fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.

bs kite
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
ilkka_nissila wrote:
bs kite wroteAnd nobody else has this lens. Why not yet!
15000+ 500PF's are reported in Roland Vink's serial number database. Lots of 500 PF lenses are in use.

I don't see any point in posting images for this thread since image sharpness can only really be evaluated from original resolution files, and with this combination, I find there is a lot of shot-to-shot variability which would not be seen in posts that typically highlight successful captures. Furthermore I find f/8 very limiting and the lens quality would be diminished by the necessary high ISO required for practical applications that I might have.

But then, I am not sure if you really want
...Show more →

Does it matter that you don’t see the point in posting images for this thread? Why bother saying that? You don’t post any images anywhere, anyway, do you? Don’t you just go from thread to thread, giving opinions? that’s ok too. You have a right to your opinion.

When I asked why others do not have the lens yet, I was referring to other manufacturers.

There’s always a lot of shot-by-shot variability within *any* thread and within any shoot, including those that “typically highlight successful captures".

You say F8 is limiting? F8 is closer to the sweet spot of any glass. Meaning the image is going to be innately sharper to begin with. Ahh, actually, in the case of the TC14, I believe f8 is effectively the same as the 500PF’s f5.6 isn’t it?

Regarding your ISO comment: If you had followed this thread, you would have known that we all agree, that plenty of light is a pre-requisite for success with these TC’s. If there is not plenty of quality light (low, direct, strong), don’t bother with the TC’s. Everyone is aware of this, especially after this thread.

We have threads to learn these things from others.

I am very impressed by the potential that the two new (III series) TC’s have with this lens. And I learned that *as a result of seeing the images posted on this thread*

Now, I hope we can continue to enjoy more images captured with the TC combinations.

peace to you.




Jun 21, 2020 at 04:26 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
Taking it up a few notches with the 1.7 and 2.0 TCs....I really only recommend these TCs on a Z body...way too inconsistent on the DSLRs. But I threw in a D850 shot anyways...



















Jun 21, 2020 at 06:32 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
The Chickadees are perfect! And that Pintail could pass for being been taken with no TC.

Jun 22, 2020 at 02:31 AM
Tstop
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
While AF lags slightly, for larger BIF that reasonably fill the frame, 500PF+1.4TCIII is perfectly usable. Here is an osprey sequence, in difficult lighting, showing its not just a one-off 'best' image scenario.

For stationary or large subjects, the detail is good enough that I have no qualms about the combination.

Last pic is another bird, also in difficult light (note point sources of light) that the PF+TC handles well (no visible flare etc).


































Jun 22, 2020 at 07:31 AM
multibit
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
Very interesting thread and some excellent images , the IQ with the 500mm PF + TC looks pretty damn good to me, if the focus would be reliable with my D850 i'd get one of these lenses next . IQ with the x1.4 TC on my 200-500 isn't bad but the focus reliability goes out the window
Jun 22, 2020 at 10:08 AM
EyeSpyEagle
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
A couple more samples.






Backlit Swan






Baled Eagle on a pole






Goose - Optical exam

Jun 22, 2020 at 11:04 AM
EyeSpyEagle
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
bs kite wrote:
EyeSpyEagle...

These are superb! And I am amazed at how sharp the 2X ones are.

I am not aware of any post-processing program that sharpens as smoothly as this. Regarding sharpening, (to me anyway), these images look as though they came directly from the camera.

Reference your wife liking the 1.4: In an early post (in this thread) I think Gary Irwin said that he pretty much keeps the 1.4 attached.

This is all too much for me! And nobody else has this lens. Why not yet?

Go Nikon!



Thanks. I've not had that as good of results with the 2x on my DSLR's, but on the Z bodies it works surprisingly well with just about all of my lenses.

I'm not sure if there was a question buried in the sharpening statement or not. All I use is Topaz DeNoise AI to remove noise and occasionally add a bit of sharpening. The BE shots are softer just because it was an instantaneous opportunity. It was there, then it was gone - literally.

Regards,
Phil
Jun 22, 2020 at 01:24 PM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
A couple from a few weeks ago.
Birds are shy over here, so I almost always have to use the 1.4x TC.









Jun 22, 2020 at 01:35 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
Chris Dees wrote:
A couple from a few weeks ago.
Birds are shy over here, so I almost always have to use the 1.4x TC.


I’d be shy too, if I had 6 legs.

Hi Chris

What species is that? Do you know? Looks like it might be trying to protect two young ones, by the downy-looking feathers underneath.

No?


Jun 22, 2020 at 03:31 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
multibit wrote:
Very interesting thread and some excellent images , the IQ with the 500mm PF + TC looks pretty damn good to me, if the focus would be reliable with my D850 i'd get one of these lenses next . IQ with the x1.4 TC on my 200-500 isn't bad but the focus reliability goes out the window


You’ve done a great job with that 200-500. I was forever seeing your name above some of the very best 200-500 images. Now, since I bought this agile 500mm PF, my 200-500 is semi-retired

I bought the 500PF, and put down the now-heavy and now-slow 200-500; the only thing I miss is zoom.


Jun 22, 2020 at 03:42 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
EyeSpyEagle wrote:
bs kite wroteEyeSpyEagle...

These are superb! And I am amazed at how sharp the 2X ones are.

I am not aware of any post-processing program that sharpens as smoothly as this. Regarding sharpening, (to me anyway), these images look as though they came directly from the camera.

Reference your wife liking the 1.4: In an early post (in this thread) I think Gary Irwin said that he pretty much keeps the 1.4 attached.

This is all too much for me! And nobody else has this lens. Why not yet?

Go Nikon!
Thanks. I've not had that as good of results with the 2x on my DSLR's, but on the Z bodies it works surprisingly well with just about all of my lenses.

I'm not sure if there was a question buried in the sharpening statement or not. All I use is Topaz DeNoise AI to remove noise and occasionally add a bit of sharpening. The BE shots are softer just because it was an instantaneous opportunity. It was there, then it was gone - literally.

Regards,
Phil


Hi Phil

I believe Arbitrage (Geoff) is also saying the results are lots better with the Z’s than with the DSLR’s.

At close range, it appears that this 500PF with TC’s, is just as sharp as it is without the TC’s. I know that can’t be, but the close shots are tack sharp.

Regards to you

Robert

Jun 22, 2020 at 03:50 PM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
bs kite wrote:
Chris Dees wroteA couple from a few weeks ago.
Birds are shy over here, so I almost always have to use the 1.4x TC.
I’d be shy too, if I had 6 legs.

Hi Chris

What species is that? Do you know? Looks like it might be trying to protect two young ones, by the downy-looking feathers underneath.

No?



Hi Robert, it's a Pied Avocet (Recurvirostra avosetta), in Dutch "Kluut". They're not hard to find in certain area's.
When it's cold/windy,rainy the chicks seek shelter under a parent.
Jun 23, 2020 at 12:54 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
bs kite wrote:
EyeSpyEagle wrote
bs kite wroteEyeSpyEagle...

These are superb! And I am amazed at how sharp the 2X ones are.

I am not aware of any post-processing program that sharpens as smoothly as this. Regarding sharpening, (to me anyway), these images look as though they came directly from the camera.

Reference your wife liking the 1.4: In an early post (in this thread) I think Gary Irwin said that he pretty much keeps the 1.4 attached.

This is all too much for me! And nobody else has this lens. Why not yet?

Go Nikon!
Thanks. I've not had that as good of results with the 2x on my DSLR's, but on the Z bodies it works surprisingly well with just about all of my lenses.

I'm not sure if there was a question buried in the sharpening statement or not. All I use is Topaz DeNoise AI to remove noise and occasionally add a bit of sharpening. The BE shots are softer just because it was an instantaneous opportunity. It was there, then it was gone - literally.

Regards,
Phil
Hi Phil

I believe Arbitrage (Geoff) is also saying the results are lots better with the Z’s than with the DSLR’s.

At close range, it appears that this 500PF with TC’s, is just as sharp as it is without the TC’s. I know that can’t be, but the close shots are tack sharp.

Regards to you

Robert



As with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web sized output) as you'd get with the TC and cropping less.

I love experimenting with TCs and therefore I can always pull out good examples out of my archives but for most of my lenses (excepting my f/2.8 and f/4 primes I've owned over the years) I rarely use my lenses with TCs. Also every time I've done a controlled test between cropping and TCs, the images usually equal out. If you have to push up ISO too far past your comfortable/acceptable range because of the light loss from the TC then the bare lens and cropping can actually be better. Not to mention the AF downgrade when using them. The only camera I've used that can keep up its AF prowess with TCs attached is the A9(II).

In the past I tried to use TCs in order to reach out too far to distant subjects like ducks half way across a lake. It has taken me a while to finally learn that it is pointless because of all the air you are shooting through. I think too many people try to do this type of work when they buy a TC and end up disappointed.

TCs are a thorn in my side because I always want to reach for them but deep down know they are usually a lost battle.
Jun 23, 2020 at 06:16 AM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
arbitrage wrote:
As with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web
...Show more →

I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say here. AF with the Z7+500PF+1.4TC is better than the lens/tc on the D500 where accuracy and consistency is concerned, but the only real reason I can think of for putting the 1.4TC on the 500PF, is more pixels for printing. Of course the 500PF+1.4TC can produce beautiful images in the right light, but when using the 500PF bare for some time, then use it with the 1.4TC for some time, and then bare again, it still feels like a much nicer shooting experience and the images just look better in similar circumstances. Better colors overall, better depth, better acuity or whatnot.

Comparing this to the Canon 400DOII, it is quite a difference. On the 400DOII, the effect of the 1.4TC was much less obvious and visible, and there was no clear reason to leave the 1.4TC off other than wanting 400mm. In my opinion it is not a small difference, but a very tangible difference. With the 400DOI I glued the 1.4TC on, only to take it off when putting the 2.0TC on. With the 500PF I keep taking the 1.4TC off, even when I really want more reach, because it doesn't really help to give more reach visually (cropping actually looks better in many cases) but only gives you more pixels for printing.

So the 1.4TC has its uses, and when light is perfect, it can produce very good images, but I still don't want it on all the time, despite wanting more reach.
So I would still like a lens that can take the 1.4TC and not show it or hardly show it, like the Canon 400DOII, to have a better balance between IQ and reach. I am hoping the Nikon 500mmf4E will be such a lens, that lets me shoot at 700mm f5.6 all the time without leaving me with a feeling that I am not using the lens at its best or at least, near its best.
The 500PF is just perfect for light packing, shines at closer distances and Nikon made the lens for that after all. Better "reach" obviously starts with the better bare lens, not with putting TC's on.

On a side note, I have been extremely impressed with the Z lenses, 24mm f1.8S and 50mm f1.8S, have even traded in my Zeiss Loxia lenses for them, and there is a Z200-600mm (albeit not a "s") lens on the roadmap. It will be very interesting to see if Nikon can match or even better the Sony 200-600mm. That would also give more reach and without a TC.



Edited on Jun 23, 2020 at 06:47 AM · View previous versions
Jun 23, 2020 at 06:36 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
ChrisMak wrote:
arbitrage wroteAs with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web sized output) as you'd get with the TC and cropping less.

I love experimenting with TCs and therefore I can always pull out good examples out of my archives but for most of my lenses (excepting my f/2.8 and f/4 primes I've owned over the years) I rarely use my lenses with TCs. Also every time I've done a controlled test between cropping and TCs, the images usually equal out. If you have to push up ISO too far past your comfortable/acceptable range because of the light loss from the TC then the bare lens and cropping can actually be better. Not to mention the AF downgrade when using them. The only camera I've used that can keep up its AF prowess with TCs attached is the A9(II).

In the past I tried to use TCs in order to reach out too far to distant subjects like ducks half way across a lake. It has taken me a while to finally learn that it is pointless because of all the air you are shooting through. I think too many people try to do this type of work when they buy a TC and end up disappointed.

TCs are a thorn in my side because I always want to reach for them but deep down know they are usually a lost battle.
I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say here. AF with the Z7+500PF+1.4TC is better than the lens/tc on the D500 where accuracy and consistency is concerned, but the only real reason I can think of for putting the 1.4TC on the 500PF, is more pixels for printing. Of course the 500PF+1.4TC can produce beautiful images in the right light, but when using the 500PF bare for some time, then use it with the 1.4TC for some time, and then bare again, it still feels like a much nicer shooting experience and the images just look better in similar circumstances. Better
...Show more →

I owned the 500E for awhile and it does do much better with the 1.4TC. That said, of all the f/4 super-tele lenses I've owned over the years, the 500E was the least impressive with TCs. I still didn't like using it with 1.7 and 2.0TCs where as I use(d) my 600II, 400DOII, 300II and 600GM with 2xTCs all the time. I think it is well established that Nikon has the weakest TC performance of the big three manufacturers. Still, the 500E with 1.4TC is a much better experience than the 500PF/1.4TC.
Jun 23, 2020 at 06:46 AM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
arbitrage wrote:
ChrisMak wrote
arbitrage wroteAs with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web sized output) as you'd get with the TC and cropping less.

I love experimenting with TCs and therefore I can always pull out good examples out of my archives but for most of my lenses (excepting my f/2.8 and f/4 primes I've owned over the years) I rarely use my lenses with TCs. Also every time I've done a controlled test between cropping and TCs, the images usually equal out. If you have to push up ISO too far past your comfortable/acceptable range because of the light loss from the TC then the bare lens and cropping can actually be better. Not to mention the AF downgrade when using them. The only camera I've used that can keep up its AF prowess with TCs attached is the A9(II).

In the past I tried to use TCs in order to reach out too far to distant subjects like ducks half way across a lake. It has taken me a while to finally learn that it is pointless because of all the air you are shooting through. I think too many people try to do this type of work when they buy a TC and end up disappointed.

TCs are a thorn in my side because I always want to reach for them but deep down know they are usually a lost battle.
I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say here. AF with the Z7+500PF+1.4TC is better than the lens/tc on the D500 where accuracy and consistency is concerned, but the only real reason I can think of for putting the 1.4TC on the 500PF, is more pixels for printing. Of course the 500PF+1.4TC can produce beautiful images in the right light, but when using the 500PF bare for some time, then use it with the 1.4TC for some time, and then bare again, it still feels like a much nicer shooting experience and the images just look better in similar circumstances. Better colors overall, better depth, better acuity or whatnot.

Comparing this to the Canon 400DOII, it is quite a difference. On the 400DOII, the effect of the 1.4TC was much less obvious and visible, and there was no clear reason to leave the 1.4TC off other than wanting 400mm. In my opinion it is not a small difference, but a very tangible difference. With the 400DOI I glued the 1.4TC on, only to take it off when putting the 2.0TC on. With the 500PF I keep taking the 1.4TC off, even when I really want more reach, because it doesn't really help to give more reach visually (cropping actually looks better in many cases) but only gives you more pixels for printing.

So the 1.4TC has its uses, and when light is perfect, it can produce very good images, but I still don't want it on all the time, despite wanting more reach.
So I would still like a lens that can take the 1.4TC and not show it or hardly show it, like the Canon 400DOII, to have a better balance between IQ and reach. I am hoping the Nikon 500mmf4E will be such a lens, that lets me shoot at 700mm f5.6 all the time without leaving me with a feeling that I am not using the lens at its best or at least, near its best.
The 500PF is just perfect for light packing, shines at closer distances and Nikon made the lens for that after all. Better "reach" obviously starts with the better bare lens, not with putting TC's on.
I owned the 500E for awhile and it does do much better with the 1.4TC. That said, of all the f/4 super-tele lenses I've owned over the years, the 500E was the least impressive with TCs. I still didn't like using it with 1.7 and 2.0TCs where as I use(d) my 600II, 400DOII, 300II and 600GM with 2xTCs all the time. I think it is well established that Nikon has the weakest TC performance of the big three manufacturers. Still, the 500E with 1.4TC is a much better experience than the 500PF/1.4TC.


Thanks for your comment. I have zero intention of using a 1.7 or 2.0TC on the 500E. Does Nikon's 1.4TC also perform weaker with a f4 lens than Sony or Canon, or is it mainly the 1.7 and 2.0TC's?
11000,- is a lot of money to spend when 1.4TC performance is anything other than right up there with the best. It would drive me to either the Sigma 500mmS or indeed, to Nikon's coming Z200-600mm.
Jun 23, 2020 at 06:50 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
ChrisMak wrote:
Does Nikon's 1.4TC also perform weaker with a f4 lens than Sony or Canon, or is it mainly the 1.7 and 2.0TC's?


That would depend on the individual lens and TC compared. For example, here in the 600/4 FL vs. Canon 600/4 IS III comparison with 1.4X TCs applied, the Nikon lens and TC appear quite a bit sharper in the center:

https://www.the-digital-picture.com/Reviews/ISO-12233-Sample-Crops.aspx?Lens=1220&Camera=1210&Sample=0&FLI=1&API=1&LensComp=1227&CameraComp=979&SampleComp=0&FLIComp=1&APIComp=0

However, in that site, if you turn on the 2X on both sides, the Nikon lens and TC again wins in center sharpness. It seems that with the Mk III generation, Canon reduced weight substantially but not without cost to image quality.
Jun 23, 2020 at 07:04 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
ChrisMak wrote:
arbitrage wrote
ChrisMak wrote
arbitrage wroteAs with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web sized output) as you'd get with the TC and cropping less.

I love experimenting with TCs and therefore I can always pull out good examples out of my archives but for most of my lenses (excepting my f/2.8 and f/4 primes I've owned over the years) I rarely use my lenses with TCs. Also every time I've done a controlled test between cropping and TCs, the images usually equal out. If you have to push up ISO too far past your comfortable/acceptable range because of the light loss from the TC then the bare lens and cropping can actually be better. Not to mention the AF downgrade when using them. The only camera I've used that can keep up its AF prowess with TCs attached is the A9(II).

In the past I tried to use TCs in order to reach out too far to distant subjects like ducks half way across a lake. It has taken me a while to finally learn that it is pointless because of all the air you are shooting through. I think too many people try to do this type of work when they buy a TC and end up disappointed.

TCs are a thorn in my side because I always want to reach for them but deep down know they are usually a lost battle.
I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say here. AF with the Z7+500PF+1.4TC is better than the lens/tc on the D500 where accuracy and consistency is concerned, but the only real reason I can think of for putting the 1.4TC on the 500PF, is more pixels for printing. Of course the 500PF+1.4TC can produce beautiful images in the right light, but when using the 500PF bare for some time, then use it with the 1.4TC for some time, and then bare again, it still feels like a much nicer shooting experience and the images just look better in similar circumstances. Better colors overall, better depth, better acuity or whatnot.

Comparing this to the Canon 400DOII, it is quite a difference. On the 400DOII, the effect of the 1.4TC was much less obvious and visible, and there was no clear reason to leave the 1.4TC off other than wanting 400mm. In my opinion it is not a small difference, but a very tangible difference. With the 400DOI I glued the 1.4TC on, only to take it off when putting the 2.0TC on. With the 500PF I keep taking the 1.4TC off, even when I really want more reach, because it doesn't really help to give more reach visually (cropping actually looks better in many cases) but only gives you more pixels for printing.

So the 1.4TC has its uses, and when light is perfect, it can produce very good images, but I still don't want it on all the time, despite wanting more reach.
So I would still like a lens that can take the 1.4TC and not show it or hardly show it, like the Canon 400DOII, to have a better balance between IQ and reach. I am hoping the Nikon 500mmf4E will be such a lens, that lets me shoot at 700mm f5.6 all the time without leaving me with a feeling that I am not using the lens at its best or at least, near its best.
The 500PF is just perfect for light packing, shines at closer distances and Nikon made the lens for that after all. Better "reach" obviously starts with the better bare lens, not with putting TC's on.
I owned the 500E for awhile and it does do much better with the 1.4TC. That said, of all the f/4 super-tele lenses I've owned over the years, the 500E was the least impressive with TCs. I still didn't like using it with 1.7 and 2.0TCs where as I use(d) my 600II, 400DOII, 300II and 600GM with 2xTCs all the time. I think it is well established that Nikon has the weakest TC performance of the big three manufacturers. Still, the 500E with 1.4TC is a much better experience than the 500PF/1.4TC.
Thanks for your comment. I have zero intention of using a 1.7 or 2.0TC on the 500E. Does Nikon's 1.4TC also perform weaker with a f4 lens than Sony or Canon, or is it mainly the 1.7 and 2.0TC's?
11000,- is a lot of money to spend when 1.4TC performance is anything other than right up there with the best. It would drive me to either the Sigma 500mmS or indeed, to Nikon's coming Z200-600mm.


I think the 1.4 still did really well with the 500E. I didn't hesitate to use it as needed. I think it probably is as good as the Canon/Sony ones on their f/4 primes I've owned. Although I think the Canon and Sony (and likely Nikon) 600/4s are a notch up from the 500/4.
Jun 23, 2020 at 08:51 AM
kurisuhoyin
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
The 500pf with 14eiii comebo works really well for me. I don't have to do any AF fine tuning on my D850 with this combo at all. Results are wonderful. IQ degration is very minimal if there is at all. Here's a photo I took with the combo on my D850. The set up was on a tripod with a shutter release cable.
Jun 23, 2020 at 07:20 PM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Let’s see images captured with the Nikon 500 PF/TC14 combo.
This weekend I encountered the Sony 600GM "in the wild" for the first time. The person shooting it had the hood reversed, and it did not seem all that big, until I took a good look at the front element, it's huge. There was another person shooting the 200-600mm. And two guys, including myself, shooting the Nikon 500PF. It used to be 90% Canon. I've yet to see a 90D.
We discussed using the 1.4TC for a while, and the other Nikon shooter, who used to shoot a 500/4, said that he had sold his 1.4TC after switching to the 500PF, because he did not see the benefit.
Just some anecdotal info.

arbitrage wrote:
ChrisMak wrote
arbitrage wrote
ChrisMak wrote
arbitrage wroteAs with all systems be it DSLRs or MILCs and from whichever manufacturer, TCs are best utilized to fill the frame more so with small yet close subjects and fair much worse to try and bring distant subjects closer.

My Pintail image is just that, magnifying an already very close bird (they are ridiculously tame and fed at the location I shot that and often will come within MFD).

There is still no doubt that the bare lens has a lot better micro-contrast and in many situations can just be cropped harder to end up with an identical result (especially for web sized output) as you'd get with the TC and cropping less.

I love experimenting with TCs and therefore I can always pull out good examples out of my archives but for most of my lenses (excepting my f/2.8 and f/4 primes I've owned over the years) I rarely use my lenses with TCs. Also every time I've done a controlled test between cropping and TCs, the images usually equal out. If you have to push up ISO too far past your comfortable/acceptable range because of the light loss from the TC then the bare lens and cropping can actually be better. Not to mention the AF downgrade when using them. The only camera I've used that can keep up its AF prowess with TCs attached is the A9(II).

In the past I tried to use TCs in order to reach out too far to distant subjects like ducks half way across a lake. It has taken me a while to finally learn that it is pointless because of all the air you are shooting through. I think too many people try to do this type of work when they buy a TC and end up disappointed.

TCs are a thorn in my side because I always want to reach for them but deep down know they are usually a lost battle.
I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say here. AF with the Z7+500PF+1.4TC is better than the lens/tc on the D500 where accuracy and consistency is concerned, but the only real reason I can think of for putting the 1.4TC on the 500PF, is more pixels for printing. Of course the 500PF+1.4TC can produce beautiful images in the right light, but when using the 500PF bare for some time, then use it with the 1.4TC for some time, and then bare again, it still feels like a much nicer shooting experience and the images just look better in similar circumstances. Better colors overall, better depth, better acuity or whatnot.

Comparing this to the Canon 400DOII, it is quite a difference. On the 400DOII, the effect of the 1.4TC was much less obvious and visible, and there was no clear reason to leave the 1.4TC off other than wanting 400mm. In my opinion it is not a small difference, but a very tangible difference. With the 400DOI I glued the 1.4TC on, only to take it off when putting the 2.0TC on. With the 500PF I keep taking the 1.4TC off, even when I really want more reach, because it doesn't really help to give more reach visually (cropping actually looks better in many cases) but only gives you more pixels for printing.

So the 1.4TC has its uses, and when light is perfect, it can produce very good images, but I still don't want it on all the time, despite wanting more reach.
So I would still like a lens that can take the 1.4TC and not show it or hardly show it, like the Canon 400DOII, to have a better balance between IQ and reach. I am hoping the Nikon 500mmf4E will be such a lens, that lets me shoot at 700mm f5.6 all the time without leaving me with a feeling that I am not using the lens at its best or at least, near its best.
The 500PF is just perfect for light packing, shines at closer distances and Nikon made the lens for that after all. Better "reach" obviously starts with the better bare lens, not with putting TC's on.
I owned the 500E for awhile and it does do much better with the 1.4TC. That said, of all the f/4 super-tele lenses I've owned over the years, the 500E was the least impressive with TCs. I still didn't like using it with 1.7 and 2.0TCs where as I use(d) my 600II, 400DOII, 300II and 600GM with 2xTCs all the time. I think it is well established that Nikon has the weakest TC performance of the big three manufacturers. Still, the 500E with 1.4TC is a much better experience than the 500PF/1.4TC.
Thanks for your comment. I have zero intention of using a 1.7 or 2.0TC on the 500E. Does Nikon's 1.4TC also perform weaker with a f4 lens than Sony or Canon, or is it mainly the 1.7 and 2.0TC's?
11000,- is a lot of money to spend when 1.4TC performance is anything other than right up there with the best. It would drive me to either the Sigma 500mmS or indeed, to Nikon's coming Z200-600mm.
I think the 1.4 still did really well with the 500E. I didn't hesitate to use it as needed. I think it probably is as good as the Canon/Sony ones on their f/4 primes I've owned. Although I think the Canon and Sony (and likely Nikon) 600/4s are a notch up from the 500/4.

Jun 24, 2020 at 12:23 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell

You are not logged inLog inRegister