rscheffler wrote:
I will hold tight and wait for Canon... either DSLR or FF mirrorless, haha. I honestly think they could release a competitive mirrorless camera right now. It's more a question of if they want to. For me there's no point flip-flopping systems as it's just a money losing exercise with minimal gain (in respect to potential earnings vs. the needs of my clients). I would definitely like to see a Canon 50MP 10fps camera. I'm sure it will happen eventually, but sooner would be great.
D850 does sound amazing... But I would probably go Sony before I go Nikon due to Canon lens compatibility (as well as Leica M with limitations) to ease integration....Show more →
I remember a comment from somebody who posted it in the Canon forum many years ago after the release of the D800(E) cameras - he had some insider information and claimed that people who are interested in High MP/high DR cameras should better switch ASAP instead of waiting with Canon.....at the time many members there said the same - Canon will soon make something competitive etc etc. We know the outcome, the poster was right, Canon did nothing for a very long time since 2012, only the 5DsR finally gave better resolution and the 5D MkIV better DR....but the competition is miles ahead. I lost count how many punches Canon got by Nikon and Sony since 2012....I have also very low expectations for a Canon FF mirrorless camera even I wish they would release one ASAP to give Sony some competition at least to have Sony prices dropped a bit!
rscheffler wrote: adamdewilde wroteM10 - 3 batteries per camera. I will note that I haven't tested this but I do have two M10s and 6 batteries so I technically could if I bought the right lenses to shoot weddings. But since I sold off all my M lenses I've only picked up 3 lenses thus far and they're not suitable for weddings IMHO. My biggest gripe with the M10 BTW is battery life and from my biggest day of shooting I got 500 shots over 4 hours and although I didn't need to change the battery I wasn't shooting heavily as it wasn't a wedding but the battery life was low enough where I'd have wanted to change it during a quiet moment to not miss a special moment had I been shooting a wedding.
Don't know how this helps but thought I'd chime in since I probably won't have anything interesting to add to the D850 discussion unless I crack and buy the 105/1.4 and then of course I'd get the D850 Apparently with the grip and the D5 battery, the D850 is rated for over 5000 frames. Haha... BTW, this is a great idea that Canon should copy - make a 5D series grip that takes the 1D series batteries. At least for guys like me already shooting 1D, it means only one type of battery to carry and charger to pack (they need to make the charger a lot smaller).
M10 sounds a lot like M9 in respect to in-use battery life. I was lucky to scratch 400 images per battery at weddings with the M9, but I also had sleep disabled due to the long wake time, which I'd likely do with the M10 too, for jobs. M240 I would usually burn through 3 batteries in 12-14 hours because sleep was disabled. If it's enabled, I'd probably be able to do a full wedding on one.
Battery life is the only feature downgrade of the M10 vs. M240 that significantly bothers me, but the many improvements of the M10 still make me want one.
---------------------------------------------
I will hold tight and wait for Canon... either DSLR or FF mirrorless, haha. I honestly think they could release a competitive mirrorless camera right now. It's more a question of if they want to. For me there's no point flip-flopping systems as it's just a money losing exercise with minimal gain (in respect to potential earnings vs. the needs of my clients). I would definitely like to see a Canon 50MP 10fps camera. I'm sure it will happen eventually, but sooner would be great.
D850 does sound amazing... But I would probably go Sony before I go Nikon due to Canon lens compatibility (as well as Leica M with limitations) to ease integration....Show more →zhangyue wroteNow official, any alt fellows will get it?
Yes for work I would turn off auto-sleep it's annoying with M mount cameras. But I'd still probably switch the camera on and off after taking the shot simply because I have two around my neck and sometimes I drop the 75mm and use the 35mm for a stretch.. So better to get into the habit of switching on and off cameras. ESPECIALLY for EVF cameras.
Wait a minute! Someone told me this morning that Canon is now dead in the water. Or it may have been two weeks ago that I heard Nikon was on the brink of bankrupcy. Geez, now I am really confused.... And this D850 may be in the cards for me for landscape use. Or A7RIII....
I preordered it, I will report back after I get the camera. I will be honest about what I think.
Gary, For landscape, I doubt I can do much better than A7RII give me, well maybe other than a few cases drop bit and eat star and of course famous compress raw. Still You can't really get much better than Sony for landscape for both size and lens selection reason.
Having saId that, I am surprised many people holding their purchase decision between the two. (D850 and A7RIII) I think it should be a easy choice one way or the other as they are so fundamentally different.
For me, choose Nikon is not because of how it will be best DR monster, spec monster or 9frame/sec etc but mainly for day to day shooting experience, as I find myself almost never pick up RX1 or A7RII if I am not traveling or do long hike. The selling point of this one for me is actually Nikon finally fine turn with everything to make a almost perfect fit for me. Every little details such Bright big OVF, illuminated button, -4EV center AF, flip LCD etc make it irresistible and I also agree with members here that Nikon file have some smooth character though I am not totally fond of its color for latest body.
I thought I will like A7RII given it is so popular and got so many love from people here, but after get it on hand and use it on trip make me a little bit disappointed, maybe I give it too much expectation. It improves many thing over original A7R at the same time, I still get the exact same feeling/complain about its feel and operation. Fundamentally, it doesn't change much IMO. Having said that, once I set my expectation accordingly, I realize my travel kit with this little body indeed significantly smaller and lighter and it can bring me as good or almost as good IQ, especially given Leica is almost useless for long exposure, this one is way better, a perfect companion for M system.
Hope it doesn't make me looks like Nikon fanboy and it makes some sense and helpful for other members
retrofocus wrote: rscheffler wroteI will hold tight and wait for Canon... either DSLR or FF mirrorless, haha. I honestly think they could release a competitive mirrorless camera right now. It's more a question of if they want to. For me there's no point flip-flopping systems as it's just a money losing exercise with minimal gain (in respect to potential earnings vs. the needs of my clients). I would definitely like to see a Canon 50MP 10fps camera. I'm sure it will happen eventually, but sooner would be great.
D850 does sound amazing... But I would probably go Sony before I go Nikon due to Canon lens compatibility (as well as Leica M with limitations) to ease integration.I remember a comment from somebody who posted it in the Canon forum many years ago after the release of the D800(E) cameras - he had some insider information and claimed that people who are interested in High MP/high DR cameras should better switch ASAP instead of waiting with Canon.....at the time many members there said the same - Canon will soon make something competitive etc etc. We know the outcome, the poster was right, Canon did nothing for a very long time since 2012, only the 5DsR finally gave better resolution and the 5D MkIV better DR....but the competition is miles ahead. I lost count how many punches Canon got by Nikon and Sony since 2012....I have also very low expectations for a Canon FF mirrorless camera even I wish they would release one ASAP to give Sony some competition at least to have Sony prices dropped a bit! ...Show more →
The release of the D800(E) triggered a very interesting journey for me. I got that same feeling, that Canon would not release anything similar for some years, and I got a D800E. The image quality was fantastic, and I could use some of the manual focus lenses I already have in Nikon mount, and I added some native Nikon AF lenses. There was one real problem I had with the D800E, the poor LiveView implementation that made manual focus for landscape very frustrating, It was almost impossible to assert critical focus with magnification.
I was not ready to switch system, and kept my Canon lenses. When the A7r was released, it was very cool to have such a small FF camera, and be able to use all my lenses. There were also some difficulties with that camera. The shutter vibration issue is real, and affect a large range of common shutter speeds for a large range of focal lengths. Even on a tripod with normal focal lengths, there is a subtle sharpness reduction. Most frustrating was hand held use with longer focal lengths, both manual and with Image Stabilisation. The keeper rate was very low.
There is no need to tell my that I dont know how to use the D800E or A7r, I have learned the tricks and workarounds, but it was not enough for me.
Then enter the 5DS R and A7r II. Apart from the obvious attraction of 50 MP, I longed back to the operating experience of a Canon DSLR. The 5DS R did not disappoint for handheld use with its fantastic AF and cropability. Regarding dynamic range, it still uses the old sensor tech with limited dynamic range, but on the positive side the banding was gone, and the usable dynamic range was larger than with the 5Dmk II even though the measurable dynamic range at normalized resolution was only slightly larger thanks to the effect of the high native resolution. The only real downside of the 5DS R is still the limited dynamic range. I don't need more than 5 fps.
I also considered the A7rII, but did not get it early because of the uncertainties of AF performance with adapters, and the new problems with increased noise at long exposures. That is an important consideration for me.
My conclusions is that all systems have their quirks. As someone who appreciates more dynamic range, and I am ready to upgrade to a camera with greater dynamic range, it is still only one of many considerations. When I compare my A7r files (the sharp ones) with my 5DS R files, the difference that I can most often see is the higher resolution of the 5DR S, more often than the lower shadow noise of the A7r.
The D850 looks like a fantastic camera, but in terms of image quality it is only an incremental upgrade from what I can do with a combination of the 5DS R and A7r, each used to suit their strengths. If I had a D810, it would also be only an incremental upgrade.
The journey goes on. I am very happy for the release of the D850, and I hope it will sell well and not have any new quirks. It will certainly make a very capable tool for a wide range of photography. The strength of the camera is that it seems to balance many performance aspects, on a high level.
I also switched to D800E when it came out but then switched back to 5DSR. D850 looks great but I think I am fine with the ~1.5 stop less DR at base iso of the 5DSR. Canon skin tones are nicer.
So I am good for now.
Thanks, alundeb and Wayne for offering different perspective. It all make sense to me. I also don't think switching system is a good option. The benefit of Sony is adding it to any existing system is much easier without swap lenses. I was thinking about buy 5DIV with 16-35 f2.8 before but after seeing how hustle to change system I give up that idea.
Now that I see there are many consideration for individual considering buying upgrading system. For sports, they want speed and frame rate, for landscape, they want pixels and DR. For portrait, they want color and maybe lens selection. Which are very valid.
For me, is none of above, (maybe a little bit of all above) and I am beginning to think I am a minority here that not value end results as sole goal to upgrade but whole experience of getting that. If I do, I think start from A7R and D800E, both will meet that goal until now. For IQ driven, you will be pretty much satisfied with any major system offered last 5 years.
Use Alundeb's example above:
I generally don't shooting anything longer than 100mm, in that case, I am quite happy with A7R's IQ actually, especially on tripod. However, I have major complain about shutter delay, weak mount cause light leak and poor corner and also poor manual system. If purely IQ driven, I would be happy by swap a strong mount which I did and be happy.
For the same reason as D800E case, I agree the line skip during LV is a major issue, but it really doesn't prevent me get focus right actually, for anything I care about sharpness and IQ, I am on tripod and use aperture smaller than f5.6, in that case, select a hyper focal point and focus at f1.4 or 2.8 shoot at f5.6 or f8 there is no chance I miss focusing. LV at night fully dark shooting could be major problem for Nikon system, (actually Sony too even it is better) but for star, I always use barrel location instead of focusing at dark. As you can see, this indeed is a hustle but not a problem to prevent I get final results again.
However, I upgraded in both case. D810 has major upgrade about LV, It still could not be clear enough to manual focus at fully darkness but it is no longer skip line and dual LV is very handy to determine DOF for SWA shooting. EFC was introduced. (have to be MLP and push shutter twice) Not only that, it also update AF system with group AF, it is just much faster and more reliable. At same time, the mirror impact is significant reduced with also much quiet shutter. ISO64 also very handy for water shooting. Handle of camera further improve hand hold experience. All those little details just made the shooting much more enjoyable.
A7RII couldn't get EVF experience further to the point I can give up OVF, but it indeed fix most of the major issues I had with A7R. It is still drop bit in long exposure and eat stat and compress file by default but I don't really complain its IQ because of that as it is really only affect very small portion of my shooting.
For D850, I know 0.75X OVF will improve my view experience, LV and silent shooting will improve LV further, 153 AF points with 99 cross type can fix issues that my unreliable DF AF on fast glass and -4ev can focus way better than me at night. flip LCD will be a major feature I value in field, illuminated button will be very useful for shooting at dark etc... Will I see major upgrade on IQ compare to D810 or A7RII, for sure not.
5DSR must get everything else right so that both of you like it. I can fully understand. I have half year experience with Canon 6D, other than poor color, I like that body.
I guess what I am trying to say is D850 won't make anyone a better photographer or can make meaningful higher IQ technically. Buying or not, upgrading or not is really upon individual's need and consideration.
zhangyue wrote:
Having saId that, I am surprised many people holding their purchase decision between the two. (D850 and A7RIII) I think it should be a easy choice one way or the other as they are so fundamentally different.
For me, choose Nikon is not because of how it will be best DR monster, spec monster or 9frame/sec etc but mainly for day to day shooting experience, as I find myself almost never pick up RX1 or A7RII if I am not traveling or do long hike. The selling point of this one for me is actually Nikon finally fine turn with everything to make a almost perfect fit for me. Every little details such Bright big OVF, illuminated button, -4EV center AF, flip LCD etc make it irresistible and I also agree with members here that Nikon file have some smooth character though I am not totally fond of its color for latest body.
I thought I will like A7RII given it is so popular and got so many love from people here, but after get it on hand and use it on trip make me a little bit disappointed, maybe I give it too much expectation. It improves many thing over original A7R at the same time, I still get the exact same feeling/complain about its feel and operation. Fundamentally, it doesn't change much IMO. Having said that, once I set my expectation accordingly, I realize my travel kit with this little body indeed significantly smaller and lighter and it can bring me as good or almost as good IQ, especially given Leica is almost useless for long exposure, this one is way better, a perfect companion for M system.
Hope it doesn't make me looks like Nikon fanboy and it makes some sense and helpful for other members...Show more →
Great post! I agree on a lot you're saying about the Sony A7r2.
I love the image quality and the raw files from the A72 to the point where I don't really desire more DR or resolution. It is just about perfect. However, I don't get much enjoyment out of shooting with the A7r2; it is OK, but it feels like I'm out shooting in order to bring back files that I can then enjoy on the computer screen, and in effect I'm not out shooting as much as I would like.
I know what the issue is. I'm coming from a Canon 1D X (yeah strange switch, I know!), but damn that was a pleasure to shoot with even with its size and weight. It was so fast and responsive, the ergonomics and handling so great. It was just sooo easy! But I wanted higher resolution and DR and got lured into the A7r2. Awesome files, but a turtle to shoot with, honestly.
I see the D850 as a step back towards the fast and joyful 1D X while maintaining the superb image quality of the A7r2. I don't need more than 7 fps. Still considering it all, but boy is D850 tempting!
I say find something and stick with it . This is more true today than it was when Weston said it well over a half century ago.
"The fact is that relatively few photographers ever master their medium. Instead they allow the medium to master them and go on an endless squirrel cage chase from new lens to new paper to new developer to new gadget, never staying with one piece of equipment long enough to learn its full capacities, becoming lost in a maze of technical information that is of little or no use since they don't know what to do with it." - Edward Weston
airfrogusmc wrote:
I say find something a stick with it . This is more true today than it was when Weston said it well over a half century ago.
"The fact is that relatively few photographers ever master their medium. Instead they allow the medium to master them and go on an endless squirrel cage chase from new lens to new paper to new developer to new gadget, never staying with one piece of equipment long enough to learn its full capacities, becoming lost in a maze of technical information that is of little or no use since they don't know what to do with it." - Edward Weston
Allen,that is a very nice quote and very true actually. I think gear, at one hand, indeed associate with photography. Master it require skill than gear itself can bring. On the other hand, it also is a separate topic as a hobby.
I absolutely agree with you that ultimately my photography is not limited by any camera tool but how I see things and how I master the camera, focal length I have. At least for the images I truly enjoy to watch, gear is not important. My favorite photographer is Robert Frank, I think most of his work, 4M pixel is enough.
All these talk about lenses rendering, sharpness, CA, camera's DR or Frame/s, pixel density are only relevant for certain type of photography. I will admit some of the pleasure come from seeing pixel level of detail, CA free, bokeh rendering for me. Are they really important for high level "ART", I'd say no. But do they bring some enjoyment? Yes, for me it is.
I can give an example for upgrade my M240 to m10. For my photography, do I really need m10 for rangefinder system? I can firmly say no, I can shoot 3200 with decent grain with m240, what I have now is way better than Robert or HCB had. But do I want upgrade to M10 to have better ISO, film like body size and handling? Absolutely yes if I have the fund now.
Gear talk can be photography related but at the same time it is also a separate topic to me.
The A7II handles pretty badly. But if you use it enough bad becomes normal. I had been using a D700 prior to the Sony and my first thoughts before I got used to it were - how can anyone like this thing?
The biggest benefits I find are the ease in shooting manual lenses and size. If you are shooting AF and don't have small f/2 lenses you might as well just be carrying a DSLR. The Dynamic Range on this D850 is likely so large I'm not sure getting a perfect exposure matters much anymore.
I still think Sony dominates the travel and landscape photography field.
Hard to beat a Sony a7r ii with loxia and voigtlander ultra wides.
Nikon will be good in all the other apartments. Telephoto lenses just feel better on a dslr and I don't think there's anything Sony can do to change that.
Video is nice on Nikon, but all the cinematographers I know in la all use the a7s ii with adapted lenses. Video is always gonna be a no sale for people when it comes to Nikon.
The A7rII and Loxia 21 is a superb combination as with other small adapted lenses but when you opt for fast lenses the difference in size and weight is minimal. In fact with fast and zoom lenses the grip and feel on the D750 and D810 is much better. I do hope that Sigma Art lens series will also include the Sony FE mount as trying to adapt them is very much a hit/miss affair.
I have just arrived back from my trip to Spain/Sweden over three weeks, I took my D750/D810 and Fuji XT2/X100F. As it turned out I ended up using exclusively my D810 with 24/35 Art and 58G/105E. This was all I needed and I just loved the output from the D810 combinations. In reality I do not have any real need to upgrade to the D850 but I do love many of the new features, particularly the D5 AF module. I was hoping for about a 10% weight reduction particularly with new high strength polymers that are available.
The reality is that with FF with fast lenses there is no short cuts to size and weight whether we are looking at MILC or DSLR's. My light/small setup is the XT2 with the XF 16 or 27.
I feel the D850 will set another corner stone as did the D810 in spite of being the antiquated DSLR I am sure this will buy Nikon some time to truly design a great MILC FF option. I would much prefer MILC in 1 or 2 years that has been designed really well and still integrates with all the existing lenses.
In the meantime if photographers need FF MILC the A7rII/A7sII/A9 are excellent options.
airfrogusmc wrote:
I say find something and stick with it . This is more true today than it was when Weston said it well over a half century ago.
"The fact is that relatively few photographers ever master their medium. Instead they allow the medium to master them and go on an endless squirrel cage chase from new lens to new paper to new developer to new gadget, never staying with one piece of equipment long enough to learn its full capacities, becoming lost in a maze of technical information that is of little or no use since they don't know what to do with it." - Edward Weston
My Sony A7r2 gives me all the image quality I want, and I don't want or need more than that for a foreseeable future. However, the A7r2 just isn't a joy to shoot, and that is a major issue for me. That is why I'm looking into the Nikon D850.
The good news is that I have at least found out what I want from an image quality point of view, now I just need to find a camera body that I feel doesn't get in my way. If I feel enjoyment from shooting the D850, it will be a camera to keep for several years.
The hunt for the latest and greatest will wear you out eventually, be expensive and you will only be truly happy with your gear as long as something better doesn't arrive. And something will sooner or later.
airfrogusmc wrote:
I say find something and stick with it . This is more true today than it was when Weston said it well over a half century ago.
"The fact is that relatively few photographers ever master their medium. Instead they allow the medium to master them and go on an endless squirrel cage chase from new lens to new paper to new developer to new gadget, never staying with one piece of equipment long enough to learn its full capacities, becoming lost in a maze of technical information that is of little or no use since they don't know what to do with it." - Edward Weston
You have a point here, but I want to put this a bit in perspective from a different angle. All digital cameras these days can take beautiful photos - the devil is more within the detail of each camera and which might fit best to the main style of a photographer. Nevertheless, technology changes quickly even some camera upgrades can be considered incremental to the existing predecessor camera version. Others might be seen more like a big lap and innovation forward - for example the introduction of the A7 series in 2014 since FF mirrorless did not exist like this before. Different story in the film days (and which I am still doing, too) - a good film camera can last for a lifetime (e.g. M series film cameras).
When it is worthwhile to upgrade a digital camera is a very personal question - I normally jump over at least one or two successor generations after I purchased a new digital camera. I feel I save more money by using it to its fullest instead of selling it a few years later for the next (more expensive) model to upgrade.
Getting used to a new digital camera and maybe even to a new digital camera brand might take a few weeks, but then its main functions become very familiar. I never use all potential electronic functions which my digital cameras provide me with anyway, but I like to have at least the option to make use of them if needed. I regard mastering a camera to know its quirks and make use of its advantages at the same time.
IMO it takes much longer to familiarize to a new lens and its potential. Even lenses which I use for many years sometimes still can surprise me in an aspect later seen in a photo. I consider this the much harder to learn aspect while taking photos than being fully aligned with the camera. Of course there is the additional point how lenses work together with a specific camera - especially when it comes to third party MF/AF lenses on a camera body.
I am reading a lot of posts and comments about the D850, and as usual with any new camera release a lot of high expectations from some and excuses from others. I believe it is a great tool especially for landscape photographers also regarding its photo stacking possibilities, I also love the feature to scan slides and negatives with its backlit sensor. For people who still shoot film and digital, this is a great feature IMO. Is it worthwhile to upgrade or even switch from another brand? This all depends on personal preference. Likely the D850 will be a good seller in the market even some (like me) rather wait for a mirrorless FF version camera with similar properties instead in the future.
alundeb -- I followed almost exactly your trajectory on image quest. I bought the D800e while my other top cameras were the Canon 1Ds3 an 5D2 21MP bodies. The D800e was a big step up in IQ -- DR and res. My main difference is that I've kept the Nikon body to support the few Nikon AF lens I accumulated, as well as MF lenses from Zeiss ZF series, Mamiya 645 series, and native Nikon AI series. I don't use it much these days, but glad to have it. I do love the ergonomics of the D800-series, even without grip. LV is damned awful for trying to focus architecture at twilight -- arrrrggggh!
Meanwhile, I bought the a7r after such good results with the Nikon sensor, and was very pleased. Again, I was able to use my existing Nikon AI lenses, ALONG WITH all my Canon and Alt lenses! That was a large boon. Much better LV experience, and I've come to appreciate the EVF too. This lead me to the much-improved a7R2, but I's surprised I still kept and still use the a7R along with the a7R2 many times.
After the a7R, I bought the Canon 5DsR inbetween that and the a7R2. Amazing camera, and I feel exactly the same as you, that is a terrific high res machine, and that makes up a lot for the DR superiority of the Nikon and Sony bodies. Great handling too -- a proper fit for larger hands -- and I still love Canon menus and user manual best of the three.
The upshot is that I may upgrade my D800e to a nice used D810 someday, or even further down the line, a nice used D850. My upgrade path for Canon will be an even higher MP body to upgrade the 5DsR to about 70MP. The Sony is my primary system, even with its toy-like quality and controls, so I'm very keen on what they produce for an a7R3.
As you can see, I leapfrog my systems, but never find I'm out-gunned using the previous itteration of each brand to keep my costs down to reasonable levels. I know juggling three systems seems silly or wasteful to many photographers, but I find it entertaining to stay up on the three main brands, as well as make use of the many lenses that come my way.
If I were being given only one option at this moment, it would be the Sony system, mainly because of its Zeiss (or Zeiss collaboration) lenses like the Loxias, although being able to use my Canon AF lenses is a big plus too!
I wish Nikon well, but mainly hoping Canon unveils a mirrorless system with IBIS, EVF with magnified focusing manual lenses, and an adapter for their EF lenses.
alundeb wrote: retrofocus wroterscheffler wroteI will hold tight and wait for Canon... either DSLR or FF mirrorless, haha. I honestly think they could release a competitive mirrorless camera right now. It's more a question of if they want to. For me there's no point flip-flopping systems as it's just a money losing exercise with minimal gain (in respect to potential earnings vs. the needs of my clients). I would definitely like to see a Canon 50MP 10fps camera. I'm sure it will happen eventually, but sooner would be great.
D850 does sound amazing... But I would probably go Sony before I go Nikon due to Canon lens compatibility (as well as Leica M with limitations) to ease integration.I remember a comment from somebody who posted it in the Canon forum many years ago after the release of the D800(E) cameras - he had some insider information and claimed that people who are interested in High MP/high DR cameras should better switch ASAP instead of waiting with Canon.....at the time many members there said the same - Canon will soon make something competitive etc etc. We know the outcome, the poster was right, Canon did nothing for a very long time since 2012, only the 5DsR finally gave better resolution and the 5D MkIV better DR....but the competition is miles ahead. I lost count how many punches Canon got by Nikon and Sony since 2012....I have also very low expectations for a Canon FF mirrorless camera even I wish they would release one ASAP to give Sony some competition at least to have Sony prices dropped a bit!The release of the D800(E) triggered a very interesting journey for me. I got that same feeling, that Canon would not release anything similar for some years, and I got a D800E. The image quality was fantastic, and I could use some of the manual focus lenses I already have in Nikon mount, and I added some native Nikon AF lenses. There was one real problem I had with the D800E, the poor LiveView implementation that made manual focus for landscape very frustrating, It was almost impossible to assert critical focus with magnification.
I was not ready to switch system, and kept my Canon lenses. When the A7r was released, it was very cool to have such a small FF camera, and be able to use all my lenses. There were also some difficulties with that camera. The shutter vibration issue is real, and affect a large range of common shutter speeds for a large range of focal lengths. Even on a tripod with normal focal lengths, there is a subtle sharpness reduction. Most frustrating was hand held use with longer focal lengths, both manual and with Image Stabilisation. The keeper rate was very low.
There is no need to tell my that I dont know how to use the D800E or A7r, I have learned the tricks and workarounds, but it was not enough for me.
Then enter the 5DS R and A7r II. Apart from the obvious attraction of 50 MP, I longed back to the operating experience of a Canon DSLR. The 5DS R did not disappoint for handheld use with its fantastic AF and cropability. Regarding dynamic range, it still uses the old sensor tech with limited dynamic range, but on the positive side the banding was gone, and the usable dynamic range was larger than with the 5Dmk II even though the measurable dynamic range at normalized resolution was only slightly larger thanks to the effect of the high native resolution. The only real downside of the 5DS R is still the limited dynamic range. I don't need more than 5 fps.
I also considered the A7rII, but did not get it early because of the uncertainties of AF performance with adapters, and the new problems with increased noise at long exposures. That is an important consideration for me.
My conclusions is that all systems have their quirks. As someone who appreciates more dynamic range, and I am ready to upgrade to a camera with greater dynamic range, it is still only one of many considerations. When I compare my A7r files (the sharp ones) with my 5DS R files, the difference that I can most often see is the higher resolution of the 5DR S, more often than the lower shadow noise of the A7r.
The D850 looks like a fantastic camera, but in terms of image quality it is only an incremental upgrade from what I can do with a combination of the 5DS R and A7r, each used to suit their strengths. If I had a D810, it would also be only an incremental upgrade.
The journey goes on. I am very happy for the release of the D850, and I hope it will sell well and not have any new quirks. It will certainly make a very capable tool for a wide range of photography. The strength of the camera is that it seems to balance many performance aspects, on a high level. ...Show more →
I think finding the right equipment (system) and sticking with it are key. I do this for a living and I shot with 500 C/Ms for a couple of decades as well as shooting with Canon F-1s which I still have. No need to change. There was nothing better.
It can take years to get to a point where you are not even thinking about the tool in your hand while you are working. What Weston is saying is if you are constantly changing things like systems as we see many do these days, how can that tool ever become second nature?
If you are chasing features then the gadget-go-round will never end. There is always going to be another latest/greatest. One that is on the type of journey will probably never master their equipment. It really does take a very long time.
charles.K wrote:
The A7rII and Loxia 21 is a superb combination as with other small adapted lenses but when you opt for fast lenses the difference in size and weight is minimal. In fact with fast and zoom lenses the grip and feel on the D750 and D810 is much better. I do hope that Sigma Art lens series will also include the Sony FE mount as trying to adapt them is very much a hit/miss affair.
I have just arrived back from my trip to Spain/Sweden over three weeks, I took my D750/D810 and Fuji XT2/X100F. As it turned out I ended up using exclusively my D810 with 24/35 Art and 58G/105E. This was all I needed and I just loved the output from the D810 combinations. In reality I do not have any real need to upgrade to the D850 but I do love many of the new features, particularly the D5 AF module. I was hoping for about a 10% weight reduction particularly with new high strength polymers that are available.
The reality is that with FF with fast lenses there is no short cuts to size and weight whether we are looking at MILC or DSLR's. My light/small setup is the XT2 with the XF 16 or 27.
I feel the D850 will set another corner stone as did the D810 in spite of being the antiquated DSLR I am sure this will buy Nikon some time to truly design a great MILC FF option. I would much prefer MILC in 1 or 2 years that has been designed really well and still integrates with all the existing lenses.
In the meantime if photographers need FF MILC the A7rII/A7sII/A9 are excellent options. ...Show more →
Yes with fast glass the only savings is in the body, but it's nice to have the option of much smaller slower lenses when you travel that save a lot of weight over the big DSLR kit. I don't need 1.4 glass when I travel and my Sony travel kit savings in bulk and weight is very substantial compared to my DSLR system of old. And I don't give up any image quality with a full frame mirrorless travel kit unlike going a cropped route to save on bulk and weight. If I want to really save a bunch of weight, I can pull out my A6000 and put a lens like the Sony 35 onto it and have an extremely light kit for when I'm just out for the day / evening. The beauty is I don't need a different system to lug along when I want to go very light...my A6000 shares everything with my A7R...no need for separate batteries, lenses, chargers, memory cards etc...
chez wrote: charles.K wroteThe A7rII and Loxia 21 is a superb combination as with other small adapted lenses but when you opt for fast lenses the difference in size and weight is minimal. In fact with fast and zoom lenses the grip and feel on the D750 and D810 is much better. I do hope that Sigma Art lens series will also include the Sony FE mount as trying to adapt them is very much a hit/miss affair.
I have just arrived back from my trip to Spain/Sweden over three weeks, I took my D750/D810 and Fuji XT2/X100F. As it turned out I ended up using exclusively my D810 with 24/35 Art and 58G/105E. This was all I needed and I just loved the output from the D810 combinations. In reality I do not have any real need to upgrade to the D850 but I do love many of the new features, particularly the D5 AF module. I was hoping for about a 10% weight reduction particularly with new high strength polymers that are available.
The reality is that with FF with fast lenses there is no short cuts to size and weight whether we are looking at MILC or DSLR's. My light/small setup is the XT2 with the XF 16 or 27.
I feel the D850 will set another corner stone as did the D810 in spite of being the antiquated DSLR I am sure this will buy Nikon some time to truly design a great MILC FF option. I would much prefer MILC in 1 or 2 years that has been designed really well and still integrates with all the existing lenses.
In the meantime if photographers need FF MILC the A7rII/A7sII/A9 are excellent options.Yes with fast glass the only savings is in the body, but it's nice to have the option of much smaller slower lenses when you travel that save a lot of weight over the big DSLR kit. I don't need 1.4 glass when I travel and my Sony travel kit savings in bulk and weight is very substantial compared to my DSLR system of old. And I don't give up any image quality with a full frame mirrorless travel kit unlike going a cropped route to save on bulk and weight. If I want to really save a bunch of weight, I can pull out my A6000 and put a lens like the Sony 35 onto it and have an extremely light kit for when I'm just out for the day / evening. The beauty is I don't need a different system to lug along when I want to go very light...my A6000 shares everything with my A7R...no need for separate batteries, lenses, chargers, memory cards etc... ...Show more →
Agree with size and weight save potential and IQ of Sony. No complain there. I'd like people to put different perspective on viewing thing make this thread more informative and helpful than simple brand loyalty.
We should only be loyal to the type of equipment that best suits the way we each see and work. And that can be very different for many people. The problem today is there are not many choices outside a one size fits all type camera both mirrorless and DSLR.
I also travel VERY light. I do most of my personal work and thus travel with an original MM and a 35 six FLE. I tend to naturally see in B&W and at a 35mm (on FF) FoV. So I usually travel with my MM and a 35 lux FLE plus batteries and charger. Thats it. A red, yellow and orange 46mm filter to.
My pro work I have 3 color Leica M bodies. M-E, M 262 and now the M 10 and I do all of my pro B&W work with my MM. Shutter speeds on a dial on top rt of the camera and aperture on the lens. Simple and on the M 10 the ISO is on the left top side, that's all I need. I have been doing it this way for over 4 decades. I am faster and can make much better exposure decisions for the way I want my files to look than any computer.
But thats me. Others may or may not like this approach. That's why it is really good to have real choices.