mjm6 wrote:
molson wrote
mjm6 wrote
molson wrote
rsk7 wrote
mmm55 wrote
Regarding diffraction, f/16 on this sensor size is pretty safe Not trying to start a debate here but from my testing there is quite a bit of noticeable diffraction between f/8 and f/16. f/16 is fine for the web but for large printing I'm going to focus stack and stay f/11 or under if I'm trying to stay sharp front to back. Other thing is DOF is thinner on GFX than FF or APS-C. I was caught off guard when I first got my GFX with both DOF and diffraction. Test for yourself and shoot for your purpose and you will be happy. Even pixel-peeping at 100% magnification, diffraction is not really noticeable until you hit f/22 with the GF 23mm f4, and even then, it's not bad; image quality does suffer at f/32. This is completely different than my experience. On my 23mm lens, the diffraction is visible in comparisons at f11 and pretty clearly visible at f16.
I suspect that in the center, the lens is sharpest at about f5.6 or so, and in the corners, maybe f8, but I haven't tested it really carefully for that.
While I will typically shoot at f 5.6 or f8 to maximize sharpness with the focus shift function to merge, I normally also take a shot at f16 or f22 or so, especially if it is a bit breezy. These are so clearly inferior to a focus shifted stack that they basically will never get used, but for insurance, I make the shot. I'm not sure how you arrived at that opinion, but I'm pretty sure you're in the minority. Are you saying that diffraction-induced resolution reduction isn't visible in comparisons at f11 and f16 to larger apertures?
Isn't whether it is visible or not totally depend on how big you are viewing the image on the screen or how big you are printing it? Sure I can see a slight reduction in sharpness due to diffraction at f/11 and a bit larger reduction in resolution at f/16 if I view an image at 1 to 1 magnification, but even at 1 to 2 magnification I am hard pressed to see even the reduction of sharpness you see at f/16 and at the typical size most images are presented here and most places on the web I wouldn't see the reduction in sharpness from f/16 at all. The situation is of course similar for prints--whether you are likely to see decreases in sharpness depends on how big you print and how close you want to get to the prints. If I print 16 X 12 at normal viewing distances I don't see the reduction in sharpness from diffraction of even f/16, and I can go to 24 X 18 and not see the reduction in sharpness from f/11. Perhaps a particular image might be different, but that is the typical situation for me. Of course your tastes, discernment, and mileage may vary.