fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020New Canon R5 Rumor

  
 
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.11 #1New Canon R5 Rumor
arbitrage wrote:
therealthings wrotehttps://www.canonrumors.com/canon-eos-r5-specifications/

Seems about right compared to the first rumors.
That is a post from Feb 2nd.

Did you mean to post this new leak: https://www.canonrumors.com/here-is-the-canon-eos-r5-we-think/


dont see the shutter covers on the sensor like the R. Could be just locked open for product view.
Feb 14, 2020 at 03:51 AM
Ralph Conway
Offline
Details
p.11 #2New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
IndyFab wrote

" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">

It's funny how he says "don't trust the rumors" and then goes ahead trusting the very first part of the highlighted rumor specs that really goes beyond what Canon has actually said, the sensor resolution.


Matt Granger (never heard about him before): "Doent believe those rumors. MY guess is, that the new camera will not have all those things ... (wich nobody said/wrote on any rumor site)."

Boring. Just another (nice) guy, trying to ride the rumor bull to increase his own traffic. The differnce is, that he is two days late and does not tell anything new, while canonrumors was already correct with nearly everything two weeks ago. Lets see if it is 45 MP, too.
Feb 14, 2020 at 04:12 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.11 #3New Canon R5 Rumor
I am excited about the announcement like everybody else, and Canon fan and everything, but I am unsettled on these questions:

Why would Canon release a flagship camera, and then some months later release a lower end camera with revolutionary new technology and higher specs?
Possible answer: To get the 1DXIII out to the olympics.
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP.

Why would Canon go to 20 fps at 45 MP when a lower speed would still outdo the competition?
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP.

Why would Canon release a flagship camera, and then some months later release a low end camera (R6) with basically the same sensor specs (20 MP 20 fps)? There would be no apparent specs difference between the newest highest ans lowest end FF cameras.
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is lower and the rumors about R5 and R6 are being mixed up at some stage.

How is Canon going to solve the heat problem with native 8K recording in this form factor body with IBIS?
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP.

How can 8K be upsampled when Canon say they can downsample 8K to 4K?
Possible answer: It still makes sense to downsample to 4K if the 8K video is recorded at 5,5K from a 20 MP sensor.

How could Canon survive if the 8K video turns out to be upsampled and the resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP?
Possible answer: They can't and thats why they got so really upset about the R5 rumors with 45 MP sensor.
Feb 14, 2020 at 04:32 AM
Ralph Conway
Offline
Details
p.11 #4New Canon R5 Rumor
Downsampling 8 to 4K is easy. Upsampling from 4 to 8K will not result in "real" 8K. It is not possible to "calculate" any missing information by interpolation to recieve a real 8K resolution.

In my understanding that means for 8K video you NEED a minimum resolution of 7.680 by 5.120 (if you want to keep the 3/2 aspect ratio for photographs, too). What would result in the 39.321.600 pixels (wich as far I remember where already mentioned above). So it must be a 40MP sensor as a minimum, when the new camera is able to deliver 8K video in my understanding.

Am I wrong?
Feb 14, 2020 at 04:57 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.11 #5New Canon R5 Rumor
Ralph Conway wrote:
Downsampling 8 to 4K is easy. Upsampling from 4 to 8K will not result in "real" 8K. It is not possible to "calculate" any missing information by interpolation to recieve a real 8K resolution.

In my understanding that means for 8K video you NEED a minimum resolution of 7.680 by 5.120 (if you want to keep the 3/2 aspect ratio for photographs, too). What would result in the 39.321.600 pixels (wich as far I remember where already mentioned above). So it must be a 40MP sensor as a minimum, when the new camera is able to deliver 8K video
...Show more →

You are not wrong, but Canon is already producing fake 4K video in some cameras by the means of upsampling / interpolation, according to things I have read. I don't do video myself and never checked regarding the M6II.
Feb 14, 2020 at 05:02 AM
Ralph Conway
Offline
Details
p.11 #6New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
Ralph Conway wroteDownsampling 8 to 4K is easy. Upsampling from 4 to 8K will not result in "real" 8K. It is not possible to "calculate" any missing information by interpolation to recieve a real 8K resolution.

In my understanding that means for 8K video you NEED a minimum resolution of 7.680 by 5.120 (if you want to keep the 3/2 aspect ratio for photographs, too). What would result in the 39.321.600 pixels (wich as far I remember where already mentioned above). So it must be a 40MP sensor as a minimum, when the new camera is able to deliver 8K video in my understanding.

Am I wrong?
You are not wrong, but Canon is already producing fake 4K video in some cameras by the means of upsampling / interpolation, according to things I have read. I don't do video myself and never checked regarding the M6II.



I might be wrong, but as far I remember the M6 II has an 32MP sensor. That would mean downsampling to the 10MP needed for 4K. What in my opinion does not fake anything but enhance the quality of the 4K Video. It happens in downsampling, because information that would else be ignored finds its way into the final result, too. This is not possible in the other direction (upsampling). Here the missing information would just be interpolated by the average of the neighboured pixels.


Feb 14, 2020 at 05:26 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.11 #7New Canon R5 Rumor
Ralph Conway wrote:
alundeb wrote
Ralph Conway wroteDownsampling 8 to 4K is easy. Upsampling from 4 to 8K will not result in "real" 8K. It is not possible to "calculate" any missing information by interpolation to recieve a real 8K resolution.

In my understanding that means for 8K video you NEED a minimum resolution of 7.680 by 5.120 (if you want to keep the 3/2 aspect ratio for photographs, too). What would result in the 39.321.600 pixels (wich as far I remember where already mentioned above). So it must be a 40MP sensor as a minimum, when the new camera is able to deliver 8K video in my understanding.

Am I wrong?
You are not wrong, but Canon is already producing fake 4K video in some cameras by the means of upsampling / interpolation, according to things I have read. I don't do video myself and never checked regarding the M6II.
I might be wrong, but as far I remember the M6 II has an 32MP sensor. That would mean downsampling to the 10MP needed for 4K. What in my opinion does not fake anything but enhance the quality of the 4K Video. It happens in downsampling, because information that would else be ignored finds its way into the final result, too. This is not possible in the other direction (upsampling). Here the missing information would just be interpolated by the average of the neighboured pixels.



From what I understand, the M6II is pixel binning at 3K and then upsampling to 4K.
Feb 14, 2020 at 05:33 AM
IndyFab
Offline
Details
p.11 #8New Canon R5 Rumor
technic wrote:
therealthings wrote
technic wrote
robinlee wroteDang it, now I am so looking forward to attend CP+ in Yokohama to have first taste of the new R5, hopefully we can touch, feel and play
CP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.


Another thing to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?



Edited on Feb 14, 2020 at 08:01 PM · View previous versions
Feb 14, 2020 at 06:03 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.11 #9New Canon R5 Rumor
IndyFab wrote:
technic wrote
therealthings wrote
technic wrote
robinlee wroteDang it, now I am so looking forward to attend CP+ in Yokohama to have first taste of the new R5, hopefully we can touch, feel and play
CP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.
Another think to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?



What do they do about the yearly flu virus that kills about 1/2 million people a year??
Feb 14, 2020 at 06:07 AM
IndyFab
Offline
Details
p.11 #10New Canon R5 Rumor
arbitrage wrote:
IndyFab wrote
technic wrote
therealthings wrote
technic wrote
robinlee wroteDang it, now I am so looking forward to attend CP+ in Yokohama to have first taste of the new R5, hopefully we can touch, feel and play
CP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.
Another think to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?
What do they do about the yearly flu virus that kills about 1/2 million people a year??


Have you ever asked yourself why does the Flu appear every year around the same time, and really dont know what the Flu has to do with the Corona virus.when that was being discussed. Two different things. You dont see them quarantining folks with the flu.

My educated guess/hypothesis is they have answers/solutions for the flu, although it affects/kills the majority with compromised immune systems, ex. very young and older population, I guess you can throw in highly stressed out folks as well., but no real answers/solution of meds yet for the Corona virus !! .

Edited on Feb 14, 2020 at 07:03 AM · View previous versions
Feb 14, 2020 at 06:14 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.11 #11New Canon R5 Rumor
IndyFab wrote:
technic wrote
therealthings wrote
technic wrote
robinlee wroteDang it, now I am so looking forward to attend CP+ in Yokohama to have first taste of the new R5, hopefully we can touch, feel and play
CP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.
Another think to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?



People might hurry to get their hands on these goods by that time if the current shutdown of the China workplace continues. There is no sign yet that the virus survives for more than a short time on external surfaces. If one is buying pangolins from China it's obviously a different story, but most of them travel in the other direction
Feb 14, 2020 at 06:15 AM
IndyFab
Offline
Details
p.11 #12New Canon R5 Rumor
technic wrote:
IndyFab wrote
technic wrote
therealthings wrote
technic wrote
robinlee wroteDang it, now I am so looking forward to attend CP+ in Yokohama to have first taste of the new R5, hopefully we can touch, feel and play
CP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.
Another think to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?
People might hurry to get their hands on these goods by that time if the current shutdown of the China workplace continues. There is no sign yet that the virus survives for more than a short time on external surfaces. If one is buying pangolins from China it's obviously a different story, but most of them travel in the other direction


I was thinking that customs might not let them have the containers. However your point about "the virus survives for more than a short time on external surfaces" could very will be.. I remember hearing on the news that China authorities were hoping for a early warm up, as they mentioned something about the warm temperatures affecting the virus .. .
Feb 14, 2020 at 06:34 AM
rbeasley
Offline
Details
p.11 #13New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
I am excited about the announcement like everybody else, and Canon fan and everything, but I am unsettled on these questions:

Why would Canon release a flagship camera, and then some months later release a lower end camera with revolutionary new technology and higher specs?
Possible answer: To get the 1DXIII out to the olympics.
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP.

Why would Canon go to 20 fps at 45 MP when a lower speed would still outdo the competition?
Possible answer: The resolution of the R5 is much lower than 45 MP.

Why would Canon release a flagship
...Show more →

I am not a betting guy but I would bet the sensor is not going to be 20mp. The R6 may be. The R5 will be 40-45 mega pixels. If Canon were going to try and get 8k from a 20mp sensor they would have done so with the 1DX3.


Edited on Feb 14, 2020 at 10:24 AM · View previous versions
Feb 14, 2020 at 07:48 AM
maxx9photo
Offline
Details
p.11 #14New Canon R5 Rumor
How much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?
Feb 14, 2020 at 08:20 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.11 #15New Canon R5 Rumor
maxx9photo wrote:
How much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?


$3.5K at min....could easily push $4K or even $4.5K like the A9II.
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:00 AM
Milan Hutera
Offline
Details
p.11 #16New Canon R5 Rumor
maxx9photo wrote:
How much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?


4999
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:04 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.11 #17New Canon R5 Rumor
IndyFab wrote:
arbitrage wrote
IndyFab wrote
technic wrote
therealthings wrote
technic wroteCP+ is cancelled, it suffers from nCoV contagion. Maybe "touch, feel and play" wasn't the best idea under the circumstances ;(
I wonder where we stand in May when Photokina is set to go. I was hoping to play with the R5 there. But according to D.J.'s words, the virus will be dealth with in april if i'm right.
By April the contagion may have spread to Europe; still very difficult to know the real risks because too much of the data is missing or suspect. The virus is now clearly out in the open, spreading outside China. It's more a question of what measures are effective in keeping it under control. As long as we don't know trade fairs, mass transport facilities, cruise ships etc. are not a good place to be.
Another think to think about is the shipments of goods by sea that left China when the virus was discovered. What will they do with them when they arrive at there destination port.?
What do they do about the yearly flu virus that kills about 1/2 million people a year??
Have you ever asked yourself why does the Flu appear every year around the same time, and really dont know what the Flu has to do with the Corona virus.when that was being discussed. Two different things. You dont see them quarantining folks with the flu.

My educated guess/hypothesis is they have answers/solutions for the flu, although it affects/kills the majority with compromised immune systems, ex. very young and older population, I guess you can throw in highly stressed out folks as well., but no real answers/solution of meds yet for the Corona virus !! .


You are correct....my comment was a little insensitive and maybe in poor taste but I do think the media is blowing things a little out of proportion as they always do. Yes there are differences as no one is vaccinated for this new virus as many are for the flu each year. The mortality rate at this point is higher that the seasonal flu. I don't think they really know yet how viral this virus is yet....obviously it is affecting a higher incidence of people because it is novel and there are no vaccinated people on earth.
However, just like the flu, the people actually dying from this coronavirus are also immune-compromised for the most part. I don't believe anyone has died in N. America yet unless that has changed in the last day or so (I've been avoiding the sensationalization of this virus as much as I can).

Yes there is a real threat for a much more widespread pandemic.

I will now refrain from discussing political stuff like this in this forum and get back to discussing gear and how factory shutdowns will affect it.
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:06 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.11 #18New Canon R5 Rumor
Milan Hutera wrote:
maxx9photo wroteHow much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?
4999


I think that high would be suicidal. If it did come out that high, I would expect at least $500 knocked off within 3-6 months. Capitalize on the severe GAS and then sell it to the rest.
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:08 AM
Milan Hutera
Offline
Details
p.11 #19New Canon R5 Rumor
arbitrage wrote:
Milan Hutera wrote
maxx9photo wroteHow much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?
4999
I think that high would be suicidal. If it did come out that high, I would expect at least $500 knocked off within 3-6 months. Capitalize on the severe GAS and then sell it to the rest.


It's Canon, they market it as "pro" body that can do 12/20fps. Of course it's going to be ridiculously expensive...
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:44 AM
mb126
Offline
Details
p.11 #20New Canon R5 Rumor
Milan Hutera wrote:
maxx9photo wroteHow much do you think the price of R5? US $2k to 3k?
4999


Agree, I think 4499 or 4999 is right for the MSRP. Although from a consumer perspective I can see 4999 being much more intolerable (5k for a camera?!)

Hopefully the CAN exchange rate gets crushed shortly after release and Americans get a good street price through CPW
Feb 14, 2020 at 09:48 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister