fredmiranda.com Login

Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread

  
 
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #1Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
_jim_ wrote
j.liam wroteHorses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,
I have the Nikkor. It's a swell lens. Different strengths and weakness than the LLL 50/1.2.
I remember Leica's promotional video for the ƒ/1.2 redux and it was just so underwhelming, with its very low contrast and startlingly meager resolution. It seemed more of a notable historical landmark in optics and a collector's object than practicable kit. Everyone seems so taken by the extra 1/2 stop over an older non-ASPH Summilux, as if their photographic skills suddenly and magically change--maybe they have, but for the worse. Bastian's comparison of the various super-fast 50's is a perfect counterpoint to this mad rush to ƒ/1; the best overall lens for general use in his estimation was the CV
...Show more →

The LLL version is supposed to bring better sharpness at f/1.2 over the reissue. If the production version can't live up to that, then I'll agree it gets put in the same mush category as the Leica reissue. But we can't yet know based on these first shots on 3200 speed film at 1/15 sec.
Jan 07, 2024 at 10:54 AM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.48 #2Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
j.liam wrote
_jim_ wrote
j.liam wroteHorses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,
I have the Nikkor. It's a swell lens. Different strengths and weakness than the LLL 50/1.2.
I remember Leica's promotional video for the ƒ/1.2 redux and it was just so underwhelming, with its very low contrast and startlingly meager resolution. It seemed more of a notable historical landmark in optics and a collector's object than practicable kit. Everyone seems so taken by the extra 1/2 stop over an older non-ASPH Summilux, as if their photographic skills suddenly and magically change--maybe they have, but for the worse. Bastian's comparison of the various super-fast 50's is a perfect counterpoint to this mad rush to ƒ/1; the best overall lens for general use in his estimation was the CV 1,2/50 and for good reason. If you've got the cash and need an extra lens for the 5 images a year for which a 1mm DOF is suited for, then a Mr Ding will do. Its rendering seems more relevant than the unholy "mush" of the Leica of LLL knockoff 50/1.2.
The LLL version is supposed to bring better sharpness at f/1.2 over the reissue. If the production version can't live up to that, then I'll agree it gets put in the same mush category as the Leica reissue. But we can't yet know based on these first shots on 3200 speed film at 1/15 sec.


Perhaps I'm wrong but getting that ƒ/1.2 lens to resolve better requires precision collimation and adjustment before it's shipped--Leica messes up on this all too often. Given the LLL price point, don't expect much QA before it's sent out of the workshop. Also with LLL, they probably tore apart one or two random, original samples and copied the elements, including the hand-ground aspherical, tweaking the design. This is also a limiting factor in the end-product.
Jan 07, 2024 at 11:17 AM
Dan Chang
Offline
Details
p.48 #3Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
A cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Jan 07, 2024 at 11:21 AM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.48 #4Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Dan Chang wrote:
A cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens


Completely agree.
Jan 07, 2024 at 11:23 AM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #5Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
j.liam wrote
_jim_ wrote
j.liam wroteHorses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,
I have the Nikkor. It's a swell lens. Different strengths and weakness than the LLL 50/1.2.
I remember Leica's promotional video for the ƒ/1.2 redux and it was just so underwhelming, with its very low contrast and startlingly meager resolution. It seemed more of a notable historical landmark in optics and a collector's object than practicable kit. Everyone seems so taken by the extra 1/2 stop over an older non-ASPH Summilux, as if their photographic skills suddenly and magically change--maybe they have, but for the worse. Bastian's comparison of the various super-fast 50's is a perfect counterpoint to this mad rush to ƒ/1; the best overall lens for general use in his estimation was the CV 1,2/50 and for good reason. If you've got the cash and need an extra lens for the 5 images a year for which a 1mm DOF is suited for, then a Mr Ding will do. Its rendering seems more relevant than the unholy "mush" of the Leica of LLL knockoff 50/1.2.
The LLL version is supposed to bring better sharpness at f/1.2 over the reissue. If the production version can't live up to that, then I'll agree it gets put in the same mush category as the Leica reissue. But we can't yet know based on these first shots on 3200 speed film at 1/15 sec.
Perhaps I'm wrong but getting that ƒ/1.2 lens to resolve better requires precision collimation and adjustment before it's shipped--Leica messes up on this all too often. Given the LLL price point, don't expect much QA before it's sent out of the workshop. Also with LLL, they probably tore apart one or two random, original samples and copied the elements, including the hand-ground aspherical, tweaking the design. This is also a limiting factor in the end-product.


My understanding was the point of the 1.2 remake from LLL was not to just copy the original but to improve it both in sharpness and bokeh rendering wide open. I thought I remember seeing some comparisons with their prototype that illustrated this. Leica took a different route using modern lens manufacturing techniques but still remaining faithful to the "mush". It's ironic that LLL is more closely copying the original glass types but trying for better IQ while Leica is using modern techniques but kept the performance similar to the original.

Jury is still out though. There was a big difference between the rendering of the LLL 50 SPII prototypes and the production version – almost a completely different lens from an optics perspective – so the same may hold true for this 50 1.2. Waiting on some digital comparisons between the LLL, the original, and the reissue like Fred mentioned.
Jan 07, 2024 at 11:36 AM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #6Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Dan Chang wrote:
A cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens


Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
Jan 07, 2024 at 11:41 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.48 #7Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Dan Chang wrote:
A cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens


The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Jan 07, 2024 at 12:45 PM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.48 #8Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.


You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote:
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.


Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Jan 07, 2024 at 03:59 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.48 #9Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of
...Show more →


Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?


Jan 07, 2024 at 04:22 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #10Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of
...Show more →

You have seen samples from the LLL 1.2 on an M11? I must have missed that, too.
Jan 07, 2024 at 04:22 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #11Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
RustyRus wrote:
j.liam wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?



People don’t need high res samples or direct experience to give well-informed opinions
Jan 07, 2024 at 04:26 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.48 #12Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
RustyRus wrote
j.liam wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?
People don’t need high res samples or direct experience to give well-informed opinions


I just don’t understand how people can form such over the top opinions (nothing is useable with x lens) with never even touching it. The internet is a beautiful thing
Jan 07, 2024 at 04:33 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #13Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
RustyRus wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RustyRus wrote
j.liam wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?
People don’t need high res samples or direct experience to give well-informed opinions
I just don’t understand how people can form such over the top opinions (nothing is useable with x lens) with never even touching it. The internet is a beautiful thing


Probably because they're easily triggered by things they don't understand or are prejudiced against. All started with "China" being too red and prominent, IIRC.




Jan 07, 2024 at 04:37 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.48 #14Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Those complaining about the ‘performance’ of the LLL lens would be tripping over themselves in orgasmic delight if it had a Leica badge on it.
Jan 07, 2024 at 05:26 PM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.48 #15Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
RustyRus wrote
j.liam wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?
People don’t need high res samples or direct experience to give well-informed opinions


Save the snark for someone else. You too Rusty. Desmo, well, that's the tone you take with everyone. If you had actually read what I wrote, I looked at the samples Leica provided on the 50/1.2 and the work of others with that lens. Can only go off the images online for the LLL which mimics that performance. The CV 50/1 was rented for a project and speak from experience. Doesn't take 3 years with the lens to see what the Leica 50/1.2 is about. Go spring $8k, Mr Mesa and tell us of all your wondrous insights. On pins and needles for that one.
Jan 07, 2024 at 05:39 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.48 #16Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RustyRus wrote
j.liam wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
Oh wow, so you're telling me that a Voigtlander lens designed in 2022 has better IQ than a faithful remake of a 57-year old lens? Stunning.
You missed the point. Of course the newby will be superior (duh) but the CV will deliver the millimeters-deep DOF when subject isolation is the goal, "imperfect" rendering--slightly glowy at ƒ/1 plus more usability at ƒ/1.7-2.0, the range that you'd even bother with such an optic. The Leica just looks unusable at any aperture unless of course you're filming a hazy dream sequence for a horror movie. Like the re-released Thambar, it's a "thing" and the (pricey) charm of it fades quickly. The LLL at $2k for this level of (non) performance? Ehh.

Fred Miranda wrote
Dan Chang wroteA cheaper Voigtlander 50mm f1 can do better and faster. The posted images are unimpressive for a 2K lens
The LLL 50/1.2 lens isn't designed for modern high resolution and contrast. You're correct, but that's beside the point, as this lens has a different purpose.
Yup. Some can't wait for the thrill of the mush, others will wonder what's the point. Everyone's entitled to their own aesthetic.
Liam, could you post some photos you took with any of the lenses in question?
People don’t need high res samples or direct experience to give well-informed opinions
Save the snark for someone else. You too Rusty. Desmo, well, that's the tone you take with everyone. If you had actually read what I wrote, I looked at the samples Leica provided on the 50/1.2 and the work of others with that lens. Can only go off the images online for the LLL which mimics that performance. The CV 50/1 was rented for a project and speak from experience. Doesn't take 3 years with the lens to see what the Leica 50/1.2 is about. Go spring $8k, Mr Mesa and tell us of all your wondrous insights. On pins
...Show more →

Keep telling us all what to think, what we should like, what we should not like, and why. It has been truly uplifting and encouraging to read all your posts in this thread. However, at this time I feel it wise to hide your posts. That said, I hope you continue to bring love and light to this forum
Jan 07, 2024 at 06:28 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.48 #17Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
I would love to test out the Leica Re-issue vs the LLL - Anyone up for a short term trade of the lens?

Happy to reciprocate something for it-

Jan 07, 2024 at 06:36 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.48 #18Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
The discussion got a bit intense, and some posts were removed. Let's steer the conversation back to civil discussion about Light Lens Lab gear. Thanks!
Jan 07, 2024 at 08:11 PM
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.48 #19Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread


RustyRus wrote:
I would love to test out the Leica Re-issue vs the LLL - Anyone up for a short term trade of the lens?

Happy to reciprocate something for it-



Sure. Let’s meet up. We can play with each other’s lenses. I’m in NW.
Jan 07, 2024 at 10:24 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.48 #20Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
RustyRus wroteI would love to test out the Leica Re-issue vs the LLL - Anyone up for a short term trade of the lens?

Happy to reciprocate something for it-

Sure. Let’s meet up. We can play with each other’s lenses. I’m in NW.


I didn’t even realize you were in Portland- 100% let’s make something happen.

Jan 07, 2024 at 11:51 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister