fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR

  
 
akjackson1
Offline

p.1 #1200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
I've been shooting for a while with a D810, Nikon 200-500 and my Kenko 1.4 lives on it most of the time. The difference in sharpness with and without the teleconverters is barely noticeable for me.

However, I find myself wanting better background separation, faster focus, and possibly more possibilities with teleconverters. I've been thinking about the older 500 f4 VR but noticed it only has 3 stops of VR (compared to 4.5 of the 200-500) and some people complain that even a 1.4 teleconverter produces poor results.

My question is, will this be a significant upgrade? Or will I be going backwards in some regards? I shoot birds most of the time either handheld or on a monopod. The extra 3 lbs doesn't seem to concern me as I'm young and ambitious.

What are your thoughts? My budget is about $5000, so the new FL version isn't a possibility.
Apr 25, 2016 at 08:21 PM
Elijah
Offline
Details
Apr 25, 2016 at 09:03 PM
akjackson1
Offline
Details
p.1 #3200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
Apr 25, 2016 at 09:04 PM
Aloicious
Offline
Details
p.1 #4200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
akjackson1 wrote:
Elijah wrotehttp://nikonrumors.com/2016/03/26/nikon-200-500mm-f5-6e-zoom-vs-the-500mm-f4e-prime-lens-comparison.aspx/
That's comparing the new FL version.


no, that article is mis labeled, that is comparing an older pre-VR AFS version of the 500 f/4.
Apr 25, 2016 at 09:06 PM
akjackson1
Offline
Details
p.1 #5200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR


Aloicious wrote:
akjackson1 wrote
Elijah wrotehttp://nikonrumors.com/2016/03/26/nikon-200-500mm-f5-6e-zoom-vs-the-500mm-f4e-prime-lens-comparison.aspx/
That's comparing the new FL version.
no, that article is mis labeled, that is comparing an older pre-VR AFS version of the 500 f/4.


Good to know. I read through that article and read all the comment conversation. It's not the greatest article, so I'm hoping somebody can share their experiences.
Apr 25, 2016 at 09:10 PM
Aloicious
Offline
Details
p.1 #6200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
akjackson1 wrote:
Good to know. I read through that article and read all the comment conversation. It's not the greatest article, so I'm hoping somebody can share their experiences.



yeah I wish they'd fix it, its rather misleading.

he frequently mentions how the 500 f4 "has no VR", and in the comments someone found this info:
"The lens is ID'd as an AF-S Nikkor 500mm f/4D IF-ED prime. I'm not sure if the article title was suggested by you or created by NR, however, I would recommend correcting the title (assuming the exiftool information is correct) and clarifying early in the article which version of the 500mm f/4 was used for the comparison."
Apr 25, 2016 at 09:28 PM
Christian H
Offline
Details
p.1 #7200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
Hard to say. If you don't see a difference between the bare 200-500 and the 200-500 with a Kenko converter, you may not notice much of a difference between the 200-500 and the 500 either.

The 500 VR is a small step backwards in terms of VR but the image quality is divine: bokeh and rendering of fine detail are superb, AF speed is faster than the zoom. It also works fairly well with the 1.4 TC III.

Bottom line: if you need a zoom, get the zoom. If you don't need a zoom, get the prime. IQ alone is such a close call that the difference is meaningless for nonprofessional use. (The 500 VR will let you "get the shot" in almost all light conditions, whereas the slower zoom is more light-challenged.)

Apr 26, 2016 at 04:28 AM
TAM63
Offline
Details
p.1 #8200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
Here's a comparison to the G lens

https://photographylife.com/nikon-200-500mm-f5-6-vs-500mm-f4-at-block-creek-ranch?shared=email&msg=fail

All I can say is, looking at the pics could I pick out which ones were which - and yes, I got it right each time.
Apr 26, 2016 at 04:51 AM
mmarconi
Offline
Details
p.1 #9200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
+1 on everything Christian stated.

I shoot both and will add. The 200-500 to loves good light, but when you start losing the light it struggles some in AF. But more importantly you will notice it's lack of micro contrast compared to a 500 f4.. That means for wildlife your somewhat handicapped at the margins of the day.

Here is a pick from each to illustrate. Both taken in low light. The 500 f4 one on a cloudy, rainy overcast day. The 200-500 at the last light of the day (actually better light than the first).

All that said I love my 200-500 and shoot it more than the 500 f4. But if I'm planning to sit somewhere and I know the light will be challenging or I'll need lighting quick AF, I take the 500 f4 every time.

Mike









Apr 26, 2016 at 05:28 AM
cohenfive
Offline
Details
p.1 #10200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
I agree...these new superzooms are amazing (I have the sigma sport) especially for the money, but when things get tough you just can't beat all that extra glass you get with the big, fixed focal length long lenses. The good news is that the existence of the new superzooms has collapsed the price of the big glass so it is a lot cheaper to have both now....
Apr 26, 2016 at 11:19 AM
akjackson1
Offline
Details
p.1 #11200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
Thanks for all the responses! I really appreciate it. I think I've been convinced that I won't be disappointed after upgrading to the 500 f4 G. Anybody wanting to sell their copy?
Apr 26, 2016 at 11:28 AM
ckcarr
Offline
Details
p.1 #12200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
akjackson1 wrote:
Thanks for all the responses! I really appreciate it. I think I've been convinced that I won't be disappointed after upgrading to the 500 f4 G. Anybody wanting to sell their copy?


Unfortunately for you they had been selling off the old version at Amazon and also in Canada at Henry's camera at a substantial discount, up to $2,500 or more off depending on the day. Sort of mad I didn't buy when they were available. Seem to be all gone now.

Apr 26, 2016 at 12:32 PM
akjackson1
Offline
Details
p.1 #13200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
ckcarr wrote:
Unfortunately for you they had been selling off the old version at Amazon and also in Canada at Henry's camera at a substantial discount, up to $2,500 or more off depending on the day. Sort of mad I didn't buy when they were available. Seem to be all gone now.



Interesting, that probably would still have been a little out of my budget. I was actually bidding on one on ebay (but lost) and it sold for $3900! Hoping to spending between $4000 - $5000 used. Will see!
Apr 26, 2016 at 12:37 PM
cohenfive
Offline
Details
p.1 #14200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
There are a few of them for sale here on FM, at least there have been some of late. Well worth the money if you can swing it. I sure paid a lot more for mine a few years ago. Good luck!
Apr 26, 2016 at 01:11 PM
architect7
Offline
Details
p.1 #15200-500 5.6 vs 500 f4 VR
Elijah wrote:
http://nikonrumors.com/2016/03/26/nikon-200-500mm-f5-6e-zoom-vs-the-500mm-f4e-prime-lens-comparison.aspx/


One of the worst lens comparisons ever published on the internet. Should not be taken even 1% seriously.


I have both the 200-500 and a 500mm f4D AF-S II (pre-VR). I take the 200-500 hiking, on the kayak, etc. when I need to keep weight down. I also hand hold the 500mm f4 and I take it when weight isn't as much of an issue and/or I need absolute best image quality and AF speed. I tend to use the 200-500 more often but the 500 f4 IQ/AF is in another league.
Apr 26, 2016 at 04:28 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister