fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread

  
 
eke2k6
Offline
Details
p.11 #1Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
Elijah wrote:
BSPhotog wrote
eke2k6 wrote
Elijah wroteOne of few reasons I returned my 28E lens...
35mm f/1.4G vs 28mm f/1.4E, see below. Worth the 1k difference? Naw...

I'd rather buy 775 McChickens for that money.
Hhhhhhhhhhmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, where have I heard this before?

eke2k6 wroteThanks for the samples guys. The lens looks great...sharp, and the falloff is smooth.

But the samples confirm that I'll definitely be sticking with the 35mm 1.4. 35mm just has that extra compression over the 28mm focal length, and the much lower perspective distortion means I can get more intimate with framing than with a 28mm.

Back to my 20mm + 35mm combo on the wide end.
---------------------------------------------------------

But jokes aside, try a fast 20mm. I love the Sigma 20mm f/1.4 Art, but I know your aversion to third party glass, so give the nikon 20 1.8 a try. Either way, the 20mm is the perfect complement to the 35. During the party time of receptions, shooting the 20mm+35mm on two bodies feels as natural as shooting 35+85,

Honestly, it's as ground breaking for me as my 35mm was to separate a subject while still being able to fit so much into the composition. Rent it for a weekend and see.
If you look in the Nikon 20mm f/1.8g official image thread, I am fairly certain you'll find some contributions from @Elijah. IIRC
---------------------------------------------

eke2k6 wrote
BSPhotog wrote
eke2k6 wrote
Elijah wroteOne of few reasons I returned my 28E lens...
35mm f/1.4G vs 28mm f/1.4E, see below. Worth the 1k difference? Naw...

I'd rather buy 775 McChickens for that money.
Hhhhhhhhhhmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, where have I heard this before?

eke2k6 wroteThanks for the samples guys. The lens looks great...sharp, and the falloff is smooth.

But the samples confirm that I'll definitely be sticking with the 35mm 1.4. 35mm just has that extra compression over the 28mm focal length, and the much lower perspective distortion means I can get more intimate with framing than with a 28mm.

Back to my 20mm + 35mm combo on the wide end.
---------------------------------------------------------

But jokes aside, try a fast 20mm. I love the Sigma 20mm f/1.4 Art, but I know your aversion to third party glass, so give the nikon 20 1.8 a try. Either way, the 20mm is the perfect complement to the 35. During the party time of receptions, shooting the 20mm+35mm on two bodies feels as natural as shooting 35+85,

Honestly, it's as ground breaking for me as my 35mm was to separate a subject while still being able to fit so much into the composition. Rent it for a weekend and see.
If you look in the Nikon 20mm f/1.8g official image thread, I am fairly certain you'll find some contributions from @Elijah. IIRC
Jeez. I thought I was bad when it comes to going through gear
Found my old gear list from 2012. Ya'll are behind in terms of my gear, get with the program I stopped updating since then...
Geez, I cannot believe I owned so many Stigma lenses

"Bodies: Nikon D800 + MB-D12
Nikon D200
Nikon 16-35mm f/4 G ED VR
Nikon 24-70mm f/2.8 G
Sigma 35mm f/1.4 DG A1
Nikon 50mm f/1.8G Nikon
85mm f/1.8G
Nikon 70-200mm f/2.8 G VR II

Strobist:

Nikon SB-900 Phottix Odin Transceiver
Phottix Odin receiver (4)
Sanford & Davis tripod w/ FM18 fluid head
Gitzo 6x systematic 4-section tripod
RRS BH-55 ballhead with LR & L-Plate
...Show more →


Wowww. Ok, let me tally mine, current and former.


Bodies

Sigma DP1s
Sigma DP2M
Fuji X100S
Fuji X100
Fuji X100T
Canon 5D
Canon 5D Mark 2
Canon 5D Mark 3
Canon 6D
Nikon D750 (x6)
Nikon D800
Nikon D700
Nikon D600
Nikon D610
Nikon Df
Sony a6000
Sony a6300
Fuji X-T1

And I'm sure I'm missing a few


As I was tallying the bodies, I realized I've had far too many lenses for each system to even begin to try to count.

Maybe I'll add that 28E to the list one day.

Aug 08, 2017 at 01:54 AM
mifoto
Offline
Details
p.11 #2Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
In my view this lens is outstanding and comes quality wise very close to the Nikon AF-S 105mm f1.4E ED. Most of my subjects are not in the centre, like on some samples shown here, and it delivers off centre results which are not possible to achieve with the 35mm 1.4G and the 24mm 1.4G ED with the aperture wide open. I had it now for 2 weeks on loan from NPS, so enough time to try it out and I was completely blown away by the quality that this lens delivers, like the 105mm I really use it only wide open. It made me sell the 24mm and the 35mm and I've ordered my own copy of it. One wide angle prime is enough for me and I do really like 28mm as a focal length. It is expensive, but it is also worth it as I know that my clients will absolutely love the unique look that this lens creates.
Aug 08, 2017 at 03:23 AM
JohnK007
Offline
Details
p.11 #3Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
Elijah wrote:
I'm beginning to miss the hell out of this lens already... Need four more days to get it back


Sometimes "good enough" just doesn't feel "good enough" ... which forces you to go back and re-acquire the best you can do.

It's not the ordinary photos, where photos from both lenses "look the same" which matter ... it's the extraordinary photos, where the exceptional quality of the 28 f/1.4E stands out, which matter

It always feels better to know you kept that ability rather than knowing you got rid of it.
Aug 08, 2017 at 07:19 AM
azenis
Offline
Details
p.11 #4Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
After checking all the wonderful shots in this thread... (kudos to all!) I think I have concluded that I'd hold on to my 28D.

Other than some better CA suppression and a bit more sharpness, not much else is missing on the old 28D. In fact, I prefer the rendition on the 28D much better than 28E. The difference is subtle, but it's there.





cousin

Aug 08, 2017 at 10:56 AM
Joseph.
Offline
Details
p.11 #5Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
eke2k6 wrote:
Jeez. I thought I was bad when it comes to going through gear


I guess you haven't met Jonathan and supermario??
Aug 08, 2017 at 12:53 PM
JohnK007
Offline
Details
p.11 #6Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
azenis wrote:
After checking all the wonderful shots in this thread... (kudos to all!) I think I have concluded that I'd hold on to my 28D.

Other than some better CA suppression and a bit more sharpness, not much else is missing on the old 28D. In fact, I prefer the rendition on the 28D much better than 28E. The difference is subtle, but it's there.


Other than the fact the 28 f/1.4E is faster, sharper, has light-years better bokeh, less CA, and less vignetting ... you're "going to stick with the 28 D"?

You might want to really analyze that thought process ...

You say, "Not much else is missing," but in reality the 28D has 'not much to justify its existence' by comparison ...
Aug 08, 2017 at 01:29 PM
eke2k6
Offline
Details
p.11 #7Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
Joseph. wrote:
eke2k6 wroteJeez. I thought I was bad when it comes to going through gear
I guess you haven't met Jonathan and supermario??


I dare not mention the names of gods from my mortal mouth
Aug 08, 2017 at 02:11 PM
azenis
Offline
Details
p.11 #8Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
JohnK007 wrote:
azenis wroteAfter checking all the wonderful shots in this thread... (kudos to all!) I think I have concluded that I'd hold on to my 28D.

Other than some better CA suppression and a bit more sharpness, not much else is missing on the old 28D. In fact, I prefer the rendition on the 28D much better than 28E. The difference is subtle, but it's there.
Other than the fact the 28 f/1.4E is faster, sharper, has light-years better bokeh, less CA, and less vignetting ... you're "going to stick with the 28 D"?

You might want to really analyze that thought process ...

You say, "Not much else is missing," but in reality the 28D has 'not much to justify its existence' by comparison ...


Faster: tried both in store on a D4, speed difference? yes, but nowhere near in truly fast focusing primes like big teles vs. their AF counterparts or AF-D vs. sth like 24-70mm AF-S.

Sharper: Yes, I mentioned that but 28D is sharp enough for my needs.

Bokeh: light year better? please enlight me because I haven't seen anything that suggests that. Horatio at streetsilhouettes did a test on both and I find the bokeh more pleasing to my eyes on the 28D, but bokeh can be a subjective matter. To say "light year better", please do let me know what qualifies as a truly excellent bokeh on a wide angle lens before anything else.

Less vignetting/CA... etc: this is the same reason why I got rid of my Otus. Sure, they are sharper and have less optical deficiencies than most of the classic lenses. But at what cost? sterile images or "character". I have extremely hard time to tell apart a pic taken by Otus 55mm vs. another taken by Sigma 50mm Art. They are very close sharpness-wise and lacks any signature look or rendition.

By your definition of a better lens, no one should bother with 28E either... why not go Otus and get the "best" 28mm out there? Except for the lack of AF, it's better in pretty much every measurable optical term than the 28E.

My point is, 28E is no doubt an excellent lens. But not enough for me to give up the character of a 28D. I'm saying this as a 28D owner. 28E is not a viable upgrade... but rather tradeoffs I have to make.

Now, if I were to go out there and buy a 28mm today... the normal me would still pick 28D because it's a lens with character. If it's optical performance that I'm after, then I'd go for an Otus.
Aug 08, 2017 at 02:16 PM
JohnK007
Offline
Details
p.11 #9Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
azenis wrote:
Faster: tried both in store on a D4, speed difference? yes, but nowhere near in truly fast focusing primes like big teles vs. their AF counterparts or AF-D vs. sth like 24-70mm AF-S.


But faster nonetheless, right?



azenis wrote:
Sharper: Yes, I mentioned that but 28D is sharp enough for my needs.


The 2nd step in your compromising.

You've admitted to two of the points already.



azenis wrote:
Bokeh: light year better? please enlight me because I haven't seen anything that suggests that. Horatio at streetsilhouettes did a test on both and I find the bokeh more pleasing to my eyes on the 28D, but bokeh can be a subjective matter. To say "light year better", please do let me know what qualifies as a truly excellent bokeh on a wide angle lens before anything else.


The Nikkor 28 f/1.4 E has better bokeh than the Sigma 24 Arts and equal quality bokeh to the Otus. Please see these reference quotes:

    "The Nikkor AF-S 28 mm f/1.4E ED ... during our test it proved that it is able to compete on equal terms with the Otus 1.4/28, an instrument not only physically bigger but also much more expensive; apart from that the new Nikkor prevailed over the slower AF-S 28 mm f/1.8G model in practically all testing categories.."
    LensTip


  1. "The Sigma 24mm f1.4 Art ... cannot match the excellent center resolution or the Bokeh of the 28mm."

  2. "The Nikon 28mm f1.4E is a high quality wide lens that fills the gap between their 24/1.4G and 35/1.4G lenses for full-frame bodies. It delivers very good image quality coming close to or even surpassing the Zeiss Otus 28/1.4 in my tests ... all-in-all the new Nikon 28/1.4E decidedly looks like the better choice for everyday use.."
    Camera Labs




azenis wrote:
Less vignetting/CA... etc: this is the same reason why I got rid of my Otus. Sure, they are sharper and have less optical deficiencies than most of the classic lenses. But at what cost? sterile images or "character". I have extremely hard time to tell apart a pic taken by Otus 55mm vs. another taken by Sigma 50mm Art. They are very close sharpness-wise and lacks any signature look or rendition.


You shift gears to other lenses. The Sigma 50 Art is *not* the Nikkor 28mm D. (I never understood why people, when cornered with facts and logic ... instead of admitting the truth ... they "switch to something else" to keep talking.)

So let's come back to the subject lenses

The vignetting in your posted image is awful. Every image I've seen of the 28 f/1.4E shows both quality of bokeh as well as character.



azenis wrote:
By your definition of a better lens, no one should bother with 28E either... why not go Otus and get the "best" 28mm out there? Except for the lack of AF, it's better in pretty much every measurable optical term than the 28E.


You're wrong.

The Nikkor 28 E has bokeh as good as the Otus 28. It is sharper in the center, not so in the corners, but this only makes the Zeiss a better landscape lens. For humans (or food) a slight softening in the corners will only enhance its superior center-sharpness, and equal-quality bokeh effect, leaving a more compelling portrait/food/product image. The fact that the Nikkor is half the price, half the weight, and also AF means it blows the Zeiss out of the water as an overall tool for the money.



azenis wrote:
My point is, 28E is no doubt an excellent lens. But not enough for me to give up the character of a 28D. I'm saying this as a 28D owner. 28E is not a viable upgrade... but rather tradeoffs I have to make.


We disagree as to character.
Ultimately, it sounds like the only 'tradeoff' is selling your old lens, and trading extra money, to get the superior option.



azenis wrote:
Now, if I were to go out there and buy a 28mm today... the normal me would still pick 28D because it's a lens with character. If it's optical performance that I'm after, then I'd go for an Otus.


