fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness

  
 
madlantern
Offline

p.1 #1FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
After getting a Sony body, I've been comparing sony vs canon lens sharpness. I'm surprised at relatively how close the Sony 16-35mm is tot the Canon, since the Canon is brand new and very well reviewed. All tests done on a tripod on the A7r II with a Metabones IV adapter. (raw files still uploading).

16mm f/8



16mm f/2.8
Dec 11, 2016 at 03:13 AM
phuviano
Offline
Details
p.1 #2FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Canon looks sharper (viewing on my iPhone). Looks like a very nice lens indeed.
Dec 11, 2016 at 03:27 AM
MJKoski
Offline
Details
p.1 #3FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Canon looks a lot sharper AND you should remember that MB-adapter most likely ruins adapted lens' performance towards edges without proper shimming. Especially with wide angle lenses.
Dec 11, 2016 at 04:54 AM
madlantern
Offline
Details
p.1 #4FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
MJKoski wrote:
Canon looks a lot sharper AND you should remember that MB-adapter most likely ruins adapted lens' performance towards edges without proper shimming. Especially with wide angle lenses.


Indeed the Canon is sharper. But I was nonetheless impressed by how sharp the Sony is consider its small size.

How do you shim an adapter?
Dec 11, 2016 at 05:25 AM
Disaster
Offline
Details
p.1 #5FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Agree on Canon kickin b_tt. What are your favorite Canon lenses adapted to the Sony?
Dec 11, 2016 at 06:04 AM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.1 #6FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
What part of the frame did these crops come from?

I have not used the Canon 16-35 III, however in my own experience with the Sony 16-35 the center was just fine, it was for me always the edges that left a lot to be desired.
Dec 11, 2016 at 06:44 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.1 #7FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
For me, in real world shooting with the lighter Sony and the OSS, I would think I would get more keepers and sharper images as I use my Sony for street shooting many times in dark areas where the lighter lens and especially the OSS will overcome any slight sharpness gains the Canon lens has.

Sometimes real world shooting conditions need to be taken into account when looking at the performance of one lens over another...that is unless you are into shooting test charts off a tripod.
Dec 11, 2016 at 08:16 AM
3catsinky
Offline
Details
p.1 #8FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Yikes. that Sony doesnt look very impressive. Batis 18 instead.
Dec 11, 2016 at 09:09 AM
engardeknave
Offline
Details
p.1 #9FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Exif info and labels don't appear to match. Obvious motion blurring in the third photo.
Dec 11, 2016 at 09:58 AM
MJKoski
Offline
Details
p.1 #10FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
xoda wrote:
MJKoski wroteCanon looks a lot sharper AND you should remember that MB-adapter most likely ruins adapted lens' performance towards edges without proper shimming. Especially with wide angle lenses.
Indeed the Canon is sharper. But I was nonetheless impressed by how sharp the Sony is consider its small size.

How do you shim an adapter?


If you use MB adapter, you can remove the metal ring surface which is in contact with lens and insert thin metal foils in there to adjust sensor to lens distance. Not all adapters need this, but some do as there seems to be some copy-to-copy variance. Especially with A7R2. I had very mushy results towards edges with Canon 24mm TS-E mk2 with a7r2 using MB4-T but the same lens worked just fine with 5Dsr.

I do not remember who it was but anyway, some user here posted very nice guide to shimming metabones for use with TS-E lenses (17mm and 24mm).
Dec 11, 2016 at 10:38 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #11FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
The Sony 16-35/4 has better resolution at long distances (infinity). Most of the reviews test it at close distance.
Also at 16mm f/8 it looks worse than at f/5.6 (even for the edges). In fact, after f/5, there is no resolution/contrast gain center or extreme corners at 16mm. With my copy, 18-24mm needs f/5.6, 28mm needs f/6.3 and 35mm needs f/9 for even sharpness across the field.
Dec 11, 2016 at 11:27 AM
MJKoski
Offline
Details
p.1 #12FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Diglloyd review of Canon MKIII (shot with Canon body) shows very good results at distance. My Zony 16-35 was nowhere near as good at infinity. However, using Canon 16-35/4L with Fotodiox or MB4-T gave me total failure at infinity with A7R2 - I could get the center sharp or the edges. Never both. Again, the adapter failed to make the adapted lens work properly. I should have some test shots available from that experiment in my archive.

This is Canon 16-35/4L & Fotodiox Pro adapter on A7R2. Test scene as follows:

http://mjkoski.1g.fi/kuvat/Miscellaneous/trash/canon1635_sony/_DSC0555.jpg/_full.jpg

Lens wide open, focused to the brick wall of the building on the right. We see the lens resolves nicely:

http://mjkoski.1g.fi/kuvat/Miscellaneous/trash/canon1635_sony/_DSC0555-2.jpg/_full.jpg

Now, let us have a look at distance in the center of the image:

http://mjkoski.1g.fi/kuvat/Miscellaneous/trash/canon1635_sony/_DSC0555-3.jpg/_full.jpg

What the Insane field curvature. That did not happen with a Canon body.

Now, focused in the center we get rich details (but edges were totally blurred):

http://mjkoski.1g.fi/kuvat/Miscellaneous/trash/canon1635_sony/_DSC0557.jpg/_full.jpg

...

So I will never ever use a wide angle again adapted to Sony. Only native lenses.
Dec 12, 2016 at 07:46 AM
InFocus2014
Online
Details
p.1 #13FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
I sold my FE 16-35mm f4 some time ago. From 16mm to about 28mm it was a great lens, but it was too soft at 35mm f4 for my taste. I replaced it with the Canon 16-35mm f4L, which was noticeably sharper at some settings (all on my A7RII's).

I also shoot Canon 5DSR's, so I purchased the new Canon 16-35mm f2.8L III. This lens is absolutely stunning and it also works great on on my A7RII's. As a note, it works well with both the MBIV and MC-11 (latest firmware on both adapters), although the MB-IV allows for Eye Focus, which the MC-11 does not provide for on Canon lenses.

Dec 12, 2016 at 04:41 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.1 #14FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
MJKoski wrote:
Diglloyd review of Canon MKIII (shot with Canon body) shows very good results at distance. My Zony 16-35 was nowhere near as good at infinity. However, using Canon 16-35/4L with Fotodiox or MB4-T gave me total failure at infinity with A7R2 - I could get the center sharp or the edges. Never both. Again, the adapter failed to make the adapted lens work properly. I should have some test shots available from that experiment in my archive.

This is Canon 16-35/4L & Fotodiox Pro adapter on A7R2. Test scene as follows:

http://mjkoski.1g.fi/kuvat/Miscellaneous/trash/canon1635_sony/_DSC0555.jpg/_full.jpg

Lens wide open, focused to the brick wall of the building
...Show more →

These lenses do have moderate field curvature wide open (Canon and Sony). Try doing the same test at f/5.6 and the field should flatten quite a bit.
However, your sample is very extreme and I'm sure it's related to your adapter flange distance. If the adapter is not up to specs, it will induce field curvature.
I would try a different adapter.
Dec 22, 2016 at 03:33 PM
davidbogdan
Offline
Details
p.1 #15FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Been through 2 copies of the fe 16-35 and in the past have shot the nikon 14-24 for a few years followed by the sony 16-35 f/2.8. None of the above can match my Tamron 15-30 f/2.8. The new Canon will be doing well if it can match or maybe even slightly surpass the Tammy in one aspect or another at twice the price.

db
Dec 25, 2016 at 07:55 PM
chiron
Online
Details
p.1 #16FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
chez wrote:
For me, in real world shooting with the lighter Sony and the OSS, I would think I would get more keepers and sharper images as I use my Sony for street shooting many times in dark areas where the lighter lens and especially the OSS will overcome any slight sharpness gains the Canon lens has.

Sometimes real world shooting conditions need to be taken into account when looking at the performance of one lens over another...that is unless you are into shooting test charts off a tripod.


Yes, for most hand held shooting, which is what I usually am doing, image stabilization improves my sharpness also, probably more than marginal optical differences do. But this may be becoming moot with IBIS--I am still getting used to having it on the 6500.

For a landscaper on a tripod, it might be a different story, although then you are probably shooting at f/8 or greater, and the lenses may be very similar at those apertures.
Dec 25, 2016 at 10:35 PM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.1 #17FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Fred Miranda wrote:
MJKoski wroteSo I will never ever use a wide angle again adapted to Sony. Only native lenses.
These lenses do have moderate field curvature wide open (Canon and Sony). Try doing the same test at f/5.6 and the field should flatten quite a bit.
However, your sample is very extreme and I'm sure it's related to your adapter flange distance. If the adapter is not up to specs, it will induce field curvature.
I would try a different adapter.


Hi Fred,

Does the adapter-induced field curvature you mention present itself even if the lens does not have a floating element? I have heard many times that an adapter which is too short will cause problems with a lens using a floating element, but I am unsure whether the problem may also occur on a UWA without one.

I have been testing out my Tamron 15-30 on my A7RII (Novoflex adapter) today. As far as I know, it does not have a floating element (maybe it does - but I can find no reference to one whatsoever online) however shooting at 15mm wide open I find more field curvature is present than I observe on my D810. It is nowhere near as extreme as the example posted by MJKoski, but it is nonetheless a noticeable difference. At f8 (only other tested aperture) the effect is gone.

The Novoflex is definitely too short, but I don't know whether this will make a difference on a UWA if it doesn't have a floating element in it?
Jan 04, 2017 at 03:31 AM
scrappydog
Offline
Details
p.1 #18FE 16-35 f/4 vs EF 16-35 f/2.8 III sharpness
Disaster wrote:
Agree on Canon kickin b_tt. What are your favorite Canon lenses adapted to the Sony?


The 16-35/4, 24-70/2.8 II, 70-200/2.8 II, 100-400 II, 400/5.6, and 500/4 II are all sharp and perform well with the MB IV. The 24-70 and 100-400's bokeh are pretty ugly. If you include non-Canon EF glass, the Zeiss Distagon 25/2 ZE is its usual awesome self on the A7RII (it's a "character" lens and the extreme edges are soft regardless of the camera it is mounted on). I get distortion with my TS-E 17, which I haven't shimmed, with my MB IV and generic EF-to-Sony E-mount adapters.
Jan 06, 2017 at 06:31 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister