rbf_ wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
Veering a bit off topic, but I've always been fascinated with people's reaction to strong color. Strong color warms some people, yet offends others. I'm also fascinated when people react negatively to photos they deem "unnatural", as if they are somehow being cheated by being shown something that is not real. It's interesting that the same person who reacts negatively to oversaturated color in a photograph often has a completely different reaction to an oil painting that goes even further. I suppose many people have an implied "trust" in photographs. Photographs have a duty to show them reality, and when their brain tells them they are not seeing reality, the aesthetic opinion of the work is diminished. There is a lot to think about in that paragraph, and it aligns with much of my thinking and that of quite a few photographers.
The "implied 'trust'" issue is a tricky one. I'm not one to set objective boundaries around what a photograph can and cannot do. There is an element of "honesty" and "truth" in art and in photographs, but that is more complex than some attempt at objective reality in a photograph. (In my view, and objectively real photograph is an impossibility.)
As an example of how complicated this is, and perhaps of how some principles can work across a wide range of work, consider a couple of things we may have seen.
In the first case, think of some of those photographic images that, for example, add a gigantic and obviously impossible moon into a landscape photograph. While we can't (or at least I can't) say that this is wrong or shouldn't be done, I/we can think about how this works in the relationship between the photographer and viewer. Most viewers — as long as they aren't photographers or astronomers — simply find such things "spectacular" and see them as extraordinary "captures" of something in the real world that normal people simply don't see. Some photographers may go even further and — as in one famous example that I won't identify — accompany the image with text describing the incredible lengths the photographer went to in order to find and capture this spectacular and elusive phenomenon.
The problem that such photographs bring is that the extent to which they "work" depends almost wholly on a deception that is made particularly strong when the image of the moon is presented in photographic form, using a medium that most viewers trust to represent the reality it captured. Take away the deception — tell the viewer that it was a photoshop trick — and the power of the image is gone.
In a second case, consider the work of photographers such as Jerry Uelsmann or others who "construct" fantastical images using photographic techniques. (A couple years ago I saw marvelous prints by a Chinese photographer that edited together large numbers of photographs of buildings in order to create impossible architectures.) Uelsmann, using film technology, produces imaginary landscapes which, for example, may combine the nude human form with natural landscapes.
What he does is no more or less unreal than what the "giant moon" photographer does — so it can't simply be the use of manipulative techniques that is the problem. It is the context. Uelsmann is not trying to trick anyone. His work is utterly honest and truthful. It presents his own subjective reality, constructed photographically. It would be absurd to object to it because it involves manipulations. The answer to that would be, "Of course!"
I have a friend who once reminded me that the simplest and least sophisticated response to a temptation or a challenge is to resort to simple rule following, and that a more sophisticated response involves considering complex and sometimes contradictory elements and then making a case-by-case judgment. I think that is true of photography, too.
Speaking for myself, I'm very put off by the giant moon school of photography, but I'm very impressed by the kinds of imaginary work done by people like Uelsmann.
And finally, for me, the goal of simply recreating some sort of objective photographic recording of "the thing I saw" is both impossible (all photographs lie) and pointless (it can never be more real than the thing itself). To me, the most interesting photographs show me how the photographer sees the world, and even includes me in that constructed world. I've also wondered why these same photographers who are allergic to vivid colors as "not what I saw" although we encounter and see them often in real life are also often romantically attached to Black and White photography. I like B+W photography myself but I've never seen anything in B+W. It seems to be an inconsistent position to hold. It's probably also prudent to note that people perceptions and biological ability to see color varies a bit and isn't standard.
I think the key lies in the concept of “suspension of disbelief” whereby black and white photos innately telegraph their intent to the viewer saying, “This is not reality, but you like it, don’t you?”
Another big win for black and white is even though it’s less real than a color photograph, it is simpler, less complex. The viewer can make aesthetic observations about the scene they may have overlooked in a color photo. People seem less likely to fault a b&w shot for a dramatically-black daytime sky than they are to criticize an overly deep blue sky in a color photo — even though both may have been shot with the same level of polarization.