Thanks for the comments and inputs. Very informative and interesting. I believe I like the tight comp a little better as well but on location I was more drawn to the beauty of the wider expanse. However, as I think about it I think the two canyons intersecting at Spider Rock is a stronger composition.
eriet30 - NM, in this case, stands for National Monument. Since New Mexico is next door, I can see how NM could be misleading.
Dave
harshaj1 wrote:
Both are very good and it is hard to decide but if I had to pick one it would be the second.
Harsha
---------------------------------------------
JimKied wrote:
What Harsha said. I like the second better as well, but both are good.
---------------------------------------------
Gary Clennan wrote:
What a grand view! #2 is my favourite.... Wow.
---------------------------------------------
lostinjapan wrote:
The second one is my favorite. The tighter crop just works better.
Ryan
---------------------------------------------
fingerda wrote:
I too vote for the 2nd, but both are great,
DaveF
---------------------------------------------
kwilliam8 wrote:
Dave, these are both really great! If I was forced to make a choice, I would pick the second.
Keith W.
---------------------------------------------
eriet30 wrote:
I like the subject in number one but number two pops better for some reason.... also its still in AZ not NM
---------------------------------------------
Aztatlan wrote:
The 2nd for me, also. The light on the rocks is nicer and I prefer it without the little grey bush in the corner, although the sky is better in #1.