This is a brief review of the 135/2 variously branded as Rokinon or Samyang. As a snob of German glass, I would normally be expected to acquire the CZ Apo Sonnar (as built by Cosina). After seeing some pretty impressive imagery from a certain Korean company, I decided to give them a try—and save $1500 at the same time.
The review concentrates on my studio use case for this lens, and select optical attributes. Top priorties are smooth bokeh and a high level of color correction. The setup was a (FF) D3X, studio lighting, and subjects at 2m distance. I evaluated wide open and at f/5.6, both in the center and along the edges.
First image show an overview of the test frames. Chrome screws provide plenty of speculars to observe f/g bokeh, b/g bokeh, color correction, sharpness, and plane of focus. Critical DOF at f/2 is less than one screw length:
Test #1 demonstrates blur quality. E2 is far edge performance @ f/2, E5.6 is far edge performance @ f/5.6, C2 is center performance @ f/2, and C5.6 is center performance @ f/5.6:
Unscaled crop is available HERE. I find these results to be excellent, with just a bit of trouble in frame center, w/o, and just in front of the plane of focus. Grade A.
Test #2 demonstrates color control and sharpness on the long edge. For comparison, I include the Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, a truly awesome zoom (and I dislike zooms):
Unscaled crop is available HERE. With both lenses wide open, these results are also excellent. Performance is generally comparable, but note that the Rokinon is operating two stops faster! The Nikkor falls apart in the very corner (no suprise). The Rokinon suffers from field curvature which can be masked by stopping down: the far corners can be made blisteringly sharp but the center will then degrade. The difference in vignetting is significant.
Test frames were shot as JPEG, and web-sized pics resized and sharpened. The linked images were not sharpened. No vignette correction in post, but camera vignette feature was enabled.
Build quality for the Rokinon is a mixed bag. Mount is metal, as is a bit of the barrel, but most of the cladding is plastic. I am particular unimpressed by the fragile pastic at the filter ring. Samyang needs to follow the lead of Nikon or Sigma in choice of build material. Plastic does make the lens quite light, and the compact design keeps the camera maneuverable. Focus action is a bit too stiff, but free of play. Focus throw is decent at half a turn or more. I also like the close focus capability, and internal focus.
I did not test linearity, or infinity performance (2m will be my tabletop norm).
Finally, here is my first Rokinon shot, and an example where chromatic errors can be unwelcomed and pronounced. This was taken @ f/8, and I would probably stop down further or change focus distance:
Thanks for sharing. It's a good idea to use chrome screw as testing object. As I remember, this 135mm has very good CA performance. (on par or even better than Zeiss)
I might add the Samyang (Rokinon) 135mm is a fantastic astrophotography lens. It is sharp corner to corner and with no noticeable aspherical astigmatism (coma).
Nice review, hopeully it will help spread the gospel of Rokinon
As a sidenote, that coffee pot must have seen its fair share of coffee, considering it was made in West Germany...
Thanks for the comments! Final sample image using the Rok 135 wide open, two lights, uncropped. No post of note except to set white/black points. Flying witch created by my 9-year old daughter, as inspired by Scooby Doo. Happy dreams!