fredmiranda.com Login

Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread

  
 
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.47 #1Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
The LLL may be more like the original 1.2...but it's hard to say. There are so few example photographs taken with that lens (at sufficient resolution) to judge. The street silhouettes blog has the most images, but again, a little hard to discern. The LLL '1966' is absolutely gorgeous, but here are the onion rings in question (a throw away image, for sure, but highlights what I am talking about).

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53434147041_f92ec3f24b_b.jpgLLL50mm12 by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

If you compare that to the original 1.2 shots from this blog post, I think you could maybe argue there is more structure in the LLL:

https://www.streetsilhouettes.com/home/2016/7/8/crazy-comparison-bokeh-shootout-between-leica-canon-and-nikon?rq=1.2


That does seem so, the Leica 1.2 does appear less onion ringy. But then again, unless you have both lenses in front of you for a legit comparison, it is hard to tell.
This however was interesting from his comparison:

Where it gets interesting is when you compare the lens with itself between the two different sensors. For example, the bokeh on the Leica 50mm f/0.95 Noctilux has more blur on the M240 sensor than on the Sony sensor, which appears to be slightly more harsh. To me, it almost appears as if the bokeh on the Leica sensor is less busy and more relaxed than the bokeh on the Sony sensor. Upon comparing the rest of the grouping, it appears that consistently, the Sony sensor is harsher by comparison. But to be fair, I don't think that anyone would ever notice the difference - if it were not for a tedious comparison like this.
Jan 02, 2024 at 02:00 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.47 #2Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
If you compare that to the original 1.2 shots from this blog post, I think you could maybe argue there is more structure in the LLL:

https://www.streetsilhouettes.com/home/2016/7/8/crazy-comparison-bokeh-shootout-between-leica-canon-and-nikon?rq=1.2


It's challenging to determine from the streetsilhouettes's samples. If you shot under similar lighting conditions, you might not notice much of an onion pattern. Like you wrote, the limited number of online samples makes it difficult to draw conclusions.

We're looking for someone who has all three lenses: the original 50/1.2 Noct, the LLL 50/1.2 Noct, and the reissued Leica 50/1.2 Noct, to do a side-by-side comparison.
Jan 02, 2024 at 02:11 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.47 #3Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
I don't get any of that onion ring with my re-issue. I just went back and looked through every picture I've taken with that lens-

No shots exhibit anything like that-

Will check my film shots next-
Jan 02, 2024 at 03:17 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.47 #4Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
None of these are identical but I don't see any of the Onion Ring pattern in these- Some film/some M11/M11m

Some throw away frames in here but you can the point-
























Jan 02, 2024 at 03:24 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.47 #5Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
RustyRus wrote:
I don't get any of that onion ring with my re-issue. I just went back and looked through every picture I've taken with that lens-

No shots exhibit anything like that-

Will check my film shots next-



Lovely rendering.
It may be too late but take a defocused picture of your Christmas tree of light ornament. You will likely see it.
Jan 02, 2024 at 05:50 PM
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.47 #6Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Developed my first roll with the LLL 50mm f/1.2. There is not a lot of light this time of year, so I experimented with T-Max P3200 shot at 800. The lens's draw is quite striking - a mix of soft out-of-focus and swirl. There is not a ton of resolution...but that's also part of the look. I am excited to keep learning how to use it successfully.

Hoop by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Barnaby by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Sign by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Mike by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Jenny by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Tex by Jim Fischer, on Flickr

Sign by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Jan 04, 2024 at 04:09 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.47 #7Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread



Late review of the 50 SPII.
Jan 05, 2024 at 08:25 PM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.47 #8Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:



Late review of the 50 SPII.


I like the videos of the guy.
He does mention the lack of flare as being a disappointment, I must say it was the only thing that I regret also about the lens, I hoped for some big time.
The blue cast is interesting but the lack of flare is the thing that makes me go back often to the Heliar.
Jan 06, 2024 at 05:40 AM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.47 #9Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:



Late review of the 50 SPII.


He mentions how smooth the focus action is, while others have complained and had the helicoils regreased.
Jan 06, 2024 at 11:31 AM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.47 #10Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
Developed my first roll with the LLL 50mm f/1.2. There is not a lot of light this time of year, so I experimented with T-Max P3200 shot at 800. The lens's draw is quite striking - a mix of soft out-of-focus and swirl. There is not a ton of resolution...but that's also part of the look. I am excited to keep learning how to use it successfully.



Horses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,
Jan 06, 2024 at 11:56 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

stgrove
Online
Details
p.47 #11Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam

Being unfamiliar with older Nikkor lenses how does your lens compare to the Nikkor 58mm 1.2 that seems very pricey?
Jan 06, 2024 at 02:23 PM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.47 #12Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
stgrove wrote:
j.liam

Being unfamiliar with older Nikkor lenses how does your lens compare to the Nikkor 58mm 1.2 that seems very pricey?


The 50/1.2, a symmetrical design without aspherical elements, demonstrates a lot of so-called 'veiling flare' at ƒ/1.2-1.4 but underneath it all, there's still fairly high resolution. Beyond ƒ/2, sharp as a tack.

The 58/1.2, has a curvature of field that can be tricky, but to my eye, still has a higher resolution & contrast at ƒ/1.2-2 and lower haze than the older Leica 50/1.2--or the CV 58/1.4. Controls comma a bit better too. It was a true low-light lens of the late 1970's and 1980's, whereas the Nikkor 50/1.2 was and is more of 'character' lens.

Neither Nikkor renders in this super-soft "mush".The Leica 50/1.2 redux or this LLL knockoff, appear something that would appeal more to videographers rather than still photographers nowadays. Shooters in the 1960's with money or the need, when the Leica appeared, had little choices with relatively slower emulsions then available.

Edited on Jan 06, 2024 at 02:55 PM · View previous versions
Jan 06, 2024 at 02:47 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.47 #13Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Desmolicious wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote



Late review of the 50 SPII.
He mentions how smooth the focus action is, while others have complained and had the helicoils regreased.


Did anyone ever go through with the regrease? Mine smoothed out after a few weeks and is very smooth now. My only mechanical complaint about the lens is it's always getting moved off f/2 even though the aperture ring resistance is fairly stiff. I'm guessing the length of the lens makes it easier for the aperture ring to grab onto things when the camera is being moved around.

I still need to take off the "wings" on the focusing ring to see how I like that. I have a feeling I'll like it better, but it's a trade-off since the wings act like a foot when I put down the camera, which keeps the camera from tipping forward.
Jan 06, 2024 at 02:49 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.47 #14Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
Developed my first roll with the LLL 50mm f/1.2. There is not a lot of light this time of year, so I experimented with T-Max P3200 shot at 800. The lens's draw is quite striking - a mix of soft out-of-focus and swirl. There is not a ton of resolution...but that's also part of the look. I am excited to keep learning how to use it successfully....


One of the features of the LLL version was supposed to be better sharpness at f/1.2. Have you checked the rangefinder alignment with the LCD or Visoflex on a digital M? That said, I wouldn't expect a ton of resolving power with T-Max 3200 even stopped down
Jan 06, 2024 at 02:55 PM
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.47 #15Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
_jim_ wroteDeveloped my first roll with the LLL 50mm f/1.2. There is not a lot of light this time of year, so I experimented with T-Max P3200 shot at 800. The lens's draw is quite striking - a mix of soft out-of-focus and swirl. There is not a ton of resolution...but that's also part of the look. I am excited to keep learning how to use it successfully....
One of the features of the LLL version was supposed to be better sharpness at f/1.2. Have you checked the rangefinder alignment with the LCD or Visoflex on a digital M? That said, I wouldn't expect a ton of resolving power with T-Max 3200 even stopped down


No need to check the accuracy with a digital M (which I don't have). I have good eyesight, a focus magnifier and recently aligned rangefinders. I can attest that the lens focuses accurately.

Keep in mind, any of the indoor images that I shared are shot at 1/15 of second or less. Motion blur from the subjects or myself is unavoidable.

Jan 06, 2024 at 05:46 PM
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.47 #16Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
j.liam wrote:
Horses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,


I have the Nikkor. It's a swell lens. Different strengths and weakness than the LLL 50/1.2.


Jan 06, 2024 at 05:57 PM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.47 #17Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
_jim_ wroteDeveloped my first roll with the LLL 50mm f/1.2. There is not a lot of light this time of year, so I experimented with T-Max P3200 shot at 800. The lens's draw is quite striking - a mix of soft out-of-focus and swirl. There is not a ton of resolution...but that's also part of the look. I am excited to keep learning how to use it successfully....
One of the features of the LLL version was supposed to be better sharpness at f/1.2. Have you checked the rangefinder alignment with the LCD or Visoflex on a digital M? That said, I wouldn't expect a ton of resolving power with T-Max 3200 even stopped down
No need to check the accuracy with a digital M (which I don't have). I have good eyesight, a focus magnifier and recently aligned rangefinders. I can attest that the lens focuses accurately.

Keep in mind, any of the indoor images that I shared are shot at 1/15 of second or less. Motion blur from the subjects or myself is unavoidable.



1/15 sec, 3200 speed film, f/1.2, a lens design from 1966, and not a ton of resolution all go together like peas and carrots.
Jan 06, 2024 at 09:33 PM
stgrove
Online
Details
p.47 #18Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
:
highdesertmesa wrote:
1/15 sec, 3200 speed film, f/1.2, a lens design from 1966, and not a ton of resolution all go together like peas and carrots.


But I bet you are seriously considering ordering one. No?
Jan 07, 2024 at 08:29 AM
highdesertmesa
Online
Details
p.47 #19Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
stgrove wrote:
:
highdesertmesa wrote1/15 sec, 3200 speed film, f/1.2, a lens design from 1966, and not a ton of resolution all go together like peas and carrots.
But I bet you are seriously considering ordering one. No?


I'm constantly seriously considering everything
Jan 07, 2024 at 10:44 AM
j.liam
Offline
Details
p.47 #20Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
j.liam wroteHorses for courses. I think I'll walk instead.

Just a suggestion if interest in a fast lens "with character" is what drives you, the Nikkor 50/1.2 AIS (abundant and affordable) on a Shoten adapter for M bodies with a built in helicoid, is a nice alternative. Higher central resolution than the Leica @ ƒ/1.2, in my experience. Using the EVF makes focusing pretty straightforward,
I have the Nikkor. It's a swell lens. Different strengths and weakness than the LLL 50/1.2.



I watched Leica's promotional video for the ƒ/1.2 redux and it was just so underwhelming, with its very low contrast and startlingly meager resolution, even stopped down. It seemed more of a notable historical landmark in optics and a collector's object than practicable kit. Everyone seems so taken by the extra 1/2 stop over an older non-ASPH Summilux or CV, as if their photographic skills suddenly and magically change--maybe they have, but for the worse. Bastian's comparison of the various super-fast 50's is a perfect counterpoint to this frantic embrace of ƒ/1; the best overall lens for general use in his estimation was the CV 1,2/50 and for good reason. If you've got the cash and need an extra lens for the 5 images a year for which a 1mm DOF is suited for, then a Mr Ding will do. Its rendering seems more relevant than the unholy "mush" of the Leica of LLL knockoff 50/1.2.

Edited on Jan 07, 2024 at 10:55 AM · View previous versions
Jan 07, 2024 at 10:45 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister