Here is a good example of 2 different users shooting with 2 different environments.
One uses a full frame D800E with at least 1 to 1.5 stop better noise handling than the crop frame D7200.
The D800E user might be able to push it all the way to ISO 12800 and still able or willing to accept that kind of noise level, resolution and sharpness. Just look at the pictures on a monitor screen and one will see quite an amount of noise. The resolution and sharpness will be softer than if used with a lower ISO settings due to the on camera processing firmware which we have no control over. Than there is this additional noise generated by each additional stage of the cascaded amplifiers for each steps of ISO increment on the camera that we can minimize if we use post processing because our computers can handle the S/N level better than a camera due to its higher signal levels and less confined space for EMI.
The next thing is the D800E with an aperture of f/2.8 will give a DOF of about 2.87 ft compare to that of the D7200 which will give about 2.3 ft shooting at the same distant of about 35 yds or 100 ft. As can be seen on the first picture that the focus is more on the defender #36 than on the receiver. This could have been avoided if there is a little more DOF coverage, and also make it simpler for the shooter to track moving objects which is by itself already difficult.
Finally, it also comes down to the lighting situation one is shooting in. Based on the pictures, Andre is shooting in a less well lighted field than Trevorma just by judging from the background illumination. This will make it even more difficult for users using a DX compare to the advantage of having a FX other than the X-factor.
So the difference between the 2 users and situations are different. The only way one can tell which is the best combination is to try all possible options provided by users here which have already helped to narrow down the possible combinations.
So once again, good luck for whatever settings one chooses!