nehemiahphoto wrote:
...The Minolta 58 1.2 hard vignettes more, and even before the hard vingetting, the corners get wonky...
Like a lot of adapted lenses used in this thread, the Minolta 58 1.2 works well at close distance when the vignetting adds to the look of the image (many examples in the GFX FB group). I'll go back and re-test mine – if there was a hard vignette, a minor crop removed it. Wondering out loud if there could be minor variations between versions over the years. In any case, there is an artistic use for the Minolta 58 1.2 outside the bounds of the 35mm frame.
As a general statement for people new to adapting to 44x33: Most all 135-format lenses from 50mm and wider will have soft to smeared corners (often but not always with heavy vignetting), so when I see wide angle lenses in a list, I assume no one is shooting infinity landscapes at full 44x33 with them unless they are going for a casual/vintage look. Also most all of these lenses can be shot at 1:1, 16:9, or XPan ratio with great results. For example, the Contax Zeiss 35mm f/1.4 (C/Y) has unusable corner smearing for infinity shots even stopped down to f11, but can be cropped somewhere between 44x33 and 135-format and look great. You can even use it full width XPan ratio and the farthest edges are no more soft than the X100F. Another way to cheat the corner performance and vignetting on many lenses is to use them with extension tubes.
Using distortion correction in C1/LR/PS on the wide lenses (either by profile or by generic) often will hide the darkest hard corners left over after light falloff/vignette correction. Lenses with a profile available in C1/LR/PS are much easier to correct light falloff for since the profile is applying a custom correction based on the lens – makes a big difference compared to just using the Vignette slider. (Many of the Contax Zeiss C/Y lenses have Zeiss ZE/ZF-equivalent profiles that work perfectly.)
It will be interesting to see if the BSI sensor on the GFX 100 helps improve corner performance on adapted lenses.