If you don't need AF, and need corner-to-corner sharpness, the Otus may be justified in spending more than twice as much, and carrying twice the weight.

If you shoot people or products, need AF, and appreciate center-sharpness ... with graduated bokeh-blur outward ... the Nikkor 28 f/1/4 E is the best lens period.
Aug 08, 2017 at 03:42 PM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.11 #10Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
I also prefer the overall rendering of the 28d.

azenis wrote:
JohnK007 wrote
azenis wroteAfter checking all the wonderful shots in this thread... (kudos to all!) I think I have concluded that I'd hold on to my 28D.

Other than some better CA suppression and a bit more sharpness, not much else is missing on the old 28D. In fact, I prefer the rendition on the 28D much better than 28E. The difference is subtle, but it's there.
Other than the fact the 28 f/1.4E is faster, sharper, has light-years better bokeh, less CA, and less vignetting ... you're "going to stick with the 28 D"?

You might want to really analyze that thought process ...

You say, "Not much else is missing," but in reality the 28D has 'not much to justify its existence' by comparison ...
Faster: tried both in store on a D4, speed difference? yes, but nowhere near in truly fast focusing primes like big teles vs. their AF counterparts or AF-D vs. sth like 24-70mm AF-S.

Sharper: Yes, I mentioned that but 28D is sharp enough for my needs.

Bokeh: light year better? please enlight me because I haven't seen anything that suggests that. Horatio at streetsilhouettes did a test on both and I find the bokeh more pleasing to my eyes on the 28D, but bokeh can be a subjective matter. To say "light year better", please do let me know what qualifies as
...Show more →
Aug 08, 2017 at 05:34 PM
supermario343
Offline
Details
p.11 #11Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
Joseph. wrote:
eke2k6 wroteJeez. I thought I was bad when it comes to going through gear
I guess you haven't met Jonathan and supermario??


Funny you say that...I ordered the lens this morning lol it's like you knew!
Aug 08, 2017 at 08:27 PM
ariel777
Offline
Details
p.11 #12Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
Supie, what took you so long?
Aug 08, 2017 at 08:56 PM
azenis
Offline
Details
p.11 #13Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
JohnK007 wrote:
If you shoot people or products, need AF, and appreciate center-sharpness ... with graduated bokeh-blur outward ... the Nikkor 28 f/1/4 E is the best lens period.


I don't want to argue useless points.

You are free to think that 28E is superior, but I am not convinced. Both lenses have their pros and cons, no argument on that. You prefer 28E's pros and think its cons are justifiable. I don't. I'm very picky when it comes to lens purchases and I only keep a lens if I feel it's worth the money. Even if it's a very very small point.

To give you an idea, take another Nikon lens for example, I got the 58G on day 1, believing that I was finally fulfilling my dream of having an AF Noct. Sold it after a month. Yes it has AF. It renders probably 98% of a Noct (I did a test between Noct, 58G and Noctilux a while back here), all the modern bells and whistles... But it wasn't a noct. It didn't feel as one and yes I was paying AF and their price difference for Noct's name and the mere 0.2 aperture difference. I found it justifiable.

So, let's just agree to disagree, and so no, 28E is NOT the best lens, period.
Aug 08, 2017 at 10:46 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.11 #14Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
The Nikon 28 1.4e has quite a bit of LoCA, which is one of the strengths of the Otus 28 and is achieved by all the special super low low dispersion elements in it which obviously add significantly to the price. This APO performance may or may not be important to you. Everyone weights all these things differently so hard to say it's the best period for everyone. Bokeh and rendering is subjective and a complex subject. Some like the undercorrected SA smoother, background obliterating bokeh type lenses like the 28d which will not be as sharp wide open as the .ore fully corrected SA lenses like the 28e. The shape of subjects in the OOF areas will retain their shape better which some like and seems to be what the Otus lenses were designed for.
I think the newer lenses are mostly designed this way for video.
I can appreciate both bokeh rendering styles and lots of times get different lenses in same FL to be able to choose which style I want for a particular situation. We should really be thankful there are so many choices.
Aug 08, 2017 at 10:58 PM
supermario343
Offline
Details
p.11 #15Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
ariel777 wrote:
Supie, what took you so long?


Been busy with life and real estate lately. I just hope I get enough time to enjoy it
Aug 09, 2017 at 06:29 AM
JohnK007
Offline
Details
p.11 #16Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
azenis wrote:
I don't want to argue useless points.


Then don't. Argue useful ones.



azenis wrote:
You are free to think that 28E is superior, but I am not convinced. Both lenses have their pros and cons, no argument on that. You prefer 28E's pros and think its cons are justifiable. I don't. I'm very picky when it comes to lens purchases and I only keep a lens if I feel it's worth the money. Even if it's a very very small point.


Same here. I don't think the 28D has a single 'pro' over the 28E.

The Otus may have a few, which it should at that price point, but I don't think the 28D does ... or, at least, have yet to be convinced.



azenis wrote:
To give you an idea, take another Nikon lens for example, I got the 58G on day 1, believing that I was finally fulfilling my dream of having an AF Noct. Sold it after a month. Yes it has AF. It renders probably 98% of a Noct (I did a test between Noct, 58G and Noctilux a while back here), all the modern bells and whistles... But it wasn't a noct. It didn't feel as one and yes I was paying AF and their price difference for Noct's name and the mere 0.2 aperture difference. I found it justifiable.


Good point. However, this would be a good (and comparable) argument for favoring the twice-as-much, both optically-superior *Otus 28* over the Nikkor 28E ... but there is no 'superior edge' like this that the 28D enjoys.



azenis wrote:
So, let's just agree to disagree, and so no, 28E is NOT the best lens, period.


Okay, we can agree to disagree. However, at least quote me correctly. I didn't call the 28E 'the best lens,' period; I called it the best AF 28mm lens, and that spills into the 24mm Sigma Art territory, as well as into 35mm territory. But your point about, the 28mm Otus would probably fall into the Noct analogy you describe above.
Aug 09, 2017 at 07:58 AM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.11 #17Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
John.

Just a friendly suggestion that you may want to consider. Rather than arguing what lens is best, maybe let people know what lens you prefer and for what reasons. There really is no "best" lens at anything unless you clearly define what you are comparing. (ie, sharpness, af speed, build quality, price etc) If you add multiple variables to define what is the best, then that muddies the water further and for subjective qualities like bokeh, you can't define "best". Add too many variables for comparison and it quickly becomes an argument of semantics.

Corey
Aug 09, 2017 at 09:07 AM
Vcook
Offline
Details
p.11 #18Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
JohnK007 wrote:
Same here. I don't think the 28D has a single 'pro' over the 28E.


Price
Aug 09, 2017 at 09:48 AM
eke2k6
Offline
Details
p.11 #19Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
JohnK007 wrote:
azenis wroteI don't want to argue useless points.
Then don't. Argue useful ones.




Interesting thought. Perhaps apply it to yourself.

You chastised the guy for bringing in other lenses into the 28E vs 28D debate, but you've repeatedly tried comparing the 28E's bokeh to that of wider and tighter lenses like the 24mm and 35mm, when even an amateur would know that even 4mm of extra compression on the wide end is quite significant (see Elijah's recent take on why he returned the 28E for the 35G).

My interactions with you in the 135mm Art thread have shown you have a very pointed tongue when discussing lenses you've neither seen nor touched, much less used. Especially confusing is the matter-of-fact pseudo-scientific tone you take when picking apart another person's preferences.

Perhaps reconsider your approach, or justify it by acquiring the lenses you have such strong opinions about and conducting your own tests.It will garner a good bit more respect for your opinion - at least from me.


Aug 09, 2017 at 10:11 AM
Elijah
Offline
Details
p.11 #20Nikon 28mm f/1.4E ED Image Thread
eke2k6 wrote:
JohnK007 wrote
azenis wroteI don't want to argue useless points.
Then don't. Argue useful ones.
Interesting thought. Perhaps apply it to yourself.

You chastised the guy for bringing in other lenses into the 28E vs 28D debate, but you've repeatedly tried comparing the 28E's bokeh to that of wider and tighter lenses like the 24mm and 35mm, when even an amateur would know that even 4mm of extra compression on the wide end is quite significant (see Elijah's recent take on why he returned the 28E for the 35G).

My interactions with you in the 135mm Art thread have shown you have a very pointed tongue when discussing lenses you've neither seen nor touched, much less
...Show more →






Aug 09, 2017 at 10:30 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister