kaplah wrote: CanadaMark wroteStoffer wroteCanadaMark wroteohsnaphappy wroteQuestion, if I drop down to medium raw on the D850, or even small, will I sacrifice any DR?
Also I assume, small raw and medium raw WILL sacrifice detail, since they're will be less MP's.
I'd pre-order two D850's but I absolutely don't want MORE resolution. So I'm hoping medium raw will meet my needs.
Thanks!The reduced file size RAWs are captured in lossless compressed 12bit however the good news is that they appear to be actual RAWs unlike what we have seen in the past.Hmmm, where have you seen indications on them being actual RAWs? Would be great if white balance isn't baked in already, but I remain skeptical. Before they were 11bit (but presented as 12bit) with baked in WB, now they are apparently lossless compressed 12bit and Nikon support claims you can change WB in post. We still don't know for sure yet which is why I was not certain in my previous post.
The D810 has a caveat on the sRAW that they are uncompressed and cannot be retouched. This does not appear in the D850 manual.Some guy on dpreview has an early copy of the D850, reports that WB, highlight and shadow recovery on the 'small' and 'medium' Raw formats appears to be actual Raw.
Sounds like Nikon got it right this time.
Sounds promising - I think this will end up being a standout feature if it works well.
kaplah wrote: CanadaMark wroteStoffer wroteCanadaMark wroteohsnaphappy wroteQuestion, if I drop down to medium raw on the D850, or even small, will I sacrifice any DR?
Also I assume, small raw and medium raw WILL sacrifice detail, since they're will be less MP's.
I'd pre-order two D850's but I absolutely don't want MORE resolution. So I'm hoping medium raw will meet my needs.
Thanks!The reduced file size RAWs are captured in lossless compressed 12bit however the good news is that they appear to be actual RAWs unlike what we have seen in the past.Hmmm, where have you seen indications on them being actual RAWs? Would be great if white balance isn't baked in already, but I remain skeptical. Before they were 11bit (but presented as 12bit) with baked in WB, now they are apparently lossless compressed 12bit and Nikon support claims you can change WB in post. We still don't know for sure yet which is why I was not certain in my previous post.
The D810 has a caveat on the sRAW that they are uncompressed and cannot be retouched. This does not appear in the D850 manual.Some guy on dpreview has an early copy of the D850, reports that WB, highlight and shadow recovery on the 'small' and 'medium' Raw formats appears to be actual Raw.
Sounds like Nikon got it right this time.
You would think they would highlight that more in marketing for those who were disappointed with the D810; or possibly Nikon doesn't want to admit they messed up sRAW in the D810 so they are trying to be nonchalant with the D850 even though this could be a big feature for photographers trepidatious about such a high MP body. I am very curious how the new sRAW/mRAW formats handle high ISO and DR with the former being the main reason why I would like to see a baby D5, for me personally I would prefer better handling of high ISO over higher MP; however, with Nikon's claim the D850 is a full 1 stop better with noise vs. the D810 I am impressed. It will be interesting to see how the D850 compares to the D5 in high ISO tests under controlled conditions.
wjmeyer wrote: kaplah wroteCanadaMark wroteStoffer wroteCanadaMark wroteohsnaphappy wroteQuestion, if I drop down to medium raw on the D850, or even small, will I sacrifice any DR?
Also I assume, small raw and medium raw WILL sacrifice detail, since they're will be less MP's.
I'd pre-order two D850's but I absolutely don't want MORE resolution. So I'm hoping medium raw will meet my needs.
Thanks!The reduced file size RAWs are captured in lossless compressed 12bit however the good news is that they appear to be actual RAWs unlike what we have seen in the past.Hmmm, where have you seen indications on them being actual RAWs? Would be great if white balance isn't baked in already, but I remain skeptical. Before they were 11bit (but presented as 12bit) with baked in WB, now they are apparently lossless compressed 12bit and Nikon support claims you can change WB in post. We still don't know for sure yet which is why I was not certain in my previous post.
The D810 has a caveat on the sRAW that they are uncompressed and cannot be retouched. This does not appear in the D850 manual.Some guy on dpreview has an early copy of the D850, reports that WB, highlight and shadow recovery on the 'small' and 'medium' Raw formats appears to be actual Raw.
Sounds like Nikon got it right this time.You would think they would highlight that more in marketing for those who were disappointed with the D810; or possibly Nikon doesn't want to admit they messed up sRAW in the D810 so they are trying to be nonchalant with the D850 even though this could be a big feature for photographers trepidatious about such a high MP body. I am very curious how the new sRAW/mRAW formats handle high ISO and DR with the former being the main reason why I would like to see a baby D5, for me personally I would prefer better handling of high ISO over higher MP; however, with Nikon's claim the D850 is a full 1 stop better with noise vs. the D810 I am impressed. It will be interesting to see how the D850 compares to the D5 in high ISO tests under controlled conditions. ...Show more →
Compared to the D5, the smaller RAWs shouldn't be better for ISO performance than just reducing a native D850 file to match the 20MP D5. The D5 has class leading high ISO performance, and one way they got there was sacrificing some DR. I don't think you'll quite get there by down-sampling a D850 file, but it might be close enough. You will always have the option of down-sampling to improve the D850's high ISO performance - just another advantage of high resolution.
As for DR, you will have less of it near base ISO with the S/M RAWs but at higher ISOs DR should be similar if they are true RAWs.
Regardless, the options are most welcome.
And Nikon's claim of 1 stop higher ISO performance appears to hold up to objective tests, probably thanks to the new dual gain sensor:
mbphoto_2.8 wrote:
Just downsample the files and you'll get another "stop" for free, especially if you don't need 45MP.
I suppose I'm curious if that's how Nikon handled the new D850 sRAW/mRAW already. In other words, will downsampled 45MP high ISO files look "better" than the equivalent sRAW/mRAW ?
CanadaMark wrote: wjmeyer wrotekaplah wroteCanadaMark wroteStoffer wroteCanadaMark wroteThe reduced file size RAWs are captured in lossless compressed 12bit however the good news is that they appear to be actual RAWs unlike what we have seen in the past.Hmmm, where have you seen indications on them being actual RAWs? Would be great if white balance isn't baked in already, but I remain skeptical. Before they were 11bit (but presented as 12bit) with baked in WB, now they are apparently lossless compressed 12bit and Nikon support claims you can change WB in post. We still don't know for sure yet which is why I was not certain in my previous post.
The D810 has a caveat on the sRAW that they are uncompressed and cannot be retouched. This does not appear in the D850 manual.Some guy on dpreview has an early copy of the D850, reports that WB, highlight and shadow recovery on the 'small' and 'medium' Raw formats appears to be actual Raw.
Sounds like Nikon got it right this time.You would think they would highlight that more in marketing for those who were disappointed with the D810; or possibly Nikon doesn't want to admit they messed up sRAW in the D810 so they are trying to be nonchalant with the D850 even though this could be a big feature for photographers trepidatious about such a high MP body. I am very curious how the new sRAW/mRAW formats handle high ISO and DR with the former being the main reason why I would like to see a baby D5, for me personally I would prefer better handling of high ISO over higher MP; however, with Nikon's claim the D850 is a full 1 stop better with noise vs. the D810 I am impressed. It will be interesting to see how the D850 compares to the D5 in high ISO tests under controlled conditions.Compared to the D5, the smaller RAWs shouldn't be better for ISO performance than just reducing a native D850 file to match the 20MP D5. The D5 has class leading high ISO performance, and one way they got there was sacrificing some DR. I don't think you'll quite get there by down-sampling a D850 file, but it might be close enough. You will always have the option of down-sampling to improve the D850's high ISO performance - just another advantage of high resolution.
As for DR, you will have less of it near base ISO with the S/M RAWs but at higher ISOs DR should be similar if they are true RAWs.
Regardless, the options are most welcome.
And Nikon's claim of 1 stop higher ISO performance appears to hold up to objective tests, probably thanks to the new dual gain sensor:
Thank you Mark, "close enough" is what I'm hoping for, that would satisfy my baby D5 envy and allow the D850 to be the "one camera to rule them all" (to borrow from Tolkein) for me. Also, if down-sampling the 45MP image gives me better high ISO "look" to the images vs. using sRAW/mRAW then I'd rather do that for the majority of my shooting (which tends to involve higher ISO situations). When the D800 was first released I was baffled at Nikon because they claimed it was the D700 replacement - but that was not the case for me as a true D700 would have had the premium AF engine and class leading high ISO capabilities; however, with the D850 we have (finally) the class leading AF engine as well as extremely good high ISO capabilities, they may not be class leading (as compared to the D5) but if they are "close enough" I will be more than satisfied.
wjmeyer wrote:
possibly Nikon doesn't want to admit they messed up
Yeah, that's what drives most of their communications. A camera can be recalled 15 times and the notice will still start "on a very small number of cameras..." or "in a very rarely occurring issue...".
With the shrinking of the camera market especially at the consumer end and Nikon realizing that they have to go upmarket I think BS like that is one of the things they're going to have to stop.
After a day of using the 850, my main "complaint" and what I was really hoping it would have (but doesn't) is:
- quieter shutter. The shutter sounds nice, but I was really hoping it'd be quieter than the 810, or at least the same. I hate how loud the 750 is. Personally I'd sacrifice framerate for sound, but that's just me.
- I LOVE how they give you options to mask or just mark 1:1 or 5:4 crops in the viewfinder. But I HATE how they actually implement the aspect ratios, in that it actually crops the raw file, instead of just writing the crop to the metadata. The GFX did an amazing job of doing this perfectly: it let you mask the viewfinder to one of the various aspect ratios, so you could visualize them; then wrote it to the file, instead of cropping the file. So when you opened it in editing, the crop was applied, but fully reversible. I can't even fathom why Nikon didn't do it this way.
Certainly there are areas where D850 could be improved:
- wider AF point spread
- better AF in live view mode, including smooth AF for video
- electronic viewfinder of some sort (e.g. to shoot concerts without lighting the room from the back screen)
- real "small" and "medium" RAW formats (as was mentioned above)
- full control from a smartphone or tablet
- built-in GPS
That being said, D850 already has many big improvements. And I certainly want one :-)
RyanFlynn wrote:
After a day of using the 850, my main "complaint" and what I was really hoping it would have (but doesn't) is:
- quieter shutter. The shutter sounds nice, but I was really hoping it'd be quieter than the 810, or at least the same. I hate how loud the 750 is. Personally I'd sacrifice framerate for sound, but that's just me.
- I LOVE how they give you options to mask or just mark 1:1 or 5:4 crops in the viewfinder. But I HATE how they actually implement the aspect ratios, in that it actually crops the raw file, instead of just writing the crop to the metadata. The GFX did an amazing job of doing this perfectly: it let you mask the viewfinder to one of the various aspect ratios, so you could visualize them; then wrote it to the file, instead of cropping the file. So when you opened it in editing, the crop was applied, but fully reversible. I can't even fathom why Nikon didn't do it this way....Show more →
vitalishe wrote:
Certainly there are areas where D850 could be improved:
- wider AF point spread
- real "small" and "medium" RAW formats (as was mentioned above)
They can't make the AF spread much wider, it is a physical and geometric limitation both with how PDAF is implemented in modern DSLRs and also with lenses with long barrels. Everyone is running into the same limitations. The level of complete redesign necessary to improve the AF point spread much beyond what it's already at would be far too much.
The S/M RAW files appear to be real RAWs, unlike on previous models.
CDAF is also a lot faster than it is in the D810, and it can focus in near darkness.
CanadaMark wrote:
They can't make the AF spread much wider, it is a physical and geometric limitation both with how PDAF is implemented in modern DSLRs and also with lenses with long barrels. Everyone is running into the same limitations. The level of complete redesign necessary to improve the AF point spread much beyond what it's already at would be far too much.
I don't doubt any of that, but I mean the question didn't specify "within the bounds of what's feasible in the current minor-iterations-and-sensor-updates-on-established-SLR-tech paradigm." If the answers to "what more than the D850 do you need" exceeds that stipulation, I think that's all the more relevant a point someone needs to be making to Nikon and Canon...