fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20184k or 2k monitor?

  
 
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.3 #14k or 2k monitor?
IzelPhotograph wrote:
Looks a fantastic monitor but at 149ppi I'm not sure I'd want to rely on it for checking off image sharpness. Is there some features I'm missing? That's well over the 100ppi optimum for checking sharpness for print jobs and agency work. A lot of the marketing seems to concentrate on" footage with a, " At a dense 149 ppi, it’s suited for not only video editing but also photo retouching and printing."

It would be interesting to do a side by side test with an image you'd bin because it didn't meet required standards on a 27" 2k monitor (or
...Show more →

Hard to imagine that the most prestigious company for media monitors created a flagship with a less than ideal specs.

My guess is that if first-tier pros all over the world use this thing it's probably OK for most here.

You can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.

Nov 25, 2018 at 12:45 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #24k or 2k monitor?
GMPhotography wrote:
This looks to be it. If I was going to do this than this would beat my NEC 27 wide Gamut. Have to sell mine though

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1083238-REG/eizo_ev3237fx_bk_led_backlit_ips.html


I have the 27" 2K version of that monitor and it is fantastic. I am not sure for photos I see any reason to go to 4K, but if I did I would get this monitor. Yes, if you go to 4K going up to 32" makes sense though. The flagship Eizo monitors are fantastic and very high priced. The major benefit of them, however, is that they self calibrate which is great if you use them enough to justify the expense. This more basic version is still fantastic (maybe 95% of the high priced one in quality) and if you know how to calibrate and do it often enough (I calibrate about once a month) then will get you wonderful performance at a much reduced price.
Nov 25, 2018 at 12:51 PM
tb_a
Offline
Details
p.3 #34k or 2k monitor?
You can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.

That's exactly what I'm doing on my EV3237 if pixel peeping is required. ;-)

Nov 25, 2018 at 01:00 PM
IzelPhotograph
Offline
Details
p.3 #44k or 2k monitor?
DaveFP wrote:
IzelPhotograph wroteLooks a fantastic monitor but at 149ppi I'm not sure I'd want to rely on it for checking off image sharpness. Is there some features I'm missing? That's well over the 100ppi optimum for checking sharpness for print jobs and agency work. A lot of the marketing seems to concentrate on" footage with a, " At a dense 149 ppi, it’s suited for not only video editing but also photo retouching and printing."

It would be interesting to do a side by side test with an image you'd bin because it didn't meet required standards on a 27" 2k monitor (or other100ppi ish monitor) and this new high density screen. If it makes the reject look ok then it would be a non starter.

To be honest, I would be more likely to upgrade my 27 Cintiq to the new 32 4k Pro one and then I'd have a good 2k monitor for proofing and a high pixel density 4k monitor for viewing footage and drawing with. I could get the Cintiq and save a £1k
Hard to imagine that the most prestigious company for media monitors created a flagship with a less than ideal specs.

My guess is that if first-tier pros all over the world use this thing it's probably OK for most here.

You can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.



You could be right but from previous experience, bumping to 200% doesn't help / make it look right either. Try that with Retina screens I have and it looks nothing like the output at 100% on a 2k screen. I just had a feeling this was a monitor they'd push towards video and motion graphics users who also do stills work. For footage the specs of that monitor are incredible. 3d Lut's, HDR gamma, True Black, Broadcast and Cine presets as well as luminance warnings are very much geared towards the motion side of things.

There could also be some features that make it easy to QC stills but I haven't seen them mentioned. As I said, it would be interesting to do the side by side test to see how it compares to a tried and tested 2k monitor for stills. Fingers have been burned once before so it would come down to, "Seeing is believing"

Edit.... just looked on their site and they do have the CG279X, 27 @109ppi. Now that is the one I'd go for All the benefits of the above but 109ppi. Save a wad of cash as well!

tb_a wrote:
Earlier quoteYou can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.
That's exactly what I'm doing on my EV3237 if pixel peeping is required. ;-)


Haha....Unfortunately, viewing at 100% is a necessary evil when it comes to work
Nov 25, 2018 at 01:00 PM
tb_a
Offline
Details
p.3 #54k or 2k monitor?
IzelPhotograph wrote:
DaveFP wrote
IzelPhotograph wroteLooks a fantastic monitor but at 149ppi I'm not sure I'd want to rely on it for checking off image sharpness. Is there some features I'm missing? That's well over the 100ppi optimum for checking sharpness for print jobs and agency work. A lot of the marketing seems to concentrate on" footage with a, " At a dense 149 ppi, it’s suited for not only video editing but also photo retouching and printing."

It would be interesting to do a side by side test with an image you'd bin because it didn't meet required standards on a 27" 2k monitor (or other100ppi ish monitor) and this new high density screen. If it makes the reject look ok then it would be a non starter.

To be honest, I would be more likely to upgrade my 27 Cintiq to the new 32 4k Pro one and then I'd have a good 2k monitor for proofing and a high pixel density 4k monitor for viewing footage and drawing with. I could get the Cintiq and save a £1k
Hard to imagine that the most prestigious company for media monitors created a flagship with a less than ideal specs.

My guess is that if first-tier pros all over the world use this thing it's probably OK for most here.

You can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.
You could be right but from previous experience, bumping to 200% doesn't help / make it look right either. Try that with Retina screens I have and it looks nothing like the output at 100% on a 2k screen. I just had a feeling this was a monitor they'd push towards video and motion graphics users who also do stills work. For footage the specs of that monitor are incredible. 3d Lut's, HDR gamma, True Black, Broadcast and Cine presets as well as luminance warnings are very much geared towards the motion side of things.

There could also be some features
...Show more →
tb_a wrote
Earlier quoteYou can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.
That's exactly what I'm doing on my EV3237 if pixel peeping is required. ;-)


Well, I'm talking about "pixel peeping" for e.g. ultimate lens comparison and not about normal viewing or editing work. Then the 100% view works perfectly well on this 32" 4K monitor. Due to the high resolution you can look from much closer distances to the screen if you want to view the details. That's not really recommendable with a 2K screen.

Nov 25, 2018 at 04:14 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.3 #64k or 2k monitor?
tb_a wrote:
IzelPhotograph wrote
DaveFP wrote
IzelPhotograph wroteLooks a fantastic monitor but at 149ppi I'm not sure I'd want to rely on it for checking off image sharpness. Is there some features I'm missing? That's well over the 100ppi optimum for checking sharpness for print jobs and agency work. A lot of the marketing seems to concentrate on" footage with a, " At a dense 149 ppi, it’s suited for not only video editing but also photo retouching and printing."

It would be interesting to do a side by side test with an image you'd bin because it didn't meet required standards on a 27" 2k monitor (or other100ppi ish monitor) and this new high density screen. If it makes the reject look ok then it would be a non starter.

To be honest, I would be more likely to upgrade my 27 Cintiq to the new 32 4k Pro one and then I'd have a good 2k monitor for proofing and a high pixel density 4k monitor for viewing footage and drawing with. I could get the Cintiq and save a £1k
Hard to imagine that the most prestigious company for media monitors created a flagship with a less than ideal specs.

My guess is that if first-tier pros all over the world use this thing it's probably OK for most here.

You can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.
You could be right but from previous experience, bumping to 200% doesn't help / make it look right either. Try that with Retina screens I have and it looks nothing like the output at 100% on a 2k screen. I just had a feeling this was a monitor they'd push towards video and motion graphics users who also do stills work. For footage the specs of that monitor are incredible. 3d Lut's, HDR gamma, True Black, Broadcast and Cine presets as well as luminance warnings are very much geared towards the motion side of things.

There could also be some features that make it easy to QC stills but I haven't seen them mentioned. As I said, it would be interesting to do the side by side test to see how it compares to a tried and tested 2k monitor for stills. Fingers have been burned once before so it would come down to, "Seeing is believing"

Edit.... just looked on their site and they do have the CG279X, 27 @109ppi. Now that is the one I'd go for All the benefits of the above but 109ppi. Save a wad of cash as well!

tb_a wrote
Earlier quoteYou can always bump it to 200% for more separated pixels if that's a concern.
That's exactly what I'm doing on my EV3237 if pixel peeping is required. ;-)
Haha....Unfortunately, viewing at 100% is a necessary evil when it comes to work
Well, I'm talking about "pixel peeping" for e.g. ultimate lens comparison and not about normal viewing or editing work. Then the 100% view works perfectly well on this 32" 4K monitor. Due to the high resolution you can look from much closer distances to the screen if you want to view the details. That's not really recommendable with a 2K screen.



I also like to set close when editing and yes; 4K really allows you to do that.

Nov 25, 2018 at 06:17 PM
jchapell
Offline
Details
p.3 #74k or 2k monitor?
I know it's been a few days, but how does the (now discontinued) Apple thunderbolt display compare in the 27" range discussed here? The used options in my local craigslist are $300-400, and it's 2k (truly 2560 QHD)...but it's also a few years old.
Dec 04, 2018 at 04:04 PM
thrice
Offline
Details
p.3 #84k or 2k monitor?
Apple displays are difficult to calibrate (on Mac OS) and this is more important than a slightly bigger gamut!

I have an Acer PE320QK and I couldn't be happier. Came from a Dell U2711 which technically had a bigger colour gamut but both are 100% AdobeRGB.
Dec 04, 2018 at 06:13 PM
sesser
Offline
Details
p.3 #94k or 2k monitor?
jchapell wrote:
I know it's been a few days, but how does the (now discontinued) Apple thunderbolt display compare in the 27" range discussed here? The used options in my local craigslist are $300-400, and it's 2k (truly 2560 QHD)...but it's also a few years old.


I have one still. I was using it for hobby level photo work and was pleased with it. As you start to dig deeper into professional options and the feature they support vs what Apple's offers, it becomes clear that if color accuracy is important, your money would be better spent on a calibrated IPS. Don't get me wrong, they beautiful to look at and integrate well if you have a pre-Thunderbolt 3 Macbook, but it needs to calibrated for color accuracy and even then doesn't seem to cover wide-gamuts like some other options in a similar price range.

Some links...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Thunderbolt_Display#Technical_specifications
Check the coverage of AdobeRGB... only ~76% and the uncalibrated delta E
https://www.anandtech.com/show/4832/the-apple-thunderbolt-display-review/5

I'm actually in the market to replace it so I've been reading up. Figured it would be the perfect time to upgrade to a 4k monitor, but after further consideration (and not wanting to shell out a grand), I might just get another 27" 2K that supports a wider gamut (and is newer tech)... like the BenQ SW2700PT.
Jan 30, 2019 at 04:47 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #104k or 2k monitor?
I absolutely love my 27 inch 4K dell ultrasharp. The one downside is 24 megapixel files will no longer satiate your need for pixel peeping!
Jan 30, 2019 at 05:10 PM
Chainring
Offline
Details
p.3 #114k or 2k monitor?
-rce- wrote:
I finally wound up with a Dell UP2516D and like it a lot.

They claim:
"
- Wide color coverage offers 100 percent Adobe RGB and 100 percent sRGB as well as two new color spaces
- Amazing clarity with QHD resolution 2560 x 1440p for exceptional viewing on an expansive 25 inch screen with in plane switching
"

I ran a Spyder Pro over it and the difference in profiles is just about non-existent. (to my eyes anyway)

I have the same monitor for photo editing. It's fantastic.

For casual viewing and general usage, I have a Dell U2718Q (27" 4K), and a Dell U2518D (25" 2560x1440). Love the combo of those.

Jan 30, 2019 at 05:49 PM
akashyap
Offline
Details
p.3 #124k or 2k monitor?
RoamingScott wrote:
I absolutely love my 27 inch 4K dell ultrasharp. The one downside is 24 megapixel files will no longer satiate your need for pixel peeping!


Looks like you need to get an R camera!

How do you like 27 in terms of size? I have a vertical 1080 24 inch and a horizontal 1440p 25 inch going on right now, and I am thinking about a bigger size and more resolution for my main monitor (then I can move the 1440p as my vertical monitor).

It is either the 27 or the 32 inch 4K panels by Dell.
Jan 30, 2019 at 06:39 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #134k or 2k monitor?
I have an A7R3 so I’m covered!

I have no desire to go larger than 27, I find it completely adequate for all uses with 4K. I use 1080p 24” at work and they seem so antiquated now, lol.

akashyap wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI absolutely love my 27 inch 4K dell ultrasharp. The one downside is 24 megapixel files will no longer satiate your need for pixel peeping!
Looks like you need to get an R camera!

How do you like 27 in terms of size? I have a vertical 1080 24 inch and a horizontal 1440p 25 inch going on right now, and I am thinking about a bigger size and more resolution for my main monitor (then I can move the 1440p as my vertical monitor).

It is either the 27 or the 32 inch 4K panels by Dell.

Jan 30, 2019 at 07:28 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #144k or 2k monitor?
I have an A7R3 so I’m covered!

I have no desire to go larger than 27, I find it completely adequate for all uses with 4K. I use 1080p 24” at work and they seem so antiquated now, lol.

akashyap wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI absolutely love my 27 inch 4K dell ultrasharp. The one downside is 24 megapixel files will no longer satiate your need for pixel peeping!
Looks like you need to get an R camera!

How do you like 27 in terms of size? I have a vertical 1080 24 inch and a horizontal 1440p 25 inch going on right now, and I am thinking about a bigger size and more resolution for my main monitor (then I can move the 1440p as my vertical monitor).

It is either the 27 or the 32 inch 4K panels by Dell.

Jan 30, 2019 at 07:28 PM
nampramos
Offline
Details
p.3 #154k or 2k monitor?
You probably already have more replies than you actually need.

If you never spent some decent time in front of a 4K monitor (don’t mean looking at a movie or a slideshow of photos), then I recommend you do.

It’s a massive difference the user experience from even a 2K screen. Everything will look A LOT smaller, even if you’re using a 32” screen like I am.

I got a great deal on a lightly used Samsung that does 99% AdobeRGB, mate screen, self calibration on every startup and all you’d expect from a professional grade monitor. Before I also had a great Dell, 27” 2K. I must say I questioned my decision for a while.

Even just the size difference from 27” to 32” is quite considerable. Then the resolution difference is even bigger. I wouldn’t be surprised if many here and in other forums are using scaled resolutions, maybe even without knowing.

At native 4K, things get really small. Not only that, you’ll easily have 3 browser windows open side by side. This means the right 1/3 and left 1/3 of the screen when browsing are normally not used, unless you want to me moving right and left on your desk all the time.

When editing on LR you’ll be presented with a beautiful big image on the center of your monitor when on the Develop module but all your controls on the right and left will be very small and you might see yourself sometimes moving your head to one or the other side to see what control you’re actually changing.

It’s a lot better now in terms of experience, after almost a month, but everything is still as small as it was in the beginning, my eyes/brain just got a bit more used to it now but if I was to start again, I’d probably do 27” and 2K or 32” 5K and scale it 2x (retina).

Either way, look at your local used market. I bought mine for under half the price and it’s a fantastic professional monitor.
Jan 31, 2019 at 01:36 AM
kosmiq
Offline
Details
p.3 #164k or 2k monitor?
I recently made the jump from a 27" 4k 100% sRGB (benq bl2711u) to 32" 4k >99% aRGB monitor (Thinkvision u32-p10).

And I really like the extra space. I do not think anything gets too small. Sure controls are smaller but I get more image so to speak. I am of course running it on native resolution, so no scaling on my Mac. On my PC I do use 125% scaling since Windows 10 gets smaller than MacOS. I do my photo edits on the Mac though.

Running unscaled 4k on the 27" was a no go though. On that one I actually ran it scaled as a 5k monitor to get 2560x1440 screen estate. I always thought that 1080p (4k default scale on 27" to a mac gives the same screen estate as a 1080p monitor since that will give exactly 4 pixels per rendered point) was too "zoomed in" on a 27" monitor, guess that's why most non-4k 27" are 2560x1440.

One of the major benefits with the 32" is that I can easier work with two images side by side and compare them without as much zooming around.

The thinkvision is probably an underdog, but good factory calibration, built in USB switch (using it for two computers), thunderbolt 3 built in (only 60w charging though so still using my TB3 dock but via thunderbolt to the screen).

The feature I like the most though is that I can, via the screen menu, easily switch between aRGB, sRGB, DCI-P3 and a few other color spaces. Works great!

As for the jump itself from 27" to 32" I'd really recommend it. Running unscaled 4k really gave me something. A lot of screenspace. But boy is it massive on the desk. I could never go back though.

A sidenote for anyone running MacOS on a 4k monitor with scaled resolution: media (images and video) in most editing apps (adobe suite, capture one) and apples own viewing apps are actually unscaled. The GUI of photoshop will be scaled but the image itself is displayed via unscaled pixels. Not sure how Windows works in this regard.

@nampramos@ regarding 5k scaled @2x I'd actually recommend a 27" for that. That way you'll get a 2560x1440 rendered screen estate, just like a regular 27", but at retina resolution. But like I said above, if you got a mac, media that you edit will be displayed un-scaled. That way you can actually work with a 4k video unscaled (aka in its full glory) on a 5k monitor scaled to retina, and still have all GUI. If you place everything correctly of course.

Running 2560x1440 on a 32" would probably feel like 1080p on 27": wrong and to "zoomed in".
Jan 31, 2019 at 11:13 AM
milkod2001
Offline
Details
p.3 #174k or 2k monitor?
I found 2018 model of Eizo which is under 2grand. Could be the best option with pro specs at reasonable price.

https://www.amazon.com/FlexScan-ev3285-31-5-Type-Supported-Monitor-DisplayPort/dp/B07D58QQ9N

However if you only add few $100s extra you can get yourself 5k iMac, gorgeous screen with PC inside, more than capable to process images (C1, Photoshop etc).

If someone already owns very capable Windows workstation then external monitor is the only way to go but if starting from scratch 5k iMac is the best value IMO.
Jan 31, 2019 at 02:52 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #184k or 2k monitor?
milkod2001 wrote:
5k iMac is the best value IMO.


To not get too far into the weeds, I humbly disagree and assert you can build a much more powerful W10 machine with similar display for around the same cost.

(I bought an iMac, found myself disgusted at its paltry performance, then built a PC/4K monitor for much less money)
Jan 31, 2019 at 03:07 PM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.3 #194k or 2k monitor?
RoamingScott wrote:
milkod2001 wrote5k iMac is the best value IMO.
To not get too far into the weeds, I humbly disagree and assert you can build a much more powerful W10 machine with similar display for around the same cost.

(I bought an iMac, found myself disgusted at its paltry performance, then built a PC/4K monitor for much less money)


Walking closer to the weeds...

Strongly agree - Apple is not comparable, not even close in value to a home built Windows 10 solution.

Edited on Jan 31, 2019 at 03:23 PM · View previous versions
Jan 31, 2019 at 03:22 PM
milkod2001
Offline
Details
p.3 #204k or 2k monitor?
RoamingScott wrote:
milkod2001 wrote5k iMac is the best value IMO.
To not get too far into the weeds, I humbly disagree and assert you can build a much more powerful W10 machine with similar display for around the same cost.

(I bought an iMac, found myself disgusted at its paltry performance, then built a PC/4K monitor for much less money)


No so sure about that. But whatever makes you happy. 5k Windows monitor: $1200-1500. If you build Windows PC with similar specs as per iMac you will need another $1000. Add cost of Windows 10 into that and you end up paying pretty much the same money. But if you intend to build workstation beast with much bigger budget in mind 4000-5000+ then yeah can't go wrong with that.
Jan 31, 2019 at 03:23 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell