fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!

  
 
pleaseshoot
Offline
Details
p.21 #1Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
ugdog wrote:
It's currently $2739 at stores in Canada


Yup, ordered mine on Sunday while it was still on sale. Sony Canada and US aren't always parallel in terms of promotion dates. My guess is the price will go back up on B&H / Adorama soon.
Apr 17, 2018 at 10:08 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #2Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Luvwine wrote:
Still at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.


I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
Apr 17, 2018 at 10:14 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.21 #3Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Fred Miranda wrote:
Luvwine wroteStill at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.
I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.


I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty well centered I think--I remember showing you the crops--but may well not be as good as the very best copies out there (I have no way of comparing as I have only owned one copy of the lens). I do like the 100-300 as it has great high contrast rendering for landscapes, is very sharp for a zoom, and is compact and light weight. It is just rare to find a zoom that is truly the equal of really good primes.
Apr 17, 2018 at 10:48 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #4Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wroteStill at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.
I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty
...Show more →

That's very interesting. I've compared the Zeiss 100-300 vs Leica 135/3.4 @135mm and the zoom did noticeably better everywhere, especially the mid-zone. Corners were very similar. It also did better than the Contax 100/3.5 (mid-zone again). The Contax zoom does show some lateral CA, which is more noticeable after 200mm.
I sold a very good copy of this lens and regret it. The 100-400GM fills the void but it does not render similar micro-contrast or colors.

Does your copy shows balsam separation? It's usually noticeable towards the corners. I tried 3 mint copies recently and unfortunately they all had it.
Apr 17, 2018 at 10:54 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.21 #5Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Fred Miranda wrote:
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wroteStill at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.
I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty well centered I think--I remember showing you the crops--but may well not be as good as the very best copies out there (I have no way of comparing as I have only owned one copy of the lens). I do like the 100-300 as it has great high contrast rendering for landscapes, is very sharp for a zoom, and is compact and light weight. It is just rare to find a zoom that is truly the equal of really good primes.
That's very interesting. I've compared the Zeiss 100-300 vs Leica 135/3.4 @135mm and the zoom did noticeably better everywhere, especially the mid-zone. Corners were very similar. It also did better than the Contax 100/3.5 (mid-zone again). The Contax zoom does show some lateral CA, which is more noticeable after 200mm.
I sold a very good copy of this lens and regret it. The 100-400GM fills the void but it does not render similar micro-contrast or colors.

Does your copy shows balsam separation? It's usually noticeable towards the corners. I tried 3 mint copies recently and unfortunately they all had it.


I am not sure I know what to look for to diagnose balsam separation. Here are the crops I showed you when I bought the lens testing corner uniformity at different focal lengths and with different focus points (center focus, left edge or corner focus). Here are the crops. How does this copy look to you?

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/100-300_centering_test&page=all

Also, here are the crops where I informally tested against different focal lengths at infinity--two different scenes. The labels should be self explanatory.

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/zeiss_100-300_tests&page=all
Apr 17, 2018 at 11:20 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #6Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wroteStill at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.
I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty well centered I think--I remember showing you the crops--but may well not be as good as the very best copies out there (I have no way of comparing as I have only owned one copy of the lens). I do like the 100-300 as it has great high contrast rendering for landscapes, is very sharp for a zoom, and is compact and light weight. It is just rare to find a zoom that is truly the equal of really good primes.
That's very interesting. I've compared the Zeiss 100-300 vs Leica 135/3.4 @135mm and the zoom did noticeably better everywhere, especially the mid-zone. Corners were very similar. It also did better than the Contax 100/3.5 (mid-zone again). The Contax zoom does show some lateral CA, which is more noticeable after 200mm.
I sold a very good copy of this lens and regret it. The 100-400GM fills the void but it does not render similar micro-contrast or colors.

Does your copy shows balsam separation? It's usually noticeable towards the corners. I tried 3 mint copies recently and unfortunately they all had it.
I am not sure I know what to look for to diagnose balsam separation. Here are the crops I showed you when I bought the lens testing corner uniformity at different focal lengths and with different focus points (center focus, left edge or corner focus). Here are the crops. How does this copy look to you?

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/100-300_centering_test&page=all

Also, here are the crops where I informally tested against different focal lengths at infinity--two different scenes. The labels should be self explanatory.

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/zeiss_100-300_tests&page=all


At 100mm the upper right + upper left look softer than the other areas. Meaning that at 100mm, the top area of the frame is softer than the bottom.

At 135mm, the Upper left (especially) + Lower left (so entire left side) is slightly softer than the right side.

Same for 200mm but to a lesser degree. At 200mm+, CA is more evident.

At 300, the left side is softer than the right size (more than at 135mm)

When you showed me this, I thought it was not a big issue since this is a telephoto zoom lens and centering seemed average. My copy was better centered with no tilt up until 250mm though. Only at 300mm, it was very slightly tilted.

If you look at the rear element against the light, see if there is any evidence of balsam separation. It looks almost like haze around an area of the element but it's not very noticeable unless you look closely.
Apr 17, 2018 at 11:36 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.21 #7Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Fred Miranda wrote:
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wroteStill at 1499 on Amazon as well. B&H notes a $500 savings off regular price of $1999. Hard to know what the deal is. I got mine in yesterday but too much going on to even mount it on my camera yet. Will certainly be doing some testing before long. Am supposed to be working on a review of the 100 STF and suspect at least the Batis 135 and Zeiss 100-300 will get compared to it.
I expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty well centered I think--I remember showing you the crops--but may well not be as good as the very best copies out there (I have no way of comparing as I have only owned one copy of the lens). I do like the 100-300 as it has great high contrast rendering for landscapes, is very sharp for a zoom, and is compact and light weight. It is just rare to find a zoom that is truly the equal of really good primes.
That's very interesting. I've compared the Zeiss 100-300 vs Leica 135/3.4 @135mm and the zoom did noticeably better everywhere, especially the mid-zone. Corners were very similar. It also did better than the Contax 100/3.5 (mid-zone again). The Contax zoom does show some lateral CA, which is more noticeable after 200mm.
I sold a very good copy of this lens and regret it. The 100-400GM fills the void but it does not render similar micro-contrast or colors.

Does your copy shows balsam separation? It's usually noticeable towards the corners. I tried 3 mint copies recently and unfortunately they all had it.
I am not sure I know what to look for to diagnose balsam separation. Here are the crops I showed you when I bought the lens testing corner uniformity at different focal lengths and with different focus points (center focus, left edge or corner focus). Here are the crops. How does this copy look to you?

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/100-300_centering_test&page=all

Also, here are the crops where I informally tested against different focal lengths at infinity--two different scenes. The labels should be self explanatory.

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/zeiss_100-300_tests&page=all
At 100mm the upper right + upper left look softer than the other areas. Meaning that at 100mm, the top area of the frame is softer than the bottom.

At 135mm, the Upper left (especially) + Lower left (so entire left side) is slightly softer than the right side.

Same for 200mm but to a lesser degree. At 200mm+, CA is more evident.

At 300, the left side is softer than the right size (more than at 135mm)

When you showed me this, I thought it was not a big issue since this is a telephoto zoom lens and centering seemed average. My
...Show more →

Yes, I am not surprised that your copy was better. I just looked online at images of balsam separation online and I don't think my copy is affected by this--certainly I have not seen any lines towards the edge of elements. I also don't recall haziness, but I will look again to be sure. I had considered buying more copies of the 100-300 to try to get a better one, but I also don't feel like entering the lens lottery to find most copies having balsam separation. I have found the images produced to be really very fine. The crops of course are wide open to reveal inequalities so stopping down also helps a good bit.

Edited on Apr 17, 2018 at 12:18 PM · View previous versions
Apr 17, 2018 at 11:46 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #8Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Luvwine wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Luvwine wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI expect the VS 100-300 will compare well at 135mm, since it is its optimum FL.
I am interested to test again. When I did some initial comparisons when I first got my 100-300, I found the 100-300 not to be the equal of primes that I tested against--at least away from the central region. On center, it is sharp as anything, but in the corners it compares less well and also has more CA--especially at longer focal lengths. I found the STF 100 and even Leica 135/3.4 apo to be better tho by smaller margins than at longer focal lengths. I will do some careful testing and see how it does. My 100-300 is pretty well centered I think--I remember showing you the crops--but may well not be as good as the very best copies out there (I have no way of comparing as I have only owned one copy of the lens). I do like the 100-300 as it has great high contrast rendering for landscapes, is very sharp for a zoom, and is compact and light weight. It is just rare to find a zoom that is truly the equal of really good primes.
That's very interesting. I've compared the Zeiss 100-300 vs Leica 135/3.4 @135mm and the zoom did noticeably better everywhere, especially the mid-zone. Corners were very similar. It also did better than the Contax 100/3.5 (mid-zone again). The Contax zoom does show some lateral CA, which is more noticeable after 200mm.
I sold a very good copy of this lens and regret it. The 100-400GM fills the void but it does not render similar micro-contrast or colors.

Does your copy shows balsam separation? It's usually noticeable towards the corners. I tried 3 mint copies recently and unfortunately they all had it.
I am not sure I know what to look for to diagnose balsam separation. Here are the crops I showed you when I bought the lens testing corner uniformity at different focal lengths and with different focus points (center focus, left edge or corner focus). Here are the crops. How does this copy look to you?

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/100-300_centering_test&page=all

Also, here are the crops where I informally tested against different focal lengths at infinity--two different scenes. The labels should be self explanatory.

http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/zeiss_100-300_tests&page=all
At 100mm the upper right + upper left look softer than the other areas. Meaning that at 100mm, the top area of the frame is softer than the bottom.

At 135mm, the Upper left (especially) + Lower left (so entire left side) is slightly softer than the right side.

Same for 200mm but to a lesser degree. At 200mm+, CA is more evident.

At 300, the left side is softer than the right size (more than at 135mm)

When you showed me this, I thought it was not a big issue since this is a telephoto zoom lens and centering seemed average. My copy was better centered with no tilt up until 250mm. Only at 300mm, it was very slightly tilted.
Yes, I am not surprised that your copy was better. I just looked online at images of balsam separation online and I don't think my copy is affected by this--certainly I have not seen any lines towards the edge of elements. I also don't recall haziness, but I will look again to be sure. I had considered buying more copies of the 100-300 to try to get a better one, but I also don't feel like entering the lens lottery to find most copies having balsam separation. I have found the images produced to be really very fine.


Recently bought 2 copies from Japan where the Ads mentioned "no balsam separation" and one from the US. They all had balsam separation and were mint copies. None was as well centered as my original copy.

So, I agree, it's not easy to find a good copy and there is no guarantee that this issue won't happen with a good copy eventually. Too bad, this was an amazing zoom. Hopefully, Zeiss will port it to the E-mount....dreaming.
Apr 17, 2018 at 11:53 AM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.21 #9Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Fred Miranda wrote:
Zelaya wroteIt looks like Adorama and BH still have sale price. Getting my 135mm batis today. Can't wait to try it and compare with my Batis 85mm.
Could this be the new permanent price for this lens?


Quick perusal suggests all the "Wedding Weeks" promotions are still holding...

I'm still guessing that after the sale, this lens (as opposed to the others on sale) will settle in somewhere between the old price and the sale price. This sale is (conveniently) a sly way to distract a straight drop in price.

Apr 17, 2018 at 03:24 PM
seanoc
Offline
Details
p.21 #10Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
I just recieved a 135 Batis yesterday. Here is one of my first shots with it. I know it's a cat but he's a good model.





Buddy the Cat

Apr 19, 2018 at 09:00 AM
Neurad1
Offline
Details
p.21 #11Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Is $1200 a good price for this lens now or do you think the price will come down further? I am thinking of pulling the trigger....
Apr 19, 2018 at 09:15 AM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.21 #12Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Pull! If you need it....

Neurad1 wrote:
Is $1200 a good price for this lens now or do you think the price will come down further? I am thinking of pulling the trigger....

Apr 19, 2018 at 09:18 AM
Neurad1
Offline
Details
p.21 #13Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Exactly. That is the question. I previously had an order accepted through Greentoe for $1200. Subsequently got an "out of stock/backordered " email from the accepting vendor, which I found VERY ANNOYING. Cancelled the order because I am impulsive and was a little PO'd.

I saw today that this same vendor lists the lens as in stock on their web page. I then chatted with an agent who apologized but informed me that in fact the lens was NOT in stock. It is a "web problem" he commented. I think this particular vendor has a habit of listing things as "order to ship today" that often are not in fact in stock. It is not at all Adorable, if you catch my drift-orama.
Apr 19, 2018 at 09:24 AM
Zelaya
Offline
Details
p.21 #14Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
seanoc wrote:
I just recieved a 135 Batis yesterday. Here is one of my first shots with it. I know it's a cat but he's a good model.


Great caption. Hopefully, if the weather permits, I'll try mine this weekend. Thank you for sharing!
Apr 19, 2018 at 09:30 AM
Zelaya
Offline
Details
p.21 #15Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Neurad1 wrote:
Exactly. That is the question. I previously had an order accepted through Greentoe for $1200. Subsequently got an "out of stock/backordered " email from the accepting vendor, which I found VERY ANNOYING. Cancelled the order because I am impulsive and was a little PO'd.

I saw today that this same vendor lists the lens as in stock on their web page. I then chatted with an agent who apologized but informed me that in fact the lens was NOT in stock. It is a "web problem" he commented. I think this particular vendor has a habit of listing things as
...Show more →

Impulse or not, it's a great lens at a great price. Several months ago not in a million years I would pay 2k for it. Have you try calling Greentoe back and see if they would honor your prior offer. Their customer service is top notch and the response right away. Good luck

Apr 19, 2018 at 09:33 AM
Neurad1
Offline
Details
p.21 #16Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
I'd pursue it if it was truly in stock and available to ship today from the vendor. But I don't want another order accepted only to be informed that the item is backordered.
Apr 19, 2018 at 09:37 AM
Zelaya
Offline
Details
p.21 #17Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
Neurad1 wrote:
I'd pursue it if it was truly in stock and available to ship today from the vendor. But I don't want another order accepted only to be informed that the item is backordered.


I purchased two Batis lenses in the same month with Greentoe and same vendor and I had zero issues. They usually after you accept the offer your credit charge gets hit 24 hrs later. Don't knock it until you try it.

Apr 19, 2018 at 09:42 AM
Neurad1
Offline
Details
p.21 #18Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
I'm knocking it because I did try it. Did you read my post? I offered $1200 USD for the Batis 135 through Greentoe. I was informed by Greentoe that the order was accepted by a vendor. Then I got an email from that vendor saying the lens was backordered. So I cancelled the order. I am not the only person who has experienced this. I blame the vendor, not Greetoe.
Apr 19, 2018 at 09:45 AM
jawjr1957
Offline
Details
p.21 #19Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
I placed a bid for $1199 which was accepted 3/30. It was on back order as I checked the vendors website. I received it on 4/18. My card didn't get charged until it was shipped from the vendor on 4/12. I think Greentoe is great if you don't need something right away. I saved $300 from the sale price, definitely worth 2+ week wait.
Apr 19, 2018 at 11:38 AM
Neurad1
Offline
Details
p.21 #20Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO on sale for $1,499!!
I would have been willing to wait but am leaving the country soon and didn't want it to get shipped to my home while I wasn't there....
Apr 19, 2018 at 12:20 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister