Here's a question I've been thinking about a long time ...
If you're using an alt zoom with no electronic communications (like the Contax 35-70mm, or Contax 80-200mm f4) with a camera with IBIS like the A7II or A7RII -- does it make sense to leave the IBIS on & set the IBIS focal length to the shortest end of the zoom?
At the short end, the IBIS will provide correct stabilization, and at the longer focal lengths it will still provide some stabilization, right?
I guess what I'm asking is whether the stabilization set to some focal length X is "correct" just not "strong enough" to fully stabilize the zoom at longer focal lengths.
I think you're essentially correct, that when the real focal length is longer that what is programmed into the camera then it will move the sensor in the correct direction but a much shorter distance than necessary.
It might be a worthwhile strategy with something like a 80-200mm lens, but for a walkabout zoom (24-70) there doesn't seem much point, you'll get stabilisation at the short end where you don't really need it, and ineffectual stabilisation at the long end...
I'm thinking the same...
But anyway, I have assigned a button to change FL so it's so easy to change FL...just click a button and then scroll the wheel to select the correct one.
I just tested this on a Series E 75-150. As far as I can tell the image on the screen is shakier when I set the IBIS to the shorter end and zoom to 150mm. However, when I set the IBIS to 150mm the image is way steadier, and it's still steady at the shorter end. I tested this hand-held at 1/30 and ISO 2500 (low light).
I think the best way to work with a zoom would be to just change the FL so IBIS is better matched to the FL.
jsv_20 wrote:
I just tested this on a Series E 75-150. As far as I can tell the image on the screen is shakier when I set the IBIS to the shorter end and zoom to 150mm. However, when I set the IBIS to 150mm the image is way steadier, and it's still steady at the shorter end. I tested this hand-held at 1/30 and ISO 2500 (low light).
I think the best way to work with a zoom would be to just change the FL so IBIS is better matched to the FL.
I'm surprised that with the IBIS set to 150mm, the image doesn't jump around at 75mm.
What's funny is that it never occurred to me try it! I was just thinking about it theoretically -- what makes sense from first principles.
There's a saying: "In theory, theory and practice are the same. In practice, they're not."