fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017FM members A7R III first impressions

  
 
Vcize
Offline
Details
p.19 #1FM members A7R III first impressions
tn1krr wrote:
Vcize wrote
IsabellaR wroteHas anyone tested long time exposures (for example, 3 minutes or more)? In a German photo forum, one has detected strong noise (hot pixels)...

Sony A7RIII vs Canon 5D IV

http://www.dslr-forum.de/showpost.php?p=14883029&postcount=124
The sony mirrorless cams are notorious for this so I'm not surprised. Small bodies that run hot with little space to dissipate that heat. Dark frames mostly take care of it.
It actually seems to be more of a BSI sensor vs. non-BSI, current BSI tech has more self-heating. Original Sony A7R is better in long exposures than the latter models. Same has been observed for Nikon D810 vs D850 (by Lloyd Chambers, at least), older non-BSI model is better when exposure times get longer; BSI tech shows way more hot pixels in this case too.

For example Sony A7II vs. A7RII

http://blog.kasson.com/the-last-word/comparing-a7rii-and-a7ii-long-exposure-self-heating/

A7R is quite good in this sense

http://blog.kasson.com/the-last-word/a7r-self-heating-for-long-exposures/


It's more than just that though. The A7x bodies are already starting from a higher threshold.

Here's a couple dark frames back when I still used to have a D750 of the D750 compared to the A7r in thermal noise. Taken on the same night just a couple minutes apart.

A7r: https://www.dropbox.com/s/e6xxkhon8gvthku/a7r-dark.jpg?dl=0
D750: https://www.dropbox.com/s/sftd4fuo8h0wtvl/D750-dark.jpg?dl=0

Download to see just how big the difference is.

You're right that the A7rII made it even worse with BSI, but the original A7x's were already pretty bad relative to the other cameras of the time.
Dec 10, 2017 at 07:09 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.19 #2FM members A7R III first impressions
lightskyland wrote:
Pixel Perfect wrote
virtualrain wrote
nandadevieast wroteI just wish they had removed EC dial and put an a9 type drive dial instead. Who needs EC dial? And a 10 fps camera should have a drive dial.
What?! I use exposure compensation all the time. The dedicated dial and ability to see EC at a glance is a huge bonus over my old Canon. Who needs a drive dial?
Huh, you can see at glance on your Canon, it's right there in the VF.
What he means is, the ability to see your exposure changes live in the viewfinder, not just a positive or negative number.



Ah, fair enough, but that's always been a feature of any mirrorless having live histogram in EVF. Of course we get that with LV shooting on a DSLR, but not as convenient in normal shooting.
Dec 10, 2017 at 07:12 PM
tn1krr
Offline
Details
p.19 #3FM members A7R III first impressions
Vcize wrote:
It's more than just that though. The A7x bodies are already starting from a higher threshold.

Here's a couple dark frames back when I still used to have a D750 of the D750 compared to the A7r in thermal noise. Taken on the same night just a couple minutes apart.

A7r: https://www.dropbox.com/s/e6xxkhon8gvthku/a7r-dark.jpg?dl=0
D750: https://www.dropbox.com/s/sftd4fuo8h0wtvl/D750-dark.jpg?dl=0

Download to see just how big the difference is.

You're right that the A7rII made it even worse with BSI, but the original A7x's were already pretty bad relative to the other cameras of the time.


Great examples. I have this vague recollection that D750 was particularly good in this area and 24 MP sensor were overall better than the 36MP one's. But you are right; the Sony never were leading in this sense; I quess it comes to small size, continuous liveview processing etc. Today BSI seems to be quite a factor too with D810 handily beating the D850 in this when exposure times get longer.

Dec 11, 2017 at 08:33 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.19 #4FM members A7R III first impressions
LBJ2 wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
---------------------------------------------

xpfloyd wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
It definitely works, you need a dummy battery (not sure if there is an a9/7riii one available yet) and the external power pack. The dummy battery doesn’t heat up at all even after hours of constant use as it’s just electrical connections as opposed to a fuel cell. You plug the battery into the power pack and insert it in the camera I.e you are not connecting to the cameras usb point. I’ve tested this and it gives less hot pixels after prolonged long exposures . I got the dummy battery on amazon.

However SR app removes the need for this on the 7rii
Hello Xpfloyd. You and I agree. I think you misread my comment. "I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera." I was responding to another comment asking if the camera would run with a direct connection to an external power source without a fake/dummy battery in the camera.



Can the A7RIII be powered by USB-External Battery Pack for long timelapse shooting? Just wondering if I can just plug in the battery pack instead of messing with this dummy battery.
Dec 11, 2017 at 09:42 AM
Messier77
Offline
Details
p.19 #5FM members A7R III first impressions
Fred Miranda wrote:
Messier77 wroteAnyone notice that the sensor is an absolute dust magnet? This is my sensor after one week of use, six lens changes and 800 shots. Also used rocket blower and in-camera sensor cleaning function before taking this shot. F/22 looking at a white wall and intentionally out of focus. Shows up on multiple lenses, so it’s definitely the sensor.

This is more dust than I had in 6+ months with my A7rii.
I didn't notice any difference. Perhaps it's because you've tried many lenses on it in a very short period of time. I just took a look at my sensor and it had one speckle on it. (After testing the new camera with at least a dozen lenses)


Well, Sony has asked me to send in the camera for evaluation after seeing the photo. I think they are concerned about what appears to be the oil spots on the sensor. I'm going to try to have it cleaned by a reputable local photography company first to see if the issue persists. If that doesn't work, I'm sending it in to Sony.
Dec 11, 2017 at 10:20 AM
echelonphoto
Offline
Details
p.19 #6FM members A7R III first impressions
Thanks for the great video....I do not get the white square over my subject only the green when I hit the back focus button. How do you set this up?
Dec 11, 2017 at 11:19 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #7FM members A7R III first impressions
Too bad your not around the corner I’d clean it for ya
Dec 11, 2017 at 11:19 AM
elimoss
Offline
Details
p.19 #8FM members A7R III first impressions
Messier77 wrote:
This is more dust than I had in 6+ months with my A7rii.


FYI, the bigger, less intense balls could be on the sensor but I usually get those from something farther away from the sensor. Rear element dust or internal lens dust near the rear element.


Dec 11, 2017 at 11:39 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #9FM members A7R III first impressions
You may need a wet clean. Easy to do but makes people nervous.
Dec 11, 2017 at 12:25 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #10FM members A7R III first impressions
You may need a wet clean. Easy to do but makes people nervous.
Dec 11, 2017 at 12:25 PM
kurt765
Offline
Details
p.19 #11FM members A7R III first impressions
Gary Clennan wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
---------------------------------------------

xpfloyd wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
It definitely works, you need a dummy battery (not sure if there is an a9/7riii one available yet) and the external power pack. The dummy battery doesn’t heat up at all even after hours of constant use as it’s just electrical connections as opposed to a fuel cell. You plug the battery into the power pack and insert it in the camera I.e you are not connecting to the cameras usb point. I’ve tested this and it gives less hot pixels after prolonged long exposures . I got the dummy battery on amazon.

However SR app removes the need for this on the 7rii
Hello Xpfloyd. You and I agree. I think you misread my comment. "I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera." I was responding to another comment asking if the camera would run with a direct connection to an external power source without a fake/dummy battery in the camera.
Can the A7RIII be powered by USB-External Battery Pack for long timelapse shooting? Just wondering if I can just plug in the battery pack instead of messing with this dummy battery.



I think that's supposed to be a feature that it now can be powered via USB? I would love confirmation of this also.
Dec 11, 2017 at 01:06 PM
kurt765
Offline
Details
p.19 #12FM members A7R III first impressions
Gary Clennan wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
---------------------------------------------

xpfloyd wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
It definitely works, you need a dummy battery (not sure if there is an a9/7riii one available yet) and the external power pack. The dummy battery doesn’t heat up at all even after hours of constant use as it’s just electrical connections as opposed to a fuel cell. You plug the battery into the power pack and insert it in the camera I.e you are not connecting to the cameras usb point. I’ve tested this and it gives less hot pixels after prolonged long exposures . I got the dummy battery on amazon.

However SR app removes the need for this on the 7rii
Hello Xpfloyd. You and I agree. I think you misread my comment. "I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera." I was responding to another comment asking if the camera would run with a direct connection to an external power source without a fake/dummy battery in the camera.
Can the A7RIII be powered by USB-External Battery Pack for long timelapse shooting? Just wondering if I can just plug in the battery pack instead of messing with this dummy battery.



I think that's supposed to be a feature that it now can be powered via USB? I would love confirmation of this also.
Dec 11, 2017 at 01:06 PM
Messier77
Offline
Details
p.19 #13FM members A7R III first impressions
GMPhotography wrote:
You may need a wet clean. Easy to do but makes people nervous.


That's what I'm hoping. Having Kolari Vision do a thorough cleaning to see if it resolves the issue.

Personally, I won't touch the sensor, as I have unsteady hands and would probably put a hole in it.
Dec 11, 2017 at 01:10 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #14FM members A7R III first impressions
Lol it is really is just glass but it’s pretty durable
Dec 11, 2017 at 01:32 PM
Messier77
Offline
Details
p.19 #15FM members A7R III first impressions
GMPhotography wrote:
Lol it is really is just glass but it’s pretty durable


So the final verdict is no oil spots, but plenty of dust on the sensor. The splotches that looked oil spots appear to be the result of internal lens dust.
Dec 11, 2017 at 02:33 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #16FM members A7R III first impressions
Good on the oil spots. That would be coming internally so that’s the good news. So they did a wet clean
Dec 11, 2017 at 02:40 PM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.19 #17FM members A7R III first impressions
te4o wrote:
Does the 7r3 transfer photos at 3.1 speed over the USB C to computer indeed?

LBJ2 wroteAnybody else super happy about USB 3.1 in the new A7rIII ? Now 42MPs files moving at top speeds directly from the A7rIII to our computers. Yippee-yi-o-ki-yay ! Oh and no more fumbling with which side to fit into the Camera...but no such luck on the USB side into the computer USB slot. But okay I'll fumble 50% less now


I believe so. I haven't measured yet but looks to be similar load time ( at least on my USB 3 compatible iMac) compared to plugging Sony SF-G Series UHS-II SDHC Memory Card into the Sony USB 3.1 SD card reader that I normally use.
Dec 11, 2017 at 02:53 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.19 #18FM members A7R III first impressions
I really don’t recommend using the camera to download. To me and this me talking not the engineer talk but you run the risk of screwing up the camera port after time and just putting more wear on the camera. If your using the Song G cards and their reader than running as fast as you can anyway. Do what you will but do think about this. I shoot tethered a lot and I don’t want to risk that port
Dec 11, 2017 at 03:01 PM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.19 #19FM members A7R III first impressions
Gary Clennan wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
---------------------------------------------

xpfloyd wrote
LBJ2 wrote
GMPhotography wroteLike to get a link for that setup.

Not sure there is a fake battery yet for this cam. I wonder if we can take the battery out completely and power through the USB port. That would be ideal
Donesn't appear to work. I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera. I think this was the same with the A7rII. With the A7r2 I used the $20 Neewer AC Power Supply Adapter AC-PW20. Hopefully we will see something similar for the A9/A7rIII's NPFZ100 Z-series battery soon.
It definitely works, you need a dummy battery (not sure if there is an a9/7riii one available yet) and the external power pack. The dummy battery doesn’t heat up at all even after hours of constant use as it’s just electrical connections as opposed to a fuel cell. You plug the battery into the power pack and insert it in the camera I.e you are not connecting to the cameras usb point. I’ve tested this and it gives less hot pixels after prolonged long exposures . I got the dummy battery on amazon.

However SR app removes the need for this on the 7rii
Hello Xpfloyd. You and I agree. I think you misread my comment. "I did a quick test with my Kmashi 15000 mAh external battery power bank and unless there is some internal setting I don't know about, the battery or a fake battery needs to remain in the camera for external power to charge the camera." I was responding to another comment asking if the camera would run with a direct connection to an external power source without a fake/dummy battery in the camera.
Can the A7RIII be powered by USB-External Battery Pack for long timelapse shooting? Just wondering if I can just plug in the battery pack instead of messing with this dummy battery.


I haven't tested extended time lapse yet with my external battery pack and the NP-FZ100 in camera. I did notice Sony's NPA-MQZ1K Multi Battery Adapter Kit comes with a dummy battery...

Maybe someone else on the forum has tried this with the A9 or the A7rIII ?



Dec 11, 2017 at 03:06 PM
jamato8
Offline
Details
p.19 #20FM members A7R III first impressions
I checked my sensor. About 8 bits of dust, normal stuff that blew right off. Now the sensor has nothing on it. I use canned air, that I clear first before using and have for years. I also wet clean if needed. I have cleaned my sensors from the Leica, Canon and Sony for a long time and just do it lightly when wet cleaning. No big deal. When I lived in China I got a Canon shipped (new) from Hong Kong and the sensor was like they had left the camera on a shelf with no lens or body cap. Worst I have ever seen. Took a few weeks of cleaning each day to get the internal area clean, it was horrible. I didn't have any of the modern techniques (I was out in remote areas) and used a special sensor liquid with lens paper and my finger in the lens paper. lol
Dec 11, 2017 at 03:08 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister