fredmiranda.com Login

Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar

  
 
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #1Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Luvwine wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
pdmphoto wroteIt is, without a doubt, a fine lens. Being a 65mm lens, and a macro lens that only does 2:1 does make it a bit of an oddball. Regardless, I have wanted this lens from the beginning. The problem is I aquired the Loxia 85/2.4 waiting for it. I can put two small extension tubes on the Loxia and get 2:1 macro. And I get more working distance. I might like the bokeh from the 85 w/wo the tubes better than the 65.
Sure, but putting the tubes on the Voigtlander gets you to close to 1:1 I would think. Having said that, the Loxia 85 is a great lens and if the focal length works for you, what is the problem? For me, I like having both, but that means carrying more weight and spending more money and everyone has different tolerances for both.
The FC's fairly horrendous on the CV 65 on tubes. The FLE giveth, the FLE taketh away.
I shot some flower pics with tubes and did not notice a problem, of course, the subjects were not Edge to edge. I am not saying you are incorrect, just that it did not cause me difficulties i noticed in my limited use.


Don't you think your dime shot showed it clearly? Or was that an uneven surface?
Aug 23, 2017 at 09:09 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #2Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Sounds very good than. Anything that can beat a Rodie I'm in.
Aug 23, 2017 at 09:10 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.14 #3Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
freaklikeme wrote:
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
pdmphoto wroteIt is, without a doubt, a fine lens. Being a 65mm lens, and a macro lens that only does 2:1 does make it a bit of an oddball. Regardless, I have wanted this lens from the beginning. The problem is I aquired the Loxia 85/2.4 waiting for it. I can put two small extension tubes on the Loxia and get 2:1 macro. And I get more working distance. I might like the bokeh from the 85 w/wo the tubes better than the 65.
Sure, but putting the tubes on the Voigtlander gets you to close to 1:1 I would think. Having said that, the Loxia 85 is a great lens and if the focal length works for you, what is the problem? For me, I like having both, but that means carrying more weight and spending more money and everyone has different tolerances for both.
The FC's fairly horrendous on the CV 65 on tubes. The FLE giveth, the FLE taketh away.
I shot some flower pics with tubes and did not notice a problem, of course, the subjects were not Edge to edge. I am not saying you are incorrect, just that it did not cause me difficulties i noticed in my limited use.
Don't you think your dime shot showed it clearly? Or was that an uneven surface?


Well, I looked at that pic and the lower right corner of the desk surface in the pic is not level as it has a lip down toward the edge. I also cannot swear the camera was perfectly level with the desk as I was only concerned with getting the dime in focus to show magnification. Having said this, the corners are weak and that my well be caused by FC. Still, often when going for magnification of a small subject, some FC won't matter. I used I think a 16mm tube for this shot: http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/image/166045812 And I don't think it hurts anything. My original point is that the CV is more versatile than the Loxia 85 and I think it is basically correct. I own both and love the Loxia. I also am a huge fan of my Leica R 180 apo elmarit, so I cannot quarrel with your taste in glass! 😊
Aug 23, 2017 at 09:34 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #4Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
To be fair to the Rodie, the a7rII has a smaller pixel pitch than that for which it was designed. It's still the king for a 40mp 33x44 sensor and has enough IC to make a nice normal PC lens for my Aptus 75. It also plays better with the Kolari mod, so, in my mind, it's the clear winner.
Aug 23, 2017 at 09:37 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #5Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Luvwine wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
pdmphoto wroteIt is, without a doubt, a fine lens. Being a 65mm lens, and a macro lens that only does 2:1 does make it a bit of an oddball. Regardless, I have wanted this lens from the beginning. The problem is I aquired the Loxia 85/2.4 waiting for it. I can put two small extension tubes on the Loxia and get 2:1 macro. And I get more working distance. I might like the bokeh from the 85 w/wo the tubes better than the 65.
Sure, but putting the tubes on the Voigtlander gets you to close to 1:1 I would think. Having said that, the Loxia 85 is a great lens and if the focal length works for you, what is the problem? For me, I like having both, but that means carrying more weight and spending more money and everyone has different tolerances for both.
The FC's fairly horrendous on the CV 65 on tubes. The FLE giveth, the FLE taketh away.
I shot some flower pics with tubes and did not notice a problem, of course, the subjects were not Edge to edge. I am not saying you are incorrect, just that it did not cause me difficulties i noticed in my limited use.
Don't you think your dime shot showed it clearly? Or was that an uneven surface?
Well, I looked at that pic and the lower right corner of the desk surface in the pic is not level as it has a lip down toward the edge. I also cannot swear the camera was perfectly level with the desk as I was only concerned with getting the dime in focus to show magnification. Having said this, the corners are weak and that my well be caused by FC. Still, often when going for magnification of a small subject, some FC won't matter. I used I think a 16mm tube for this shot: http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/image/166045812 And I don't think
...Show more →

Yeah, I should probably qualify "horrendous". I used postage stamps when I was testing it, and for flat surface reproduction, I think it would bother anyone. For objects with greater depth, it wouldn't be as noticeable.

And I agree with your assessment regarding the Loxia, but I do think it makes a better portrait lens.
Aug 23, 2017 at 09:47 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.14 #6Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
freaklikeme wrote:
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wroteSure, but putting the tubes on the Voigtlander gets you to close to 1:1 I would think. Having said that, the Loxia 85 is a great lens and if the focal length works for you, what is the problem? For me, I like having both, but that means carrying more weight and spending more money and everyone has different tolerances for both.
The FC's fairly horrendous on the CV 65 on tubes. The FLE giveth, the FLE taketh away.
I shot some flower pics with tubes and did not notice a problem, of course, the subjects were not Edge to edge. I am not saying you are incorrect, just that it did not cause me difficulties i noticed in my limited use.
Don't you think your dime shot showed it clearly? Or was that an uneven surface?
Well, I looked at that pic and the lower right corner of the desk surface in the pic is not level as it has a lip down toward the edge. I also cannot swear the camera was perfectly level with the desk as I was only concerned with getting the dime in focus to show magnification. Having said this, the corners are weak and that my well be caused by FC. Still, often when going for magnification of a small subject, some FC won't matter. I used I think a 16mm tube for this shot: http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/image/166045812 And I don't think it hurts anything. My original point is that the CV is more versatile than the Loxia 85 and I think it is basically correct. I own both and love the Loxia. I also am a huge fan of my Leica R 180 apo elmarit, so I cannot quarrel with your taste in glass! 😊
Yeah, I should probably qualify "horrendous". I used postage stamps when I was testing it, and for flat surface reproduction, I think it would bother anyone. For objects with greater depth, it wouldn't be as noticeable.

And I agree with your assessment regarding the Loxia, but I do think it makes a better portrait lens.


Sounds right. Not arguing, but curious, are you using an UT Kolari modded A7RII for testing? If so, would that exacerbate the FC versus a stock camera?

Re: Loxia 85, agreed. I too like the focal length better for portraiture than the CV 65. I like the GM 85 and 100 STF better too, but the Voigtlander will do in a pinch. Having lower native contrast than the Loxia is also nice for portraits (but does not alter or overcome the focal length advantage of 85 over 65).
Aug 23, 2017 at 10:05 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.14 #7Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Does it have lower contrast than the Loxia 50/2 at around f/5.6? I wish Voigtlander would start posting MTF graphs...
Aug 23, 2017 at 10:16 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.14 #8Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Does it have lower contrast than the Loxia 50/2 at around f/5.6? I wish Voigtlander would start posting MTF graphs...


Agreed on the MTF graphs. Here are a few test shots I took where the light was similar (I think) and where both pics are shot at F5.6 with NO post processing other than lightroom import and changed color temp to "daylight" for both: Let me know if you want crops (Loxia then Voigtlander all at F5.6):











I have more if you want cityscapes or waterfalls or what have you. To me, the Loxia has a bit more contrast pre-processing and has a bit more 3D effect. Sharpness, color correction are different stories--especially at wider apertures. Tell me if you agree.

Edit: Two more both at F5.6 and same exposure (1/125):





And another:





Edited on Aug 23, 2017 at 11:35 PM · View previous versions
Aug 23, 2017 at 10:56 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #9Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Luvwine wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wroteThe FC's fairly horrendous on the CV 65 on tubes. The FLE giveth, the FLE taketh away.
I shot some flower pics with tubes and did not notice a problem, of course, the subjects were not Edge to edge. I am not saying you are incorrect, just that it did not cause me difficulties i noticed in my limited use.
Don't you think your dime shot showed it clearly? Or was that an uneven surface?
Well, I looked at that pic and the lower right corner of the desk surface in the pic is not level as it has a lip down toward the edge. I also cannot swear the camera was perfectly level with the desk as I was only concerned with getting the dime in focus to show magnification. Having said this, the corners are weak and that my well be caused by FC. Still, often when going for magnification of a small subject, some FC won't matter. I used I think a 16mm tube for this shot: http://www.pbase.com/luvwine/image/166045812 And I don't think it hurts anything. My original point is that the CV is more versatile than the Loxia 85 and I think it is basically correct. I own both and love the Loxia. I also am a huge fan of my Leica R 180 apo elmarit, so I cannot quarrel with your taste in glass! 😊
Yeah, I should probably qualify "horrendous". I used postage stamps when I was testing it, and for flat surface reproduction, I think it would bother anyone. For objects with greater depth, it wouldn't be as noticeable.

And I agree with your assessment regarding the Loxia, but I do think it makes a better portrait lens.
Sounds right. Not arguing, but curious, are you using an UT Kolari modded A7RII for testing? If so, would that exacerbate the FC versus a stock camera?


It is worse on the UT, but I have both stock and modded, so all of the tests were with both cameras. I was nervous about the mod, so I picked up a second body during the spring sale. I planned to sell the unmodded once I was satisfied nothing critical to me was negatively impacted, but then I got curious about other lenses, and the 100-400 looked promising, as did this lens. After having spent time with both those lenses and few other rentals, I have this strong and foreign feeling of contentment with my UT kit. I can forgive both the Rodie and Cron for not being as strong objective performers as the CV, mostly because they're not so far off that I'll feel the impact and, put together, they take up less space in my bag.
Aug 23, 2017 at 11:11 PM
Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.14 #10Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
A few more samples from yesterday:

f/2:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

f/8:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

f/11:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

f/2:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

f/4:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

f/5:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr

And the last one is crazy, take a look at the non-existent LoCA - That scene is highly demanding:


The fabolous APO-Lanthar 2/65 by Jannik Peters, auf Flickr
Aug 24, 2017 at 12:28 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.14 #11Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Three more samples. The first one was captured at f/2 and shows once more the crazy LoCA correction.

Second shows that is possible to combine bokeh and sun star at f/8

Third one is f/2 as well.














Aug 24, 2017 at 12:54 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.14 #12Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Jannik Peters wrote:
Three more samples. The first one was captured at f/2 and shows once more the crazy LoCA correction.

Second shows that is possible to combine bokeh and sun star at f/8

Third one is f/2 as well.


I like your bokeh and sunstar shot!
Aug 24, 2017 at 01:21 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.14 #13Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
This lens although a shorter focal length seems to be a true successor to the 125 f/2.5 APO macro. Everything about it reminds me of that lens except the focal length.
Aug 24, 2017 at 01:24 PM
Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.14 #14Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Luvwine wrote:
I like your bokeh and sunstar shot!


Thank you! I have really hoped that this combination would be possible. Wasn't sure about that.
Aug 24, 2017 at 01:25 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.14 #15Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Jannik Peters wrote:
Three more samples. The first one was captured at f/2 and shows once more the crazy LoCA correction.

Second shows that is possible to combine bokeh and sun star at f/8

Third one is f/2 as well.


Great samples Jannik. It looks like you are having fun with your new lens!

I really like the rendering. Way better than the Loxia 50's harshness!
Do you think the CV 65/2 lacks the Zeiss contrast or it's more in line with the Voigtlander look? Contrast looks very high on your shots. Did you bump it in post?
Aug 24, 2017 at 03:24 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #16Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
These shots look just about perfect to me. I'm just waiting for a little SmugMug money September 7 and I'm ordering it
Aug 24, 2017 at 03:35 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #17Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Steve Spencer wrote:
This lens although a shorter focal length seems to be a true successor to the 125 f/2.5 APO macro. Everything about it reminds me of that lens except the focal length.


Was the 125 as flare-sensitive, Steve? I couldn't remember and I don't have any shots with it pointed at a bright light source.

That was another lens well corrected for spherochromatism. I think that's part of the reason it was preferred over the Leica and Zeiss 100 macros, and now their 60's have this with which to compete.
Aug 24, 2017 at 09:00 PM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.14 #18Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
The mighty little CV 1.7/35 is actually more flare resistant than either the ZM 1.4/35 or Loxia 2/35 so flare resistance is not a general issue of CV lenses.

And with the CV65 it is far from bad either, the Lox50 for example does not perform any better. It is just that it beats the high end competition in almost any aspect but some lenses outperform it in this aspect.

Edited on Aug 25, 2017 at 01:03 AM · View previous versions
Aug 24, 2017 at 10:53 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.14 #19Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
freaklikeme wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteThis lens although a shorter focal length seems to be a true successor to the 125 f/2.5 APO macro. Everything about it reminds me of that lens except the focal length.
Was the 125 as flare-sensitive, Steve? I couldn't remember and I don't have any shots with it pointed at a bright light source.

That was another lens well corrected for spherochromatism. I think that's part of the reason it was preferred over the Leica and Zeiss 100 macros, and now their 60's have this with which to compete.


I was never able to get a copy of the 125, so I can't really say. I wanted the lens badly at one point, but could never find one when I had the money to spend on it. I do hope to be able to try out this 65 f/2 at some point, however.
Aug 24, 2017 at 11:48 PM
Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.14 #20Official: Voigtlander 65mm f/2 Macro Apo-Lanthar
Fred Miranda wrote:
Great samples Jannik. It looks like you are having fun with your new lens!


Thank you, Fred! I'm definitely having fun, it's really exciting to play around with that lens. I'm really picky when it comes to LoCA, so this lens is heaven to me

Fred Miranda wrote:
I really like the rendering. Way better than the Loxia 50's harshness!
Do you think the CV 65/2 lacks the Zeiss contrast or it's more in line with the Voigtlander look? Contrast looks very high on your shots. Did you bump it in post?


Yes, way better than the Loxia 2/50. The Loxia is mainly a landscape lens and starts to shine at f/5.6. I think the CV 2/65 eats it for breakfast across the frame at brighter stops. The bokeh of the Loxia 2/50 can be very harsh and the spherical aberrations towards the edges are annoying.

The CV 2/65 has got high contrast, but my images were of course post-processed a little towards contrast. (whites bumped a little up, blacks pulled a little down if needed, saturation usually untouched).
Aug 25, 2017 at 12:30 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister