molson wrote:
The IQ3 backs are still cropped from the 645 format, so they are "miniMF" as well.
Someone made a similar funny claim here earlier about full frame since some are not 24mm x 36mm but are actually 23.9mm x 35.9mm. ;-)
Go back and see how close the 645 film area is to the IQ3 size.
[quot]If you want to get really technical, the GFX and X1D systems are actually "full frame" because there is no crop factor with any lens that will mount directly to the camera.
I can't make sense out of that.
"Crop factor" always a relative scale that reflects differences in size (to say it a simple way) between multiple formats. We are used to referencing it to full frame, but that isn't a requirement. (Canon is 1.6x crop, Fujifilm is 1.5x, and micro fourth thirds is 2x cropped.)
Depending on how you measure it*, the difference between miniMF and full frame is much smaller than that between full frame and the 1.5x and 1.6x cropped factors, perhaps being in a range between about 1.2 and 1.4. (Differences in measurement depend on whether you go simply by diagonal dimensions or try to use the same aspect ratio in both cases, and which aspect ratio you choose in the latter case.)
Alternatively, we could call the 44x33 sensors "SuperMF" just as APS-C sized cameras have been called "Super35" since before digital was invented.
Oh, boy. That's not really making your case.
35mm has always been called 35mm because the film width was 35mm. "Super35" was a motion picture film format that slightly increased the image area by comparison to traditional 35mm film format. Among other things, this was done to provide a "wider" aspect ratio on the same motion picture film stock.
(Likewise 645, 6x6, 6x7 and other medium formats all used the 6cm wide film — this doesn't refer to image area or aspect ratio.)
On the other hand, it makes at least as much sense, I suppose, to call 33mm x 44mm format "superFullFrame" then, right? ;-)
In the end, miniMF is really clearly exactly what we know it to be: a 33mm x 44mm digital format — larger than full frame and smaller than any pre-existing MF format. Clear, concise, accurate, and it gives the format the benefit of claiming an MF connection. Seems odd that folks get hung up on calling a smaller-than-traditional-MF format by a name that is accurate and clear.
(At times I wish that Pentax had never tried to suggest that its 33 x 44 cameras were 645 format cameras. Leica was less devious with its name for its own 30mm x 45mm sensor format.)
Dan