fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? ...

  
 
nikonos6
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
I did write this several times in other threads here already:
Why does Nikon not come up with a great 16-35mm 2.8E eventually?
Do they not believe they can top the Canon version?
I just wonder because to me it seems being such a versatile zoom range and
If they can manage to reach the same level like their new 70-200mm FL then it should
really shine in the hands of lots of photographers during the next years!
Yes it would be quite big ( depends of having VR or not) - I would probably be satisfied without
VR and therefore rather being a bit smaller.

Edited on Sep 05, 2017 at 08:22 PM · View previous versions
Sep 05, 2017 at 07:51 PM
Elijah
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
nikonos6 wrote:
I did write this several times in other threads here already:
Why does Nikon not come up with a great 16-35mm 2.8E eventually?
Do they not believe they can top the Canon version?
I just wonder because to me it seems being such a versatile zoom range and
If they can manage to reach the same level like their new 70-200mm FL then it should
really shine in the hands of lots of photographers during the next years!
Yes it would be quite big ( depends of having VR or not) - I would probably be satisfied without
VR and therfore rather being a bit smaller.
...Show more →

That's actually a great point... I would love a 16-35mm f/2.8E
I'll be able to eliminate both lenses, 12-24mm and 24mm f/1.4G
Sep 05, 2017 at 07:53 PM
BSPhotog
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)


nikonos6 wrote:
I did write this several times in other threads here already:
Why does Nikon not come up with a great 16-35mm 2.8E eventually?
Do they not believe they can top the Canon version?
I just wonder because to me it seems being such a versatile zoom range and
If they can manage to reach the same level like their new 70-200mm FL then it should
really shine in the hands of lots of photographers during the next years!
Yes it would be quite big ( depends of having VR or not) - I would probably be satisfied without
VR and therfore rather being a bit smaller.
...Show more →


If they give it VR, I suspect it won't be a f/2.8 lens. Then again, we already have the f/4 VR.
Sep 05, 2017 at 08:14 PM
milkod2001
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
nikonos6 wrote:
I did write this several times in other threads here already:
Why does Nikon not come up with a great 16-35mm 2.8E eventually?
Do they not believe they can top the Canon version?
I just wonder because to me it seems being such a versatile zoom range and
If they can manage to reach the same level like their new 70-200mm FL then it should
really shine in the hands of lots of photographers during the next years!
Yes it would be quite big ( depends of having VR or not) - I would probably be satisfied without
VR and therefore rather being a bit smaller.
...Show more →


Canon's 16-35 2.8 III is over €2500. Nikon's 16-35 2.8E with optics like 70-200 FL would cost very close to €3000.
Would you pay that much if you can get f4 version for half price and you will use it mostly for landscapes stopped down to f8-11 anyway?
Sep 06, 2017 at 04:04 AM
gnjphotography
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
The 16-35 f/2.8 has been a lens I have wanted for nikon since the 14-24 was introduced. The 17-35 is long in the tooth and has been a staple PJ lens. I do occasional landscapes, but really love the focal length for storytelling and putting the subject in the environment. Though, I feel they will update the 14-24 before they update the 17-35.
Sep 06, 2017 at 06:29 AM
nikonos6
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Well - it would for sure be an expansive lens !
And assuming that the price would be between 2500-3000 $ or at least as much in € here in Germany,
I would wait one year and get it used for much less ( depending on exchange rate of course) in Japan,
which I do visit for business almost every year.
So yes - it is defenitely a question of price too, but I just miss this focal length in a 2.8 zoom really much.
( the 14-24mm is just quite special indeed...)
Sep 06, 2017 at 01:45 PM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
swifty168 wrote:
Secondly, I think a 180/2.8E.


Swifty beat me to it. 180/2.8D is another one that's gone a loooooooong time without update. 1986. That's even older than the 105DC and 28/1.4D. The 135DC is also early 90's.

People arguing back and forth whether the G lenses were designed to fully take advantage of higher resolution sensors, but I can tell you for sure D lenses from the 80's and 90's weren't! I think Nikon's trying to clear those ancient designs out before they panic too much about the G primes. Only reason I can think of that two prime releases in a row were for very low-demand focal lengths.
Sep 08, 2017 at 05:08 AM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
The more I shoot with my D850 the more I realize that Nikon needs a new 50 and or 85 asap!

Edited on Sep 24, 2017 at 10:14 AM · View previous versions
Sep 24, 2017 at 09:24 AM
mbphoto_2.8
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Would love for Nikon to make a 500mm f/5.6E PF FL VR lens, size and weight of a 70-200/2.8E.
Sep 24, 2017 at 10:08 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Dj R wrote:
The more I shoot with my D850 the more I realize that Nikon needs a new 50 and or 85 asap!


Why? Do the current versions not work well? What about the Sigma Art versions? Do they not hold up?
Sep 24, 2017 at 03:56 PM
DavidM5
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
gdsf2 wrote:
What about the Sigma Art versions? Do they not hold up?


I own the Sigma 85 Art and while it focuses well using the centre focusing point, the side ones do not especially at close range.

I find I also have to take a couple more shots just to make sure the centre focusing point nails it properly as It is not 100% consistent.

The lens has been sent back to Sigma twice for this issue but no solution has been found.
It's too bad because I have to live with this issue and am hesitant to get the 135 Art.

My post was here:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1484397/0#13990966
Sep 24, 2017 at 05:21 PM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
there is a bit of a battle on the 58 1.4g photo thread regarding whether the lens is any good or not.
I own the lens.
I didn't want to continue the debate there, and disrespect the artists there.

It makes wonderful images, with swirly/artistic bokeh. It's an interesting FL that blurs the lines between 50/85. But that's it. I don't think there is much to figure out with the lens. Just stay at 5'+ away. And don't expect tack sharp. Imagine that somewhere smeared something on an element, to make it a bit hazy, like there's anti-sharpness filter on it.

When you go to AF fine tune it, after tuning other glass, it's very evident that this is not designed to be sharp, even in the center.
It is designed to be soft. Nikon has said this from launch.
So there is nothing wrong with them. Sort of.

I am in camp realist. I'm not a hater of this lens. I'm a realist.
Sure we can deliver amazing images from the 58G. Clients like the images, with the amazing bokeh, and great composition and tones. But if it were a little sharper, they would love it even more.

Let's say you rate the bokeh 100/100.
If making this lens sharper were to come at the expense of a tick less interesting bokeh, fine.
99/100 bokeh would work for me.
Your clients really don't care of the bokeh balls are round, onion shape, harsh, perfect. Your clients want to see sharpness, trust me (among other things, naturally).

A lens can be sharp or super sharp, and still have character.
Oct 02, 2017 at 08:13 AM
Blakehfreeman
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
1. Nikon 16-35mm 2.8E
2. Nikon 58mm 1.4E (1.2?!)
3. Nikon 200mm 2.0E (although I'm afraid to see the price on this one!)
Oct 02, 2017 at 08:59 AM
Elijah
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Blakehfreeman wrote:
1. Nikon 16-35mm 2.8E
2. Nikon 58mm 1.4E (1.2?!)
3. Nikon 200mm 2.0E (although I'm afraid to see the price on this one!)


I would’ve thought you would know this by now: it’s literally impossible to make a 1.2 lens (with contacts, autofocus, etc) due to F mount restrictions.
Keep dreaming
Oct 02, 2017 at 09:29 AM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
elijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!
Oct 02, 2017 at 09:45 AM
Blakehfreeman
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
You each owe me $1 when they announce a 1.2! I always hear difficult/expensive but never impossible. I actually think a huge issue with 1.2 was the mechanical link for aperture..and my guess would be that this should be easier now that the aperture link is electronic. But you negative Nancy's can keep raining on my parade!

Dj R wrote:
elijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!

Oct 02, 2017 at 10:45 AM
Dj R
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Blakehfreeman wrote:
You each owe me $1 when they announce a 1.2! I always hear difficult/expensive but never impossible. I actually think a huge issue with 1.2 was the mechanical link for aperture..and my guess would be that this should be easier now that the aperture link is electronic. But you negative Nancy's can keep raining on my parade!

Dj R wroteelijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!


it's the mount. 1.2 glass is too large to fit.
Oct 02, 2017 at 11:28 AM
Blakehfreeman
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
1.2 can fit. I am in agreement that it is unlikely... but just don't buy into the view of "can't"... when I'm sure it can, but at what cost. There are current 50mm 1.2 (Nikon) and 85mm 1.2 (3rd party) lenses for the f mount.

Again, do I think it will happen... who knows, but I do think it's possible. *And yes, I'm aware both those lenses are MF.

Dj R wrote:
Blakehfreeman wroteYou each owe me $1 when they announce a 1.2! I always hear difficult/expensive but never impossible. I actually think a huge issue with 1.2 was the mechanical link for aperture..and my guess would be that this should be easier now that the aperture link is electronic. But you negative Nancy's can keep raining on my parade!

Dj R wroteelijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!
it's the mount. 1.2 glass is too large to fit.

Oct 02, 2017 at 11:33 AM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
Blakehfreeman wrote:
1.2 can fit. I am in agreement that it is unlikely... but just don't buy into the view of "can't"... when I'm sure it can, but at what cost. There are current 50mm 1.2 (Nikon) and 85mm 1.2 (3rd party) lenses for the f mount.

Again, do I think it will happen... who knows, but I do think it's possible. *And yes, I'm aware both those lenses are MF.

Dj R wrote
Blakehfreeman wroteYou each owe me $1 when they announce a 1.2! I always hear difficult/expensive but never impossible. I actually think a huge issue with 1.2 was the mechanical link for aperture..and my guess would be that this should be easier now that the aperture link is electronic. But you negative Nancy's can keep raining on my parade!

Dj R wroteelijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!
it's the mount. 1.2 glass is too large to fit.


F1.2 manual glass is possible. F1.2 with autofocus contacts is probably not totally impossible but would cost way way way too much to manufacture.
Oct 02, 2017 at 11:46 AM
Blakehfreeman
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Nikon E Lens - what do you want & expect next? (1.4 glass, etc)
But if three or four of us on here tell Nikon we'd buy it I'm sure that would bring down the cost... (kidding)! Let us crazies in California dream darnit!

Hardcore wrote:
Blakehfreeman wrote1.2 can fit. I am in agreement that it is unlikely... but just don't buy into the view of "can't"... when I'm sure it can, but at what cost. There are current 50mm 1.2 (Nikon) and 85mm 1.2 (3rd party) lenses for the f mount.

Again, do I think it will happen... who knows, but I do think it's possible. *And yes, I'm aware both those lenses are MF.

Dj R wrote
Blakehfreeman wroteYou each owe me $1 when they announce a 1.2! I always hear difficult/expensive but never impossible. I actually think a huge issue with 1.2 was the mechanical link for aperture..and my guess would be that this should be easier now that the aperture link is electronic. But you negative Nancy's can keep raining on my parade!

Dj R wroteelijah is right
but Blake, well, he's in CA. so yes, he's a dreamer!
actually, I am a dreamer, I wish I was in CA!
it's the mount. 1.2 glass is too large to fit.
F1.2 manual glass is possible. F1.2 with autofocus contacts is probably not totally impossible but would cost way way way too much to manufacture.

Oct 02, 2017 at 11:50 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister