I read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wrote:
If you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.
Zach-55 wroteSorry, but do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?
zerograin wroteD850 + Zeiss Milvus 85mm f1.4
Had to try the focus peaking. I was able to capture this at f1.4 with sunlight behind the model, which would have been impossible with the D810. For me alone was worth the upgrade.
The D810 is totally capable of taking this photograph, what you’re still missing is the fact that it would be harder or as he said “impossible” for him to achieve perfect focus manually with the D810 versus the D850 with focus Peaking. I have the D810 and I used to have that Zeiss 85mm Milvus also, and it was difficult focusing that lens. Focus speaking would’ve been great for me when I had that lens when I was shooting a toddler and trying to keep up with his movements with manual focus. Quite difficult. Anyway this is not my post this is not my argument. If you need further assistance with your argument, then you need to consult the original poster.
Zach-55 wrote:
I read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wroteIf you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.
Zach-55 wroteSorry, but do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?
zerograin wroteD850 + Zeiss Milvus 85mm f1.4
Had to try the focus peaking. I was able to capture this at f1.4 with sunlight behind the model, which would have been impossible with the D810. For me alone was worth the upgrade.
zerograin wrote: Zach-55 wroteSorry, but do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?
zerograin wroteD850 + Zeiss Milvus 85mm f1.4
Had to try the focus peaking. I was able to capture this at f1.4 with sunlight behind the model, which would have been impossible with the D810. For me alone was worth the upgrade.Just to clarify, there's no way I would have been able to manually nail focus at f1.4 with the d810. Image wise, I find the d850 to have more color information when editing in Photoshop. I absolutely love the D850.
Manually focusing any lens faster than ~ f/2-2.8 using the optical viewfinder is extremely difficult... but there are other ways around that limitation. I'm sure focus peaking helps, but with other cameras you can use zoomed in live view (preferably w/ exposure preview active), rangefinder mode, or even the AF confirmation indicator.
To say you couldn't nail focus at f/1.4 w/ a D810 due to the shallow DOF is like saying the D810 is no good for macro work, it's actually excellent for macro work... if you don't mind stacking a ton of images.
Zoom in and shoot portrait is a no go for me. LV with peaking is another poor way to shooting portrait as well IMHO.
There is no focus screen difference between D810 and D850, both f2.4. and 0.75X OVF won't help much as well. However, both capable to do WO portrait at that close distance with OVF Zerogain posted.(though, judged DOF at f1.4, he might crop the original image) It is not impossible but need experience and skill.
However, I can say D850's manual focus aid is improved upon D810/D800/DF etc... It almost like algorithm change, it is more accurate and at the same time also more easier to have it confused (both arrow turn on), I prefer this way than other Nikon body that easily turn solid dot even with confused situation or with wider margin of acceptance. I'd say it is more usable now, I prefer it to peaking in EVF, which is almost unusable under high contrast situation, you see lots of peaking in a wide range, accuracy is not acceptable.
I will admit that for each revision of higher megapixel, manual focus become more and more challenge, I personally still enjoy for family picture as I can shoot in close distance and for walk around cityscape, landscape, I still prefer manual focus especially with improved D850 focus aid.
A few more samples with D850, still JPEG only, I look forward LR support. They are OK but I am sure I can do better with RAW. I shoot some REDWOOD forest images, those definitely require RAW edit for high dynamic range. With more use with D850, I feel D810's shutter definitely quieter and handhold easier to get sharp images.
Believe he's saying the D850 is easier to work with than his old D810. But if he hates it I can pm him my address
youie wrote:
Hi Nisa,
Could you elaborate a bit more on you comment if you don't mind "It's was much easier to work then with D810 I had before"
Thank You.
Please, explain in what way it was much easier to work with D850 than with D810 during photo-session like that one in studio (controlled light environment)?
Thanks!
Nisa wrote:
First Studio photo session with D850 and 105 1,4. Absolutely beast of the camera. It's was much easier to work then with D810 I had before.
Todd wrote:
The D810 is totally capable of taking this photograph, what you’re still missing is the fact that it would be harder or as he said “impossible” for him to achieve perfect focus manually with the D810 versus the D850 with focus Peaking. I have the D810 and I used to have that Zeiss 85mm Milvus also, and it was difficult focusing that lens. Focus speaking would’ve been great for me when I had that lens when I was shooting a toddler and trying to keep up with his movements with manual focus. Quite difficult. Anyway this is not my post this is not my argument. If you need further assistance with your argument, then you need to consult the original poster.
...Show more →Zach-55 wroteI read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wroteIf you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.
Zach-55 wroteSorry, but do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?
Oh man... I didn't mean for this to be a debate.
When I bought the Milvus 85mm, I had a terrible time nailing focus with the D810 optical view finder. The focus dot had too much slack for me to get a perfect focus every time; a good shot ruined by bad focus is frustrating. Most times the Milvus would sit in the bag. Others with better skills can tell a different story.
I rarely shoot with live view. The D850 with FOCUS PEAKING is a game changer. It's very accurate at f1.4 even under harsh lighting.
The shot was a test to show the value of focus peaking, not an image comparison. I still hold high regards for the D810.
"I didn't mean for this to be a debate"... welcome to the internet! 😂
zerograin wrote: Todd wroteThe D810 is totally capable of taking this photograph, what you’re still missing is the fact that it would be harder or as he said “impossible” for him to achieve perfect focus manually with the D810 versus the D850 with focus Peaking. I have the D810 and I used to have that Zeiss 85mm Milvus also, and it was difficult focusing that lens. Focus speaking would’ve been great for me when I had that lens when I was shooting a toddler and trying to keep up with his movements with manual focus. Quite difficult. Anyway this is not my post this is not my argument. If you need further assistance with your argument, then you need to consult the original poster.
Zach-55 wroteI read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wroteIf you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.Oh man... I didn't mean for this to be a debate.
When I bought the Milvus 85mm, I had a terrible time nailing focus with the D810 optical view finder. The focus dot had too much slack for me to get a perfect focus every time; a good shot ruined by bad focus is frustrating. Most times the Milvus would sit in the bag. Others with better skills can tell a different story.
I rarely shoot with live view. The D850 with FOCUS PEAKING is a game changer. It's very accurate at f1.4 even under harsh lighting.
The shot was a test to show the value of focus peaking, not an image comparison. I still hold high regards for the D810. ...Show more →
zerograin wrote:
Oh man... I didn't mean for this to be a debate.
Sorry
zerograin wrote:
I rarely shoot with live view. The D850 with FOCUS PEAKING is a game changer. It's very accurate at f1.4 even under harsh lighting.
The shot was a test to show the value of focus peaking, not an image comparison. I still hold high regards for the D810.
I would say it's actually more of a change in technique to using live view... the results will (should) be the same whether you use focus peaking or zoomed in magnification (focus peaking is still better for video IMO).
Although zhangyue indicated that the focus indicators in the viewfinder behave differently w/ the D850... that would be a real improvement for manual focus photography. I understand that previous Nikons have a looser AF tolerance when a MF lens is used (or when switched to manual focus mode)... I don't really know if that's true as my eyes are too crappy to use MF through the viewfinder with any lens. But if they changed that it would make sense.
zerograin wrote: Todd wroteThe D810 is totally capable of taking this photograph, what you’re still missing is the fact that it would be harder or as he said “impossible” for him to achieve perfect focus manually with the D810 versus the D850 with focus Peaking. I have the D810 and I used to have that Zeiss 85mm Milvus also, and it was difficult focusing that lens. Focus speaking would’ve been great for me when I had that lens when I was shooting a toddler and trying to keep up with his movements with manual focus. Quite difficult. Anyway this is not my post this is not my argument. If you need further assistance with your argument, then you need to consult the original poster.
Zach-55 wroteI read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wroteIf you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.Oh man... I didn't mean for this to be a debate.
When I bought the Milvus 85mm, I had a terrible time nailing focus with the D810 optical view finder. The focus dot had too much slack for me to get a perfect focus every time; a good shot ruined by bad focus is frustrating. Most times the Milvus would sit in the bag. Others with better skills can tell a different story.
I rarely shoot with live view. The D850 with FOCUS PEAKING is a game changer. It's very accurate at f1.4 even under harsh lighting.
The shot was a test to show the value of focus peaking, not an image comparison. I still hold high regards for the D810. ...Show more →
I was a little confused by your comment about nailing focus as well, partially because I do not understand your focus points. Traditionally in portraits, the eye is the focus point. In none of your examples did you seem to use the eye as a focus point at all, and I am guessing since that you felt you nailed the focus points thanks to focus peaking, the models lips were more of a focus point than the eyes. Not to be critical, but when I looked at your samples, my first thought is "What is he trying to focus on here?", somewhat incongruent with your statement that you felt you nailed it.
Anyway, I am intrigued by focus peaking, although never having used it, it looks like it would be much more valuable for static macro work. I suppose the takeaway is, if you declare that your 850 can do something that an 810 cannot, there will be a lot of 810 shooters wanting to know what and why.
First think I notice when I checked in Lightroom how perfectly sharp almost all my images are. I shoot a lot at F/2 (105 1,4 and 58 1,4) in studio and with D810 quite alot of images was out of focus. With D850 almost all of the images perfectly in focus. I really was surprised when i look 1:1 in Lightroom. I also working with models in quite quick pace so now I can trust D850 like i do in my D5.
Well, if a lot of images taken with D810 in studio were out of focus, you were obviously doing something wrong ... or you simply have faulty D810.
Yes, D850 has more sophisticated AF system, but for studio work that does not make a difference, some 10 years D700 will do just fine for studio work, not to mention D800 or D810.
So, you better check out your D810 or your way of setting up D810 for studio shooting.
Nisa wrote:
First think I notice when I checked in Lightroom how perfectly sharp almost all my images are. I shoot a lot at F/2 (105 1,4 and 58 1,4) in studio and with D810 quite alot of images was out of focus. With D850 almost all of the images perfectly in focus. I really was surprised when i look 1:1 in Lightroom. I also working with models in quite quick pace so now I can trust D850 like i do in my D5.
Zach-55 wrote:
Well, if a lot of images taken with D810 in studio were out of focus, you were obviously doing something wrong ... or you simply have faulty D810.
Yes, D850 has more sophisticated AF system, but for studio work that does not make a difference, some 10 years D700 will do just fine for studio work, not to mention D800 or D810.
So, you better check out your D810 or your way of setting up D810 for studio shooting.
Nisa wroteFirst think I notice when I checked in Lightroom how perfectly sharp almost all my images are. I shoot a lot at F/2 (105 1,4 and 58 1,4) in studio and with D810 quite alot of images was out of focus. With D850 almost all of the images perfectly in focus. I really was surprised when i look 1:1 in Lightroom. I also working with models in quite quick pace so now I can trust D850 like i do in my D5.
He could easily miss focus with D810 in studio if he was using strobes but the camera had focus in dim light.
D850's AF is a huge improvement in that it handles low light focusing very well.
zerograin wrote: Todd wroteThe D810 is totally capable of taking this photograph, what you’re still missing is the fact that it would be harder or as he said “impossible” for him to achieve perfect focus manually with the D810 versus the D850 with focus Peaking. I have the D810 and I used to have that Zeiss 85mm Milvus also, and it was difficult focusing that lens. Focus speaking would’ve been great for me when I had that lens when I was shooting a toddler and trying to keep up with his movements with manual focus. Quite difficult. Anyway this is not my post this is not my argument. If you need further assistance with your argument, then you need to consult the original poster.
Zach-55 wroteI read carefully enough, thanks.
Yes, D810 has no FP in LV, but that still does not mean that kind of photo could not be taken with D810, right? He did not say "could not be taken that way with D810" but only " would have been impossible with the D810". That is a huge difference in meaning, agree?
Todd wroteIf you would read more carefully you will see that he used focus peaking on the new D850 of which, the 810 does not have. He was stating that using live view on the D810 would’ve been more difficult than with the D850 with its focus peaking ability.
Zach-55 wroteWhich part of my Q makes you such a huge problem to understand?
Zerograin states "... would have been impossible with the D810."
I ask him "... do you seriously believe that this kind of photo would be impossible with D810?"
In other words, why he believes that photo would be impossible to take with D810? What is so demanding about that particular photo that D810 would fail to take it?
Blakehfreeman wrote*The image quality difference between the D810 and D850 is nominal, the upgrade to me is mostly around shooting speed and focus etc. so not sure I even understand the premise of this comment.Oh man... I didn't mean for this to be a debate.
When I bought the Milvus 85mm, I had a terrible time nailing focus with the D810 optical view finder. The focus dot had too much slack for me to get a perfect focus every time; a good shot ruined by bad focus is frustrating. Most times the Milvus would sit in the bag. Others with better skills can tell a different story.
I rarely shoot with live view. The D850 with FOCUS PEAKING is a game changer. It's very accurate at f1.4 even under harsh lighting.
The shot was a test to show the value of focus peaking, not an image comparison. I still hold high regards for the D810. ...Show more →
Totally agree For most who now have the D850 have come from the D810 or still have it. The discussion relating
to the D810 is mute as we discussing our experiences with the D850. The D810 is still a superb camera even 4 years after its release and will continue to be a great workhorse for many years yet
For portraits in normal and low light, the AF with the D850 is superb. For the most part I set it on face recognition regardless of whether it is a Nikon or Sigma Art lens and it will find the closest eye even under dynamic conditions. Why, because it works reliably
The D810 worked about 70% to 80 % in speed and accuracy to that of the D850 in lower lighting. The Sigma Art focusing could sometimes be erratic with the D810 but is no longer an issue.
Also I really like the MF with the D850. I have used the focus peaking with LV and it is excellent now with better implemented focus confirmation. The focus peaking I use very similar to a Leica M240 RF as I roll in and out of the plane of focus. It becomes clear with some practice where the exact point of focus is even with fast f/1.4 lenses. The focus peaking does need to be adjusted well to suit your vision.