Thank for explanation. You can always learn things. I will spend some effort to research/understand this and see how this affect my real world shooting.
bjornthun wrote: Steve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteWith a Sony, you get 5axis stabilization and a host of other good things. You will have to wait for a long time, at least until the D7 is released.
zhangyue wroteAt least you can use this one on Nikon with EXIF if you want. I will at least wait for a few more years before Voigtlander confirm no native Nikon Z and Canon R Mount version. There are so many options for me in this region.You have asked before whether you get 5-axis stabilization with the Nikon Z cameras and the TechArt adapter. I still am not sure that you get 5-axis stabilization, but I noticed that it does encode distance and that is reported right on the top LCD with the Techart adapter, so I would think that the camera which has the information it needs does implement 5-axis stabilization with Voigtlander E-mount lenses and the Techart adapter, but I am not sure that it does.Does the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.
zhangyue wrote:
Yes, 5 win over 3. Happy?
In this case, With smart adapter, what is the issue? vdo1 wroteShill harder guys.
"When working with adapted lenses, the camera's in-body image stabilization system drops to offering correction in three axes: pitch, yaw and roll."
A dyed in the wool Nikonian should have known.
F-mount Nikkors from D-type and forward encode distance, i.e. all VR type F-mount lenses. My guess is that IBIS will work in conjunction with the VR mechanism of VR lenses and offer five axis stabilization with those. The VR mechanism in the lens will handle yaw and pitch in that case.
I expect lens and camera stabilization to work mostly the same way on Nikon, Olympus, Panasonic and Sony.
Edit: the stabilization mechanism in the camera body can do 5-axis stabilization too, but it works less well with telephoto lenses. For telephoto lenses it is best to divide the stabilization job between the IBIS in the camera and the optical stabilizer in the lens. In this case the lens does yaw and pitch and the camera handles (barrel) roll and translation, which is the movement of the camera body and lens horizontally and vertically.
I think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wrote: Steve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteWith a Sony, you get 5axis stabilization and a host of other good things. You will have to wait for a long time, at least until the D7 is released.
zhangyue wroteAt least you can use this one on Nikon with EXIF if you want. I will at least wait for a few more years before Voigtlander confirm no native Nikon Z and Canon R Mount version. There are so many options for me in this region.You have asked before whether you get 5-axis stabilization with the Nikon Z cameras and the TechArt adapter. I still am not sure that you get 5-axis stabilization, but I noticed that it does encode distance and that is reported right on the top LCD with the Techart adapter, so I would think that the camera which has the information it needs does implement 5-axis stabilization with Voigtlander E-mount lenses and the Techart adapter, but I am not sure that it does.Does the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.
zhangyue wrote:
Fred, I don’t think distance information is needed but only focal length. IBIS Should mainly compensate vibration as angle offset on sensor, which is not directly relate to distance.
For example, for deep DOF image, you would not want camera give priority for certain distance.
I could be wrong given I didn’t research this topic before, but concept wise, only angle of view matters with compensation.
Edit, or few out of 5 axis need this? Fred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.
Distance is needed for 5-axis IBIS, otherwise it will only be 3-axis. (like the Loxia line which does not report distance)
All Voigtlander E-mount lenses report distance and therefore can achieve 5-axis IBIS.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Check the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.
Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.
realVivek wrote:
I think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteWith a Sony, you get 5axis stabilization and a host of other good things. You will have to wait for a long time, at least until the D7 is released. You have asked before whether you get 5-axis stabilization with the Nikon Z cameras and the TechArt adapter. I still am not sure that you get 5-axis stabilization, but I noticed that it does encode distance and that is reported right on the top LCD with the Techart adapter, so I would think that the camera which has the information it needs does implement 5-axis stabilization with Voigtlander E-mount lenses and the Techart adapter, but I am not sure that it does.Does the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.
I don't think we know that. It depends on what the camera think they are seeing with the Techart adapter. Does it think it is seeing an S lens? I don't know how one would know that. What I do know is that the camera is reading distance information and it shows up on the top LCD.
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.
Now that I remember about mentioning of 3 vs 5 in original Z market materials. I am happy with it mostly for stabling EVF either adapting or use native glasses or video, so I didn’t pay attention to this.
For OVF camera like M10p, I never miss IBIS. bjornthun wrote: zhangyue wroteYes, 5 win over 3. Happy?
In this case, With smart adapter, what is the issue? vdo1 wroteShill harder guys.
"When working with adapted lenses, the camera's in-body image stabilization system drops to offering correction in three axes: pitch, yaw and roll."
A dyed in the wool Nikonian should have known.F-mount Nikkors from D-type and forward encode distance, i.e. all VR type F-mount lenses. My guess is that IBIS will work in conjunction with the VR mechanism of VR lenses and offer five axis stabilization with those. The VR mechanism in the lens will handle yaw and pitch in that case.
I expect lens and camera stabilization to work mostly the same way on Nikon, Olympus, Panasonic and Sony.
Edit: the stabilization mechanism in the camera body can do 5-axis stabilization too, but it works less well with telephoto lenses. For telephoto lenses it is best to divide the stabilization job between the IBIS in the camera and the optical stabilizer in the lens. In this case the lens does yaw and pitch and the camera handles (barrel) roll and translation, which is the movement of the camera body and lens horizontally and vertically....Show more →
Notice that the lens comes in E mount and is not for R or Z or S.
zhangyue wrote:
Why anytime we have to deal this with some people with this brand?
realVivek wroteWith a Sony, you get 5axis stabilization and a host of other good things. You will have to wait for a long time, at least until the D7 is released.
zhangyue wroteAt least you can use this one on Nikon with EXIF if you want. I will at least wait for a few more years before Voigtlander confirm no native Nikon Z and Canon R Mount version. There are so many options for me in this region.
realVivek wroteTime to ditch Nikon. I love Nikon too.
zhangyue wroteGreat lens, Zeiss is dead, sorry, I do love Zeiss.
Thanks Fred
How this translate real world shooting compare loxia with V? Fred Miranda wrote: zhangyue wroteFred, I don’t think distance information is needed but only focal length. IBIS Should mainly compensate vibration as angle offset on sensor, which is not directly relate to distance.
For example, for deep DOF image, you would not want camera give priority for certain distance.
I could be wrong given I didn’t research this topic before, but concept wise, only angle of view matters with compensation.
Edit, or few out of 5 axis need this? Fred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Distance is needed for 5-axis IBIS, otherwise it will only be 3-axis. (like the Loxia line which does not report distance)
All Voigtlander E-mount lenses report distance and therefore can achieve 5-axis IBIS.
bjornthun wrote: Steve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteWith a Sony, you get 5axis stabilization and a host of other good things. You will have to wait for a long time, at least until the D7 is released.
zhangyue wroteAt least you can use this one on Nikon with EXIF if you want. I will at least wait for a few more years before Voigtlander confirm no native Nikon Z and Canon R Mount version. There are so many options for me in this region.You have asked before whether you get 5-axis stabilization with the Nikon Z cameras and the TechArt adapter. I still am not sure that you get 5-axis stabilization, but I noticed that it does encode distance and that is reported right on the top LCD with the Techart adapter, so I would think that the camera which has the information it needs does implement 5-axis stabilization with Voigtlander E-mount lenses and the Techart adapter, but I am not sure that it does.Does the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.
You do get much better performance with IBIS on than when it is off, but I don't think that tells us whether it is 5 axis or 3 axis. We know the camera has both the focal length of the lens and the distance information so it has the information it needs for 5 axis IBIS, but does it actually use that information? I don't really know.
Knowing Nikon’s planned obsolescence strategy, I think only S lenses would offer 5.
Steve Spencer wrote: realVivek wroteI think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroteYou have asked before whether you get 5-axis stabilization with the Nikon Z cameras and the TechArt adapter. I still am not sure that you get 5-axis stabilization, but I noticed that it does encode distance and that is reported right on the top LCD with the Techart adapter, so I would think that the camera which has the information it needs does implement 5-axis stabilization with Voigtlander E-mount lenses and the Techart adapter, but I am not sure that it does.Does the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.I don't think we know that. It depends on what the camera think they are seeing with the Techart adapter. Does it think it is seeing an S lens? I don't know how one would know that. What I do know is that the camera is reading distance information and it shows up on the top LCD.
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.Install Exiftool (https://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/)
Go to terminal and enter:
exiftool -focusdistance2
My Mac is doing an annoying security thing where it won't let me install it becomes it is from an unidentified developer. If someone else could check the photo I mentioned that would be great.
I think it is tricky here as with dumb m adapter, there is not even focal length record in EXIF but I am very sure it take input focal length for IBIS given mentioned experiment I did. Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.Install Exiftool (https://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/)
Go to terminal and enter:
exiftool -focusdistance2
Steve Spencer wrote:
My Mac is doing an annoying security thing where it won't let me install it becomes it is from an unidentified developer. If someone else could check the photo I mentioned that would be great.
Knowing Nikon’s planned obsolescence strategy, I think only S lenses would offer 5.
Steve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteI think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteDoes the Techart transfer the focal length to the Z6/Z7 cameras?Yes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.I don't think we know that. It depends on what the camera think they are seeing with the Techart adapter. Does it think it is seeing an S lens? I don't know how one would know that. What I do know is that the camera is reading distance information and it shows up on the top LCD.
Yeah, but that doesn't answer the question of whether the Techart adapter codes the lenses so they are viewed as S lenses. It does transfer the focus distance and I think normally that is only transferred for S lenses. If someone wants to check my image for transfer of the focus distance to the EXIF, then we will know for sure the adapter transfers focus distance. We still won't know if the camera uses it, however. For that we would need to know the code that the adapter is using *and* how the camera is using the code.
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.Install Exiftool (https://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/)
Go to terminal and enter:
exiftool -focusdistance2My Mac is doing an annoying security thing where it won't let me install it becomes it is from an unidentified developer. If someone else could check the photo I mentioned that would be great.
Knowing Nikon’s planned obsolescence strategy, I think only S lenses would offer 5.
Steve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteI think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroteYes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.I don't think we know that. It depends on what the camera think they are seeing with the Techart adapter. Does it think it is seeing an S lens? I don't know how one would know that. What I do know is that the camera is reading distance information and it shows up on the top LCD.Yeah, but that doesn't answer the question of whether the Techart adapter codes the lenses so they are viewed as S lenses. It does transfer the focus distance and I think normally that is only transferred for S lenses. If someone wants to check my image for transfer of the focus distance to the EXIF, then we will know for sure the adapter transfers focus distance. We still won't know if the camera uses it, however. For that we would need to know the code that the adapter is using *and* how the camera is using the code.
Knowing Nikon’s planned obsolescence strategy, I think only S lenses would offer 5.
Steve Spencer wroterealVivek wroteI think only S lenses give 5. Nikon DSLR lenses give only 3 despite the presence of distance encoders (in D and later lenses).
So, at best 3 with CV lenses on Nikon Z.
bjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroteYes and that even always shows up in the EXIF.3-axis requires focal length info and 5-axis requires focal length + distance information, so I guess you get 5-axis IBIS. You could test and compare to what happens if you turn off IBIS. I suppose there is a menu setting for that on Nikon too.I don't think we know that. It depends on what the camera think they are seeing with the Techart adapter. Does it think it is seeing an S lens? I don't know how one would know that. What I do know is that the camera is reading distance information and it shows up on the top LCD.Yeah, but that doesn't answer the question of whether the Techart adapter codes the lenses so they are viewed as S lenses. It does transfer the focus distance and I think normally that is only transferred for S lenses. If someone wants to check my image for transfer of the focus distance to the EXIF, then we will know for sure the adapter transfers focus distance. We still won't know if the camera uses it, however. For that we would need to know the code that the adapter is using *and* how the camera is using the code.
F-mount lenses from the mid 1990’ies and newer communicate distance information, since this is used by the flash system. Nikon implemented this before VR, IBIS and digital.
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteCheck the EXIF for "focus distance 2". If distance is there, it's transmitted by the adapter.Hi Fred,
I can't find that in the EXIF. I typically don't dig into EXIF that deep and don't know how to find it. I also don't have EXIF viewer set up on any of my computers. If someone wants to look at my entry in the alt monthly competition that was shot with the Voigtlander 110 f/2.5 on the Nikon Z7 and it should have the EXIF data intact.Install Exiftool (https://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/)
Go to terminal and enter:
exiftool -focusdistance2
Sorry to ask Fred, but how do you specify the file. I suck at command line processing.