gdanmitchell wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
Perspective refers to the relative sizes and positions of objects as seen by the lens — consisting of depth, up/down and left/right positioning, and where they appear in the frame. (You can do a web search on "definition of perspective in photography" and find lots of descriptions.)
A change in perspective is produced by moving the camera position.
By definition, there should be no difference in perspective among photographs of a scene made from the same camera position and using lenses with the same angle-of-view.
(Technically, using a lens with a different angle-of-view doesn't change perspective. That isn't actually relevant here since we can duplicate the angles-of-view with different formats by using different focal lengths.)
There may be one added complexity when comparing miniMF 33x44 (and other) formats with a 4:3 aspect ration to full frame (and other) formats with a 3:2 aspect ratio if you plan to use the entire frame in both cases. (If, like me in most cases, you crop the 3:2 full frame image to 4:3 or you crop the 4:3 image to 3:2 this issue is moot.) I don't see that as relevant in the case we are discussing here, though I'm mentioning it in case someone was thinking of that option. But here, the difference cuts both ways, if you think about it carefully. I'll just leave that there, since a full explanation gets complicated...
Dan Thanks for the reply. I think that's what everyone is trying to say here: moving from full frame at 18mm to miniMF at 23mm causes a perspective change when you keep the FOV the same because keeping the FOV the same necessitates a change in camera position. So, how is that an advantage of medium format cameras, as the other poster wrote in the post to which I replied? You can move to different focal lengths on the same camera (whether miniMF, full frame, crop, or whatever). You could even use a focal length with a larger angle-of-view on a camera with a smaller format and move forward.
If the point is that using a different focal and changing camera position affects the composition... that doesn't tell us anything about format comparisons.
I'm still trying to figure out what it is that I supposedly don't understand about this.
Dan
The change in composition results in a change in the spatial character of the image. That's as simply as I can define it. Is that an advantage? Some are saying they prefer the spatial character of MF over full frame, and that is a subjective conclusion. Perhaps it boils down to how we are comparing this to our own human vision:
Everyone has had the experience early in their photographic endeavors of being presented with a majestic landscape scene only to be dissapointed with how it looks after raising the camera with wide angle lens to their eye. Those mountains across the horizon, they seem so much smaller. Why is it that nearly every wide angle landscape photo needs a big foreground object to pull off the shot? It's more than the application of good compositional rules, it's also a technique for making the most out of the way a wide angle renders a given scene.
Now imagine what if I could see this same majestic landscape, and when I raised the camera to my eye, the mountains didn't seem to recede as far away? I can still use an interesting object in the foreground to create a nice composition that leads the viewer's eye through the image, but I can show them the scene more as I saw it with my human eyes. I realize this is subjective. It may be an advantage in some instances to minimize objects at infinity and exaggerate foreground objects, but not to me.
For the same reason – the comparison with human vision – medium format can give a normal to telephoto scene a unique quality. Is it better? I find it more interesting. Will you? I couldn't say. The example I gave a few posts ago (lighting not withstanding) of a Canon 5D with a Zeiss 50mm Makro @f/2 next to a GFX with the 63mm at f/2.8 demonstrates how changing formats and camera position to keep the same FOV affects the viewer's perception of the image. Can you see it? I can. Is it better? I like it better. I have always disliked the 50mm on full format because of the way it renders space. It makes me want to yawn, even with interesting compositions. But when I look at images from the 63mm on the GFX, my mind says, "Hey, wait, something's different here, I'm seeing a "normal" field of view, but with the perspective/spatial quality that says 'mild telephoto'. Interesting..."