fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement

  
 
RoyC
Offline
Details
p.2 #1D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
jhinkey wrote:
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteBill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

D810 vs D850 Read Noise
Excellent. With this data, and the fact that the sensor is BSI CMOS in combination with using copper, there is no doubt in my mind that this is very similar technology to the Sony A7r2 sensor. Which is a good thing.

It is tweaked to do native ISO 64 with a bit better DR there, and of course no phase detect AF on the sensor, so not a direct copy of the one in A7r2. And of course no 12-bit limitation for continuous shooting, so I wonder whether something is tweaked to the A/D converters too?
How do you know there is no 12 bit limitation for continuous shooting?


Error my bad.

Edited on Aug 28, 2017 at 10:59 AM · View previous versions
Aug 28, 2017 at 07:57 AM
bclaff_too
Offline
Details
p.2 #2D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
RoyC wrote:
jhinkey wrote
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteBill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

D810 vs D850 Read Noise
Excellent. With this data, and the fact that the sensor is BSI CMOS in combination with using copper, there is no doubt in my mind that this is very similar technology to the Sony A7r2 sensor. Which is a good thing.

It is tweaked to do native ISO 64 with a bit better DR there, and of course no phase detect AF on the sensor, so not a direct copy of the one in A7r2. And of course no 12-bit limitation for continuous shooting, so I wonder whether something is tweaked to the A/D converters too?
How do you know there is no 12 bit limitation for continuous shooting?
Per page 38 of the D850 brochure the 12 BIT limit @ 7 FPS is 170 shots before buffer fills. This will of course be smaller @ 9 FPS.

This isn't a "limit" you get 51 at 14-bit and 170 at 12-bit; the choice is yours.

Unlike Sony Nikon never changes the bit depth from what you have selected.

Aug 28, 2017 at 09:18 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.2 #3D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
RoyC wrote:
jhinkey wrote
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteBill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

D810 vs D850 Read Noise
Excellent. With this data, and the fact that the sensor is BSI CMOS in combination with using copper, there is no doubt in my mind that this is very similar technology to the Sony A7r2 sensor. Which is a good thing.

It is tweaked to do native ISO 64 with a bit better DR there, and of course no phase detect AF on the sensor, so not a direct copy of the one in A7r2. And of course no 12-bit limitation for continuous shooting, so I wonder whether something is tweaked to the A/D converters too?
How do you know there is no 12 bit limitation for continuous shooting?
Per page 38 of the D850 brochure the 12 BIT limit @ 7 FPS is 170 shots before buffer fills. This will of course be smaller @ 9 FPS.


The buffer size does not decrease when FPS increases, it just fills faster.
Aug 28, 2017 at 09:20 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #4D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
RoyC wrote:
jhinkey wrote
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteBill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

D810 vs D850 Read Noise
Excellent. With this data, and the fact that the sensor is BSI CMOS in combination with using copper, there is no doubt in my mind that this is very similar technology to the Sony A7r2 sensor. Which is a good thing.

It is tweaked to do native ISO 64 with a bit better DR there, and of course no phase detect AF on the sensor, so not a direct copy of the one in A7r2. And of course no 12-bit limitation for continuous shooting, so I wonder whether something is tweaked to the A/D converters too?
How do you know there is no 12 bit limitation for continuous shooting?
Per page 38 of the D850 brochure the 12 BIT limit @ 7 FPS is 170 shots before buffer fills. This will of course be smaller @ 9 FPS.


Is "continuous shooting" the same as using the fully electronic shutter?

Aug 28, 2017 at 10:17 AM
reggieb
Offline
Details
p.2 #5D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
TAM63 wrote:
arbitrage wrote
TAM63 wrote
protikh wrote
TAM63 wrote
arbitrage wroteI would guess that if you crop into D500 DX size the D850 may look very similar. Just like when I owned 5DSR and 7D2. Cropping the 5DSR to use it for reach down into 7D2 size or further looked just like a 7D2 file (i.e. not all that great). So basically you get a D500 (-1FPS and +$$) when you need reach and a nice FX sensor when you can use the full sensor or at least more than the DX area. But viewing the files at 1:1 in LR may look the same.
Well if a cropped D850 shot looks like the D500, I am going to be heartbroken. Because I really disliked the D500 - both the noise, and just some harsh characteristic to the sensor. I sure hope you are not right on this, but I'm afraid you might be.

I can crop the heck out of the D810 and it still looks pretty good.
When examining the ISO6400 and ISO12800 bird pictures here http://www.photographyblog.com/previews/nikon_d850_photos/ , the quality looks better than D500 and D810 to me. Also files responded very nicely to noise reduction.
But of course these are relatively low shutter speed photos and high shutter speed BIF picture might be different.
Thank you. Me personally, I'm not as concerned with what the high ISO shots look like, although that is a bonus. Low to middle ISO is what I really want to shoot.

For me (and others I know) I found the D500 got some sort of noise at quite low ISOs. And it was different noise from the D810. I was just not a fan of that sensor (I sold mine). If I'm going to end up with essentially the same photos if I crop the D850, I probably would pass.
The D810 has bigger pixels so sometimes that will allow it to hold up to bigger crops. Certainly I seem to be able to get as good of quality cropping my 5D4 30MP files vs what I got with 5DSR 50MP files once you get into ISO 800 and up. Even the 20MP 1DX2 and 18MP 1DX files hold up better with bigger crops once you are getting up in the ISO range. There is always a balance and if one is using all the MPs to crop a lot you don't really gain IQ over a DX sensor with similar pixel density if the sensors are of similar generation and construction. Now the D850 has this BSI where the D500 doesn't but so far I haven't read anything that says it will make a big difference.

I think we will need to wait for a couple more weeks until sites start posting full RAW comparisons like DPReview so you can download RAWs and compare to D500 or whatever other camera.
It wasn't just how much noise - it was the type of noise, and just something else about that sensor I didn't like. Quote a few of us complained about the IQ. Hopefully the D850 will be different. I agree, we definitely need some nice RAWs to look at, time will tell.


You're the only person that I've seen complain about the image quality. Not that you're wrong to have that opinion, but I've not heard that before. I like it a lot more than my old D7100, at least. Had the D800, and like it more than that camera, too (though not for image quality reasons). To each their own. I think this D850 is going to be a pretty sweet camera.
Aug 28, 2017 at 10:43 AM
Todd
Offline
Details
p.2 #6D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
I would rather see actual photographs of this than looking at a chart that I don't understand. Charts are one thing, but a photograph, a comparison photo is much better in my opinion.
Aug 28, 2017 at 10:57 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.2 #7D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
jhinkey wrote:
RoyC wrote
jhinkey wrote
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteBill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

D810 vs D850 Read Noise
Excellent. With this data, and the fact that the sensor is BSI CMOS in combination with using copper, there is no doubt in my mind that this is very similar technology to the Sony A7r2 sensor. Which is a good thing.

It is tweaked to do native ISO 64 with a bit better DR there, and of course no phase detect AF on the sensor, so not a direct copy of the one in A7r2. And of course no 12-bit limitation for continuous shooting, so I wonder whether something is tweaked to the A/D converters too?
How do you know there is no 12 bit limitation for continuous shooting?
Per page 38 of the D850 brochure the 12 BIT limit @ 7 FPS is 170 shots before buffer fills. This will of course be smaller @ 9 FPS.
Is "continuous shooting" the same as using the fully electronic shutter?



Max continuous shooting with the electronic shutter is 6FPS with locked AF.
Aug 28, 2017 at 11:04 AM
TAM63
Offline
Details
p.2 #8D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
reggieb wrote:
TAM63 wrote
arbitrage wrote
TAM63 wrote
protikh wrote
TAM63 wroteWell if a cropped D850 shot looks like the D500, I am going to be heartbroken. Because I really disliked the D500 - both the noise, and just some harsh characteristic to the sensor. I sure hope you are not right on this, but I'm afraid you might be.

I can crop the heck out of the D810 and it still looks pretty good.
When examining the ISO6400 and ISO12800 bird pictures here http://www.photographyblog.com/previews/nikon_d850_photos/ , the quality looks better than D500 and D810 to me. Also files responded very nicely to noise reduction.
But of course these are relatively low shutter speed photos and high shutter speed BIF picture might be different.
Thank you. Me personally, I'm not as concerned with what the high ISO shots look like, although that is a bonus. Low to middle ISO is what I really want to shoot.

For me (and others I know) I found the D500 got some sort of noise at quite low ISOs. And it was different noise from the D810. I was just not a fan of that sensor (I sold mine). If I'm going to end up with essentially the same photos if I crop the D850, I probably would pass.
The D810 has bigger pixels so sometimes that will allow it to hold up to bigger crops. Certainly I seem to be able to get as good of quality cropping my 5D4 30MP files vs what I got with 5DSR 50MP files once you get into ISO 800 and up. Even the 20MP 1DX2 and 18MP 1DX files hold up better with bigger crops once you are getting up in the ISO range. There is always a balance and if one is using all the MPs to crop a lot you don't really gain IQ over a DX sensor with similar pixel density if the sensors are of similar generation and construction. Now the D850 has this BSI where the D500 doesn't but so far I haven't read anything that says it will make a big difference.

I think we will need to wait for a couple more weeks until sites start posting full RAW comparisons like DPReview so you can download RAWs and compare to D500 or whatever other camera.
It wasn't just how much noise - it was the type of noise, and just something else about that sensor I didn't like. Quote a few of us complained about the IQ. Hopefully the D850 will be different. I agree, we definitely need some nice RAWs to look at, time will tell.
You're the only person that I've seen complain about the image quality. Not that you're wrong to have that opinion, but I've not heard that before. I like it a lot more than my old D7100, at least. Had the D800, and like it more than that camera, too (though not for image quality reasons). To each their own. I think this D850 is going to be a pretty sweet camera.


There have been others that have said similar, on other discussions in the forum. Can't remember what threads offhand, sorry.

I'm not saying the D500 is horrible or anything. And maybe, compared to the other DX cameras, it's great (I haven't had a DX since the D7000). So my comparison was with the D810, and for me, it suffered by comparison. A slightly harsh quality is the best description I have been able to come up with. Terrific fun to shoot (and I bet the D850 will be too), I just preferred the IQ from the D810.
Aug 28, 2017 at 11:53 AM
PIOK
Offline
Details
Aug 29, 2017 at 03:57 PM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.2 #10D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
Realistically, I'm in the crowd for whom the extra 20 megapixels over the D750 means more oversampling rather than larger prints.

So that will cancel out some of the fact that D750 DR and read noise seem to be a decent bit better below ISO400.

But I think it's interesting that someone moving from a D750 to D850 planning to print at the same ppi could see a minor step backward in some ways.

I suspect that'll be particularly true when pulling up shadow detail (an area I already feel the D750 has too much noise). Do you think I'm right?
Sep 09, 2017 at 04:00 PM
joefoo
Offline
Details
p.2 #11D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement
reggieb wrote:
You're the only person that I've seen complain about the image quality. Not that you're wrong to have that opinion, but I've not heard that before. I like it a lot more than my old D7100, at least. Had the D800, and like it more than that camera, too (though not for image quality reasons). To each their own. I think this D850 is going to be a pretty sweet camera.


I've read posts from lots of people who don't care for the D500 IQ, I'm one of them.

I'd love it if Nikon could make essentially the D850 minus some megapixels to allow overall sensor performance like the D750. I suspect I might also have to give up 9FPS.
Sep 09, 2017 at 05:08 PM
Frode
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #12D850: Bill Claff's data shows significant High ISO DR improvement

snapsy wrote:
Bill added more preliminary D850 today, this time read noise for much of the ISO range. Read noise corresponds to engineering DR, ie way DxO represents their DR measurements. The values indicate a nearly 1EV improvement in High ISO DR start at ISO 400, which matches Nikon's claim for the D850's 1-stop improvement in High ISO performance (although this is performance in the deeper tones/shadows vs an overall noise reduction that would be more useful).

I trust Nikon.

According to Nikon the DR for D850 is the same as in thpe D810.

Nothing more or less.

https://m.dpreview.com/news/6772782345/exclusive-nikon-answers-20-popular-questions-about-the-nikon-d850

Sep 09, 2017 at 05:33 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister