more consistent with other smaller fast primes (Like 20/1.8 and 24/1.4).
I like the design of Sigma over smooth and polished Batis design and if it was the same weight and size as Batis, I'd be inclined to go with it.
I didn't mention that the image from Grand Canyon posted in the first page is actually the right side of a pano I took. And here is the complete pano of that.
The ironic aspect of this was that there were only 4 people at the spot to witness and capture that wonderful weather phenomenon. It started out as a crowd of approximately 90-100 people that morning at that point. Then it started raining pretty hard. The vast majority of people just ran back to the shuttles and left, leaving only 4 people there, including myself. Boy, those people didn't know what they missed. After a few short minutes the cloud burst moved towards the canyon itself and the 4 of us were treated with light/shadow spectacles. It was changing at a fairly rapid speed. Every minute or so, a different mood/lighting aspect came about that lasted again just a few minutes. And the sun peeked, adding a unique aspect. It was truly a wonderful experience! I got somewhat wet but no big deal, it was only water and the gear was protected.
ramesesthe2nd wrote: gheller wroteI am wondering how this would stack up with the new Sigma 85 f/1.4 DG DN for Sony. Almost every review describes the Sigma as a faster version of the Batis.
For me, I would prefer the faster lens for around the same price which has fairly similar dimensions.
Any reason those of you chose the Batis over the 85 DN? I mean, other than it may not have been available at the time of your purchase.
gWeight: It is 50% lighter than Sigma.
Price: A used Batis is significantly cheaper than Sigma. Sigma is too new and still in the honeymoon period.
Size: Still smaller than Sigma and 67mm filter thread is more consistent with other smaller fast primes (Like 20/1.8 and 24/1.4).
I like the design of Sigma over smooth and polished Batis design and if it was the same weight and size as Batis, I'd be inclined to go with it.
Good info, but for the price, not really accurate comparing the cost of a used lens to a new lens, right? The new costs are very close. For me, I would rather have the extra stop of the faster lens (given that the quality is on par).
I just ordered the Sigma and will report here with my thoughts.
AGeoJO wrote:
I didn't mention that the image from Grand Canyon posted in the first page is actually the right side of a pano I took. And here is the complete pano of that.
The ironic aspect of this was that there were only 4 people at the spot to witness and capture that wonderful weather phenomenon. It started out as a crowd of approximately 90-100 people that morning at that point. Then it started raining pretty hard. The vast majority of people just ran back to the shuttles and left, leaving only 4 people there, including myself. Boy, those people didn't know what they missed. After a few short minutes the cloud burst moved towards the canyon itself and the 4 of us were treated with light/shadow spectacles. It was changing at a fairly rapid speed. Every minute or so, a different mood/lighting aspect came about that lasted again just a few minutes. And the sun peeked, adding a unique aspect. It was truly a wonderful experience! I got somewhat wet but no big deal, it was only water and the gear was protected....Show more →
AGeoJO wrote:
I didn't mention that the image from Grand Canyon posted in the first page is actually the right side of a pano I took. And here is the complete pano of that.
The ironic aspect of this was that there were only 4 people at the spot to witness and capture that wonderful weather phenomenon. It started out as a crowd of approximately 90-100 people that morning at that point. Then it started raining pretty hard. The vast majority of people just ran back to the shuttles and left, leaving only 4 people there, including myself. Boy, those people didn't know what they missed. After a few short minutes the cloud burst moved towards the canyon itself and the 4 of us were treated with light/shadow spectacles. It was changing at a fairly rapid speed. Every minute or so, a different mood/lighting aspect came about that lasted again just a few minutes. And the sun peeked, adding a unique aspect. It was truly a wonderful experience! I got somewhat wet but no big deal, it was only water and the gear was protected....Show more →
Great story-what we photogs live to experience and a beautiful image to back it up ! Another thing I like about Zeiss Batis...rain or shine
shac wrote: AGeoJO wroteI didn't mention that the image from Grand Canyon posted in the first page is actually the right side of a pano I took. And here is the complete pano of that.
The ironic aspect of this was that there were only 4 people at the spot to witness and capture that wonderful weather phenomenon. It started out as a crowd of approximately 90-100 people that morning at that point. Then it started raining pretty hard. The vast majority of people just ran back to the shuttles and left, leaving only 4 people there, including myself. Boy, those people didn't know what they missed. After a few short minutes the cloud burst moved towards the canyon itself and the 4 of us were treated with light/shadow spectacles. It was changing at a fairly rapid speed. Every minute or so, a different mood/lighting aspect came about that lasted again just a few minutes. And the sun peeked, adding a unique aspect. It was truly a wonderful experience! I got somewhat wet but no big deal, it was only water and the gear was protected.Fabulous image Joshua
David
Thank you very much, David!
LBJ2 wrote: AGeoJO wroteI didn't mention that the image from Grand Canyon posted in the first page is actually the right side of a pano I took. And here is the complete pano of that.
The ironic aspect of this was that there were only 4 people at the spot to witness and capture that wonderful weather phenomenon. It started out as a crowd of approximately 90-100 people that morning at that point. Then it started raining pretty hard. The vast majority of people just ran back to the shuttles and left, leaving only 4 people there, including myself. Boy, those people didn't know what they missed. After a few short minutes the cloud burst moved towards the canyon itself and the 4 of us were treated with light/shadow spectacles. It was changing at a fairly rapid speed. Every minute or so, a different mood/lighting aspect came about that lasted again just a few minutes. And the sun peeked, adding a unique aspect. It was truly a wonderful experience! I got somewhat wet but no big deal, it was only water and the gear was protected.Great story-what we photogs live to experience and a beautiful image to back it up ! Another thing I like about Zeiss Batis...rain or shine
gheller wrote:
Good info, but for the price, not really accurate comparing the cost of a used lens to a new lens, right? The new costs are very close. For me, I would rather have the extra stop of the faster lens (given that the quality is on par).
True, but a used Batis in mint condition is not that hard to find v/s Sigma is just a new lens and you don't really get a choice to buy it used.
gheller wrote:
I just ordered the Sigma and will report here with my thoughts.
Awesome. You won't be disappointed with Sigma. I love the build quality and design of this lens and it is a compact lens for f/1.4.
I used my Batis 85 as my only lens for the holidays with family, partly due to this thread. I don't think I've ever used a telephoto as a main lens, so that was challenging, but very enjoyable. I did welcome the AF over my CV 40, so theres that. Either way, I got a ton of keepers and it was a nice change of pace.
akashyap wrote:
I used my Batis 85 as my only lens for the holidays with family, partly due to this thread. I don't think I've ever used a telephoto as a main lens, so that was challenging, but very enjoyable. I did welcome the AF over my CV 40, so theres that. Either way, I got a ton of keepers and it was a nice change of pace.
Good to hear this thread had a positive/enjoyable effect! Thank you for letting me know.
Much as I love my Batis 135mm and 40mm lenses, which both have some unique features (APO/OSS and CF), I've never been sold on the 85mm perhaps due to the abundance of other decent options at that focal length.
I'm curious if anyone opted for the Sony 85mm (non-GM) over the Batis or vice versa. I'd love a faster mid-tele lens (the Batis 135/2.8 and Sony 90/2.8 are my current options) but I always struggle to justify spending double the price of the Sony 85/1.8, which sounds like a very capable and compact lens
wordfool wrote:
Much as I love my Batis 135mm and 40mm lenses, which both have some unique features (APO/OSS and CF), I've never been sold on the 85mm perhaps due to the abundance of other decent options at that focal length.
I'm curious if anyone opted for the Sony 85mm (non-GM) over the Batis or vice versa. I'd love a faster mid-tele lens (the Batis 135/2.8 and Sony 90/2.8 are my current options) but I always struggle to justify spending double the price of the Sony 85/1.8, which sounds like a very capable and compact lens
I owned the Batis 25/2 and plan to again, so I was tempted to buy the Batis 85, but after trying the Sony 85/1.8, I don't really see the point. It's such a good lens and a good value. It performs well and it's small/light, so it's really a no-brainer.
I may pickup the Sigma 85 1.4 DN DG just to have a faster 85 at some point, but if I had to choose just one, it'd be the Sony 85 1.8.
I have both the Batis 25 and 85 and the sharpness, colours and micro contrast I get from them is worth every penny IMHO. Add the weather sealing and OSS and from my perspective the Batis 85 over the Sony unless you are really cash strapped.