Everything- phenomenal or “golden” copy, they all end up in the BS board.
genji wrote: GMPhotography wroteI was certainly going to sell my Loxia 50 for it but thinking about selling my Leica 75 1.5 VM too. Torn on this one my Loxia 50 is beyond good it's greatEasy choice. I think it’s fair to say that, compared to the Loxia 50, APO-Lanthar 50 will be beyond great, it will be phenomenal. Anyone care to bet against the likelihood that Guy’s Loxia 50 is destined for an appearance on the Buy & Sell board?
realVivek wrote:
Just make it 28/2 APO and 90/2 APO.
philip_pj wroteOne reason to value small APO lenses in the modern era is greater attention to tolerance control and QA at the factory. These high end lenses demand more of the manufacturing process. Leica's Herr Karbe indicated the same thing about their APO-Summicron-M 50mm f2.
'Manufacturing error affects the performance and it is difficult to actually make it, so there is a need for (stronger) performance even at the factory.' - Mr Shimada
If the Nokton 75/1.5 (ranked a 'top seller' at B&H at present, lol) is not to be revised for Sony, a similar sized 75-85-90mm f2 APO would suit a lot of manual focus users - taking APO to portrait focal length lenses at a fair price. A 35mm of similar quality would please, even if it reaches say, 500-600g.
Those two and the 50 on the A7R IV is my dream walkaround kit.
A little hard to judge until more people get the lens in hand. But if you don't need the macro, and you don't mind splitting the difference between 40 and 65, it's not the craziest thing someone has ever done.
tsdevine wrote:
A little hard to judge until more people get the lens in hand. But if you don't need the macro, and you don't mind splitting the difference between 40 and 65, it's not the craziest thing someone has ever done.
-Tim
I don't do a ton of macro, just backyard stuff and it's mostly the same every year
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Camera quest pulled the Pre-order 100 deposit. So it appears they have all the first batch accounted for. Glad I bought in when I did
I'm tempted to replace my 65mm F2 with this lens when it comes out. I expect them to be very similar when it comes to rendering and probably sharpness as well. It will probably come down to small size vs close focus ability (and focal length).
Just preordered mine. I really wonder if I’ll prefer it over the 40 1.2, but figure I’ll give it a try anyway. As far as other manual focus lenses, I also have the CV110, which is pretty incredible.
sandycrane wrote: johnahill wroteThinking of consolidating my 40 and 65 into this one lens.
Am I crazy to give up the 65?I'm thinking you'd be crazy to give up the 40. I really like the 40's colors and contrast, in addition to f1.2 and very respectable sharpness.
I don't often shoot wide open (ok we ALL shoot wide open when we get a new 1.2 lens, but I mostly do cityscapes and less of the street type shooting and rarely shoot at 1.2 unless its playing with minimum dof)
The 65 is clearly an amazing lens and I’ve been tempted, but for me 65 has always been an odd focal length so I never bought one. Now, I hope my patience has been rewarded.
With regard to this over the 40/1.2 it's a personal thing.
I've had the 40 since last September, I've shot 2196 images with it and there are more images that I like stopped down past f4 than there are wider than f2.0.
Maybe I just don't 'see' shots at 1.2, or juist got bored of shooting with no DOF, but I have only 2 worthwhile shots at 1.2