stanparker wrote:
Looks good to me, but consider the source: I've never done MW so only know what I like.
Thank you.
---------------------------------------------
Camperjim wrote:
If you are concerned about the foreground being too saturated or too bright, does it matter? There is rarely anything at all realistic about MW images so you need not worry about that issue. This has a lot of pop to it. Isn't that the point?
Lol...I say the same things to people sometimes. I did lower the saturation slider on the foreground about 15 points and reduced exposure by 1/3rd stop. Thanks for the feedback.
---------------------------------------------
twoflower wrote:
Thats a wonderful MW image, RYAN. The lighting on the foreground is nice and subtle, and I especially love how you've rendered the color temperature rather realistically instead of rendering the milky way completely bluish.
Just one suggestion, you might want to reduce the tonality [contrast and sharpness both] in the milky way part.
Interesting...like an "Orton" effect on the MW portion?
---------------------------------------------
JR Photo wrote:
Well I like it. But does it fit your vision? You say that you have played around with and are still on the fence.
J. R.
I ask a question and this guy responds with a question...lol...I like it. Simple and thought provoking. Is it what I envisioned in creating, yes, but I did let the Instagram saturation game influence me a bit too hard, so I toned it down.
---------------------------------------------
Mark Metternich wrote:
I'm only looking at the current version and it looks great! Congratulations!
I like that the Milkyway is not hyped to absurdity, which seems so common on IG these days. I like that you are taking advantage of what the camera can "see" (capture) but not pushing it into the stratosphere and showing restraint in the development and vision of the image. I like that balance.
Thanks for your feedback Mark. I did reduce the exposure by 1/3rd of a stop and the saturation about 15 points. I'm a big fan of nightscape exposure realism with darks and shadows, and glad I'm not the only one.