p.2 #1Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
If the photographer did not get a contract to set forth what he would give and what you are entitled to, that was his first mistake. Showing up to a non repeatable event like a wedding without a back up. another mistake. No excuse he can't afford one, can rent one for a couple of days for very reasonable amount. Heck, when I shoot weddings I have one camera with a 24-70 around my neck and over my shoulder another body with a 70-200 plus 2 speed lights: 11 grand worth of photo gear pluse another 2 grand in studio lights, triggers, stands and soft boxes. I have along a 35, 85 and 135 as back ups for the lenses and able to shoot in low light since they are faster glass and produce better quality images. Let me guess, this photographer was dirt cheap. You must accept some responsibility for cheaping out and this is what you can get. As to insurance, I'll bet he didn't have general liability insurance unless the venue required proof of insurance. Even if he did, covers property damage, ie breaking a statue or bodily injury, someone getting hurt but not errors and omissions which is screwing up the shots. These cheap turn and burn guys have damaged the wedding business for professionals that do all the above as matter of course. But that is overhead and we also do this for a living and have to make a reasonable profit to put food on the table. Often, these bozos, are part timers who have no clue they are working for less than minimum wage when overhead includes 2 professional cameras and speedlights, all those lenses, insurance, licensing, computers, software, website. In CA a few years back 2 different turn and burners screwed up weddings, as expected, most images under exposed because they didn't have a camera with good high iso, fast glass or have or know how to use a flash. Many were out of focus from missed focus or blurry from camera shake or subject movement at too low a shutter speed. Hey, you get what you pay for. In their case, each was sued and had a 40 grand judgement entered against them. If no e&o insurance, try buy or selling a house or buying a car with a judgment hanging over you. But if I recall, they were $500 turn and burners who thought they shot for 8 hrs and made 40+ per hour. If you photo and screw up, be aware, it is a business and like any business, you are responsible if you screw up. You see, that's why people who master the craft through study and hard work over decades get a bit annoyed when some bozo with a costco camera, kit lens and no flash takes money to shoot a wedding. They undercut by half or 3/4 prices that produce a reasonable profit for a real pro. Unfortunately, for something that is not repeatable, this is what you can get and probably no i nsurance to collect from if you sue.
p.2 #2Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
I apologize for not getting an update posted sooner. Our world, as everyone's, has been turned upside-down in the last month. Our daughter worked with the photographer and received a full refund of the agreed upon fee. She did pay some travel expenses but thought that only fair. This photographer came highly recommended with ample positive reviews and a very nice portfolio on the web. It was a very small wedding with only bride, groom, officiant, and a few friends. The contract was for the ceremony and prep only. No reception. Our plan was to have a large party/reception in May, but those plans have been postponed until fall. Thank you once again for all of your responses. Much appreciated.
p.2 #3Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
You made the choice of the photographer based solely on price and you are the one at fault.
With any wedding or commercial photography engagement there should be a contract that specifies what the "work product" will be and the delivery timeframe. If you contracted with this individual without a contract and without checking references and looking at work he has done for other clients then you screwed up and your daughter is paying the price.
There are many "shoot and burn" people that want to earn a little extra cash by photographing weddings. They lack the skills and the equipment needed but get chosen as they are cheap.
For weddings I have 3 cameras and 4 flash units and if one item fails it has zero impact on my fulfilling my contract obligations. The majority of the time I have a second photographer and that person will have at least two pro level cameras and their own flash equipment. I got food poisoning at a wedding and spent 45 minutes in the restroom and my second photographer got the shots I would have missed.
With weddings there are no "redo's" and it pays to shop around and spend the time researching all the vendors that will be used. If you don't bother to take the time to do this then any shortcomings are as much your fault as that of the vendor.
p.2 #4Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
elkhornsun wrote:
You made the choice of the photographer based solely on price and you are the one at fault.
With any wedding or commercial photography engagement there should be a contract that specifies what the "work product" will be and the delivery timeframe. If you contracted with this individual without a contract and without checking references and looking at work he has done for other clients then you screwed up and your daughter is paying the price.
There are many "shoot and burn" people that want to earn a little extra cash by photographing weddings. They lack the skills and the equipment needed but get chosen as they are cheap.
For weddings I have 3 cameras and 4 flash units and if one item fails it has zero impact on my fulfilling my contract obligations. The majority of the time I have a second photographer and that person will have at least two pro level cameras and their own flash equipment. I got food poisoning at a wedding and spent 45 minutes in the restroom and my second photographer got the shots I would have missed.
With weddings there are no "redo's" and it pays to shop around and spend the time researching all the vendors that will be used. If you don't bother to take the time to do this then any shortcomings are as much your fault as that of the vendor....Show more →
Total BS.
1. Where was price even mentioned?
2. Looks like homework was done and a contract was signed.
" This photographer came highly recommended with ample positive reviews and a very nice portfolio on the web. It was a very small wedding with only bride, groom, officiant, and a few friends. The contract was for the ceremony and prep only. No reception."
So by assuming...you are wrong on both fronts. Bottom line, the photographer screwed up here and you are trying to put the blame onto the client...BS.
p.2 #5Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
The mom chose a photographer who only one one camera. That is not a professional photographer - obviously. When I sit down with a potential client I explain what I bring to the party and why I recommend a second photographer.
I used to bring two bodies to a wedding and after one failed and I had to shoot with only one camera I added a third camera. My equipment cost for wedding photography is well over $20,000. Lots of shoot and burn shooters that buy a camera with its kit lens and then accept wedding gigs. Lots of posts where people say they want to start shooting weddings and want to know what lens to buy. It they have to ask they should not be shooting weddings.
It is like having a spare tire on a limo. It would be incredibly lame if the limo with the bride and bridesmaids did not arrive at the church on time because the limo had a flat tire and no spare tire.
I have dealt with far too many brides and MOB's that pay for the venue and the catering and the DJ and the limo and then look at what they have left in their budget for the photographer. That is fine but these are the people I turn down. If they do not prioritize the photography then they do not warrant my time.
I have also done executive portraits for accomplished professional women who when I ask about their wedding photographer will often have sour look on their face and 20 years later they still have strong regrets for hiring the photographer they did. No redo's is the saying and it applies. No point bitching about it later if you go cheap.
If a worker shows up at your house and needs to borrow tools would you hire him? I know better but evidently you do not.
p.2 #6Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
Do you really feel it's the mom's fault for not asking the photographer if they had a spare camera. Do you even think most moms know anything about camera gear? Should they ask the photographer if they have a spare tire?
This disaster is totally on the photographer as he was not prepared for equipment failure and it did happen. Trying to put blame on the client just has no justice here.
As far as a worker showing up at your door asking to borrow tools...that's not even close to what happened here. Sounds like everything was great during the contract meeting...and it was the photographer showing up with only half his gear. How the hell is this the clients issue.
Somehow you think the moms out there should know all the details of camera gear and what parts can be prone to failure. And somehow you feel the client cheaped out on the photographer by going lowball...where did you see this?
Bottom line the photographer f'd up...he should pay.
p.2 #7Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
elkhornsun wrote:
The mom chose a photographer who only one one camera. That is not a professional photographer - obviously. When I sit down with a potential client I explain what I bring to the party and why I recommend a second photographer.
I used to bring two bodies to a wedding and after one failed and I had to shoot with only one camera I added a third camera. My equipment cost for wedding photography is well over $20,000. Lots of shoot and burn shooters that buy a camera with its kit lens and then accept wedding gigs. Lots of posts where people say they want to start shooting weddings and want to know what lens to buy. It they have to ask they should not be shooting weddings.
It is like having a spare tire on a limo. It would be incredibly lame if the limo with the bride and bridesmaids did not arrive at the church on time because the limo had a flat tire and no spare tire.
I have dealt with far too many brides and MOB's that pay for the venue and the catering and the DJ and the limo and then look at what they have left in their budget for the photographer. That is fine but these are the people I turn down. If they do not prioritize the photography then they do not warrant my time.
I have also done executive portraits for accomplished professional women who when I ask about their wedding photographer will often have sour look on their face and 20 years later they still have strong regrets for hiring the photographer they did. No redo's is the saying and it applies. No point bitching about it later if you go cheap.
If a worker shows up at your house and needs to borrow tools would you hire him? I know better but evidently you do not. ...Show more →
Totally agree with Chez on his points. I am a full-time wedding pro and this was TOTALLY on the photographer, not the client.
BTW, $20K is nothing special for a full time wedding pro... A few full frame bodies and lenses is all it takes to get there. Add pro lighting, backdrop equipment and lighting, etc to see how high that figure can go. But I know of many photographers that get by on around $20K without too much trouble.
p.2 #8Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
I would never show up to shoot a wedding (any job) without backup, like at least 2 bodies, 2 on camera strobes, 2 power packs/4 heads, and another photographer who rolls the same way.
p.2 #9Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
I highly recommend ignoring the photographer's website as you do not even know if all or any of the photos were taken by them. What I show clients are albums from prior weddings so they can see the quality and completeness of what I provide.
Even with the second shooters I hire I have them mail me a DVD with all the pictures from their last wedding. I can see how well they interact with people and how skilled they are as photographers Some "wedding photographers" are clueless about posing and say they are "PJ" which is a lame excuse. Same goes for not using flash. I have watched other photographers at weddings who spend a good deal of time photographing the children of the wedding guests who are not part of the wedding party or even the immediate family and this provides nothing of value to the bride and groom and their family members.
My second photographers all have two pro level camera bodies and f/2.8 lenses and sufficient batteries and memory cards and two speedlights or I do not hire them.
I would also pass on any wedding photographer who shoots film. At a bridal fair another photographer who shot 120 film was telling me how the lab messed up 4 of the 6 rolls of film she shot. I could only think that 120 shots with no lab issues is really shortchanging the bride and groom. Roughly 10% of my shots are insurance shots so for example with the cake cutting if the bride or groom blinks and so their eyes are closed, or just their weak eye which is quite common, I still have images with both of them with their eyes wide open. If I shot film I could not afford to do this and would have to hope for the best.
When there are no retakes possible and guests who have often traveled thousands of miles to attend in what is also a family reunion in many respects, it is my responsibiltiy as a paid photographer to do everything I can to produce the desired, and promised results for my clients. Excuses just do not cut it in this situation. Being sorry or giving a refund really fixes nothing.
p.2 #10Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
elkhornsun wrote:
I highly recommend ignoring the photographer's website as you do not even know if all or any of the photos were taken by them. What I show clients are albums from prior weddings so they can see the quality and completeness of what I provide.
If you don't trust the images on a website, why would you trust the images in an album?
p.2 #11Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
Presumably one could not so easily steal a whole album's worth of images from a website, and depending on print size and web display size, it may be the quality in print wouldn't be as good as when doing the prints from one's own original photographs. Finally, one would have to do some effort on achieving a layout for the album and would one really want to do that based on stolen images?
p.2 #12Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
*EDIT* I saw you replied, glad they offered a refund. Also, I *don't* do weddings. I've done friend's weddings, who know my style and were happy with the results, but generally speaking, I'll leave that stuff to the full-time pros who want to deal with all the stress.
.....
If the photographer were truly professional, they would own their mistake and offer at least a *partial* refund. We don't know the particulars of the contract, though,nor how much money they were asking for or how much paying that amount would affect you or the photog. If it was a friend or a "semi pro" such as myself, they may be asking for significantly less than most wedding photographers charge, and if you guys chose them, well... that's kinda on you.
I've shot film for paid work, but always as a "suppliment" to the digital files,due to the inherent risks. It's cool that at least some of those came out.
If it were me, I'd offer a partial refund and/or a complimentary couples shoot, post-wedding. I'd suggest (calmly) having a conversation with the photog to see if you can come to an agreement. This sucks, but realize that the times are TOUGH for photographers, and if they weren't charging much, and you can afford what they are asking, you may just have to eat it and move on.
p.2 #13Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
EstherSP wrote:
If your daughter specifically chose this photographer for film photography, this is simply the risk you take. Generally wedding photography contracts don't list specific images delivered due to the fickle nature of weddings, nor does it require the customer to accept them as "worth the cost" after the fact.
If this was a word of mouth agreement, I'd say be a little sympathetic to the fact that that photographer will likely have very few weddings to shoot this year. Have a heart, all of the professional photographers out there are facing pretty immediate threats to their livelihood.
So.......
You feel the OP has a moral obligation to pay the a fee despite the fact that the promised service wasn't delivered
p.2 #14Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
mikeinctown wrote: saxbike wroteI want to thank everyone for the timely feedback. Our daughter contracted the photographer and these comments will give her confidence in discussing the situation.Please update the thread when you get any information. Even in film days, 30 photos of a wedding would not be sufficient.
Well, in the older film days--medium format days--it would have been sufficient, but they would all have been good shots.
p.2 #15Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
chez wrote: elkhornsun wroteI highly recommend ignoring the photographer's website as you do not even know if all or any of the photos were taken by them. What I show clients are albums from prior weddings so they can see the quality and completeness of what I provide.If you don't trust the images on a website, why would you trust the images in an album?
Presumably (at least by my presumption), seeing the album implies meeting the photographer and probably seeing much more of their work, having a chance to set each other's perceptions and expectations better.
p.2 #16Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
Beni wrote:
As an (ex) full time wedding pro, you have grounds to demand a full refund. You would also be within your rights to demand a reshoot, at the very least a bride and groom portrait shoot so they have pics to put on the wall, etc.
Dependant on the agreement and coverage contracted or agreed on, you may have grounds for making a claim in addition.
I would not, under any circumstances, pay this photographer. That could be seen as acceptance of the situation. The product, photographic coverage of the day, has not been provided. The 36 pictures which I assume do not span the entire wedding inclusive of portraits, are akin to paying for a car and receiving a single wheel. It's not what you paid for and in itself does not provide the solution you had contracted for.
p.2 #17Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
The photographer I hired for my sister's wedding had a body failure.
She paid to have every photo retouched to hide the problem (Hass had something fall in between the film and the curtain).
I don't understand how a digital body can fail- they're on the digital card. They just need to send it off to a data recovery service.
(and yes, I know there are extreme cases with the controller on the card failing. And yes I do data recovery...)
p.2 #18Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
I would not pay the photographer anything. With wedding photography there are no do-overs but too many people do not bother to check out the photographer. I used two bodies until one failed with no warning during the processional. After that I brought a third camera that I had in the trunk of the car so if a body failed I would still have two working cameras. I also use 3 speedlights for weddings so no issues if one dies.
To me a professional is someone who is paid to produce results and not excuses. Unfortunately there are many people who take on wedding jobs that lack the equipment and the experience to guarantee the results and too many brides who are too cheap to pay for a good photographer.
Usually I have found that the bride budgets for the dress and the venue and the flowers and the caterer and the DJ and the limo (which is considered by most to be a must have item) and then with what is left they look for a photographer. I have had couples on tight budgets get their cake at a bakery and flowers at the supermarket and used a boombox for the dancing so that they could afford a good photographer. It comes down to priorities.
p.2 #19Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
chez wrote: elkhornsun wroteI highly recommend ignoring the photographer's website as you do not even know if all or any of the photos were taken by them. What I show clients are albums from prior weddings so they can see the quality and completeness of what I provide.If you don't trust the images on a website, why would you trust the images in an album?
The images in an album are for a single wedding and those on a website are usually from many weddings. They provide no useful information as to how effective the photographer is in photographing the bride getting ready, the group photos, the processional, the cerermony, the bridal party, the reception and dancing.
When selecting a new second photographer I insist that they send me a DVD with all the images from their last wedding. I can see how well they work with people and with the venue and with detail shots and other elements. I can see if they know how to use their flash and make changes to camera settings or shoot only in Program mode and without flash and pretend that this is more natural instead of admitting they lack the technical skills.
I business parlance the album is the deliverable work product. That is what the couple as the clients are paying the photographer to provide.
p.2 #20Ethical question for professional wedding photogs
elkhornsun wrote:
I would not pay the photographer anything. With wedding photography there are no do-overs
Back in the film days, my father had a large, professional photograph business. Decades ago, film from a wedding got lost. I don't remember if it got lost being transported from the wedding back to the office or at the lab, but it was gone. My father paid to re-stage the wedding so that photos could be taken. Obviously, it wouldn't have the same vibe as the actual wedding, but it was as close as they could get. Now people didn't have weddings as fancy and expensive back then as they do today, but it still must have really hurt his business to have to absorb that cost.
I agree that the photographer should not be paid. Many people sign contracts without reading them and seeing how they are protected, not just the provider. There should have been a clause in the contract that the photographer will "use professional techniques as those terms are understood in the industry" and it is certainly NOT professional to show up at a wedding with just one body.
I wonder if the photographer knew the camera failed during the wedding itself and if the photographer did, did they inform the bride? If not, why not? And if the photographer did, what I would have done is announce that to the crowd, ask everyone to take smartphone photos, have them all send to the pro and the pro could have "professionally" post-processed them to try and get something out of it.
One of the long term problems with professional photography is that there's no certification - anyone can call themselves a professional photographer. I see posts from people on Facebook all the time from people who from their questions obviously don't know all that much about photography and who proclaim that they want to start shooting weddings for a fee. Buyer beware. I always thought it was a shame that there was never some kind of photographers' organization that provided both education and certification.