I'm considering purchasing a D5 or D850 with grip. I realize there's a whole bunch of big differences. Leaning more toward the D5 at this point. Ever since I rented and shot with a D3X back in 2010, I've really wanted a D single digit Nikon body. The ergonomics, speed, etc. I have a gripped D800E now that I shoot with and it's a great camera (still) but the detachable battery grips don't give one that sense of confidence that an integrated battery grip does IMO. Still satisfied with the 36 mp D800E files as well so figure I can shoot with the D800E when I want/need higher resolution with the D5 being my all around, everything else option to shoot with.
With all the hype on the web about low ISO DR on the D5, I'm curious as to whether there are any real issues with shooting the D5 at base ISO. Is there more noise visible in a well-exposed shot? Any other issues when shooting in the 100 to 800 ISO range compared to say a D4S or D800E (resolution differences aside)?
I have both and it depends what your use will be. If mainly base ISO go D850. If more low light then go D5. Don't discount the added advantage of the D850 being used in FX and DX mode. It's great for in camera cropping (19MPX) when you want it. I find it useful for sports or even when I want to get more crop reach out of a travel zoom like the 24-120.
Oh, and I don't hesitate to use the D5 at lower ISO's. But my use is mainly sports so others may have a differing opinion. My personal opinion is that the issue is overblown but I'm not a pixel peeper like some.
Spectro wrote:
I have both and it depends what your use will be. If mainly base ISO go D850. If more low light then go D5. Don't discount the added advantage of the D850 being used in FX and DX mode. It's great for in camera cropping (19MPX) when you want it. I find it useful for sports or even when I want to get more crop reach out of a travel zoom like the 24-120.
Oh, and I don't hesitate to use the D5 at lower ISO's. But my use is mainly sports so others may have a differing opinion. My personal opinion is that the issue is overblown but I'm not a pixel peeper like some....Show more →
Thanks. Re the D850, just curious as to whether you've shot with a D800/E or D810 and if you have, have you noticed an overall improvement in IQ with the D850 in comparison (better color, more detail, etc.)?
Based on what I've read so far, my impression is the D5 is the better camera in terms of AF speed, precision, ergonomics. Do you see a clear difference between the D5 & D850 at lower ISO values in terms of image quality? Also, if the D5 rates as a 9.5 for AF performance, how would you rate the D850 for AF performance?
I had both the D800e and D810. I actually sold a D810 and D500 when I got the D850 with no regrets. The only thing I missed about the D500 was the full viewfinder (vs the masked screen in crop mode on D850).
I find the low light IQ at higher ISO's to be better on the D850 than the previous D8xx cameras. AF is miles ahead of the D800e and D810. Detail and color are better and Auto ISO works very well when it's appropriate.
I like the feel of the D5 much better than the gripped D850. There is a difference. As I've said before in other posts, I would not hesitate to pick up a D5 and use it at low ISO values like I did with the D4s or D3s. I used to use dual D3s for the occasional wedding I would shoot and would happily use the D5 in the same scenario.
As for AF, if the D5 is 9.5 I would rate the D850 as a 9.0. It is very fast and accurate. I have used it for many different sports and I have never felt let down by the AF, even in close fast action like NHL. My D5 is still my go to for game action but for some sports like MLS I will use the D850 as the main in crop mode with the D5 for in close action. No issues. They compliment each other nicely.
Spectro wrote:
I had both the D800e and D810. I actually sold a D810 and D500 when I got the D850 with no regrets. The only thing I missed about the D500 was the full viewfinder (vs the masked screen in crop mode on D850).
I find the low light IQ at higher ISO's to be better on the D850 than the previous D8xx cameras. AF is miles ahead of the D800e and D810. Detail and color are better and Auto ISO works very well when it's appropriate.
I like the feel of the D5 much better than the gripped D850. There is a difference. As I've said before in other posts, I would not hesitate to pick up a D5 and use it at low ISO values like I did with the D4s or D3s. I used to use dual D3s for the occasional wedding I would shoot and would happily use the D5 in the same scenario.
As for AF, if the D5 is 9.5 I would rate the D850 as a 9.0. It is very fast and accurate. I have used it for many different sports and I have never felt let down by the AF, even in close fast action like NHL. My D5 is still my go to for game action but for some sports like MLS I will use the D850 as the main in crop mode with the D5 for in close action. No issues. They compliment each other nicely....Show more →
Thanks for excellent info. To be honest, I really want BOTH a D5 & D850, lol. Would be great if Nikon would produce another D# "X" model like a D5X or D6X with a high-rez sensor & integrated grip, full pro ergonomics, build, etc.
kwilliam8 wrote:
Putting the equipment (and shooter) to the test, well after sunset... Shot with the D5 and 400mm f/2.8 E, at f/2.8, 1/1250 sec, and ISO 32,000 (yes, 32,000).
Keith W.
32,000
nice.... and i thought the days of 12,800 on the d3s were good
Here a few of mine with the D5 and the 500mm E FL. You might have seen them in other thread.
I have both the D850 and D5 and each of them is a different beast altogether. In general will I have on my safaris the AF-S 500mm f/4 E FL on my D5 and the AF-S 70-200 f/2.8 E FL attached to the D850. Very soon, rumors have it this month, will Nikon announce the D6 and will I be in the market for this new flagship.
While it may not be the best choice if your lens is too short, there's something about the way the D5 renders (when you have lens enough to capitalize on it) that sets it apart from the others, imo.